Introductory Physics Vs. 9/11 TRUTH!!!

A more appropriate equation would have been

Kinetic Energy=(0.5)m(v^2)

The problem with using F=ma is that an airplane traveling at a constant velocity has zero acceleration.

Steve S.


How about

F=deltap/t
where p=momentum , t= time

Thus the force on the tower perimeter would be the change in momentum of the aircraft mass as it passed through the perimeter frame divided by the time it took to do so.

OR

The force exerted on the building as a whole is the momentum of the aircraft divided by the time it took for all the aircraft mass to come to a stop within the building(minus that little bit for the parts that went right through)
 
Last edited:
A more appropriate equation would have been

Kinetic Energy=(0.5)m(v^2)

The problem with using F=ma is that an airplane traveling at a constant velocity has zero acceleration.

Steve S.
The F=ma equation isn't entirely inappropriate though, since there must be a force acting on the plane in order to maintain its speed and negate the decelleration due to the friction of the air it's travelling through. Your formula is just a lot simpler to use because you don't have to waste a whole ton of time trying to figure what that force is, since you already know those particular variables . . . (m & v)

:whistling

Not bad for just the first couple of chapters in, though.

A few years back when I was tutoring the gorgeous brunnette across the hall in Algebra, we both found out that they make you learn how to do some things the difficult way at the beginning. They were actually giving her quadratics to solve in like chapter 2, and when I was going over them with her, the text actually suggested that they figure the answers by guessing values for X and Y, trying to make each guess closer until your equation "worked". You were expected to show your work for this, as well.

Well, I went along with this for a little bit, it was fun enough, until we got to one a few problems later, where X and Y weren't integers. At that point I got fed up and showed her how to use the quadratic equation, which is how we proceeded for the rest of the assignment. It turns out that her professor actually wanted them to get fed up with quadratics, so that they would appreciate the formula more . . . when they learned it in Chapter 3. :boxedin:
 
I literally cannot understand how anyone can be this stupid. If you don't know how to calculate the expected free-fall (never mind it isn't free fall, the full calculation is way out of their league) time of an object over a given distance, don't do it! Half of being intelligent is knowing when you don't know squat, and should simply shut the heck up.

Can someone please honestly tell me: This is all a funny joke, right? There aren't really people that think this stuff out there, right?

Long ago I developed something I call the "Three Word Rule."

It's a philosophy that I live my life by, because without it, I would go absolutely [rule8]ing insane.

The three words are, "People are stupid"

It works something like this. I'll be at work and a customer will walk in the door:

Me: "Welcome to RadioShack, how can I help you?"
Customer: "Yes, I just remodeled my kitchen and it's all done with exposed beams. I need power in the breakfast nook and there is no way to hide the wires. Do you have any wireless electrical outlets?"

You see what happened there? The only way to maintain sanity is to say to myself, "People are stupid".

I see a deep fundamental lack of basic understanding of how the world in general operates on a daily basis.

Sometimes it sounds very CTish as well. I often have exchanges like this one:

Customer: "I don't know anything about this and I'm not sure if they make such a thing, but I need something that does X"
Me: "Yes sir, all you need is one of these."
Customer: "I don't think that's right. That doesn't make sense to me"

I was asked the question because, by nature of my job, I am the expert on the subject. Then my conclusions and recommendations are rejected because the first party, who admits they know nothing about the subject tries to apply what they feel to be "common sense".

This happens several times a day.

Basic, simple things become complex brain twisters for what seems to be an overwhelming majority of people I deal with.

Want to take a wild guess at what appears to be the single most difficult concept on the planet? Any device that is used inline with something else. Usually this applies to VCR's, answering machines and caller ID boxes.

Wall --> Wire --> Device --> Wire --> Device

I explain it. I draw pictures. I demonstrate it with items in the store. I am met with the confused gaze of a dog attempting to do calculus.

If the "Three Word Rule" is too harsh for you, then try this one. "Ignorance can be fixed, stupidity lasts a lifetime."
 
This is going to be a horrible, horrible re-tread of things that have been done to death in other threads, but it's been slow over here, and I'd just like to point something out or else I will probably go insane and hurt myself or others....Can someone please honestly tell me: This is all a funny joke, right? There aren't really people that think this stuff out there, right?

You will understand in time that the only acceptable Physics on this forum comes from politically orthodox contributors. The free fall thing has been done to death but I have posted on this previously and offer this slightly edited version of that explanation to you.

"Free fall means falling ONLY under the influence of gravity with no other forces being involved. In this pure state the object will fall at 9.81 metres per second squared regardless of mass. It will continue to accelerate at this rate unless acted upon by any other force.

If you were to take a weight and drop it in a vacuum from the height of the roof of the WTC at 411 metres from the ground then it will take 9.15 seconds to hit the ground.

The actual value of g for New York is 9.802 metres per second so the time to free fall would actually be 9.158 seconds."


ANY mass (starting from zero initial velocity) be it a feather, a biscuit or a cannonball falling only under the influence of gravity (acceleration due to gravitational force) in a vacuum (no air resistance) over a distance of 411 metres will take 9,15 seconds to travel that distance (depending upon which value of g is appropriate). That is the benchmark for the fall NOT the failure of the building.

It is very difficult for us to intuitively grasp terms like Joules and g so don't be phased and put off the mathematics by people quoting numbers like 10^11 Joules. It becomes even more confusing when Physicists revert to the energy model for falling objects (KE. PE etc) but again the mathematics is relatively easy to understand so don't be phased by it.

I believe that the intuitive question that that most people are asking themselves (amongst others) is how did those towers fall in a time so close to 9.15 seconds?
 
I believe that the intuitive question that that most people are asking themselves (amongst others) is how did those towers fall in a time so close to 9.15 seconds?

Do you consider 14+ seconds close to 9.2 seconds?

Time it yourself. This video starts after the collapse has started.

http://www.serendipity.li/wot/tower_collapsing4web.wmv

Also note that first debris hits the ground at least 5 seconds before collapse ends.
 
Last edited:
A more appropriate equation would have been

Kinetic Energy=(0.5)m(v^2)

The problem with using F=ma is that an airplane traveling at a constant velocity has zero acceleration.

Steve S.


Actually, F=ma is a perfectly valid equation to use, if you look at it right. Sure, the airplane starts off at a constant velocity. But it comes to a stop very quickly when it hits the building. This is a large (negatively valued, but don't confuse the CTers with this) acceleration. A large (de)acceleration multiplied by the large mass of the airplane equals a very large force imparted on the airplane.

Then invoke Newton's 3rd Law. If this force was imparted on the airplane by the building, then the same force was imparted on the building by the airplane.

But you're right, when figuring out why the structure failed, calculating energy is probably more worth your while. I just wanted to point out that Newton's 2nd does hold up.
 
It is very difficult for us to intuitively grasp terms like Joules and g so don't be phased and put off the mathematics by people quoting numbers like 10^11 Joules. It becomes even more confusing when Physicists revert to the energy model for falling objects (KE. PE etc) but again the mathematics is relatively easy to understand so don't be phased by it.

I believe that the intuitive question that that most people are asking themselves (amongst others) is how did those towers fall in a time so close to 9.15 seconds?

I think the word you are looking for is fazed unless your talking about something syncronized or electricity.
 
You will understand in time that the only acceptable Physics on this forum comes from politically orthodox contributors.

Politically correct physics?

What is this supposed to mean? Physics is physics. No one's political beliefs change it. This has got to be one of the most stupid things anyone has ever said!

It's going into the top quotes thread.

Wow. Just wow.
 
That's not a terribly good video to show the collapse time - the dust hides most of what's happening after a while. There's another one filmed from below the towers that has a pretty audible "thump" after about 14 seconds, though.

I didn't time it, but I estimate the debris falling ahead of the collapse front hits the ground at about 9 seconds into the video. By that time, the collapse front still has some 100-odd floors to travel, since it's about level with the surrounding buildings.
 
You will understand in time that the only acceptable Physics on this forum comes from politically orthodox contributors.
More tedious lecturing from William Rea. Yawn.

People here are quite open to correction. Please point out the errors you've found.

I don't recall seeing your calculations showing how fast the towers should have collapsed. Have you done that work?
 
That's not a terribly good video to show the collapse time - the dust hides most of what's happening after a while. There's another one filmed from below the towers that has a pretty audible "thump" after about 14 seconds, though.

I didn't time it, but I estimate the debris falling ahead of the collapse front hits the ground at about 9 seconds into the video. By that time, the collapse front still has some 100-odd floors to travel, since it's about level with the surrounding buildings.
100-odd floors? That's one slow collapse front. It went backwards!
 
That's not a terribly good video to show the collapse time - the dust hides most of what's happening after a while. There's another one filmed from below the towers that has a pretty audible "thump" after about 14 seconds, though.

Yes, there is no single good video. But when you consider that this video starts after the collapse starts and the video itself is 15 seconds long, 14 seconds is not unreasonable.

At 12 seconds into the video, right when the loud OMG is heard, you see the core drop behind the large brown building. (not counting the columns that stood for a while)

I would like to find the original source for this clip, since it looks like it starts a couple seconds into the collapse.

You should post the link to the "thump" video. If it is better, I would start using that to debunk the near free fall claim.
 
Last edited:
I believe that the intuitive question that that most people are asking themselves (amongst others) is how did those towers fall in a time so close to 9.15 seconds?

Because that is the time it takes to fall? Yes the most massive objects would fall close to the time in a vacuum because the force of the air is negligible for large masses. Yes large masses beat air by mass. Large mass vs not so massive air. Air lost!

As for the time of the towers falling it is wrong to say the towers fell in 10 seconds since major portions were still falling at 20 to 30 seconds.

It was funny at LCF they destoryed physics but they worked it out and finally agreed. But then they failed to connect the dots.
 
I saw this image from a "recent' physics exam:
elephantinthewayrg0.jpg

I couldn't help but laugh; but this one was funny as well (you know, its that maths stuff):

findxbl1.jpg



and an article on the declining quality in mathematics in the US:
http://www.kuro5hin.org/story/2007/1/25/174426/953

which pretty much describes the those in the Truth movement.
 
Oh, snap. Those are hilarious. :D

Of course X=5 on the second one, but I can't figure the first because of the damned elephant.
 
More tedious lecturing from William Rea. Yawn.

People here are quite open to correction. Please point out the errors you've found.

I don't recall seeing your calculations showing how fast the towers should have collapsed. Have you done that work?

Filed your post under I for ignore and R for report to the moderation. No more to say to you on the subject.
 
Politically correct physics?

What is this supposed to mean? Physics is physics. No one's political beliefs change it. This has got to be one of the most stupid things anyone has ever said!

It's going into the top quotes thread.

Wow. Just wow.

You deny that there is a scientific orthodoxy?

The rest of your post just about sums up the point I was making, but please if you are going to do that use the exact phrase in your immature little top quotes thread at least use what I typed and not what you would like to think I typed.
 
A more appropriate equation would have been

Kinetic Energy=(0.5)m(v^2)

The problem with using F=ma is that an airplane traveling at a constant velocity has zero acceleration.

Steve S.


How about

F=deltap/t
where p=momentum , t= time

Thus the force on the tower perimeter would be the change in momentum of the aircraft mass as it passed through the perimeter frame divided by the time it took to do so.

OR

The force exerted on the building as a whole is the momentum of the aircraft divided by the time it took for all the aircraft mass to come to a stop within the building(minus that little bit for the parts that went right through)

Isn't F=ma is practically the same as F=mv (yes, that probably doesn't exist, but that's how it's practically applied), or the very similar p=mv?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom