Medicine should be taught in high school

Dabljuh

Muse
Joined
Jun 1, 2007
Messages
600
Another thread was sidetracking, so I start this thread now.

Medicine should be taught in schools. Drugs should no longer require a prescription.

Why?

Teaching medicine would help alleviate health costs and increase the health of a population. Free drug trade is a the only way to avoid the black market - which does not benefit anyone.
 
Last edited:
Yes medicine is a rather broad topic. I'm thinking of

- The normal function of the human body (this often gets overlooked. You can't tell what's wrong when you don't know what's normal and benign)
- Conditions, such as hereditary, infectious etc
- Treatment, drugs, safety etc
- Living healthy, nutrition, how not to catch a cold etc
- Theoretical Science, how good studies differ from bad ones, what to look out for in Pharmaceutical Marketing etc
- You know, what *you* think every person should know about "medicine"

What the subject of the new "medicine" classes should be, may also be discussed here.
 
It seems unlikely that pharmacology could be taught in high school in a way that did not result in numerous disasters from people taking the wrong drugs or too many or the wrong combinations (not forgetting addictive drugs). I guess you might argue that is good for the species as the smarter kids would survive but antibiotic resistance would be unmanageable.
 
Teaching medicine would help alleviate health costs and increase the health of a population.
How much 'medicine'? Just the basics? Enough to become a medic?

Aren't most kids already taught the basics in biology class or gym? (Note: I do think that basic health should be taught, but I also think that basic physics, chemistry, and math should be taught as well.)
Free drug trade is a the only way to avoid a black market, that does not benefit anyone.

Careful with that suggestion.

While I do agree that legalizing narcotics would eliminate eliminate the black market, is it really a good idea to legalize ALL drugs? What about anti-biotics (where the misuse can accelerate the appearance of drug-resistant strains.) Not that I suggest there are junkies looking for their next fix of penecillian, but if all drugs are available without a prescription then people may try to 'cure' themselves without seeing a doctor.
 
It seems unlikely that pharmacology could be taught in high school in a way that did not result in numerous disasters from people taking the wrong drugs or too many or the wrong combinations (not forgetting addictive drugs). I guess you might argue that is good for the species as the smarter kids would survive but antibiotic resistance would be unmanageable.
I claim that teaching basic pharmacology would result in LESS drug-related disasters than the way we handle it now. I.e. scientifically unsound scare-tactics about the dangers of cocaine on the one side, but mandatory ritalin prescriptions on the other.

How much 'medicine'? Just the basics? Enough to become a medic?
Maybe. You decide. I think you need enough basic medicine education to save your own life, first.
Aren't most kids already taught the basics in biology class or gym? (Note: I do think that basic health should be taught, but I also think that basic physics, chemistry, and math should be taught as well.)
Biology teaches a lot of stuff, for example evolution and other nonsense (I AM KIDDING DONT LIGHT ME ON FIRE PLEASE) that's also important, but not so much as to be able to diagnose & treat oneself for basic stuff, in my opinion. basic physics, chemistry (not math) are, in my opinion, less important than medical education. Because the latter one is about your butt, and everyone understands "gravity" without knowing "Ep=mhg".

While I do agree that legalizing narcotics would eliminate eliminate the black market, is it really a good idea to legalize ALL drugs? What about anti-biotics (where the misuse can accelerate the appearance of drug-resistant strains.) Not that I suggest there are junkies looking for their next fix of penecillian, but if all drugs are available without a prescription then people may try to 'cure' themselves without seeing a doctor.
Antibiotics-Abuse is already now a problem. If people are properly taught that antibiotics WILL make the strains in their body immune, and mean that they will not work in the case of an emergency, and that they WILL damage probiotics, that they WILL damage mitochondria permanently, then they'll know better. That's what education is about.
 
Last edited:
What to do in the middle of nowhere when something goes wrong, and you can't dial 911? Find out in Wilderness Medicine, taught by Marc Nelson, clinical associate professor of surgery, on Wednesdays, beginning April 5.
http://news-service.stanford.edu/pr/95/950303Arc5348.html

...The medical technology class was developed in 1994 from Carrese's desire to combine teaching, which she loved, with working in hospitals, which she missed. That year, she approached her principal, Niel Tebbano - now the district's director of curriculum and instruction - who gave the idea preliminary approval. Carrese spent the next summer developing the course, and it was approved for Regents credit.

In the fall of 1996, the course had 25 students. Now there are more than 120. The class contains a wide mix - honors students looking for something different, teens interested in the medical field and even some students considering dropping out of high school and looking for some job training.

"I'm looking into colleges for pre-med because of this class," said Kevin Pachucki, a junior. "I came in here kind of blind. I'm just incredibly happy that I took it."

Sixteen-year-old Lisa Lachanski credits that class with giving her enough training to qualify for a job as a nurse's aide at Ellis Hospital in Schenectady. "It's a lot of work," she said. "For this class, there's so much to learn."
...

Students must have two years of previous hard-science experience, and get much of their information off a Web site Carrese has set up. Most of the year is made up of labs where they learn and practice such skills as reading X-rays and prescriptions, identifying diseases from blood samples, learning medical terminology and analyzing medical studies. Every two weeks, they gather to drink decaffeinated coffee or tea and discuss medical ethics, such as the use of aborted fetuses to gather stem cells for a life-saving cancer treatment....

http://www.emsc.nysed.gov/cis/Archive/stw/mar12.html
 
It seems unlikely that pharmacology could be taught in high school in a way that did not result in numerous disasters from people taking the wrong drugs or too many or the wrong combinations (not forgetting addictive drugs). I guess you might argue that is good for the species as the smarter kids would survive but antibiotic resistance would be unmanageable.
And, if you think it can, spend some time in a HS Chemistry class.
 
I claim that teaching basic pharmacology would result in LESS drug-related disasters than the way we handle it now. I.e. scientifically unsound scare-tactics about the dangers of cocaine on the one side, but mandatory ritalin prescriptions on the other.

{snip}


Do you have any evidence to back up any of the claims contained in this statement?
 
Do you have any evidence to back up any of the claims contained in this statement?
Consider every case of drug overdose, of drug mismatch, and otherwise "irresponsible" drug use, medical and recreational, that could be avoided by additional education. Enough evidence?

Do you have any evidence that falsifies my claim? Like, a study showing that doctors are more likely to die of drug overdoses than analphabets?
Can we start with nutrition?
... Sure?
 
Consider every case of drug overdose, of drug mismatch, and otherwise "irresponsible" drug use, medical and recreational, that could be avoided by additional education. Enough evidence?

Do you have any evidence that falsifies my claim? Like, a study showing that doctors are more likely to die of drug overdoses than analphabets?
... Sure?


"I claim that teaching basic pharmacology would result in LESS drug-related disasters than the way we handle it now. I.e. scientifically unsound scare-tactics about the dangers of cocaine on the one side, but mandatory ritalin prescriptions on the other."

Do you have evidence:

1) that teaching basic pharmacology to high school students would result in FEWER "drug-related" disasters?

2) that "scientifically-unsound scare tactics" are being used w/r to cocaine education?

3) of the existence of mandatory Ritalin prescriptions?
 
Antibiotics-Abuse is already now a problem. If people are properly taught that antibiotics WILL make the strains in their body immune, and mean that they will not work in the case of an emergency, and that they WILL damage probiotics, that they WILL damage mitochondria permanently, then they'll know better. That's what education is about.
Yes, and when adults are told this by their doctor they still want her/him to make an exception in their case. Perhaps the students will nod and agree, but I wonder what they will do next time they get tonsillitis.

And that's just antibiotics. What about tranquillizers? Opiates? You really think some High School classes would cause people not misusing them?
 
medical topics:
Anatomy and Physiology - the body and how it functions
This is worthy of study in high school but not as indepth as college level classes.

Pathology - how disese affects the body
I don't see the need for this class in high school but it may be worth it for advanced high school students.

