Homeopathic Cough Medicine

What well performed homeopathy trials have been done in the last 15 years?
Have you managed to track any down yet? Remember, it was the 15 year old meta-analysis that you have repeatedly cited that said they were needed. Surely 15 years is long enough for homoeopaths to make their case.
 
Why don't you e-mail the lead authors of the studies I cited and see if they agree with you?

Suppose they do? Then what? Will you drop it then?

Nah, of course not. You'll come up with something else, and then, several pages on, when we least expect it: BANG!! This exact same study shows up in rodney's posts again, crawling back out of its horse-sized grave to annoy us one more time.

It gets kinda tedious you know ...
 
Last edited:
Have you managed to track any down yet? Remember, it was the 15 year old meta-analysis that you have repeatedly cited that said they were needed. Surely 15 years is long enough for homoeopaths to make their case.
I was relying on you to track them down. :)
 
I was relying on you to track them down. :)

Since you were the one claiming that 15 year old meta-analysis is proof of homeopathy's effectiveness, you are also the one who'll need to track down any subsequent research supporting that conclusion. After all, without it, your meta-analysis is proof of nothing at all.

In a sense, it's another empty tray you showed up with, claiming your proof is on the tray. Well, we don't see it? Where is it? Until you put something on that tray, we assume you have no evidence and that homeopathy is bunk, as the pile of evidence on our tray seems to corroborate.
 
Why don't you e-mail the lead authors of the studies I cited and see if they agree with you?

Since I quoted the results directly from the study (your second reference was not from the author of a study), there's no reason to think they wouldn't agree.

Linda
 
I was relying on you to track them down. :)
I don't think I need to: I've cited more recent meta-analyses, which have, when the authors have tracked down the available studies, found (at best) pretty much the same thing as the old study you've cited: the available research is not good enough to come to a definitive conclusion. The longer this goes on without homoeopathy producing good evidence that it works, the worse it looks for homoeopathy.

I see no reason why I should reinvent the wheel on your behalf when others have already done the work. If you think the authors of these more recent meta-anayses are wrong in their conclusions about the research into homoeopathy, you need to get off your arse and do some work.
 
Mojo, I disagree about the definitive conclusion part.

It would appear pretty definitive to me that homeopathy doesn't do squat.
 
Mojo, I disagree about the definitive conclusion part.

It would appear pretty definitive to me that homeopathy doesn't do squat.
That would certainly appear to be a valid conclusion to draw from the fact that, as the more recent meta-analyses have shown, in the 15 years since Rodney's meta-analysis called for it, no good research supporting homoeopathy has emerged.

Homoeopaths are now reduced to claiming that (to quote a spokeswoman from the Society of Homoeopaths last year): "it has been established beyond doubt and accepted by many researchers, that the placebo-controlled randomised controlled trial is not a fitting research tool with which to test homeopathy", and running uncontrolled customer satisfaction surveys and pretending that they show that homoeopathy works.
 
Amazing that.... Exactly the method that is designed to eliminate cheating and bias is not a fitting research tool for homeopathy.

When the best research protocol yet devised by man give answers that you don't like, it must the protocol and not the research subject.

But, I have never seen where they explain why placebo-controlled randomised trial isn't suitable. Or at least, not by anyone that didn't sound as if they were writing from an asylum.
 
That would certainly appear to be a valid conclusion to draw from the fact that, as the more recent meta-analyses have shown, in the 15 years since Rodney's meta-analysis called for it, no good research supporting homoeopathy has emerged.

Homoeopaths are now reduced to claiming that (to quote a spokeswoman from the Society of Homoeopaths last year): "it has been established beyond doubt and accepted by many researchers, that the placebo-controlled randomised controlled trial is not a fitting research tool with which to test homeopathy", and running uncontrolled customer satisfaction surveys and pretending that they show that homoeopathy works.

Precisely. What homeopaths and their supporters trot out first, time and time again, is the popularity of homeopathy, particularly in Europe. As if "popularity" proved anything.

Homeopathetics share one thing in common with all true believers: they want a world in which there are rock-solid, unshakable absolutes.

It bothers the heck out of them when it's pointed out that there are no absolutes. There is the ever-expanding field of knowledge, knowledge that acts as a working hypothesis until new knowledge comes along and makes everyone think again -- everyone, that is, except homeopaths, fundie religionists, Republicans, and Tom Cruise :D

M.
 
I have an absolute for homeopaths....

There is absolutely no way that homeopathy works.

Anyone feel better?
 
As an illustatration of how a person sympathetic to homepathy looks at evidence check out Ben Goldacre's Badscience: http://www.badscience.net/?p=341#more-341 ...

Apparently he got an email from Lionel Milgrom which includes the sentence "“I’ve just read your purile blog about the debate at the Natural History Museum. How did you know what Peter Fisher said? You missed most of it because you couldn’t be bothered to turn up on time. "

Uh... well, it seems that in the video Ben is shown sitting next to Peter Fisher at the beginning, and that Dr. Goldacre actually talks for quite a while.

It seems the only evidence that will be accepted is that which agrees to their preconceived perceptions of reality. Mr. Milgrom did not want to see Dr. Goldacre at the beginning of the debate, so he assumed he was absent.

This is pretty much how Rodney has been looking at the answers given to graciously by this thread's participants, especially the very patient Linda. He is reading through some kind filter that excludes data that goes against his beliefs.
 
That's just spin. Two recent major studies have found that cough medicines are generally no better than placebos. And that verdict comes from the medical doctors who led those studies, not just from those evil popular magazines. The findings of the first (2002) study were:

"We found that there is little evidence for or against the effectiveness of over-the-counter cough medicines," says lead author Knut Schroeder, MD, researcher at University of Bristol, England. His study appears in the Feb. 9 issue of the British Medical Journal.

In his analysis, Schroeder looked at trials of various types of cough preparations -- antihistamines, cough suppressants, expectorants, antihistamine-decongestant combinations, and other drug combinations -- involving 2,166 people with cold or flu symptoms.

"Antihistamines seemed to be no better than placebo," writes Schroeder.

Cough suppressants were compared with placebo in five trials. "Two studies tested codeine and found it no more effective than placebo," he says. Codeine is available over the counter in Canada and the U.K. but only by prescription in the U.S.

One of two studies of dextromethorphan -- often referred to as DM on cough medicine labels -- showed the drug to be more effective than placebo, whereas the other found no significant effect.

As for expectorants (which break up mucus), antihistamine-decongestant combinations, and other drug combinations, "there was conflicting evidence on the effectiveness," he writes.

See http://www.webmd.com/content/article/18/1689_51929


And the findings of the second (2006) study, as summarized by Dr. Richard S. Irwin, University of Massachusetts Medical School, were:

"There is no clinical evidence that over-the-counter cough expectorants or suppressants actually relieve cough,” said Dr. Irwin . “There is considerable evidence that older type antihistamines help to reduce cough, so, unless there are contraindications to using these medicines, why not take something that has been proven to work?”

See http://www.chestnet.org/about/press/releases/2006/010906a.php

Note the contradictory opinions about antihistamines and also note that some trials have found efficacy for OTC cough medicines. The overall findings of both studies, however, were negative toward these medicines.

Other people have already addressed this post much better than I could hope to.

So I'd just like to ask: Rodney, where in this post did you address the actual topic being discussed?

In case you were curious, that topic is the effectiveness and efficiacy of homeopathic remedies. That was the final point that I summarised in my post - part of the post that you edited out of your quote.

I look forward to your reply.
 
Just to clarify this point (because otherwise it may look like we are dismissing stuff we shouldn't). Cough Medicine as a category, consists of a number of different kinds of drugs. They each claim to supress the symptom of cough based on clinical and pre-clinical trials. Causes of cough are highly variable. Clinical trials demonstrate that the cause of cough and the type of drug used are relevant to whether or not cough is suppressed (i.e. not all coughs are affected by all cough medicines) and that none of the cough medicines alter the underlying disease process.



Or the articles did not speak to the specific issue of clinical trial results.



And bias.

Linda

Thankyou for clarifying, correcting and expanding on my post.

It's certainly nice to have a professional here who is able to help out.

I can't believe I left bias off that list...it is DEFINATELY an important factor.
 
Linda is definitely going to need a spinal adjustment anytime soon. :D
I would like to volunteer. :)

regards,
BillyJoe
 
Other people have already addressed this post much better than I could hope to.

So I'd just like to ask: Rodney, where in this post did you address the actual topic being discussed?

In case you were curious, that topic is the effectiveness and efficiacy of homeopathic remedies. That was the final point that I summarised in my post - part of the post that you edited out of your quote.

I look forward to your reply.
If you put the topic in bold, at least get it right. homeopathic cough medicine. I have repeatedly made the point that non-homeopathic OTC cough medicines have been shown to have little or no benefit, and that homeopathic cough medicines haven't -- to my knowledge -- been tested. Ideally, I would like to see a three-way test involving a non-homeopathic OTC cough medicine, a homeopathic cough medicine, and a placebo. Fair enough?
 
If you put the topic in bold, at least get it right. homeopathic cough medicine. I have repeatedly made the point that non-homeopathic OTC cough medicines have been shown to have little or no benefit
No, you haven't.

and that homeopathic cough medicines haven't -- to my knowledge -- been tested.
Yes, they have.

Ideally, I would like to see a three-way test involving a non-homeopathic OTC cough medicine, a homeopathic cough medicine, and a placebo. Fair enough?
No, not at all right. Each needs to be tested on its own first, to prove efficacy (Rodney, that's a big word that means "to see if it actually does anything at all").
 
Ideally, I would like to see a three-way test involving a non-homeopathic OTC cough medicine, a homeopathic cough medicine, and a placebo. Fair enough?

Now all you need to be able to do is distinguish the last two items listed here.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom