The LOST ACE - No Planer Pleads for Austrian Libertarians to Lend An Ear

Go look at the tornado link I provided, especially the picture of a vinyl record album embedded in the telephone pole. Would you seriously consider a telephone pole that porous?

First of all yes, the telephone pole may well have had a crack in it. Second, the record didn't sever the telephone pole, and then disintegrate itself. Both things are still present.

On 9/11 we are supposed to believe that the jet plane cut a cartoon cutout shape of itself through steel beams and concrete floors with steel pans, and yet also disintegrated into confetti. Impossible.
 
It's a box column. The walls of the box column may be 1.3 in thick, but you must consider the strength of the whole box. I'd be willing to bet money you're wrong. Real names only.

Where's Ryan Murrill Mackey?

You keep referring to "light weight wing tips", ignoring the fact that the leading edge of an airliner is incredibly strong and braced with spars reaching back across the entire width of the wing. The leading edges of a 767 are also rather thick - about 2m at the wing roots and still almost 1m thick well past the engines.

You paper-scissors-stone understanding of material hardness bears no relationship to reality.

-Gumboot
 
First of all yes, the telephone pole may well have had a crack in it. Second, the record didn't sever the telephone pole, and then disintegrate itself. Both things are still present.

On 9/11 we are supposed to believe that the jet plane cut a cartoon cutout shape of itself through steel beams and concrete floors with steel pans, and yet also disintegrated into confetti. Impossible.


You really do not understand basic physics, and have earlier proven that you cannot interpret basic photographic data (based on the discussion you earlier abandoned). It is no longer reasonable to discuss these types of things with you. Thanks for playing.
 
As I've said before, your video interpretation skills leave a lot to be desired. -Gumboot

You've also said that the debris did not look like the nose of a 767. THe following have some pictures of the nose of a 767, and some of the debris. If the debris doesn't look like the nose of a 767, then which are which?

PinocchioChoice.jpg
 
Yes. And houses. And private schools.
That is good.

But you do not understand how fast Flight 175 was going. It was moving at 865 feet a second. The kinetic energy was equal to 2100 pounds of TNT, that is 3,300,000,000 joules. That is enough energy to cut all, every singe column in the WTC section. That is why the plane entered the steel shell of the WTC, the energy was like a big bomb. Believe me in desert storm I saw some explosions and the impact of the plane was like an explosion cutting through the steel. Just as in all impacts. Like a bb cutting into a steel can, flight 175 cut into the WTC due to speed.

Energy is proportional to the velocity squared. That mean if you are going 30 miles per hour and hit something the energy would be a value K. If you speed up to 60 mph, the energy value would be 4K. The velocity of Flight 175 was responsible for the great damage.

I know you are not going to get this so good luck on telling lies, but beam weapons and no planes are ideas never to be supported by facts and evidence from 9/11.
 
Wrong answer.

Ah, yes, It appears that I had them reversed. But I'm correct in how I grouped them, and in stating that the two sets look distinctly different.

If it was a glitch in a computer-generated image, causing the computer image to start appearing on the other side of the building, why would it look different on the other side?

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
First of all yes, the telephone pole may well have had a crack in it. Second, the record didn't sever the telephone pole, and then disintegrate itself. Both things are still present.

On 9/11 we are supposed to believe that the jet plane cut a cartoon cutout shape of itself through steel beams and concrete floors with steel pans, and yet also disintegrated into confetti. Impossible.


It wasn't a cartoon cut out of itself. You seem to have an obsession with making observations about 9/11 that everyone except you is oblivious to.

-Gumboot
 
You've also said that the debris did not look like the nose of a 767. THe following have some pictures of the nose of a 767, and some of the debris. If the debris doesn't look like the nose of a 767, then which are which?

PinocchioChoice.jpg
The dust and debris blown out the windows on 9/11 due to flight 175 was not a nose cone or fake. Each video picked up the dust and debris blown out the windows of WTC. The plane was going over 800 feet per second. The force of the impact forced debris out the windows. The nose cone of a 757/767 is made of plastic/fiberglass to cover the radar system of the aircraft. The nose cone would be gone on impact, into tiny pieces. Your 757/767 nose-cone does not exist on impact. The debris field from a distance looks like something due to resolution of the video and the light from the different angles and the difference due to cameras and distance.

You are trying to make up junk about 9/11 with a few pixels of low quality video. No way your ideas on the subject can be true.
 
Ah, yes, It appears that I had them reversed. But I'm correct in how I grouped them, and in stating that the two sets look distinctly different.

If it was a glitch in a computer-generated image, causing the computer image to start appearing on the other side of the building, why would it look different on the other side?

Respectfully,
Myriad
How did they make the CGI show up on different video cameras at the same time? How did they make the CGI show up in people eyes and brains? I have to get some of this CGI software that infects all people and cameras at the same time in real time. What would it be called?

More lies from 9/11 truth? Why am I posting to TS, what is wrong with me?
 
That is good.

But you do not understand how fast Flight 175 was going. It was moving at 865 feet a second. The kinetic energy was equal to 2100 pounds of TNT, that is 3,300,000,000 joules. That is enough energy to cut all, every singe column in the WTC section. That is why the plane entered the steel shell of the WTC, the energy was like a big bomb. Believe me in desert storm I saw some explosions and the impact of the plane was like an explosion cutting through the steel. Just as in all impacts. Like a bb cutting into a steel can, flight 175 cut into the WTC due to speed.

Energy is proportional to the velocity squared. That mean if you are going 30 miles per hour and hit something the energy would be a value K. If you speed up to 60 mph, the energy value would be 4K. The velocity of Flight 175 was responsible for the great damage.

I know you are not going to get this so good luck on telling lies, but beam weapons and no planes are ideas never to be supported by facts and evidence from 9/11.

Oh, I get it. I don't know if your numbers are right, but I get the premise.
So the jet was "like a BB cutting into a steel can", was it? BBs can sure cut a BB-shaped hole in a can. Do BBs disintegrate afterwards? No. They are relatively intact. So the plane would be relatively intact. How then does it stop inside the building?

Whatever force is felt by the building will be felt by the plane. Show me how you arrived at your TNT numbers. Thanks.
 
Keep it up, Ace. Your posts singlehandedly discredit the "truth" movement so thoroughly on the topics upon which you opine that the rest of us can focus our efforts on other stupid twoofer theories. Well done, indeed, Agent Ace. (Your bonus cheque is in the mail.)
 
Last edited:
Ah, yes, It appears that I had them reversed. But I'm correct in how I grouped them, and in stating that the two sets look distinctly different.

If it was a glitch in a computer-generated image, causing the computer image to start appearing on the other side of the building, why would it look different on the other side?

Respectfully,
Myriad

No Myriad, if you reverse your answer, it is still wrong.

Anyone else?
 
Whatever force is felt by the building will be felt by the plane. Show me how you arrived at your TNT numbers. Thanks.

It's actually slightly higher than he says, it's 3.8x109J, or 3.8GJ.

This is calculated using KE = 1/2mv2
Empty mass of a 767-222 is 80,100kg, + 30,900kg fuel (10,000gallons at 6.54 lbs/gal) and velocity of 263ms-1 (590MPH).

I fail to see how you can claim "whatever force is felt by the building will be felt by the plane" and yet simultaneously declare that either the exterior columns or the aircraft should be undamaged by their collision. This is ridiculous. Clearly both are severely damaged by the impact.

-Gumboot
 
Ace,
Well, aside from the fact that a BB is solid and spherical, and thus will not behave as an airplane or airplane wing, your BB analogy is perfect for disproving you, even in terms that your own logic should be able to handle. (You can take a picture of it if it helps.)

Change the dimensions of the BB so that it's more like the blade of a sickle (in shape, not size). Then fill that soda can with vertical pieces, say metal screws for nice irregular surfaces, and horizontally, put in some pieces of emery paper. Now find the undamaged sickle/BB when you shoot it into that can. It would be totally deformed and if you were able, you'd find little pieces of it all over various newly created hard edges. Yet, it would probably leave a nice cut in the outside of the can, very similar to the original shape of the projectile.

The "cutout" that you see, which does have the rough outline of a plane, is on the external (read "softer") cladding. If you look at pictures from later in the day, where you can see the interior, it's quite clear that that impression is only on the surface of the tower.
 
It's actually slightly higher than he says, it's 3.8x109J, or 3.8GJ.

This is calculated using KE = 1/2mv2
Empty mass of a 767-222 is 80,100kg, + 30,900kg fuel (10,000gallons at 6.54 lbs/gal) and velocity of 263ms-1 (590MPH).

I fail to see how you can claim "whatever force is felt by the building will be felt by the plane" and yet simultaneously declare that either the exterior columns or the aircraft should be undamaged by their collision. This is ridiculous. Clearly both are severely damaged by the impact.

-Gumboot

I'm not the one who says the plane would be undamaged, it was whats his name up thread, who said it was like a BB going through a can. I'm the one who says the plane would by far get the worst of it, due to its being significantly weaker than stuctural steel.

An important concept is the reciprocal nature of the damage. Colliding objects do not mutually anihilate one another. Since we see a cutout shape of a plane, if we are to believe that a plane created this damage, we would reason that the plane must have remained relatively intact. Of course it is absurd to think that a plane would remain intact on such a collision. It would break in to bits.

Funny, we sure don't see the plane breaking into bits at all, do we? No. We don't see any damage to the plane whatsoever. And we don't see any damage to the building until after the plane is already inside.

Hence, impossible physics.
 
Hence, impossible physics.
The problem is not with the physics but rather your understanding of it.

And in any event, how is your theory more probable? How exactly do you account for multiple videos from multiple angles all showing a jetliner flying in and smashing into the building? You've got angles from close and far away, from every vantage point, including from helicopters. You've got recordings from professional cameramen as well as private individuals just using their personal camcorders. Then there's all the still camera photos of the event, and of course all the many, many eyewitnesses who saw the event occur exactly as it was recorded on videotape and film.

You have as yet to establish any sort of viable theory to explain that.
 
An important concept is the reciprocal nature of the damage. Colliding objects do not mutually anihilate one another.


Tell that to a police officer who has ever attended a high speed head-on collision.



Since we see a cutout shape of a plane


We don't, and this is where your theory disintegrates into dust. The resulting hole is not plane-shaped, it is a reflection of the mass distribution of an aircraft - that is a large hole in the middle across the engine/fuselage area with narrowing damage towards peripherals. It is not plane shaped. Not even remotely. This should be obvious. To you it isn't. I can't explain why.



if we are to believe that a plane created this damage, we would reason that the plane must have remained relatively intact. Of course it is absurd to think that a plane would remain intact on such a collision. It would break in to bits.


Yes, and it does.




Funny, we sure don't see the plane breaking into bits at all, do we? No. We don't see any damage to the plane whatsoever.


No, of course we don't see the aircraft break into bits. Once it passes the line of the exterior columns it is inside the building. Bereft of x-ray vision, we cannot see what is happening inside. However one or two eyewitnesses were inside the building at that spot, and lived to tell. They reported the aircraft breaking into pieces.

You're following the same flawed reasoning that suggests an enormous asteroid smashing to earth can be blow up. If the aircraft is ripped into fragments, those fragments are still travelling at 200+ m/s. They will be well inside the building before they've slowed any considerable amount.

As stated, once those fragments are inside the building, we can't see them.





And we don't see any damage to the building until after the plane is already inside.

There are actually a few higher-resolution videos of UA175's impact where you can see some damage before the aircraft has entirely entered the building.

The problem is most of the video is of very poor quality, and lacking the resolution required to resolve that sort of detail. As a result, we can only see the general gaping hole, which, while the plane is still entering the building, is obviously obscured by the aircraft.

-Gumboot
 
It's actually slightly higher than he says, it's 3.8x109J, or 3.8GJ.

This is calculated using KE = 1/2mv2
Empty mass of a 767-222 is 80,100kg, + 30,900kg fuel (10,000gallons at 6.54 lbs/gal) and velocity of 263ms-1 (590MPH).


-Gumboot

Now, I think you know the deception involved in using this equation. You are ignoring the energy release time, or power. 4 pounds of high explosives has about the same amount of energy as a pound and a quarter of wood being burned, which is about 8 MJ. Can the burning wood do the same destructive damage as the high explosive? No. Why? Because the explosive will release all of its energy in about 4 microseconds, the wood takes a long time to burn.

So to understand the energy release in the collision, we have to know how fast the material decelerates. We can't assume all of the Kinetic energy present in the plane simply goes at the steel beams all at once. How absurd.

So, do we see the plane decelerate very quickly, allowing for a large energy release over a short period of time? No. We see a plane that does not decelerate at all. Which is impossible. Which is why we know the videos were faked.
 
Last edited:
Oh, I get it. I don't know if your numbers are right, but I get the premise.
So the jet was "like a BB cutting into a steel can", was it? BBs can sure cut a BB-shaped hole in a can. Do BBs disintegrate afterwards? No. They are relatively intact. So the plane would be relatively intact. How then does it stop inside the building?

Whatever force is felt by the building will be felt by the plane. Show me how you arrived at your TNT numbers. Thanks.
Any one who can calculate the TNT numbers, even you could but you will not.

Okay, I will get an Al bb and a steel can and show you how the can and bb are damaged, a hole in the can, and a damaged al bb. I have a mind that can imagine using physics, you have something not even letting you calculate the energy of an aircraft impact, why?

You take 1/2MVV. I was done for you. I assumed you have the numbers since you are making up lies. You must have the speed on flight 77 it was going 590 mph, which can be calculated from the videos. You can get the weight because by FAA regulations the gross weight at takeoff has to be calculated and exact. 125,917 kilograms for aircraft weight, you have to add people and luggage. Or use 250 pounds for people to include luggage.

OOPs it was 4,380,000,000 joules for 2100 pound of TNT energy for the impact of flight 175. There are 4,184,000,000 joules in a ton of TNT.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom