Cl1mh4224rd
Philosopher
- Joined
- Dec 27, 2006
- Messages
- 9,778
There's a good chance this has been covered before, but I've seen a handful of people who aren't exactly sure why the "84% of Americans are Truthers" claim is a complete sham.
The claim originates from Alex Jones' website, on which is an article titled "Scientific Poll: 84% Reject Official 9/11 Story".
Now, here's the kicker: He links to the source of his numbers, which, when examined (not even closely) completely turns the claim on it's head.
Here's the actual question and results (source, linked to from Jones' own site):
Secondly, as anyone can see, Jones completely misrepresents the results of this poll. He shoehorns the "mostly telling the truth, but hiding something" and "Not sure" answers into "rejects the official account", where "Mostly lying" is the only answer that's even remotely relevant to his claim (keeping in mind, again, that this is about the government's statements of pre-9/11 knowledge and not the events on 9/11).
I can't even begin to believe that this could be an "honest mistake" (and one that hasn't been retracted in the 3 months since its posting). This was a deliberately constructed deception by Jones.
That it's so easily debunked is what makes this mind-boggling to me. Even worse is that people actually still believe it...
The claim originates from Alex Jones' website, on which is an article titled "Scientific Poll: 84% Reject Official 9/11 Story".
Now, here's the kicker: He links to the source of his numbers, which, when examined (not even closely) completely turns the claim on it's head.
Here's the actual question and results (source, linked to from Jones' own site):
Firstly, the question isn't even about the official account of events on September 11th. It's about what the government knew or didn't know prior to September 11th. He says it, but glosses over it.When it comes to what they knew prior to September 11th, 2001, about possible terrorist attacks against the United States, do you think members of the Bush Administration are telling the truth, are mostly telling the truth but hiding something, or are they mostly lying?
Telling the truth|16%
Hiding something|53%
Mostly lying|28%
Not sure|3%
Methodology: Telephone interviews with 983 American adults, conducted from Oct. 5 to Oct. 8, 2006. Margin of error is 4 per cent.
Secondly, as anyone can see, Jones completely misrepresents the results of this poll. He shoehorns the "mostly telling the truth, but hiding something" and "Not sure" answers into "rejects the official account", where "Mostly lying" is the only answer that's even remotely relevant to his claim (keeping in mind, again, that this is about the government's statements of pre-9/11 knowledge and not the events on 9/11).
I can't even begin to believe that this could be an "honest mistake" (and one that hasn't been retracted in the 3 months since its posting). This was a deliberately constructed deception by Jones.
That it's so easily debunked is what makes this mind-boggling to me. Even worse is that people actually still believe it...
Last edited:
