Miss Whiplash
Graduate Poster
- Joined
- May 9, 2006
- Messages
- 1,574
Goodness! You certainly missed the point. As did a few others. I am not the least bit upset. Guess I'll try another version.
I merely defended the people who replied with all the reasons the headache went away which were not addressing the question saying it might not have been because they didn't read the post. I merely noted the anecdote implied Remie was considering Headon actually had an effect. (Nothing to do with anyone's belief in homeopathy.)
If any of you happen to make it to this year's TAM, come to my Sunday presentation on "Cracking the Language Code - Deciphering hidden messages you didn't know you were sending and receiving."
Look again but take all those silly assumptions out of your filter.
Statement 1): I don't believe Headon works.
Statement 2): Could any of the ingredients in Headon work?
Logic: If you don't believe Headon works then why would you inquire about the ingredients working?
Compare that to
Statement 1): I don't believe homeopathy works.
Statement 2): Could something in Headon work and be misleading people into thinking homeopathy worked?
The second 2 statements are what Remie was asking. The first 2 were the ones she initially used. The listener (or reader) hears the hidden message and includes that in their reply. Remie thinks the reader isn't reading carefully. Maybe not, but the reason is the hidden message as much as it is the care in reading.
Remie expresses frustration that the readers are not reading carefully. But she isn't aware of the hidden message the original post included.
In your case, your filter is telling you everything I'm writing is critical and whining. But I am merely describing my observation about the hidden message. It isn't bad or good. It is an insight into something about the original post that isn't being consciously picked up on, but is being unconsciously picked up on by some readers.
My filter said this didn't sound like defending posters. It was more like a shrill scold:
You claim to not believe Headon ended your headache yet want to know if it could have. Then you get annoyed at all the replies which offer alternative explanations for your headache ending at the time you applied Headon. If you don't believe the product worked, then why would you be inquiring if any of the ingredients could be effective?
You are guilty of the same thing you claim the people posting here are guilty of, not reading the actual posts. You read, "A sample size of one doesn't meet my standards. So your report, while interesting, is not persuasive." and drew incorrect assumptions about the meaning of my post.
If you run a skeptic site, then I assume you understand skepticism isn't just discounting woo products and claims. It is understanding how one goes about determining what is woo and what isn't. I find skeptics understand evidence and false logic, but I can sometimes add additional observations which either aren't articulated so aren't noticed, or involve the bigger picture.
This is becoming very circular. You still have not addressed the point, why was it wrong of Remie to ask a simple question in the first place? Why did her phrasing get your knickers in a twist? All I'm seeing is excuses to back up your overreaction and I think that is what your filter is telling you. And around we shall go again.
My magic 8- ball says for your filter to fold instead of calling and cash in remaining chips.