Kinetics - movement of the body
I guess a hs student with a backround in physics and A&P could study this.

Pharmacology - the study of how substances interact with living organisms to produce a change in function
If you want to focus on medications this class can be taught to hs students who have taken A&P and Chemistry

Human Nutrion, Human Sexuality, psychology and abnormal psych should all have a place in hs.

I took my emergency medical technician class as a hs senior.
 
Consider every case of drug overdose, of drug mismatch, and otherwise "irresponsible" drug use, medical and recreational, that could be avoided by additional education. Enough evidence?
In Sweden you get an information sheet with every pack of medicine you buy. I don't know about the rest of the world, but I imagine it's the same in many countries. There you can read about your medicine, how to take it (ie with food,with at least a half glass of water and so on) possible side effects, possible interactions - all you need to know. If you read the information. Here's the problem: most people don't. They take the pill or whatever every morning or whatever the doctor said. Or perhaps not, they may take two because they don't think one is enough, or not take them for some days because they get a stomach ache .

You know the old proverb: You can lead your horse to the water but not force it to drink.:p
 
Medicine should be taught in schools. Drugs should no longer require a prescription.

How many semester-hours should be devoted to this topic?
ETA: Will these classes include how to draw blood, how to do a blood cell count, how to culture a bacteria, and the dozens of other things necessary to reliably produce an accurate diagnosis?

Teaching medicine would help alleviate health costs and increase the health of a population. Free drug trade is a the only way to avoid the black market - which does not benefit anyone.

Are there any countries where this approach has been successfully used?
 
Last edited:
Ummm, medical school is not easy. My mother in law used to teach pharmacology, and many people fail.

Life is dangerous enough. This would be disastrous.

Why not teach architecture and structural engineering in high school? Let any HS grad design bridges and sky scrapers!
 
Another thread was sidetracking, so I start this thread now.

Medicine should be taught in schools. Drugs should no longer require a prescription.

Why?

Teaching medicine would help alleviate health costs and increase the health of a population. Free drug trade is a the only way to avoid a black market, that does not benefit anyone.

Calculus and organic chemistry are prerequisites. These are 2nd year programs.

A highschool student is nowhere near ready to tackle even the basics.

My colleagues took mechanics in highschool - I would never let those jokers near my car. And mechanics is a lot easier than medicine.

Deregulation of prescribing will simply increase the influence of distorting advertising, and take power away from individuals and voters and into the hands of shareholders. Remember: that's the way it used to be.

The history of medical regulation is written in gravestones.
 
Why not teach architecture and structural engineering in high school? Let any HS grad design bridges and sky scrapers!

There are movements for this, too, actually.

A few years ago the BCSkeptics interviewed a chap who wanted to eliminate the 'red tape rules' surrounding construction project tenders. The law is that applicants must have a construction engineer approve the plans. Our correspondent felt this was racketeering.

His proposal was to build highway and rail bridges out of bamboo. If they became weak, it was because of bad vibes, but that was OK: he'd strengthen them up with pyramid and crystal power from time to time.
 
Do you have evidence:

1) that teaching basic pharmacology to high school students would result in FEWER "drug-related" disasters?
No. This is my hypothesis, which remains to be tested. It is up to you to consider the worthiness of my hypothesis, in absence of high-quality studies ("evidence" that would be acceptable) on the subject.
2) that "scientifically-unsound scare tactics" are being used w/r to cocaine education?
Not at hand. In general, narcotics are often vilified far beyond scientific accuracy. Not only cocaine, but also heroin, (opiates serve as pain killers) marijuana (ever heard of "reefer madness"? look it up) and other illegal drugs. Legal remedies, on the other hand, are glorified. Of course there is also certain elements, e.g. books and movies that glorify narcotics, but these aren't taught at schools.
3) of the existence of mandatory Ritalin prescriptions?
Yes. I know of a case in 1999 where a court ordered parents to give ritalin to their children. Also, there is significant pressure from schools on parents to give their "ADD child" the drug, threatening to otherwise kick the kid out of school for its bad behaviour.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom