Stop Robert Lancaster, Slanderer of Sylvia Browne

Thank you Linda for confirming that indeed Ms. Browne and the rest of you couldn't help but come to this forum to have a voice.

Your words fall on deaf ears my dear woman.

Greetings from the good Doctor.

Linda, I know your sentence structure and syntax well enough to sniff you out.
:)

The "Linda" that GBS is most likely referring to is Linda Rossi, SB's Business Manager. However, as someone else has already said, inuendo and cloak and dagger stuff won't fly here.

ST
 
Am I the only one who has a problem with this?
Does this...


"1. I was possibly wrong about the GSB guestbook issue. It seems unlikely it was Lancaster who planned or directed it, although it is probable that Lancaster's article and posts were what brought the site to the attention of some here. I apologize.

2. I do not know for sure whether or not Lancaster has violated any copyright issues. It is possible he hasn't but I would think that Lancaster has a very liberal conception of fair use. I apologize.

3. Sylvia got Devlin's first name right, which is still unlikely despite the fact it is a popular name, but she did not get his physical appearance and King was confused/mistaken.

4. Lancaster is wrong to claim that all of the guests on Exploring Psychic Powers Live spoke English, but this is only the phrasing of one sentence as part of the larger article whose general message is honest.

5. It is also wrong to make false predictions or statements to a victim's family if one is not absolutely sure of their correctness. If Sylvia is not genuinely confident about her predictions to these people then there is a problem.

6. I cannot verify or prove the 85% success rate. It is possibly not true.

7. I have falsely linked in my mind certain people and things which are not fair to link: specifically the investigations that Lancaster has done into Sylvia/Novus with the attitude towards religion that people in the skeptical community like Dawkins, Randi and some of the posters here have. I apologize then for any general rudeness.

8. Thank you angrybeliever, DJM, randfan and kittynhin


any way excuse this?

"Stop Robert S. Lancaster, slanderer of Sylvia Browne. Robert S. Lancaster has made a hostile and concerted attempt to slander, libel and defame Sylvia Browne. Browne, a woman who has brought an immeasurable amount of comfort and assistance to men and women across the country, as well as help to police departments, has been treated in a fashion completely and utterly shocking to any civilized person. Browne's success rate of 85% is ignored, Mr. Lancaster, in his sham of a website, obsessively harps on every minor error that Browne makes in her prediction. For example: when Sylvia Browne accurately predicted the nature and appearance of Shawn Hornbeck's abductor, he pretended that she had not, and distorted her actual reading to the Hornbecks. Larry King even SAID that she got it mostly right, but Mr. Randi and Mr. Lancaster have tried to deny it!

Lancaster at first tried to pretend that his analysis was scientific and forthright, but it has become increasingly frenzied and over-the-top with his hatred for Sylvia. With each new appearance of an article on StopSylviaBrowne.com, his attitude becomes more and more extreme, a trend that is disturbing to me, a follower of Browne. Lancaster's main argument seems to be that because Browne is occasionally un-eloquent in her speech, this means that she somehow had faked a master's degree in literature. He hunted down Browne's ex-husband for the express purpose of getting him to lie to that effect (a liar that was later debunked). His other arguments are that because Browne occasionally misses a minor fact (like the hair color of a missing person), she is somehow a fake. This is again IGNORING her 85% success rate. There are thousands of positive testimonials in favor of Browne and it is clear from a simple reading of Amazon.com reviews of her books that she has helped INNUMERABLE people.

Mr. Lancaster has always engaged in a vigorous campaign to attack GoSylviaBrowne.com, a completely innocuous fan website. Mr. Lancaster has been utterly vicious in this, soliciting people from this website, the JREF, to assault and destroy her guestbook. Now it is filled with hundreds of spammers, due to these 'skeptics' (more like Fascists to me) signing up the site with spam companies. Whenever Mr. Lancaster has had interactions with those in the fan community he has been nasty, and never anything short of condescending. This man who has so little positive to contribute to the world has instead set his sights on Mrs. Browne, a great spiritual leader.

Mr. Lancaster has apparently also started a campaign against Dr. Kaz deMille-Jacobsen, a 9/11 survivor and inspirational speaker, and a descendant of famous film director Cecil B. Demille. He has also insulted and questioned the honor of Montel Williams, a navy hero, who is currently suffering with multiple sclerosis. Lancaster is also a vigorous copyright abuser (posting both clips of Montel's show, transcripts, images of Sylvia, quotes from her books, and the Hay House logo), as noted by Browne's lawyers. Let's hope they pursue this case to the fullest extent of the law and stop Robert S. Lancaster's campaign of terror.."


This person comes busting through the door shouting out all that garbage like they really have someting to say. Like they are somehow righting a wrong.
Then as it turns out this person hasn't actually read Mr. Lancaster's site at all.
They did no fact checking or research of any kind before posting those horrible things about a nice man who has been nice enough to create a one stop site to any questions anyone would have about Sylvia Browne.
IMO this persons last post in no way resolves this thread!
The OP needs to apologize to Robert S Lancaster!
 

This person comes busting through the door shouting out all that garbage like they really have someting to say. Like they are somehow righting a wrong.
Then as it turns out this person hasn't actually read Mr. Lancaster's site at all.
They did no fact checking or research of any kind before posting those horrible things about a nice man who has been nice enough to create a one stop site to any questions anyone would have about Sylvia Browne.
IMO this persons last post in no way resolves this thread!
The OP needs to apologize to Robert S Lancaster!


Don't shout.

And does it excuse it? No.

But it's a step forward. The same person who came in here shouting all that vitriol took a step back, looked at the evidence, and concluded that much of his vitriol was misplaced. More to the point, he said "I apologize" several times--without any qualifiers.

I think that's a very positive thing, and should be commended.
 
This person comes busting through the door shouting out all that garbage like they really have someting to say. Like they are somehow righting a wrong.
Then as it turns out this person hasn't actually read Mr. Lancaster's site at all.
They did no fact checking or research of any kind before posting those horrible things about a nice man who has been nice enough to create a one stop site to any questions anyone would have about Sylvia Browne.
IMO this persons last post in no way resolves this thread!
The OP needs to apologize to Robert S Lancaster!
SOP, really. We are very used to it, so most of us have developed thick skins. It's sort of like waiting for a child's tantrum to blow over - a momentary storm before the calm.

The usual progression is that the posters of this style often last only a few posts, then storm right on out again citing "You are all closed-minded skeptics! Why won't you LISTEN! 10,000 anecdotes can't be wrong!" or some such. Check them out...

Thankfully, in this case, the poster has (1) stuck around manfully, and (2) seen fit to stop shouting and start discussing instead. Progress can now be made, so it's all good!
 
That took a lot of guts. Well done.

A very huge amount.

What is unfortunate about being a human, is that in situations like this, when everyone (us, in this case) is their most proud, the individual is usually the most embarassed.

I hope SylviaRox can soon be proud of taking a giant step into reality, rather than be embarrassed by being duped in the past.

Not that I claim any real insight into SylviaRox's thoughts. I am really commenting on the 'typical response'. SylviaRox may, or may not, be experiencing the above. But it would seem likely.
 
Well to be fair to Athon, Hornbeck could have been abducted by an Australian.

That, and plindboe's post bring up another point. Browne said Opal Jo Jennings was abducted by a Japanese and that Hornbeck was abducted by a Hispanic. In real life these sorts of violent predators usually prey on children of their own ethnic group.

In the 2000 census, Hispanics were found to be 14.4% of the US population.

If the abductor was in fact Hispanic, it is less likely that he would be named Michael. So Browne is actually making two contradictory statements:

(1) He is one of the 4-5% of the US males named Michael.
(2) He is one of the 14.4% of the US population whose males are less likely to be named Michael.

I have to wonder if Browne is tricky enough to make this sort of reasoning, or if she just has some prejudicial ideas about Hispanics. :confused:
 
I for one am impressed... I have rarely seen such a concise, direct, and unqualified retraction of poorly-chosen statements from someone who started with such vigor.

In fact, it's starting to make me believe that more people can be reached than we sometimes suppose... a win for RSLancaster's factual, polite approach.

ETA: I would say that it is correct to state that guessing the name of an unknown person to be "Michael" is unlikely. Even if it's one of the most common names, the probability of a given person having that name is not a sure bet. On the other hand, if you guess popular names often, or allow the guess to cover multiple unknown people, you are likely to be seen as correct even if you have no powers at all.
 
Last edited:
I have to wonder if Browne is tricky enough to make this sort of reasoning, or if she just has some prejudicial ideas about Hispanics. :confused:

I would like to know what percentage of Hispanics make up the prison population in the US, ie, if she guesses a Hispanic person committed a crime, is she likely to be right solely because Hispanics make up a larger than average part of the prison population.
 
6. I cannot verify or prove the 85% success rate. It is possibly not true.

Being able to hold ideas, any idea no matter how sure you are of it, still in a state of "possibly not true" is THE key to continuing to progress towards the truth.

I still hold that Einstein might not be right, QM might not be right, even evolution might not be right. It would take some awesome evidence to convince me that they aren't, but I try to never discount that someday, that evidence could come.

Before the early 1900s, to think that Newton's work was anything less that the complete story was probably beyond consideration for many. Yet, Special and General Relativy soon came along and showed that Newton's ideas of space, time, and gravity were merely good approximations for when speeds were low (compared with the speed of light) and gravity was comparatively mild (compared with what can be generated around a collapsed star for example).

Being able to hold an idea as 'possibly not true' is what allows one's mind to actually contemplate contrary evidence. Progress cannot be made without this attitude.

Of all the things SylviaRox said, that little statement fills me with the most hope for SylviaRox's future mental revolution. I think/hope that is what has happened, SylivaRox has started on a mental revolution. Good luck on that journey.

This might be pre-mature, but..... as things recrystalize, if 'SylviaRox' no longer suits you as a user name, the mods would probably be happy to help out.
 
I have to wonder if Browne is tricky enough to make this sort of reasoning, or if she just has some prejudicial ideas about Hispanics. :confused:

There has been some things put together showing how frequently she chooses minorities as villains in her missing persons' readings. Your wonderings have some basis.

I can't remember where it was, but I'm sure someone here can point you to it.
 
This person comes busting through the door shouting out all that garbage like they really have someting to say. Like they are somehow righting a wrong.
Then as it turns out this person hasn't actually read Mr. Lancaster's site at all.
They did no fact checking or research of any kind before posting those horrible things about a nice man who has been nice enough to create a one stop site to any questions anyone would have about Sylvia Browne.
IMO this persons last post in no way resolves this thread!
The OP needs to apologize to Robert S Lancaster!

Slow down. People react poorly when their fundamental beliefs are challenged, and while the first 9-10 pages of this thread were not dinner table compliant, there has been a huge amount of progress made. Even is SR decides to still believe in SB the fact that SR listened was huge. This speaks volumes about the exNS people on this thread, as well as oothers who gave their personal accounts of stepping away from beliefs. Let the past go. If RSL needs an apology he will ask for one, though I would hope that he eventually receives one. I wouldn't want to squander the opportunity for sane debate that this represents.
 
I don't know. I think the guy deserves the benefit of the doubt. I don't need a pound of flesh. I just want other people to consider my point of view. Let's see how he responds.

Everyone deserves another chance. After all, I sort of believed some pretty unbelievable stuff once upon a time. I hope I am wiser at my age, and that I continue to become so.

M.
 
SylviaRox, I am also among those who applaud your willingness to admit error. That is a rare find these days. It was a brave thing you did.

This makes me bring up the question that I use as a litmus test of whether a persons beliefs are rational or not. The Question is:

"What would it take for you to change your beliefs?".

As for myself, I can think of many things that would cause me to change my beliefs about Sylvia. If she could, for example, take a random group of strangers whose mothers were deceased (NOT people in her audience who had filled out information forms), and correctly identify their mothers' maiden names, that would go a long way toward making me a believer. It should be a simple task for one that can speak to the dead.

But I admit that it is more difficult to say what it would take a person to lose a belief that they had held for some time. Those of us here who are former Christians can give you a lot of stories about why they lost their faith, and it is almost never an instantaneous deconversion.

So what would Sylvia have to do before you would believe she had no ability to talk to the dead? Lie? Cheat? Be wrong a lot? Take money from grieving families?

The thing I have found with many believers of various paranormal or religious things is that they cannot think of a single thing that would convince them that they were wrong. Such an inability tells me that they are not actually considering evidence.

For the record, I don't believe you are such a person. I think you've already shown that you are capable of admitting error. So I am curious about your answer to The Question.
 
Slow down. People react poorly when their fundamental beliefs are challenged, and while the first 9-10 pages of this thread were not dinner table compliant, there has been a huge amount of progress made. Even is SR decides to still believe in SB the fact that SR listened was huge. This speaks volumes about the exNS people on this thread, as well as oothers who gave their personal accounts of stepping away from beliefs. Let the past go. If RSL needs an apology he will ask for one, though I would hope that he eventually receives one. I wouldn't want to squander the opportunity for sane debate that this represents.

Well said. I agree 100%
 
I would like to know what percentage of Hispanics make up the prison population in the US, ie, if she guesses a Hispanic person committed a crime, is she likely to be right solely because Hispanics make up a larger than average part of the prison population.
I don't think she really gives too much thought to how likely it is that her guesses will prove to be correct. First of all, we've seen her make some pretty wild guesses (the whole Hornbeck/Japan/slavery thing was definitely not any kind of cold reading!) Second, her act would be really boring if she told everyone the killer's name was John, etc. I think she falls more into the category of making up interesting stories about "safe" targets (i.e. things people can't check) than intelligent cold reading based on population statistics.
 
Damn, I KNEW I shouldn't have stopped reading this thread long enough to pretend to try to get some sleep....
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom