MRC_Hans
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Aug 28, 2002
- Messages
- 24,967
Yawn. Well somebody's gotta do it:
And that is what it shows. CT ers have been saying: "No steel structure has ever collapsed ue to fire", conviniently ignoring the many examples where they have. Well fellows, here is another example. Deal with it.
There are a number of differences, yes. We are not the ones making generalized statements, however.
Wrong. An open air environment is not the environment where you get the highest temperatures, exactly because it is open; heat is lost to the surroundings at a tremendous rate, and the in-rushing air cools the fire.
Wrong. That truss was not 200 ft in the air. The 200ft flames (probably a reporter exaggeration, btw, none of the pictures show flames of that size) indicate heat lost from the centre of the fire, where the truss was.
That truss was dimensioned to carry a much higher load than any steel member of the WTC.
The redistribution notion is nonsense. Steel is a fairly poor heat conductor, as metals go. So poor that a steel bar can be white hot in one end and cool enough to touch in the other.
Because, unlike the WTC, once the fuel fire burned out, there was no combustible material left.
We also did not hear of any thermate in the WTC debris. I know CTers try to claim various sulphur traces and slag is thermate residue, but to bring down the WTC buildings, tons of thermate would have been needed. Thermate works on a more or less pound to pound basis, that is, to melt a pound of steel, you need a pound of thermate, so if the WTC buildings were brought down by thermate, there would have to be hundreds of tons of it.
There IS a difference between the behaviour of a two-storey structure and a 110 (or 47) storey structure. Do I need to explain the differences?
And. What, in the WTC, evaporated into thin air (documentation required)?
Hans
damage control from Woo Central!
Comment: Debunkers are already using this to attack the 9/11 truth movement in claiming that this explains the collapse of the towers and WTC 7. Syndicated radio host Neil Boortz attacked Alex Jones this morning, claiming that this refutes the controlled demolition hypothesis. In reality, the freeway collapse is completely different and the comparison is ridiculous.
I can already hear defenders of the official account screaming "See, fire can cause a steel structure to collapse-the bridge collapsed!"
And that is what it shows. CT ers have been saying: "No steel structure has ever collapsed ue to fire", conviniently ignoring the many examples where they have. Well fellows, here is another example. Deal with it.
Comparing the circumstances surrounding the fire and subsequent partial collapse of this bridge to the circumstances surrounding the fires and subsequent complete collapse of the towers and WTC 7 is flawed from end to end.
There are a number of differences, yes. We are not the ones making generalized statements, however.
This fact should be obvious to most people; but let's point out a few things just in case they weren't already noticed.
1. This was an open air environment where flames were able to reach their absolute maximum temperature; white-hot and shooting upwards of 200 feet in the air.
Wrong. An open air environment is not the environment where you get the highest temperatures, exactly because it is open; heat is lost to the surroundings at a tremendous rate, and the in-rushing air cools the fire.
2. Those 200 foot flames were acting on a single support truss that was fastened to the two columns pictured here.
Wrong. That truss was not 200 ft in the air. The 200ft flames (probably a reporter exaggeration, btw, none of the pictures show flames of that size) indicate heat lost from the centre of the fire, where the truss was.
That truss (and the connectors that fastened it to the columns) represents a small fraction of the steel that would have been found on a single floor of the towers or WTC 7.
That truss was dimensioned to carry a much higher load than any steel member of the WTC.
So again, far more heat focused on a single truss and no way to redistribute the load once that truss was weakened.
The redistribution notion is nonsense. Steel is a fairly poor heat conductor, as metals go. So poor that a steel bar can be white hot in one end and cool enough to touch in the other.
3. You'll notice that despite the intense fires ability to weaken the truss and connectors that there is NO mention of molten metal in the debris.
Because, unlike the WTC, once the fuel fire burned out, there was no combustible material left.
Also, unlike the debris of the towers and WTC 7, it's not likely we're going to hear anything about thermate (specifically used to destroy steel columns) in the bridge debris.
We also did not hear of any thermate in the WTC debris. I know CTers try to claim various sulphur traces and slag is thermate residue, but to bring down the WTC buildings, tons of thermate would have been needed. Thermate works on a more or less pound to pound basis, that is, to melt a pound of steel, you need a pound of thermate, so if the WTC buildings were brought down by thermate, there would have to be hundreds of tons of it.
4. You'll notice that the concrete roadway that "pancaked down" on the roadway below did not cause the lower freeway to collapse. Nor has the concrete disintegrated into a fine powder.
There IS a difference between the behaviour of a two-storey structure and a 110 (or 47) storey structure. Do I need to explain the differences?
5. You'll notice the columns were not torn down by the collapse, nor did they evaporate into thin air, rather they are still standing (having only lost the the truss and connectors that held the roadway to them.)
And. What, in the WTC, evaporated into thin air (documentation required)?
Hans