Is there a doctor in the house?

Goodness! You certainly missed the point. As did a few others. I am not the least bit upset. Guess I'll try another version.

I merely defended the people who replied with all the reasons the headache went away which were not addressing the question saying it might not have been because they didn't read the post. I merely noted the anecdote implied Remie was considering Headon actually had an effect. (Nothing to do with anyone's belief in homeopathy.)

If any of you happen to make it to this year's TAM, come to my Sunday presentation on "Cracking the Language Code - Deciphering hidden messages you didn't know you were sending and receiving."

Look again but take all those silly assumptions out of your filter.

Statement 1): I don't believe Headon works.
Statement 2): Could any of the ingredients in Headon work?

Logic: If you don't believe Headon works then why would you inquire about the ingredients working?

Compare that to

Statement 1): I don't believe homeopathy works.
Statement 2): Could something in Headon work and be misleading people into thinking homeopathy worked?

The second 2 statements are what Remie was asking. The first 2 were the ones she initially used. The listener (or reader) hears the hidden message and includes that in their reply. Remie thinks the reader isn't reading carefully. Maybe not, but the reason is the hidden message as much as it is the care in reading.

Remie expresses frustration that the readers are not reading carefully. But she isn't aware of the hidden message the original post included.


In your case, your filter is telling you everything I'm writing is critical and whining. But I am merely describing my observation about the hidden message. It isn't bad or good. It is an insight into something about the original post that isn't being consciously picked up on, but is being unconsciously picked up on by some readers.

My filter said this didn't sound like defending posters. It was more like a shrill scold:

You claim to not believe Headon ended your headache yet want to know if it could have. Then you get annoyed at all the replies which offer alternative explanations for your headache ending at the time you applied Headon. If you don't believe the product worked, then why would you be inquiring if any of the ingredients could be effective?

You are guilty of the same thing you claim the people posting here are guilty of, not reading the actual posts. You read, "A sample size of one doesn't meet my standards. So your report, while interesting, is not persuasive." and drew incorrect assumptions about the meaning of my post.

If you run a skeptic site, then I assume you understand skepticism isn't just discounting woo products and claims. It is understanding how one goes about determining what is woo and what isn't. I find skeptics understand evidence and false logic, but I can sometimes add additional observations which either aren't articulated so aren't noticed, or involve the bigger picture.


This is becoming very circular. You still have not addressed the point, why was it wrong of Remie to ask a simple question in the first place? Why did her phrasing get your knickers in a twist? All I'm seeing is excuses to back up your overreaction and I think that is what your filter is telling you. And around we shall go again.

My magic 8- ball says for your filter to fold instead of calling and cash in remaining chips.
 
If it does increase blood flow in deep vessels, it is not by direct penetration. After permeating the skin, it goes into the circulatory system and is distributed throughout the body. (When you apply dimethylsulfoxide (DMSO) anywhere, you immediately taste it in your mouth.) So, if your hypothesis is correct, you should get the same result by applying the oil to your chest.
Drug manufacturers often design "patches" to be used over the affected area simply for the psychological benefit. For example, most people know sea-sickness is an inner ear problem- so the first patch was worn behind the ear.
I am more than dubious about your extended claims here, and you seem to have made a big misunderstanding. It is a truism to say if you introduce a chemical into a major blood vessel it will usually be carried and spread over a very large area of the circulatory system ---
but no-one was talking about introducing chemicals into major blood vessels
. The direct application of any chemical often has a far greater effect on the local area very often than on the whole circulatory system --- which is why nitro patches for a particular set of heart conditions are placed over or near the heart, not on your leg.

Should you be male, you can run a very simple test of this. Try putting a heart nitro patch on your willy; the effect will often be quite noticable. In the medical literature, it is described how one man actually did this, causing his wife to end up in medical treatment for a massive headache --- a headache the man did not share, and the difference is where and how the nitro was applied.

You can also take a bit of nitroglycerine, rub it around your leg.
Take half a day to observe any effects. Then run nitrogylcerine around your scalp. You will very certainly feel a big difference. This, BTW, is a favourite nasty trick in quarries and mines; rubbing a bit of nitro around inside the lining of a guy's hardhat. It gives the Mother Of All Headaches. Try it on your leg? Not a thing.

Or you can run a much easier experiment if you like. Take pure peppermint oil, and apply it to your temples. By your logic it should be circulating around the whole place, and so the following test should make no difference at all. Now try applying the peppermint oil to your private parts. I guarantee you will feel the difference, in a big way, for a long time.

Now the misunderstanding you had here was; you said:
If it does increase blood flow in deep vessels
Please go back and see my posts. I was extremely precise; affecting the blood vessels around the temples, forehead and sinuses. These do not IMvHO count as "deep blood vessels", and the upper cerebral circulatory system has in any case peculiarities in structure and process that the rest of the body does not share (upper head surface blood vessels often allowing permeation to the brain blood supply, for example, whereas lower head surface vessels don't).
Please correct me if I am wrong.
 
Last edited:
Gurdur, you have so very badly misinterpreted me that I feel no obligation to reply. More than that, I suspect your anecdote about the nitroglycerin patch originated in The National Enquirer. Prove me wrong.

By the way, I have formulated nitroglycerin pharmaceuticals. I am well aware of its pharmacology. You fail to impress.
 
Last edited:
Gurdur, you have so very badly misinterpreted me that I feel no obligation to reply.
I am amazed by your peculiar touchiness. I replied exactly to your post as said. Moreover, combining your rather inappropriate, "I feel no obligation to reply", together with your rather silly insults and demands for info in your next lines is more than bizarre.
More than that, I suspect your anecdote about the nitroglycerin patch originated in The National Enquirer. Prove me wrong.
Grow up, and do a MEDLINE search using the terms "heart patch penis".
By the way, I have formulated nitroglycerin pharmaceuticals. I am well aware of its pharmacology. You fail to impress.
You really fail to impress me. :p You seem to be getting terribly snarky for no apparent reason, and expressing it childishly. Are you despite your claims so totally unaware of nitro's effect on the penis?

Try this just for a start, just to improve your deficient pharmacological training :p :

Comparison of transdermal nitroglycerin and intracavernous injection of papaverine in the treatment of erectile dysfunction in patients with spinal cord lesions.
Spinal Cord. 1997 Feb;35(2):99-103.
 
Unlike much of hard science there is still a lot of unpredictability in medicine. A drug placed on the skin in the manner of "head Off" may have some absorption and then what happens to it is important as it may or may not achieve pharmacological levels in the blood stream . This is not entirely predictable. As far as any of those ingredients being shown to be useful in headaches there are none that I am aware of. So you have ingredients that were as far as I know not tested for dermal absorption and never shown to be useful in treating headaches. The alcohol could be absorbed if applied by itself but in this formulation who knows? The alcohol is known to have some pain killing effects but is also thought to cause headaches and is not known to treat them as far as I know. So maybe the ingredients could be absorbed but are they from this preparation? (need to test) They might be by some far stretch of the imagination useful in treating headaches but are they in this preparation? (need testing?) Things are not so simple as to figure out anything meaningful out of this without testing the product so whether the ingredients are absorbed under other conditions means little since it needs to be absorbed from this product and whether the ingredients are useful in other preparations it means little since it needs to be useful in this product.
 
Last edited:
The perception of pain is a complex phenomenon; the mechanisms are both physical and psychological. I still think that the cooling sensation provided by the "inactive" menthol and menthyl lactate plus the evaporation of the alcohol vehicle might cause the brain to switch its attention to the new sensation, even before any physiological effect manifests itself.

A quick google of the ingredients tells me that the combination of
[FONT=verdana,helvetica,arial]diazolidinyl urea and iodopropynyl butylcarbamate is a common cosmetic preservative known as Germall® Plus . The menthyl lactate is a cooling agent like menthol, and the other polysyllabic ingredients are basic cosmetic-stick components.
[/FONT]
 
My filter said this didn't sound like defending posters. It was more like a shrill scold:
Link to the whole post.
This is becoming very circular.
It is most certainly circular when you start over where this began 2 pages ago and ignore everything in between.

You say:
You still have not addressed the point, why was it wrong of Remie to ask a simple question in the first place?
Yet I never said anything about it being wrong to ask the question in the first place. I said getting annoyed claiming people weren't reading the question didn't take into account the influence the way the question was presented had on the reader.

Why did her phrasing get your knickers in a twist? All I'm seeing is excuses to back up your overreaction and I think that is what your filter is telling you. And around we shall go again. ....
You're welcome to your incorrect opinion. If you don't recognize the difference in

Statement 1): I don't believe Headon works.
Statement 2): Could any of the ingredients in Headon work?
&
Statement 1): I don't believe homeopathy works.
Statement 2): Could something in Headon work and be misleading people into thinking homeopathy worked?,


it follows you can't get beyond your focus that there's no point, so it must be an excuse.

-

Since we're getting nowhere, it's time to move on. I really don't care about your opinion here, but the point is still worth reiterating about the logic issues so moving along.....

... Nobody, not even a doctor, can tell you more because almost ALL of the speculation about the pharmacology of the inactive ingredients is unwarranted; especially absent realistic (analytical) data concerning concentrations.....
In response to JJMs points which were about the importance of the methods one uses in science, fls described many of the things that a skeptic should avoid yet advocated we use those methods because that's what people who don't use science accept.
I think that both [Skeptigirl] and JJM have missed the point of this exercise....

... The exercise isn't about evidence that the product is effective. It's about explaining something in a way that makes sense to the person asking the question. And I think it illustrates part of the reason why believers dismiss what skeptics have to say.

"Anecdotes" and an "N of 1" are evidence. They are evidence that a particular sequence of events happened. Sure, it's a logical fallacy to [assume causality], but our everyday experience tells us that most of the time "after this, therefore because of this" is true. The ball flies through the air because we threw it. Our toe hurts because we stubbed it on the coffee table.[*]

What it looked like to me, was that Remie recognized that even though she's a skeptic and made an effort to take cognitive bias and chance into consideration, it really seemed that her experience was consistent with other causal experiences; her headache went away because she used Head-On. And an explanation that takes that into account will be more satisfying than one that simply dismisses the connection as "not evidence".
(my bold) Notice fls even articulated what I identified as the underlying message in the way Remie's original question was posed.

Fls has the correct idea that an anecdote, while a sample size of one, is still a sample. I tried to point that out earlier. It isn't whether or not evidence comes in the form of an anecdote, it's how that evidence is systematically collected, analyzed, and whether it supports the conclusions drawn from it. But the next step is the problem I've been trying to point out. There is a difference between science and woo, not because one is 'out there' and the other isn't. The difference is in the methods used to determine reality, truth, effectiveness and so on.

JJM's comment on the same idea was
1) Bias against homeopathy is not merely cynical, it is based in knowledge of chemistry and physics, and a long history of clinical failure. So, it is reasonable for Remie to ask if the other ingredients are doing something. We can't answer this question; but it is doubtful.
We don't need to be acknowledging the acceptance of personal experience and anecdotal evidence to gain favor among the non-skeptics. We need to articulate what it is that makes a conclusion drawn on an anecdote valid or invalid. In addition, skeptics need to recognize what it is that makes something woo and what makes it science.

I merely pointed out the inconsistency that the anecdote implied consideration Headon relieved the headache while stating that wasn't being considered. And JJM merely commented on some specifics of such an investigation that appeared to be overlooked.

JJM and I were not saying the idea was flawed. I did suggest if you wanted to seriously look at the ingredients of Headon, you have to first show it does have an effect on headaches. JJM suggested you need more than an ingredient name. You need quantity and properties of any compound the ingredient might be bound into. Neither of those comments say the idea was flawed. They point out some of the issues to consider when inquiring about such a topic.

-

...I think many assumed "article" meant "scientific research paper."
The principles of science apply to the approach one uses in casual as well as formal investigation and speculation.

-

*The reason you know what caused the ball you threw to fly and that stubbing your toe was the cause of the pain is because much evidence preceded those events. There's a lot that can be elaborated on this issue that isn't relative to the problem at hand so I'll leave it for another day.
 
...The direct application of any chemical often has a far greater effect on the local area very often than on the whole circulatory system --- which is why nitro patches for a particular set of heart conditions are placed over or near the heart, not on your leg.
While there are drugs applied topically for a local effect, I am not aware of any cardiac condition where transdermal nitroglycerine is applied near the heart.

RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS:The clinical efficacy, the effect seen on plethysmography and the GTN plasma concentrations tended to increase after patch renewal, regardless of the application site of the renewed patch. Hence, cutaneous changes of clinical importance could not be demonstrated.

Should you be male, you can run a very simple test of this. Try putting a heart nitro patch on your willy; the effect will often be quite noticable. In the medical literature, it is described how one man actually did this, causing his wife to end up in medical treatment for a massive headache --- a headache the man did not share, and the difference is where and how the nitro was applied.
That headache difference would be due to genetics, tolerance , body weight, and perhaps because the vagina is lined with mucous membrane, not skin.

You can also take a bit of nitroglycerine, rub it around your leg.
Take half a day to observe any effects. Then run nitrogylcerine around your scalp. You will very certainly feel a big difference. This, BTW, is a favourite nasty trick in quarries and mines; rubbing a bit of nitro around inside the lining of a guy's hardhat. It gives the Mother Of All Headaches. Try it on your leg? Not a thing.
There are differences in vascularity and skin thickness in different anatomical sites.

However, I don't disagree there are local effects. Arterioles near the patch will deliver the drug to capillaries downstream which means local tissue. But the majority of transdermal nitroglycerine is absorbed and delivered systemically.
 
In response to JJMs points which were about the importance of the methods one uses in science, fls described many of the things that a skeptic should avoid yet advocated we use those methods because that's what people who don't use science accept.

That wasn't what I was advocating (at all). What exactly did you think I described that a skeptic should avoid?

Originally Posted by fls
I think that both [Skeptigirl] and JJM have missed the point of this exercise....

... The exercise isn't about evidence that the product is effective. It's about explaining something in a way that makes sense to the person asking the question. And I think it illustrates part of the reason why believers dismiss what skeptics have to say.

"Anecdotes" and an "N of 1" are evidence. They are evidence that a particular sequence of events happened. Sure, it's a logical fallacy to [assume causality], but our everyday experience tells us that most of the time "after this, therefore because of this" is true. The ball flies through the air because we threw it. Our toe hurts because we stubbed it on the coffee table.[*]

What it looked like to me, was that Remie recognized that even though she's a skeptic and made an effort to take cognitive bias and chance into consideration, it really seemed that her experience was consistent with other causal experiences; her headache went away because she used Head-On. And an explanation that takes that into account will be more satisfying than one that simply dismisses the connection as "not evidence".

Fls has the correct idea that an anecdote, while a sample size of one, is still a sample. I tried to point that out earlier. It isn't whether or not evidence comes in the form of an anecdote, it's how that evidence is systematically collected, analyzed, and whether it supports the conclusions drawn from it.

That's what I was referring to (part of it anyway).

But the next step is the problem I've been trying to point out. There is a difference between science and woo, not because one is 'out there' and the other isn't. The difference is in the methods used to determine reality, truth, effectiveness and so on.

Can you articulate what the "step" is that is the problem?

JJM's comment on the same idea was
We don't need to be acknowledging the acceptance of personal experience and anecdotal evidence to gain favor among the non-skeptics. We need to articulate what it is that makes a conclusion drawn on an anecdote valid or invalid.

Yes. That was what I was getting at. And that explaining why we get the impression of causality can help us frame the events in a way that allows the possibility of non-causality to make sense to non-skeptics.

*The reason you know what caused the ball you threw to fly and that stubbing your toe was the cause of the pain is because much evidence preceded those events.

Yes. The same kind of evidence that gives the impression that using Head-On relieved the headache.

Linda
 
While there are drugs applied topically for a local effect, I am not aware of any cardiac condition where transdermal nitroglycerine is applied near the heart.
Angina pectoris, owing to nitroglycerine's effect of relaxing the smooth fibers of the blood vessels, allowing the arteries to dilate. This treatment has been around for ages. The nitrates come in several forms. So I am very surprised you have not heard of it --- after all it was standard and widespread. What is your own field, professionally?
Here is a medicinenet article for you on it.
That headache difference would be due to genetics, tolerance , body weight, and perhaps because the vagina is lined with mucous membrane, not skin.
Actually it was the last which was the determinent factor in the case cited in the medical literature that I spoke of. The large area of exceedingly-well-vascularized mucous membrane in the vagina meant that the nitro was absorbed pretty much straight into the bloodstream and set on its way pretty directly --- resulting in the massive headache for the wife.
There are differences in vascularity and skin thickness in different anatomical sites.
However, I don't disagree there are local effects.
Yes and just as well, in view of your own notes here.
But the majority of transdermal nitroglycerine is absorbed and delivered systemically.
No, I disagree yet again. That really depends on how and where it is applied, which was my entire point.

Edited to add:
here is an interesting Wikipedia article on it all, which includes the interesting info that:
"A recent medical development will include a small amount of nitroglycerin in the tip of a new Durex condom to stimulate erection during intercourse. "The CSD500 condom contains a chemical in its teat, called glyceryl trinitrate (GTN), which is absorbed by the skin and causes blood vessels to dilate.""

Maybe you and JJM should be asking just why that is so arranged -- why the nitro is delivered, transdermally, inside the tip of a condom, rather than say systematically as pills.
 
Last edited:
Angina pectoris, owing to nitroglycerine's effect of relaxing the smooth fibers of the blood vessels, allowing the arteries to dilate. This treatment has been around for ages. The nitrates come in several forms. So I am very surprised you have not heard of it --- after all it was standard and widespread. What is your own field, professionally?
Here is a medicinenet article for you on it.
Right, but it doesn't matter where you place the patch. It doesn't have to be over the chest and, in fact, for men with hairy chests that's the worst place to put it. Patients are told to find a location that is relatively hairless, dry, and free of calluses (the upper arm is often recommended). Patients are also told to alternate sites to avoid skin irritation.

From the link that you provided:
Patches may be applied to any hairless site but should not be applied to areas with cuts or calluses.
 
Right, but it doesn't matter where you place the patch.
My entire point -- backed up with a few examples -- was that it does (to a degree) matter where you place it. To give the examples in summary again:

  • placing the patch (leastaways back in the old days when the doses where bigger and less time-delay managed) on your willy will give you a very different reaction than placing it on your arm or abdomen.
    .
  • placing the patch (leastaways back in the old days when the doses where bigger and less time-delay managed) on your upper head (in a hair-free part of the forehead for example) will give you a very different reaction than placing it on your arm or abdomen.

So I hope you now see just how the differences work.

A crucial point here, which I did not mention before since I though it was self-evident and well-known, is just how active the chemical is that you are applying, or how active it is in terms of the area you are applying it too, and whether it is direct or in time-delay managed holding mechanisms (such as capsules or in time-delay-giving compound form).

Applying a highly active chemical such as nitrates locally can result in strong local effects simply because the chemical is basically mostly used up at the point of delivery. That is the whole point of shoving it into the tip of a condom, the example I gave in my last post, an example so far ignored.

To give you another, simpler example: dropping some concentrated nitric acid on your hand will give you a strong local reaction, but the concentrated nitric acid (as long as it's in a small dose), while it is absorbed directly, will not act systematically simply because it is used up in reactions at the immediate point of delivery.
 
Last edited:
I was responding to this statement in the context of your larger point:

The direct application of any chemical often has a far greater effect on the local area very often than on the whole circulatory system --- which is why nitro patches for a particular set of heart conditions are placed over or near the heart, not on your leg.

Nitro patches can be placed anywhere, including on the leg. In fact, the leg is often recommended along with the upper arm as a good place for them.

Your larger point is not difficult to grasp. I merely took issue with your assertion that their location relative to the heart is a consideration when applying nitro patches.
 
My entire point -- backed up with a few examples -- was that it does (to a degree) matter where you place it. ...
Where are these examples published?

To give you another, simpler example: dropping some concentrated nitric acid on your hand will give you a strong local reaction, but the concentrated nitric acid (as long as it's in a small dose), while it is absorbed directly, will not act systematically [sic] simply because it is used up in reactions at the immediate point of delivery.
What do you mean by "absorbed," and where is this published?
 
Maybe you and JJM should be asking just why that is so arranged -- why the nitro is delivered, transdermally, inside the tip of a condom, rather than say systematically [sic] as pills.
I already explained that transderm drugs are applied near the affected site for the psychological benefit. I can't rule out some specific effect here; but innuendo is not persuasive. Do you have some data?
 
You can also take a bit of nitroglycerine, rub it around your leg.
Take half a day to observe any effects. Then run nitrogylcerine around your scalp. You will very certainly feel a big difference. This, BTW, is a favourite nasty trick in quarries and mines; rubbing a bit of nitro around inside the lining of a guy's hardhat. It gives the Mother Of All Headaches. Try it on your leg? Not a thing. ...
Literature citation?
 
:D I'm so glad.
I do wonder about the "easily satisfied" part, though. ;)
Because, very bluntly, my main point, which is the crux of the issue, appears to have been accepted by you. And that's all I care about.

Your initial post was confusing, because it looked in context of other posts like yet another meaningless quibble ignoring 75% of my post; your follow-up clarified things, and I could care less about the other minor point. You might be right, you might be wrong, I might be right, Imight be wrong; I could point out that in cases of cardiac insufficiency, you're quite possibly to be going to see other circulatory disease in the patient, even if only as secondary complications, and especially the legs get affected often, stress of odema a and so on, so if you started putting your heart patch down on your calf, you might well discover that the effective dose delivered to where it's needed --- where it's needed being the cardiac arteries --- is actually significantly lower than it would be if you placed the patch on the chest or back.

But the hell I should worry about a long discussion on patch placement for maximal effective dosage; you seem to have accepted the main point, which is that different placement can (dramatically) have different effects, and since that was all I was wanting to point out (and I still can't quite believe that so many posts revolve around such a simple little exercise), then I am bloody easily satisfied.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom