The LOST ACE - No Planer Pleads for Austrian Libertarians to Lend An Ear

The B-52 doesn't explode immediately on impact either. I'm very familiar with that footage on a frame by frame basis thanks to Killtown's UA93 thread.

The Panther is also a poor example for a number of reasons. Firstly, likewise, it does not explode immediately on impact either, secondly, it did not use the same type of fuel, lastly the Panther was so fuel-hungry it had fuel loaded in the fuselage and entire length of the wings, plus had fuel tanks in pods on the wingtips.

-Gumboot
 
Make up your mind, you said there was no plane, now you want to study the plane hitting the WTC?

Your study shows the plane did decelerate, darn, Did you know the engines were still working until they hit the building? That means if the full throttle thrust was greater than the plane and the building destruction energy, the plane continued to accelerate or go steady until the engines stopped producing thrust.

Seems like an important point to me that the "study" ignores.


With Apologies to Keith and Mick

Paint It Fade to Black

I look inside myself and my heart says "fade to black"
No I'm not retarded, not even smokin' crack
Maybe then Ill fade away and not have to face the facts
Its not easy facin up when your whole world is black

Why can't you understand I know what is true
I could not foresee this vision happening to you
If I look hard enough into the morning sun
I'm sure I can see a space beam laser gun


ETA: I didn't touch the three bolded lines, and barely did the last verse... Those lines were my strange inspiration for this bad attempt at being Weird Al.

I think this is pretty darn good. Especially the stanza I'm quoting here.
Made me laugh.

Ace, the exterior column plate thickness was 3/8''. The weakness of the columns were at there bolted connections. The cross sectional area of the four bolts was only 12% of the cross sectional area of the column plates. The connections were designed to hold the columns in place, not to resist the impact of a 100 ton airliner traveling at 500+ mph. These connections offered little resistance to the impacts, it's no wonder the planes appeared to pass through the walls like ghosts.

I'm curious as to how you define reality. With your exceedingly high standard of proof, can you possibly give an example of an event that would meet it? Did Mount St. Helens erupt? Did Jesus rise from the dead? If yes to either question please explain.

two good points. Ace seems to be relying on "logic" a little too much.

I believe it was Hans who said something to the effect that logic operates independently of reality, but makes no sense without reality...


But that will leave Ace chattering about little more than soundtracks to "Barbie" videos. The (I might add) horror!

I, for one, think he might have useful things to say, such as:

1) what kind of monitors he uses for mixing
2) whether he likes to mix loud or soft, or both
3) whether he worries about phase-cancellation when going to mono

4) his overall approach to timing to picture--in the artistic, not the technical sense--and how he thinks about continuity.
5) how he scores around dialog and sync-sound--does he use certain instruments or registers?
6) how he thinks about the overall emotional arc of the picture and how to support it
7) how he feels about having to work in a highly competitive, commercial environment--are there professional tips he could give to young film-composers?

stuff like that.


Because, otherwise, I get the impression he's saying that 2 large airplanes did NOT hit the WTC. That takes much more imagination than I have.

This won't turn on precisely what is being ejected from the other side of the building: Either it's debris, oval-shaped debris, or--surprisingly--the nose-cone of the plane before it disintegrates. More likely, it's a heavy object like an engine--which is more or less oval-shaped.

None of these options is more incredible than faking video footage from some 40 angles, and projecting a hologram into the minds of the thousands of eye-witnesses.

Call me naive. It's true.

p.s.
Here's a little quote from American Ground. I'd like to know if the MIT study has been discredited.

pg 56. "An MIT study later estimated that only 6 % of the plane's kinetic energy was expended against the south face. Almost all of the rest of the energy was expended inside..."

and he describes how one person inside the tower actually survived the tower falling. The point is that in any chaotic situation like a tornado or a tower collapse, anomalous things happen.
 
Last edited:
Then we have this video which was shown on numerous stations, live. It shows the same phenomenon that you claim the WNWY engineer tried to hide. Yet this video contains no blip. Why did the engineers not bother to fade this one?


Well, for what it's worth, I'm pretty sure that no-blip video was coming from WCBS, which was also on the North Tower, although it had a backup facility at the Empire State Building that it switched to later. (If I remember right, the WCBS footage was the one being carried live on CNN and several other news stations when the actual South Tower strike occurred, and only later did they get other footage from outlets like WABC to show the South Tower hit from different angles.) The seemingly simultaneous WNYW and WABC blips seem pretty damning nonetheless. Also, the difference between live feed and a recording supplied later might have something to do with why the WCBS footage doesn't show the blip.
 
Last edited:
The B-52 doesn't explode immediately on impact either. I'm very familiar with that footage on a frame by frame basis thanks to Killtown's UA93 thread.



I was also wondering how many wierd artifacts we could find if we treated his videos to the same frame-by-frame analysis he's applied to the WTC impact videos. I suspect most such slo-mo videos have weird, counter-intuitive things in them, if you look hard enough.
 
I was also wondering how many wierd artifacts we could find if we treated his videos to the same frame-by-frame analysis he's applied to the WTC impact videos. I suspect most such slo-mo videos have weird, counter-intuitive things in them, if you look hard enough.


Not to mention these have all been highly compressed when uploaded, which does all sorts of weird things to your video.

-Gumboot
 
Seems like an important point to me that the "study" ignores.

Not really. The aircraft engines would still be producing thrust for no more than, say, one second after the initial contact with the building. 767 thrust is about 265 kN, so given the 100 tons the aircraft weighed, this would be equivalent to at most a 13 meter per second difference in its speed just prior to impact, or about 6% at most. Probably less if, as likely, the engines stopped producing useful thrust almost instantly, being FODed out by the building perimeter. In any case, a 6% speed difference is within the uncertainty treated by NIST in its report.

Another thing that the "study" you see fit to grace with scare quotes didn't treat was the rotational momentum in the engine cores. This was omitted simply because they didn't know how to include such a detail in the structural model. I don't either. This would be a point of fantastic sophistication. I only bring it up because this additional momentum, insignificant with respect to the larger collision but significant to the trajectories of individual engine fragments, is cited by NIST as possibly explaining why engine fragments were more likely to leave the structure than they found in their model.

In any case, these corrections are not significant compared to other irreducible uncertainties, and are thus within the bounding envelope of cases studied.

p.s.
Here's a little quote from American Ground. I'd like to know if the MIT study has been discredited.

pg 56. "An MIT study later estimated that only 6 % of the plane's kinetic energy was expended against the south face. Almost all of the rest of the energy was expended inside..."

This study has not been discredited and the observation above makes perfect sense, if you think about it. The collision at the south face is the easiest part to model, because the initial conditions are so predictable. We know the state of the building when it is hit, and we know the construction of the aircraft. We therefore know exactly how much KE (pressure-impulse, actually) it takes to break the perimeter columns, and we know exactly how many of them were broken from the hole the aircraft made in the side.

If you look (yet again) at Dr. Greening's paper, Section 4.3, you will see his estimate of the perimeter columns themselves absorbing only 1.5% of the impact kinetic energy, and we may assume similar losses due to elastic strain and solid sway transmitted to the tower at the same time. This puts us in the 5% ballpark, in agreement with the MIT conclusions.

What happened after contact with the perimeter is much, much more complicated. The aircraft shatters and spreads out. The building floors absorb damage, but since they're edge-on to the crash, it's hard to predict. The building interior absorbs damage too, and there are tons of variables here. Finally pieces get to the core, which is easier to model, but it's harder to figure out how much of the plane gets there, and where its concentrated. By comparison, modeling the contact on the south face is quite easy.

and he describes how one person inside the tower actually survived the tower falling. The point is that in any chaotic situation like a tornado or a tower collapse, anomalous things happen.

Absolutely right.
 
Another thing that the "study" you see fit to grace with scare quotes didn't treat was the rotational momentum in the engine cores.

Can't be sure if you approve of the scare quotes or not,

so just so we're clear, (which I wasn't) by "study" I meant:

http://nomoregames.net/index.php?page=911&subpage1=deceleration_WTC2_myers

By Rick Rajter - October 26, 2006


and, so you're clear about my intent: I leave the serious debunking to the big dogs and only come in when things seem like they're getting ridiculous.

I've been here long enough to have some sense of who knows what and when I'm out of my depth.

thanks, caleb
 
oh. Sorry about that. I missed the spot where you started looking at Rajter, and assumed you were discussing NIST. Still, your questions were perfectly valid...

Rajter's position is the "clunkety clunk" model, the one that predicts collapse times of > 60 seconds, right? I didn't think anyone took that at all seriously. Feel free to reject that theory without comment.

Anyway, going back to look at the "cartoon airplane" (thanks for the link), Rajter and Reynold's calculated speed loss through the perimeter -- about 2.5% -- are in good agreement with Greening and MIT. It's just their interpretation that is completely daft.

Funny how the Troothers get it wrong, even when they're right, huh?
 
Last edited:
Ace, TS, or whatever you call yourself,

Could you please explain to me how the NWO, Government, or whoever you think made these videos also somehow implanted the images of 2 planes hitting the WTC in to my EYEBALLS!

See, I was there, and I personally witnessed both planes hitting the buildings.

I saw everything, EVERYTHING!

I saw it firsthand, not on video, not by description after the fact. I saw BOTH PLANES HIT THE BUILDINGS!!!

Please explain how I saw what you say didn't happen.

Please, this I gotta hear.
 
ummm....

going back to a little earlier, I did also incorrectly refer to the word "Video/programming Engineer". If the use of the word engineer in this context is incorrect, than I retract it. I just assumed just like maintenance workers have "Power Engineers", that are not Engineers in the University trained sense, so could the video industry have "Programming/video/audio/sound engineers" working at TV stations etc...

It is not exactly my field...so I will defer to those more knowledgable.

TAM:)
 
Generally in the film/TV industry you would refer to them as "technicians".

The only person who would be doing fades would be the vision mixer, who would be in the studio. On board the helicopter you would have only a camera operator, and perhaps a reporter. These days the camera operators are all-round field technicians and also deal with sounds and transmission.

Sometimes the reporter might have an assistant who provides their make up, lugs camera batteries, and so forth.

You certainly wouldn't be doing any vision mixing from the helicopter. It would either be a pre-recorded piece, or in this case, an open continuous live feed that the director in the studio control room would cut to as they desired (along with any in-studio shots to hosts/newsreaders/experts, and any other live feeds or VT (pre recorded material) available.) Live feeds would also be recorded at the studio for later use as VT.

-Gumboot
 
Ace, TS, or whatever you call yourself,

Could you please explain to me how the NWO, Government, or whoever you think made these videos also somehow implanted the images of 2 planes hitting the WTC in to my EYEBALLS!

See, I was there, and I personally witnessed both planes hitting the buildings.

I saw everything, EVERYTHING!

I saw it firsthand, not on video, not by description after the fact. I saw BOTH PLANES HIT THE BUILDINGS!!!

Please explain how I saw what you say didn't happen.

Please, this I gotta hear.
To expand on this a bit:

The metropolitan area surrounding Manhattan is very busy with vehicular traffic day and night, and certainly mid-morning is one of its most dense time periods. Moreover, the skyline of Manhattan is very prominent and eye-catching, made more so on a crystal-clear, blue-sky day. The two jets were not tens of thousand of feet above the ground, but at skyline height, well within normal visual range of thousands of nearby people in their cars, trucks, motorcycles, taxis, motorhomes, etc., traveling along (especially on the adjacent and nearby New Jersey corridor).

So I'd like Ace to state when, not to mention how, two jumbo jet airliners just popped into view a couple moments before impact, and why no one has ever reported witnessing as much.
 
To expand on this a bit:

The metropolitan area surrounding Manhattan is very busy with vehicular traffic day and night, and certainly mid-morning is one of its most dense time periods. Moreover, the skyline of Manhattan is very prominent and eye-catching, made more so on a crystal-clear, blue-sky day. The two jets were not tens of thousand of feet above the ground, but at skyline height, well within normal visual range of thousands of nearby people in their cars, trucks, motorcycles, taxis, motorhomes, etc., traveling along (especially on the adjacent and nearby New Jersey corridor).

So I'd like Ace to state when, not to mention how, two jumbo jet airliners just popped into view a couple moments before impact, and why no one has ever reported witnessing as much.

Forget that, he can't be asked to explain what people didn't see. I just want him to explain what I did see.

I was a few hundred yards from WTC1 walking towards it when the first plane hit. I looked up when I heard an incredibly loud jet engine sound a second or two before the plane hit. It was so loud that the ground was vibrating and I actually felt the sound. Of course the crash and resulting explosion was even louder, but I'll never forget the sound of the jet. Its what made me look up. Then there it was, an American Airlines jet flying full speed in to the north tower.

So please tell me Ace, how did the big bad NWO not only implant images in to my eyeball, but also have the accompanying sound effects so perfectly staged?
 
Not really. The aircraft engines would still be producing thrust for no more than, say, one second after the initial contact with the building. 767 thrust is about 265 kN, so given the 100 tons the aircraft weighed, this would be equivalent to at most a 13 meter per second difference in its speed just prior to impact, or about 6% at most. Probably less if, as likely, the engines stopped producing useful thrust almost instantly, being FODed out by the building perimeter. In any case, a 6% speed difference is within the uncertainty treated by NIST in its report.
Darn. It could be as high as 7 pounds of TNT in energy due to the thrust at contact until the engine are toast. Okay, it would only be .34 percent of all the energy, but never has a truther presented the numbers. Or have they? Or when the do present numbers they make errors or the numbers do not support them and they ignore the numbers.

It sounds like a lot more energy when it is 14,859,282 joules.
 
TS is a good example of an attention seeker. He is not bringing any valid arguements to the table. He is making an impossible conclusion then trying to fit facts to it. Its a joke of an arguement and seriously guys, I suggest we ignore him. We are only giving him what he wants. He does this not because he believes it but because he enjoys the reaction he gets. He has been shown his arguements failings and keeps coming back with the same stuff. In his determination to harass rather then learn he is actually producing even more outlandish theories which verifies that his intention is to insult and gain reaction...the more absurb the more likely we react. It is a purposeful venture.

Dont bother!

He is an insult even to regular trolls.
 
PinocchioChoice.jpg

Perhaps, Ace, no one else is answering your challenge because they don't trust you to tell the truth about whether the answers they give are correct.

I've matched each of those pictures with frames from the animated graphic of the video that you posted in post #77. A, C, and D correspond with the fourth, fifth, and sixth frames after the debris "nose" visibly emerges (or 24th, 25th, and 26th frames overall). B, E, and F match the third, fourth, and second frames after the actual nose appears from behind the logo (or the fourth, fifth, and third frames overall), not necessarily in that order.

E is a bit odd, though; it doesn't match the frame I've matched it to, or any other frame of the video before or after the crash, very well. Also, it has a bluish cast toward the bottom left, which does not match anything seen in any of the frames near the plane's nose or near the debris. So I'm less confident in that one, but it's very similar to the frames from before the crash. (There are also frames from after the crash in which the debris "nose" doesn't resemble the pre-crash airplane nose at all; naturally you have not included those in your comparison pictures, but perhaps you can explain why they look so different if they are really accidental additional frames of CGI of the same airplane.)

Which means that I was indeed correct about the grouping of the frames, after reversing my original answer -- which you've claimed was still wrong. I think you were mistaken about that.

If I'm wrong, you can prove it by presenting a magnification of a larger portion of the frame(s) I got wrong, showing how it matches one of your cropped images and including enough of the image to be able to unambiguously identify whether the frame it came from was before or after the crash.

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
Her is what I have to say about images A-F....

they are so poor, such horrible resolution, and so out of context, that I personally have no idea which are which. They could all be debris, they could all be pre-impact plane nose section...it doesnt matter, because they are so horrible godamn images....JHC!!!!!!!!

TAM:)
 
For the Record

Ace: Just for the record, ALL of the networks that showed footage of a plane crashing into the one of Twin Towers understand that there was no plane, correct?

ALL of the networks understand that the videos they're using are faked, correct?

There are people running loose who have actually faked these videos or who know people who did the evil deed, correct?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom