Metatheory and the NIST report

Are you familiar with the Law of Conservation of Momentum?
Yes, but no truther has even a 4th grade grasp of the concept, it must be the lack of attending physics class and the ability to use that knowledge in the real world. Go ahead put some more rebar in the light weight concrete floor that had none.
 
Don't forget to fix rebar around the blocks and even thicker rebar througout the interior.

And use cinder blocks that are 200 feet x 200 feet Then put tons of office furniture on each block. And fly an airplane into it.

Darn! The NWO programming is thorough. Sorry, fellow patriots. It will take a while for it to wear off.
 
There is no word in Elvish, Entish, or the tongues of men to describe this stupidity.

Try Orcish, they have 56 words for stupid.... on second thoughts, none of them come close either.

False analogy. It would more accurate to say: drop a cinder block on five fixed cinder blocks and see if it smashes through to the first block.

Now do it again and see if it happens twice, in the exact same way.

Are you honestly trying to suggest that a concrete block, less than a 1/4 of a foot square, and with roughly 30% of the volume made of solid concrete is in anyway relational to a 1 acre sized building floor where about 1% of the total volume is welded sections of steel? I true don't believe that anyone can be that dense.
 
I apologise for taking forever to respond to this, I have been busy talking over at LC and limiting my time spent here in order to do a bit more work :).

I have explained that I am talking about an average velocity and that there is some distibution of velocities in the debris (for which I proposed a range similar to that given by NIST). Nonetheless, the total momentum and average velocity are linearly proportional.
I understand you are talking about a range of velocities, but when calculating the momentum you are assuming that 'debris exiting the core' includes the entire mass of the aircraft. This is clearly not true and in fact the debris entering the core (based on damage areas) seems to be limited to approximately 1/2 to 1/3 the mass. Claiming that 'the average velocity must be 43.3mph as the mass is constant' is ludicrous, as individual bodies slow to 0mph they cancel themselves out as I'm sure you are aware. You can find images showing debris distribution in NCSTAR 1-2B Page 342 for the more severe case which NIST finally used.

I don't have enough information on which to judge the FEA simulation and I don't know if I would understand anyway. Nonetheless, I have seen no indication that NIST modelled the core contents other than partitions. The core also had elevator tracks and cables, air ducts, ac pipes, water pipes, steam pipes, sewer pipes, stairs, service rooms, storage rooms, power lines, and etc.
NIST did not model a lot of the things you mention due to the absolute impossibility of correctly modelling them. They are determined to have a negligible impact on the simulation but my point is that by questioning their fireproofing damage you are inherently questioning their FEA. The SFRM tests found the order of magnitudes of energy required to dislodge SFRM and these were inferred from workstation damage of (I believe) the same magnitude.

Now to say 'oh there is no method by which trusses could lose fireproofing' is ludicrous. The fireproofing was removed via adhesive failure due to inertial forces in NISTs test but this is not the only method, we have cohesive failure, scraping, vibration and many others. These are impossibly difficult to judge and so a 'best guess' lab test was devised predicting the energy and acceleration requirements. Now I am not going to go saying 'oh NIST is 100% correct and you can't strike them down' but I don't see your point here. You're essentially saying "There's not enough energy for fireproofing to be damaged but i'm not judging the FEA that says there was enough for office equipment to be damaged".

Regardless I think I make my point, the mass involved was not constant because large portions dissipated much of their momentum before even reaching the core. The momentum graph does not easily translate into usable post core velocity figures and even if it did the minimum we should be coming up with is 100mph or so assuming a little over half the debris has exhausted all momentum (Obviously not the case but a reasonable approximation).
 
Jay:

You have made some very good points and handled the typical JREF knee-jerk resistance to thinking outside of the NIST BOX very well!

I am happy to see someone ask some crucial CHEMICAL questions about the collapse of WTC 1 & 2.

I believe Cl2/HCl from PVC pyrolysis and combustion is key. What is more, chlorine acts catalytically in causing severe metal wastage in high temperature corrosion environments....


I wonder why you ignored my questions, Frank:

Frank, this schtick has grown really tiresome. Let's lay out the facts for everyone to see:

You came here with a well-deserved reputation for careful, thought-provoking research.

JREFers continually cited you as an authority in marshaling their arguments against conspiracy liars.

For reasons that remain obscure, you exhibited a huge chip on your shoulder and repeatedly attacked a nonexistent orthodoxy.

NO ONE here regards NIST's work as infallible. Enough already!

To the extent that your work modifies the NIST Report, providing a more accurate explanation for the collapses of the Twin Towers, people here have generally applauded it. You are not Galileo standing against obscurantist fools.

People here are having trouble figuring out where the hell you're coming from.

Are you saying that the NIST Report is worthless? No--you frequently comment that much of it is excellent science.

You claim that researchers for the agency overlooked certain chemical reactions as additional heat sources.

Have you been attacked on this forum for offering that insight?

I must have missed it.

Haven't people here commended you on advancing our knowledge of the collapses?

Where exactly is all this resistance you meet here?

Do you imagine that people should be flattered to be treated as narrow-minded dullards marching lockstep in support of an orthodoxy that only you are capable of discerning?

Would it be fair to conclude that people here resent your condescending and hostile attitude toward them, while respecting your manifest ability as a scientist?

Can we flesh out your grievance with NIST a bit?

They say that planes hit the towers. You agree.

They say that the resultant fires weakened the steel, causing inward bowing of the exterior columns, leading to a failure of the floor-trusses. You agree--right?

They say that the impacts of the planes dislodged a sufficient amount of fireproofing to facilitate heat transfer to the steel. Do you agree? Why are you so coy about this?

Tell us what part of the NIST Report we are so slavishly devoted to: All of it? The parts that accord with your own theories? The parts that don't?

Could the conspiracy liars really have something? Could they?

C'mon, Frank, you've been making insinuations for a long time.

WHAT ARE YOU SAYING?
 
Pomeroo:

"Have you (meaning me) been attacked on this forum for offering that insight?

I must have missed it."

YUP, missed it you did!

Have you not been paying attention or noticed:

The JREFERs are good examples of messeger shooters, who assume every criticism of NIST signals a TWOOFER in the house. NISTIAN soldiers who march straight into denial mode whenever they are challenged...

These JREFERs show, time and again, how well they know the NIST Report, and are able to quote it, Chapter and Verse..... but FLIP-FLOP when faced with the great UNKNOWN territory of WTC collapse information OUTSIDE of the areas studied by NIST.

These NISTIAN APOLOGISTS say that if NIST didn't study it, it's not worth studying, or NIST probably DID study it, but found nothing of interest worth reporting.

In fact, when confronted with evidence of interesting information NOT addressed by NIST they offer endless, nit-picking arguments rather than concede one single lousy point to a perceived Twoofer... And about this time the comments start from the Argwiners, Tounge Lashers and other assorted Enigmas and Pardalian Variations, that I am childish, or "a failed scientist", or whatever...

So Pomeroo, may I suggest that until some JREFERs cease and desist with such behavior, then let the chips (including the one I allegedly bear on my shoulder), fall where they may.

And PLEASE do not even try to apologize for the behavior of your compadres!

P.S. I would gladly share my research with you, but not until something changes around here.
 
And PLEASE do not even try to apologize for the behavior of your compadres!

P.S. I would gladly share my research with you, but not until something changes around here.

Dr Greening, despite your fervent belief we are all committed to the NIST explanation of everything, you might be interested to know that you have at least convinced me (and I suspect many others) that chemical heating may be responsible for undocumented heat additions to the furnaces that were the towers.

However I have yet to see a qualitative assessment of NISTs fire predictions and the shortcomings/errors therein or a comprehensive list of reactions you feel to be more likely and the differences they would cause.

I am not meaning to be offensive, your research genuinely interests me but you seem to have come to the conclusion that we would immediately reject such research despite you not actually presenting it. I assure you I have no desire to eliminate any research from the body of investigative knowledge and would welcome such a paper.
 
Pomeroo:

"Have you (meaning me) been attacked on this forum for offering that insight?

I must have missed it."

YUP, missed it you did!

Have you not been paying attention or noticed:

The JREFERs are good examples of messeger shooters, who assume every criticism of NIST signals a TWOOFER in the house. NISTIAN soldiers who march straight into denial mode whenever they are challenged...

These JREFERs show, time and again, how well they know the NIST Report, and are able to quote it, Chapter and Verse..... but FLIP-FLOP when faced with the great UNKNOWN territory of WTC collapse information OUTSIDE of the areas studied by NIST.

These NISTIAN APOLOGISTS say that if NIST didn't study it, it's not worth studying, or NIST probably DID study it, but found nothing of interest worth reporting.

In fact, when confronted with evidence of interesting information NOT addressed by NIST they offer endless, nit-picking arguments rather than concede one single lousy point to a perceived Twoofer... And about this time the comments start from the Argwiners, Tounge Lashers and other assorted Enigmas and Pardalian Variations, that I am childish, or "a failed scientist", or whatever...

So Pomeroo, may I suggest that until some JREFERs cease and desist with such behavior, then let the chips (including the one I allegedly bear on my shoulder), fall where they may.

And PLEASE do not even try to apologize for the behavior of your compadres!

P.S. I would gladly share my research with you, but not until something changes around here.
Who needs NIST? Burn the darn thing if you must Apollo! But the NIST report is only used as tool to show that truthers are full of BS. They come in with part of the darn report that tests the building design and say see, the building parts passed the test and did not fail. They do not even know it was to test the building design.

But I use the work of Dr Greening to show gravity collapse is possible. But I did not trust your work. But now I am glad I did check it, because you are a joker on this stuff. But I ran my own numbers on momentum and modeled the collapse of the structure and my numbers were close to yours. But used as much information form other journals as I could find to check the numbers of your and others. Your work is okay.

I think anyone who used one set of work may end up wrong. But using many ideas and making sound judgment. But 9/11 is not theory and giant guesses. There is no great mystery when a building fails due to fire, it has happened for thousands of years. 9/11 truth is full of BS, if I take the time to use NIST to stop them, then so be it. But I am dumb enough to use Dr Greening a lot. So, what is my next thesis topic and why is that Apollo photo messed up for you?

But yes, after a while someone pokes their head in and asks some dumb questions, we need to be kinder and gentler before we blast the guns and bring out the anti-thermite ray gun. But who do I use as my mentor, Dr Greening or Apollo, or Gravy, or chillzero?
 
Beachnut:

I am glad your calculation agrees with mine.

I think you have to choose your own mentor.

The Rover has left no tire tracks..
 
Aren't scientist supposed to be used to criticism? Isn't that the whole point of being a scientist?
 
Pomeroo:

"Have you (meaning me) been attacked on this forum for offering that insight?

I must have missed it."

YUP, missed it you did!

Have you not been paying attention or noticed:

The JREFERs are good examples of messeger shooters, who assume every criticism of NIST signals a TWOOFER in the house. NISTIAN soldiers who march straight into denial mode whenever they are challenged...

These JREFERs show, time and again, how well they know the NIST Report, and are able to quote it, Chapter and Verse..... but FLIP-FLOP when faced with the great UNKNOWN territory of WTC collapse information OUTSIDE of the areas studied by NIST.


Frank, I keep reading people complimenting you on your discovery of aspects of the collapses that NIST overlooked or minimized. You have provoked hostility by acting as though you want to overturn NIST's explanation in favor of something you steadfastly refuse to flesh out.

I suspect that many of us understand you to be saying roughly the following: NIST claims that the impact of the planes dislodged fireproofing, which augmented the capacity of the fires to weaken the structural steel. I feel that the agency neglects to consider chemical reactions which were additional sources of heat.

Have I expressed your position fairly? In other words, NIST says that the energy available was sufficient for a gravity-driven collapse. You respond that they err on the side of understatement: the energy available, taking into consideration the sources overlooked, was more than sufficient. You are correcting the NIST Report, amplifying it, making it more precise.

But, if this is true, you aren't an anti-NISTian, are you?

Are you saying something different?

What?

Was the removal of the fireproofing important or not?


These NISTIAN APOLOGISTS say that if NIST didn't study it, it's not worth studying, or NIST probably DID study it, but found nothing of interest worth reporting.

In fact, when confronted with evidence of interesting information NOT addressed by NIST they offer endless, nit-picking arguments rather than concede one single lousy point to a perceived Twoofer... And about this time the comments start from the Argwiners, Tounge Lashers and other assorted Enigmas and Pardalian Variations, that I am childish, or "a failed scientist", or whatever...

So Pomeroo, may I suggest that until some JREFERs cease and desist with such behavior, then let the chips (including the one I allegedly bear on my shoulder), fall where they may.


Let's be very specific: didn't Mackey comment that he finds your theory very interesting? Has anyone ridiculed your abilities as a chemist?



And PLEASE do not even try to apologize for the behavior of your compadres!

P.S. I would gladly share my research with you, but not until something changes around here.


Frank, many people here are trying hard to like you.
 
Not only has Frank convinced me that the area of "chemical reaction contributions to heat in the WTCs" is an area that should be investigated/studied, but it was through his selected questioning, and that of CC, that has made me fascinated with the possibility that the iron spherules Jones and crew are gone giddy over as proof of thermite, may in fact be due to nothing more elaborate, than heated human blood.

TAM:)
 
The Rover has left no tire tracks..

Frank, while your work with 9/11 has been pretty good, you really need to get your head out of Dark Moon and study the Apollo record before making really, really, really dumb comments like that.
 
We salute our wise Canadian neighbors!

AS17-134-20379.jpg
 
And we all look forward to your paper on the matter. If it's anything like your previous 9/11 work it'll be top-notch.

While I would agree that "we all" look forward to Apollo's paper (if it ever materializes) on the matter, I do not think that it is safe to say that "we all" think that Apollo's work will be "top notch". The phrase, "his cheese has slipped off his cracker" leaps to mind. Accordingly, I cannot say with any confidence that I expect top notch work from him without first seeing what he comes up with. That is not to say that he will not produce a top notch paper, but I would not posit it as a given, in the circumstances. I'm a skeptic, after all. :)
 
Beachnut:

I am glad your calculation agrees with mine.

I think you have to choose your own mentor.

The Rover has left no tire tracks..
Presenting your paper is easier than cleaning up my scratching, and Dr. adds the academic credibility to it. Your other papers do not distract.

But it is going to, had it been anywhere yet? Who put the damn thing together? I thought they had just finished it, in place. Now I have dig up the photo again. Darn. It is the first few degree of rotation for the rover.

http://www.cofdev.hq.nasa.gov/IMAGES/SMALL/GPN-2000-001306.jpg

This is the big 5 meg photo. Someone had to put the thing there, so why would there be tracks. They did not go to the car dealer and drive it home.

http://www.cofdev.hq.nasa.gov/IMAGES/LARGE/GPN-2000-001306.jpg

I think that is were they put the darn thing together. But I was busy that day dating my future wife and working at Six Flags. So was that the place they put the rover together? I like the dirt drifting back to the ground.

http://www.lpi.usra.edu/resources/apollo/frame/?AS15-85-11470 is the rover before or as it starts to move and 71 is the next photo with the rover moving some.
 
Last edited:
People who really believe man went to the moon are deranged.

The space shuttle has never gone further than 400 miles up. When it did, they beat a hasty retreat due to the radiation.
 
While I would agree that "we all" look forward to Apollo's paper (if it ever materializes) on the matter, I do not think that it is safe to say that "we all" think that Apollo's work will be "top notch". The phrase, "his cheese has slipped off his cracker" leaps to mind. Accordingly, I cannot say with any confidence that I expect top notch work from him without first seeing what he comes up with. That is not to say that he will not produce a top notch paper, but I would not posit it as a given, in the circumstances. I'm a skeptic, after all. :)

In other words....If it debunks the CTs you will accept it but if it suggests conspiracy you will assume Greening is a loon. Thats great skepticism!

BTW, what exactly are your qualifications to judge Greenings work?
 
People who really believe man went to the moon are deranged.

The space shuttle has never gone further than 400 miles up. When it did, they beat a hasty retreat due to the radiation.

Shame that Gemini made it to 1190 kilometers (738 miles) long before Apollo isn't.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom