Americans are drowning in a watery medical myth!

Coffee is a diuretic. The strength of the diuretic effect depends on whether you are looking at pro- or con- coffee sites.

Wiki has an interesting entry on coffee: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coffee_and_health

Interestingly enough, also, if coffee is not a migraine trigger, it's recommended to drink it as it (via caffeine) can help speed the absorbtion of meds.

Coffee is pretty weird like that.
 
I don't know how sound your research is but I've often doubted the 8 glasses of water a day thing. Seems like a hippie myth.

I know that if I drank that much water (coffee presumably doesn't count) I'd feel just bloated and disgusted.
 
I heard about this frequently. I always went by the rule that I didn't really need 8 glasses of water. I drink when I'm thirsty, and I drink more when working out or it's hot--which seems like common sense, really.

It's easy to think that maybe some people think they need that much water to flush "toxins" from their system but I never quite believed that a human needed to drink X amount of water. Like another poster said earlier in the thread--there really is alot more water/liquid in the food we eat everyday that I really don't feel like I'm not getting enough anyway.

I remember reading an article not long ago (possibly in Time magazine or something like that) about how the amount might have changed? Anywhere from 6-8 glasses is SUGGESTED--slippery wording I suppose!
 
That's 1 1/2 to 2 gallons! Your bladder must be stupendous!

Seriously, almost 20 years of practice has probably habituated you, just like serious alcoholics can apparently need large amounts of alcohol in their systems in order to function.

Funny you mention alcohol. I recently stopped drinking dangerous amounts of alcohol, but need (for psychological or habitual reasons) to keep sipping on something, so I would probably drink 3-4 litres of mineral water a day.

This is not entirely on the subject, but could I OD on minerals?
 
A 12-pack of beer is over a gallon. I've seen people drink twice that much in a night. Add the water they got during the day, plus whatever was in their food, and according to the anti-water foolishness shown in this thread, those folks should have just dropped dead from too much water in their systems. There might be harm from 8 glasses a day? Please, spare me the anti-rational hysteria.
I don't see anyone being "anti-water", the point is that nobody has any need to force themselves to drink more than they feel they need to satisfy their thirst. And it doesn't have to be water. Tea, coffee, juice, whatever. Even if some of these have a slight diuretic effect, the net gain is still positive.

If you're living in a hot climate, and taking quite a lot of exercise, you'll obviously need more water than someone in a cool climate who isn't exercising. But your body will tell you about this. It's the pressurising of people in cool climates who don't exercise to force down water they neither need nor want that is the woo.

I don't imagine eight glasses of water, spaced out throughout the day, is going to hurt anyone. But what's the point, if you're not thirsty and you don't want it? It's of no benefit.

Rolfe.
 
I have another method to ensure that I am having enough water. I look at my urine. If that is either clear or a pale yellow in the afternoon then everything is OK. If it is a deep yellow then I need to drink more water. This can happen in summer. It can be yellow in the morning as I do not drink overnight.

Even this may not be backed up by research.
 
It's the pressurising of people in cool climates who don't exercise to force down water they neither need nor want that is the woo.

Oh wow, the "pressure" of having to drink all that water... my heart goes out to the victims.

Did you ever think it might just be that water doesn't have any sugar or stimulants in it, and the "pressure" is felt when the person drinking the water has to do without their "fix"?
 
I don't know how sound your research is but I've often doubted the 8 glasses of water a day thing. Seems like a hippie myth.

I know that if I drank that much water (coffee presumably doesn't count) I'd feel just bloated and disgusted.
That's what I got when I tried it. I just couldn't manage the whole 8 glasses thing at all, even when I spaced them out.
I drink almost no water at all. Apart from what I eat, all my fluids come from tea, milk and fruit juice. I might have a couple of mouthfuls of water at bedtime to stop me from getting dehydrated at night - I have blood pressure problems that make my kidneys get wonky sometimes and I can generally tell when that's likely to happen.
I rely on my body's signals to tell me what it needs - not some anonymous "expert".
 
Last edited:
Oh wow, the "pressure" of having to drink all that water... my heart goes out to the victims.

Did you ever think it might just be that water doesn't have any sugar or stimulants in it, and the "pressure" is felt when the person drinking the water has to do without their "fix"?

No, the pressure is felt when "health" writers in the newspapers regurgitate claims by the bottled water companies that if you don't drink 8 glasses a day you will go down with all kinds of lurgies.

If you are in good health, it is sufficient to drink when you feel thirsty. Millions of years of evolution have refined your thirst reflex. Trust it!
 
Um, 64 ounces a day cannot reasonably constitute a "burden", unless you try to drink it all in a real short time - say, a ten-minute period. I'll agree with JoeEllison's contribution concerning soda intake.

People easily down a couple of times that much fluid everyday without thinking twice. Seriously.

Yeah, I've reconsidered. I probably drank 3 cans of Diet Pepsi (caffeine-free...I try to keep caffeine intake to my occassional cup of coffee) yesterday and two 15 oz. bottles of water. No "burden" (and when I used that word I meant "burden" as in a pain in the butt, not like having to climb Mt. Everest with no shoes on)

But according to some sources the soda wouldn't count and I'd still need an additional 6 or 8 glasses of water which is wholly unnecessary.
 
No, the pressure is felt when "health" writers in the newspapers regurgitate claims by the bottled water companies that if you don't drink 8 glasses a day you will go down with all kinds of lurgies.

If you are in good health, it is sufficient to drink when you feel thirsty. Millions of years of evolution have refined your thirst reflex. Trust it!
Sounds like big business conspiracy woo to me.
 
I probably drank 3 cans of Diet Pepsi (caffeine-free...I try to keep caffeine intake to my occassional cup of coffee) yesterday and two 15 oz. bottles of water.

Yesterday, I drank 3 8-oz glasses of lo-fat milk, 1 8-oz can of V8, and 1 12-oz bottle of pink grapefruit juice, plus a 4-oz mixed-fruit cup packed in juice. That's been a typical daily liquid intake for me for several years, and I've heard doctors argue that the milk wouldn't count. FWIW, I'm 6'2" and currently weigh 270 lbs.

BTW, I had abdominal surgery (prostate, actually) ~2 months ago, and was in the hospital for the next three days. Some of the nurses kept trying to force liquids into me while others would just shrug and say I'd drink when my body told me to. It could take half a day for me to down 12 oz of ginger ale (the only thing I had a taste for), and I ate virtually nothing the entire time. I did have a maintenance IV, but that was mainly an avenue for pain self-medication.
 
I have another method to ensure that I am having enough water. I look at my urine. If that is either clear or a pale yellow in the afternoon then everything is OK. If it is a deep yellow then I need to drink more water. This can happen in summer. It can be yellow in the morning as I do not drink overnight.

Even this may not be backed up by research.


This is probably the best way to make sure that you're drinking an appropriate amount of water. Why would a set quantity be right for everyone? People have different heights, weights, activity levels, metabolisms, etc. - in other words, one person will need more or less water than the next for a variety of reasons.

When all else fails, look at your pee pee. ;)
 
This is probably the best way to make sure that you're drinking an appropriate amount of water. Why would a set quantity be right for everyone? People have different heights, weights, activity levels, metabolisms, etc. - in other words, one person will need more or less water than the next for a variety of reasons.

When all else fails, look at your pee pee. ;)
Yeah, that's what I say. A lot, actually.

Maybe that's why I don't get invited to the really cool parties?
 
No, the pressure is felt when "health" writers in the newspapers regurgitate claims by the bottled water companies that if you don't drink 8 glasses a day you will go down with all kinds of lurgies.

If you are in good health, it is sufficient to drink when you feel thirsty. Millions of years of evolution have refined your thirst reflex. Trust it!


What he said.

Why should people be encouraged, urged, berated, nagged and so on by woo-woo "health" articles into drinking a quantity of water they neither need nor desire?

Rolfe.
 
Sounds like big business conspiracy woo to me.
I'm not sure that I understand your response. Are you saying that the implication that bottled water manufacturers are trying to push the 8 glasses a day myth is a conspiracy theory?

If that's what you're saying, then that's a bit silly. It's called 'marketing'. Anecdotal of course, but a friend of mine is a sales manager at Culligans bottled water. He told me once how drinking tap water is slowing killing us, because some chemicals added to it are carcinogenic. Of course it's in his company's best interest to spread falsehoods like this.

The bottled water industry is not as big as it is because everyone knows all of the facts about daily required water intake, and the safety of bottled water vs. tap water. This is just good business for them.

Is it ethical? Well, that's a whole separate discussion. :)
 
What he said.

Why should people be encouraged, urged, berated, nagged and so on by woo-woo "health" articles into drinking a quantity of water they neither need nor desire?

Rolfe.
I'm guessing the "desire" part is more important to you than the "need" part. My magical online intuition is screaming "libertarian"... :jaw-dropp

Seriously, though, you seem to be giving off kind of angry vibes about having to drink water. Water's good for you! Builds strong bones and, errr... stuff!
 
I'm not sure that I understand your response. Are you saying that the implication that bottled water manufacturers are trying to push the 8 glasses a day myth is a conspiracy theory?

No, what I'm saying is that since the 8 glasses a day recommendation existed long before bottled water was a big seller, the idea that it came from the bottled water companies is a bit silly. I'm perfectly aware that they're pushing it hard.

I just have to add: water is nummy. And, evil corporations have corrupted our brains, in order to make us convince ourselves that we don't need water, or vegetables, or anything else that is good for us and 5 year olds don't want to eat or drink. :D
 
No, the pressure is felt when "health" writers in the newspapers regurgitate claims by the bottled water companies that if you don't drink 8 glasses a day you will go down with all kinds of lurgies.

Because obviously the only water available comes in bottles.

Seriously, 8 glasses a day is nothing, and I very much doubt there is a single person posting here who doesn't drink at least that much. Most people I know drink more than that just in tea and coffee. You need water to live. Your body doesn't care if it is just plain water or if it comes mixed with coffee or oranges or whatever.

As for Rolfe's question of why people need to be told this (although for the record I've never actually seen anyone telling anyone this, I suspect it's an American thing), people need to be told pretty much everything. We shouldn't need to be told to eat fruit, we shouldn't need to be told to eat a balanced diet, we shouldn't need to be told not to sniff glue, we shouldn't need to be told an awful lot of things. But despite the fact that we are told all these things, people still don't pay attention and mostly just eat ready meals and burgers. Condsidering how bad people are with very basic health and nutrition, why is it surprising that they are just as bad when it comes to drink?
 
First time I ever saw the "8 glasses a day" thing was on the label on a bottle of mineral water. The woo nutritionists then picked up on it , because obviously drinking water out of a plastic bottle is what nature intended. Personally, I drink the water that comes out of the tap. I pay Thames water £300 pa for the stuff and don't see the point of paying £1 per litre for French mineral water.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom