Homeopathic Cough Medicine

Rodney believes that Homoeopathy has been neither proven nor disproven and that it could work by some unknown mechanism. It seems to me that he is not actually promoting it. However, because it has not been disproven, he does think it is therefore okay to sell it and to use it.

Is that about it, Rodney?
It has been neither proven nor disproven that Rodney is promoting homoeopathy. Therefore, by this logic, it is OK to behave as though he is.
 
I'm pretty sure Rodney has not promoted homoeopathy. I won't look back through all those posts, but I think he has said that he isn't suggesting we should use homoeopathic cough mixtures. Just that there is no evidence against its use, so go ahead and try it if you want to. And buyer beware.
 
Rodney believes that Homoeopathy has been neither proven nor disproven and that it could work by some unknown mechanism. It seems to me that he is not actually promoting it. However, because it has not been disproven, he does think it is therefore okay to sell it and to use it.

Is that about it, Rodney?
That's correct, assuming that a "homeopathic" medicine has not been shown to be dangerous. (I put the word in quotation marks because it is unclear whether all medicines labeled as homeopathic actually are.) Some controlled studies have shown that homeopathic medicines work better than placebo, while others have shown that they do not. Further, it appears that a number of homeopathic medicines, such as cough medicines, have never been subjected to a controlled study.
 
It has been neither proven nor disproven that Rodney is promoting homoeopathy. Therefore, by this logic, it is OK to behave as though he is.
It has been neither proven nor disproven that Mojo is sane. Therefore, by this logic, it is OK to behave as though he is . . . not. ;)
 
Some controlled studies have shown that homeopathic medicines work better than placebo, while others have shown that they do not.

You are misunderstanding the process of drawing conclusions from a research study, and you have misrepresented the nature of the research results. A truer representation would be:

"Some controlled studies have shown a statistically significant difference between the treated and un-treated groups. Since flaws in study design, execution, and/or analysis can easily account for these differences, no conclusions can be drawn about the existence or magnitude of a treatment effect. Studies that minimize flaws in study design, execution, and analysis do not show any differences between the treated and un-treated groups, and one can conclude that there is no significant treatment effect."

An even truer representation would be:

"When we allow the opportunity for chance and wishful thinking to influence the outcome, researchers get the results they hope to get. When we reduce or eliminate the opportunity for chance and wishful thinking to influence the outcome, the "positive" results disappear."

Linda
 
You are misunderstanding the process of drawing conclusions from a research study, and you have misrepresented the nature of the research results. A truer representation would be:

"Some controlled studies have shown a statistically significant difference between the treated and un-treated groups. Since flaws in study design, execution, and/or analysis can easily account for these differences, no conclusions can be drawn about the existence or magnitude of a treatment effect. Studies that minimize flaws in study design, execution, and analysis do not show any differences between the treated and un-treated groups, and one can conclude that there is no significant treatment effect."

An even truer representation would be:

"When we allow the opportunity for chance and wishful thinking to influence the outcome, researchers get the results they hope to get. When we reduce or eliminate the opportunity for chance and wishful thinking to influence the outcome, the "positive" results disappear."

Linda

And an even truer, truer representation would be: "Researchers found 22 high-caliber studies, 15 of which showed that homeopathic medicines were effective. Of further interest, they found that 11 of the best 15 studies showed efficacy." See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homeopathy
 
And an even truer, truer representation would be: "Researchers found 22 high-caliber studies, 15 of which showed that homeopathic medicines were effective. Of further interest, they found that 11 of the best 15 studies showed efficacy." See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homeopathy

You are basing your interpretation upon a comment written by someone that is sympathetic to the idea of homeopathy from a Wikipedia article. Unfortunately, that comment is inaccurate. If you actually look at the studies in question, instead of depending upon 3rd and 4th hand subjective reports, those studies are not "high-caliber". They all contain significant flaws including (but not limited to) non-randomization, variation in measurement of outcomes, non-blinding, or inappropriate statistical analysis. Plus, most are not tests of classical homeopathy - they contain substances in pharmacologic doses.

Linda
 
You are basing your interpretation upon a comment written by someone that is sympathetic to the idea of homeopathy from a Wikipedia article.
The article has a number of negative comments about homeopathy, so why do you believe it is biased in favor of homeopathy?

Unfortunately, that comment is inaccurate. If you actually look at the studies in question, instead of depending upon 3rd and 4th hand subjective reports, those studies are not "high-caliber". They all contain significant flaws including (but not limited to) non-randomization, variation in measurement of outcomes, non-blinding, or inappropriate statistical analysis. Plus, most are not tests of classical homeopathy - they contain substances in pharmacologic doses.
Linda
So you've researched in depth all of the 15 "high-caliber" studies that showed homeopathic medications were effective?
 
The article has a number of negative comments about homeopathy, so why do you believe it is biased in favor of homeopathy?

Because I have a lot of experience reading between the lines, and I have independent knowledge of the information they are writing about. The article gives the impression that there is a middle ground.

So you've researched in depth all of the 15 "high-caliber" studies that showed homeopathic medications were effective?

I don't know what you mean by "researched in depth". Just reading them is enough to pick out the flaws. And as has been pointed out several times, other researchers have published reviews using rigorous, objective criteria as to the quality (something that was not done in that one review you keep referring to).

Linda
 
The [wikipedia] article has a number of negative comments about homeopathy, so why do you believe it is biased in favor of homeopathy?
Because the article is biased. Wiki usually incorporates token, negative comments. But, the articles on quackery are dominated by quacks- i.e., the inmates are running the jail. If you want to use wiki, you have to go to the cited sources and evaluate them.

So [Linda] you've researched in depth all of the 15 "high-caliber" studies that showed homeopathic medications were effective?
Homeopathy makes thousands of claims: tinselweed 10X cures this, the color red 5C cures that, etc. In the past century of scientific medicine, you think there are 15 confirmatory studies!? Why not list them, and explain how they support the other thousands?* You also need to explain how the results cannot be attributed to statistical randomness and/or doping with actual drugs. And they truly need to be "high quality" studies, not wishful thinking about that phrase. The particular claims that pass those tests need to be confirmed with legitimate (phase I, II, and III) clinical trials.

*They can't; each claim needs its own supporting research.
 
Last edited:
It has been neither proven nor disproven that Mojo is sane. Therefore, by this logic, it is OK to behave as though he is . . . not. ;)
Well, it's your logic, not mine. It's the logic you are using when you say that it is acceptable for homoeopaths to sell ineffective medicines as long as they claim to be ignorant of their ineffectiveness. It's the logic of every charlatan who says "keep an open mind" to cover up the absence of evidence for their claims.
 
Rodney, your insistence of the "weight of anecdotes" (which is what you are doing, in reality) has reminded me that we have visited this scenario before some years back with another poster called Kumar. He swore by all the gods that the more people said something, the "truer" it made what they said. Like this:

 
And an even truer, truer representation would be: "Researchers found 22 high-caliber studies, 15 of which showed that homeopathic medicines were effective. Of further interest, they found that 11 of the best 15 studies showed efficacy." See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homeopathy
An even truer, truer, truer representation would be to quote the conclusion of that meta-analysis from the same Wikipedia article*:
The meta-analysis on homeopathy concluded, "At the moment the evidence of clinical trials is positive but not sufficient to draw definitive conclusions because most trials are of low methodological quality and because of the unknown role of publication bias. This indicates that there is a legitimate case for further evaluation of homoeopathy, but only by means of well performed trials."
Do you understand, Rodney? I'll type this very slowly: THE META-ANALYSIS YOU KEEP CITING DID NOT CONCLUDE THAT HOMOEOPATHY WORKS. And more recent meta-analyses have failed to show results that are any better.

That paper was published 15 years ago, Rodney. Do you have any evidence that the "well performed trials" that the authors concluded were needed have since been carried out, and have shown homoeopathy to work?

You keep saying that the jury is still out. After 15 years, perhaps it's time to ask them to look at the evidence and come back in to announce their verdict.



*By the way, as it follows a colon rather than a full stop in your post, your capitalisation of the word "researchers" was not necessary, as it was not the start of a sentence in the article you quoted it from. Perhaps you should have included the first word of the sentence. ;)
 
Last edited:
Rodney, your insistence of the "weight of anecdotes" (which is what you are doing, in reality) has reminded me that we have visited this scenario before some years back with another poster called Kumar. He swore by all the gods that the more people said something, the "truer" it made what they said. Like this:

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_710457bfee3d0ad4.jpg[/qimg]
Hey, we were talking about that table on the train on the way back from yesterday's pre-Xmas meet-up.

Spooky!
 
Rodney,

Do you realize that "equivalent to, or indistinguishable from, a placebo" is a failure for the test preparation?
 
THE META-ANALYSIS YOU KEEP CITING DID NOT CONCLUDE THAT HOMOEOPATHY WORKS.
I never said it did. I've argued only "that there is a legitimate case for further evaluation of homeopathy, but only by means of well performed trials."

And more recent meta-analyses have failed to show results that are any better.
Are you referring to the 2005 Lancet study? A good review of that is given by Peter Fisher:

"The meta-analysis at the centre of the controversy is based on 110 placebo-controlled clinical trials of homeopathy and 110 clinical trials of allopathy (conventional medicine), which are said to be matched. These were reduced to 21 trials of homeopathy and 9 of conventional medicine of ‘higher quality’ and further reduced to 8 and 6 trials, respectively, which were ‘larger, higher quality’. The final analysis which concluded that ‘the clinical effects of homoeopathy are placebo effects’ was based on just the eight ‘larger, higher quality’ clinical trials of homeopathy. The Lancet's press release did not mention this, instead giving the impression that the conclusions were based on all 110 trials.

"The criteria for the matching of the homeopathic and conventional trials were not clearly stated, and it is evident from the numbers above that the clinical trials of homeopathy and conventional medicine were not, as claimed, well matched—the homeopathic trials were generally of better quality. And this is a crucial parameter [as Shang et al. acknowledge]; it is well established that high quality trials are less likely to be positive than those of lower quality. Because of the individualization involved, it is difficult to do large-scale trials of homeopathy (again this is evident from the figures above), so the final sample is unlikely to be representative of trials of homeopathy. An example is a study that may have been included in the final eight, which looked at the use of a homeopathic medicine for prophylaxis of influenza, an indication for which it is not recommended, and obscured the identity of the homeopathic medication. However, a Cochrane Review has concluded that it is probably effective for treatment (as opposed to prevention) of flu-like illnesses. A number of similar instances could be cited, but since we do not know which studies are under discussion, there is little point." [footnotes omitted] See http://ecam.oxfordjournals.org/cgi/content/full/3/1/145

Or perhaps you are referring to the 2006 European Journal of Cancer study, which concluded that "the evidence emerging from this systematic review is encouraging but not convincing. Further research should attempt to answer the many open questions related to homeopathy." See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homeopathy

That paper was published 15 years ago, Rodney. Do you have any evidence that the "well performed trials" that the authors concluded were needed have since been carried out, and have shown homoeopathy to work?
What well performed homeopathy trials have been done in the last 15 years?

You keep saying that the jury is still out. After 15 years, perhaps it's time to ask them to look at the evidence and come back in to announce their verdict.
Based on what new evidence?
 
Homeopathy makes thousands of claims: tinselweed 10X cures this...
Actually, homoeopathy doesn't claim that particular remedies will cure particular conditions; it claims that the remedy needs to be "individualised" to the particular patient.

In practice this means that after the initial consultation the homoeopath will prescribe a remedy. If the patient doesn't get better they will say they haven't found the right remedy and prescribe another. This will continue until the patient gets better (or doesn't return for further consultations), at which point the homoeopath will claim a cure.

The stuff about individualisation is the basis for their claim that homoeopathy cannot be tested by DBPC trials. This isn't true, of course; it is quite possible to design a DBPC trial of individualised homoeopathy, and at least one has been carried out and (guess what) shown results no better than placebo.
 
Rodney,

Do you realize that "equivalent to, or indistinguishable from, a placebo" is a failure for the test preparation?

Yes. Do you realize that (non-homeopathic) cough medicines have generally failed to meet that burden?
 
Yes. Do you realize that (non-homeopathic) cough medicines have generally failed to meet that burden?

You are incorrect. Non-homeopathic cough medicines have generally exceeded that burden. And you have been provided with the evidence for this numerous times. That you have elected to remain ignorant is not for lack of trying on our part.

Linda
 
Are you referring to the 2005 Lancet study?
That one, certainly. Also Professor Ernst's "Systematic Review of Systematic Reviews of Homeopathy", which I have previously referred you to but which you haven't so far bothered commenting on. There are plenty of others to choose from. At best, they say pretty much what the 1991 paper you have cited says: there may be some trials which show an effect above placebo, but the evidence is not good enough in quality for definitive conclusions to be reached and more good quality research is needed. note in particular what that last one says:
Studies of high methodological quality were more likely to be negative than the lower quality studies.

What well performed homeopathy trials have been done in the last 15 years?
Well, here's one.

A more relevant question for your purposes would be "what well performed trials in the last 15 years have found that homoeopathy works?"

Based on what new evidence?
Why has the evidence supporting homoeopathy not been forthcoming? Don't homoeopaths want to show that their treatments are effective?

If homoeopathy was trying to prove its case in a court of law, it would have been thrown out for want of prosecution long ago.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom