Fire leads to collapse of California highway overpass

Yawn. Well somebody's gotta do it:

damage control from Woo Central!

Comment: Debunkers are already using this to attack the 9/11 truth movement in claiming that this explains the collapse of the towers and WTC 7. Syndicated radio host Neil Boortz attacked Alex Jones this morning, claiming that this refutes the controlled demolition hypothesis. In reality, the freeway collapse is completely different and the comparison is ridiculous.
I can already hear defenders of the official account screaming "See, fire can cause a steel structure to collapse-the bridge collapsed!"

And that is what it shows. CT ers have been saying: "No steel structure has ever collapsed ue to fire", conviniently ignoring the many examples where they have. Well fellows, here is another example. Deal with it.

Comparing the circumstances surrounding the fire and subsequent partial collapse of this bridge to the circumstances surrounding the fires and subsequent complete collapse of the towers and WTC 7 is flawed from end to end.

There are a number of differences, yes. We are not the ones making generalized statements, however.

This fact should be obvious to most people; but let's point out a few things just in case they weren't already noticed.
1. This was an open air environment where flames were able to reach their absolute maximum temperature; white-hot and shooting upwards of 200 feet in the air.

Wrong. An open air environment is not the environment where you get the highest temperatures, exactly because it is open; heat is lost to the surroundings at a tremendous rate, and the in-rushing air cools the fire.

2. Those 200 foot flames were acting on a single support truss that was fastened to the two columns pictured here.

Wrong. That truss was not 200 ft in the air. The 200ft flames (probably a reporter exaggeration, btw, none of the pictures show flames of that size) indicate heat lost from the centre of the fire, where the truss was.

That truss (and the connectors that fastened it to the columns) represents a small fraction of the steel that would have been found on a single floor of the towers or WTC 7.

That truss was dimensioned to carry a much higher load than any steel member of the WTC.

So again, far more heat focused on a single truss and no way to redistribute the load once that truss was weakened.

The redistribution notion is nonsense. Steel is a fairly poor heat conductor, as metals go. So poor that a steel bar can be white hot in one end and cool enough to touch in the other.

3. You'll notice that despite the intense fires ability to weaken the truss and connectors that there is NO mention of molten metal in the debris.

Because, unlike the WTC, once the fuel fire burned out, there was no combustible material left.

Also, unlike the debris of the towers and WTC 7, it's not likely we're going to hear anything about thermate (specifically used to destroy steel columns) in the bridge debris.

We also did not hear of any thermate in the WTC debris. I know CTers try to claim various sulphur traces and slag is thermate residue, but to bring down the WTC buildings, tons of thermate would have been needed. Thermate works on a more or less pound to pound basis, that is, to melt a pound of steel, you need a pound of thermate, so if the WTC buildings were brought down by thermate, there would have to be hundreds of tons of it.

4. You'll notice that the concrete roadway that "pancaked down" on the roadway below did not cause the lower freeway to collapse. Nor has the concrete disintegrated into a fine powder.

There IS a difference between the behaviour of a two-storey structure and a 110 (or 47) storey structure. Do I need to explain the differences?

5. You'll notice the columns were not torn down by the collapse, nor did they evaporate into thin air, rather they are still standing (having only lost the the truss and connectors that held the roadway to them.)

And. What, in the WTC, evaporated into thin air (documentation required)?

Hans
 
Go to the link in Brainster's post then sit in the corner wearing a dunce cap for 30 minutes :)

Done and done, did some penance lashes too. Hope that will suffice.

ETA - Some people miss everything...

Actually I overlooked that there was a link in Brainster's post. I must be more tired than I thought.
 
Galvanized bolts may be used on bridges but they are NOT recommended for high temperature applications (See ASTM A325 or A490 Bolt Specification) because of possible zinc embrittlement.

By the way, did NIST do any surface/XRF/Auger analysis of WTC bolts, floor pans, floor concrete?
 
Galvanized bolts may be used on bridges but they are NOT recommended for high temperature applications (See ASTM A325 or A490 Bolt Specification) because of possible zinc embrittlement.

By the way, did NIST do any surface/XRF/Auger analysis of WTC bolts, floor pans, floor concrete?

Ok, I consulted with my brother, who has done bridge design for a company in texas for 20-some years. He's only an Civil engineer, not a chemist, but he does specifications.
Galvanized steel is generally not used in bridge construction. There are many reasons, but one must also consider that galvanization is a surface condition, and it can crack, leading to hidden corrosion, and that is a bad thing.
I would like to hear/see Crazy Chainsaw's galvanized steel test set-up, and I would also like to know more about the timing, distribution and quantity of the steel-zinc spheroids around WTC.
Nowhere have I doubted that the reactions described in total lack of detail do not occur. My question is in the time factor. We know that steel heated loses strength rapidly. Dr. G's apparent contention is that the chemical effects are great enough to be a major contributer. I see in the list of folks involved with the NIST report several fire safety experts.
Has anyone contacted them (Yes, I'm looking at you, Apollo20) to see if those things were considered?
As far as hydrogen release and burning go, I am still not convinced that the additional heat gained from the hydrogen is greater that that required to actually liberate the hydrogen. I need more on this.
So far, nothing anyone has said, without any evidence, or even theoretical equations, to back it up, has done anything to convince me that chemical reactions were of any great importance in any of the collapses under discussion.
 
The chemical energy released by the reactions of iron and zinc with HCl and O2 on the fire-affected floors of WTC 1 & 2 was about ten times LARGER than the potential energy released by the first one story drop of the upper section of WTC 1. So the CHEMICAL energies liberated in the WTC collapse were far larger than the gravitational energies.

And no one has answered my question about NIST's analysis of bolts and concrete, yet I have been assured NIST found no evidence for embrittlement.

And we haven't even talked about embrittlement of the welds.

And finally, I HAVE contacted NIST and been completely ignored!

Other scientists have, however, been most helpful including Profs Bazant, Cahill, and Barnett, etc, etc...
 
Ok, I consulted with my brother, who has done bridge design for a company in texas for 20-some years. He's only an Civil engineer, not a chemist, but he does specifications.
Galvanized steel is generally not used in bridge construction. There are many reasons, but one must also consider that galvanization is a surface condition, and it can crack, leading to hidden corrosion, and that is a bad thing.
I would like to hear/see Crazy Chainsaw's galvanized steel test set-up, and I would also like to know more about the timing, distribution and quantity of the steel-zinc spheroids around WTC.
Nowhere have I doubted that the reactions described in total lack of detail do not occur. My question is in the time factor. We know that steel heated loses strength rapidly. Dr. G's apparent contention is that the chemical effects are great enough to be a major contributer. I see in the list of folks involved with the NIST report several fire safety experts.
Has anyone contacted them (Yes, I'm looking at you, Apollo20) to see if those things were considered?
As far as hydrogen release and burning go, I am still not convinced that the additional heat gained from the hydrogen is greater that that required to actually liberate the hydrogen. I need more on this.
So far, nothing anyone has said, without any evidence, or even theoretical equations, to back it up, has done anything to convince me that chemical reactions were of any great importance in any of the collapses under discussion.

The metal is the energy source, as is the Oxygen in the air the Hydrogen is just the way to get the energy out of the metal. Eventually the metal reacts on its own with steam to produce hydrogen and heat. If the metal get hot enough it can also burn spontaneously like in a chimney effect.
 
429truth3fi5.jpg


WAKE UP TEH SHEEPLE!!!!!!!1111
 
The chemical energy released by the reactions of iron and zinc with HCl and O2 on the fire-affected floors of WTC 1 & 2 was about ten times LARGER than the potential energy released by the first one story drop of the upper section of WTC 1. So the CHEMICAL energies liberated in the WTC collapse were far larger than the gravitational energies.
You and Crazy Chainsaw keep asserting this, but when asked about volumes and concentrations,as well as origins of the HCl, there is silence.
How much HCl gas do you figure was generated, and why, with a great roaring fire down below, did it stick around with all those broken windows to exit from?

Secondly, with the sulfur noted in the piles, why would not the sulfur burn, and the combustion products mix with all that water, forming sulfuric acid, which has a much stronger effect on carbon steel than HCl does?
And no one has answered my question about NIST's analysis of bolts and concrete, yet I have been assured NIST found no evidence for embrittlement.
NIST also did not mention the lack of evidence of laser cutting, thermonuclear devices, pink pixies, or invading aliens from somewhere in Orion.
The facts are what they are. You state what is there, not what is not.

And we haven't even talked about embrittlement of the welds.

And finally, I HAVE contacted NIST and been completely ignored!

Other scientists have, however, been most helpful including Profs Bazant, Cahill, and Barnett, etc, etc...
Ok, how about some links to what they say about all you are postulating. It would be most helpful.
ETA: And in re: your first paragraph: How does the chemical energy get turned into kinetic energy in the open system that is the towers? AFAICT, it would simply be imbedded in the heat exiting the building--the heat that already exists from the chemical reaction of oxygenand existing and imported hydrocarbons
 
Last edited:
You and Crazy Chainsaw keep asserting this, but when asked about volumes and concentrations,as well as origins of the HCl, there is silence.
How much HCl gas do you figure was generated, and why, with a great roaring fire down below, did it stick around with all those broken windows to exit from?

That would depend on how many computer, how much carpeting, How many PVC pipes and Vinyl Chloride plastics were used in the buildings, probably a lot.


Secondly, with the sulfur noted in the piles, why would not the sulfur burn, and the combustion products mix with all that water, forming sulfuric acid, which has a much stronger effect on carbon steel than HCl does?

There are lead acid batteries in the buildings as well as a lot of sulfur from other sources including the fuels that have been stored for decades we are looking at both types of acids but once the sulfur combines with Calcium it become calcium sulfate, gypsum.
However HCl becomes Calcium Chloride that reacts with Zinc to form Zinc Chloride.

One of the reason not to use galvanized bolts on bridges is because calcium salts cause Zinc desegregation and possible hydrogen embrittlement in micro fractures, if Zinc invades the micro fractures under the oxide layer then Zinc embrittlement occurs in the bolts.

NIST also did not mention the lack of evidence of laser cutting, thermonuclear devices, pink pixies, or invading aliens from somewhere in Orion.
The facts are what they are. You state what is there, not what is not.
That was just stupid chemical reactions are likely, and what you just mentioned is fantasy not reality please come back to it.

Ok, how about some links to what they say about all you are postulating. It would be most helpful.

I will see if I can find some for you a little later today.
 
Sigh,
~enigma~, I'm sorry, but that is too good a "Stundie" material to let pass. No hard feelings, 'ol buddie, 'ol pal?:D
That is fine but it is a question that I would like to hear Apollo answer. You see to me it appears that he has no idea what a trawman is nor do I think he understands that silence does not necessarily mean disagreement.
 
That is fine but it is a question that I would like to hear Apollo answer. You see to me it appears that he has no idea what a trawman is nor do I think he understands that silence does not necessarily mean disagreement.

Oh, I agree with you--I would like to know how he contacted them, and his wording. In this actual case, does ignore mean that he got nothing in return (truly ignored) or a response that his ideas were being taken into consideration, or that his ideas had no merit, or that they had ben previously considered and found to have no significance... Just what dos ignored mean, here? I have a sneaking suspicion that anything other than O my Gawd! How could we have missed that!" will/would be less than acceptable in this case.
But, on the other hand,
I know that when I get a letter or email that begins with words tot the effect "You Idiot, you haven't a clue...", unless it is from my boss, I tend to ignore it.
 
Oh, I agree with you--I would like to know how he contacted them, and his wording. In this actual case, does ignore mean that he got nothing in return (truly ignored) or a response that his ideas were being taken into consideration, or that his ideas had no merit, or that they had ben previously considered and found to have no significance... Just what dos ignored mean, here? I have a sneaking suspicion that anything other than O my Gawd! How could we have missed that!" will/would be less than acceptable in this case.
But, on the other hand,
I know that when I get a letter or email that begins with words tot the effect "You Idiot, you haven't a clue...", unless it is from my boss, I tend to ignore it.
My boss once said that to me but he didn't expect the backlash...HR promoted me to manager and demoted him to assistant manager. Needless to say he resigned about a week later....
 
Do you guys not understand what the word "ignored" means?

It means I received NO answer to a 16 page report that was received with great interest by Profs Cahill, Bazant and Barnett..... In fact two of these gentlemen phoned me to discuss my work!

As for links, I can only give you references to peer-reviewed papers in journals of science, engineering, physics, and chemistry.

But I guess you googlescientists are too lazy to go look them up!


Apollo20, keep things civil; don't personalize the discussion by adding insults. I'll leave the first and fourth sentences intact this time for your benefit, but keep this kind of commentary out of your responses, please.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: jmercer
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Do you guys not understand what the word "ignored" means?
What was this immature attack for? I must say that I am not surprised if anybody chooses to ignore you when it is clear to me and others that you have a really bad attitude.
 
I think rwquinn doesn't want to do your work for you in proving your theory.

Anyway, I'm not sure I follow. Wouldn't NIST have mentioned something like chemical reactions on that scale if it had found evidence of them?
Why would they look for evidence of a chemical reaction? You do realize that in the case of the wtc that would be akin to searching for evidence that gravity makes things fall...IOW a total waste of time and resources not to mention that it wasn't a stated goal of the report Apollo's slanderously calls nothing more than a feel-good attempt to explain building codes.
 
But I guess you googlescientists are too lazy to go look them up!

Gee, with snips like this I wonder why they haven't bother to get back to you?:rolleyes:

Again you persist with insults when you have so far shown little of your actual work. I don't deny that you've done it, but you are still playing coy little games with it.

So again I say: GROW UP!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom