North Pole is melting faster than predicted

CO2 is a greenhouse gas, and without it there'd be no liquid water on the planet. OK, maybe a little bit at midday in the tropics, but more than that is better. Consider temperatures on the Moon, which shares our orbit. Without the grenhouse effect that's pretty much what we'd have down here.

CO2 isn't bad. It is what it is, and does what it does. There's third more of it doing just that than in 1850. It's counter-intuitive to suggest that that wouldn't make a significant difference. And it has.:rolleyes:

Yes, CO2 it does what indeed it does, perhaps nothing. There's a third more of it doing nothing, also.

Can you show some relation between co2 increase and temperature?

I have yet to see that.

Start with 1850, and take it from there...that's where there starts to be a little ice age and slight temperature increases from that. Perhaps use the relative increases and decreases in the atmosphere due to CO2 and correlate that with temperature increases and decreases.

Right?
 
This is inter related - many schemes to "reduce emissions" have a net effect of moving it offshore. If some large fraction of China's production went to the US (it does) then pro rata fraction of our consumption is at their level of emissions. To reduce it you hurt them, seriously...

Yet you don't apply the same logic to GDP as you do to consumption. When you think about it, these are closely linked. A major cause of China's growth has been its assumption of much of the US's basic manufacturing - which is an inherently energy-hungry economic sector. The US has turned to finance and services - low energy sectors - to maintain its GDP. Which pays for its consumption. (Along with loans from East Asia, but let's not complicate matters.)

If you regard carbon emissions per dollar GDP as a useful measure you'll want to take that into account.

Any scheme to "reduce emissions" is either political ...

Since by "scheme" I think you mean policy, yes, it would be political.

... a transfer of cash to underdeveloped countries (a la Kyoto) ...

That did what now? Anyway, it sounds like a good thing.

... or realistic, which has harsh and non trivial impacts on those developing countries.

Alarming, isn't it? Realism?

In either case, you must look at the developing nations to understand the future, developing problem of greenhouse gas emissions (AGW believer), or question the veracity of the argument based on CO2 directly (AGW skeptic).

If I read this right, you question the veracity of greenhouse science (and the basic science behind it) because of projections of CO2 emissions by developing regions. I'm definitely zeroing-in on the meaning of "alarmism" now.

Personally, I accept the science, accept that we're screwed, and remain unalarmed. I get bloody irritated at times, but that's an entirely different matter.
 
When that happens to me, I can use a beer:D

I think you misread mhaze's point. At first read I tought the same as you, but then I noticed that he is saying that the future emissions of CO2 by development countries will probe that AGW by CO2 or pollution is false.


If I read this right, you question the veracity of greenhouse science (and the basic science behind it) because of projections of CO2 emissions by developing regions. I'm definitely zeroing-in on the meaning of "alarmism" now.

Personally, I accept the science, accept that we're screwed, and remain unalarmed. I get bloody irritated at times, but that's an entirely different matter.
 
If I read this right, you question the veracity of greenhouse science (and the basic science behind it) because of projections of CO2 emissions by developing regions. I'm definitely zeroing-in on the meaning of "alarmism" now.

Personally, I accept the science, accept that we're screwed, and remain unalarmed. I get bloody irritated at times, but that's an entirely different matter.

We are in total agreement on that perspective. ***IF*** IPCC/GORE AGW CO2 theory - note the CO2 theory statement - turned out to be accurate as of the Feb 2007 IPCC summary for policymakers, then I would agree that those who say the Feb 2007 IPCC SPM was too conservative were correct, or as you put it, "we're screwed".

The IPCC documents by the way have nothing to say about "tipping points" that is a separate contrivance by alarmists.

Now let's all return to reality from that brief exercise in science fiction.
There is no crisis and no reason for the alarmism.:D
 
Yes, CO2 it does what indeed it does, perhaps nothing. There's a third more of it doing nothing, also.

That it does something is easily proven in the lab, as was done years ago.

It's also an amazing fertilizer according to CO2 science. It's actually much more than that, it's where plants get their Carbon to make their organic compounds.

Can you show some relation between co2 increase and temperature?

I have yet to see that.
Demonstrated in the IPCC report.
 
Last edited:
Yet you don't apply the same logic to GDP as you do to consumption. When you think about it, these are closely linked. A major cause of China's growth has been its assumption of much of the US's basic manufacturing - which is an inherently energy-hungry economic sector. The US has turned to finance and services - low energy sectors - to maintain its GDP. Which pays for its consumption. (Along with loans from East Asia, but let's not complicate matters.)

If you regard carbon emissions per dollar GDP as a useful measure you'll want to take that into account.

A subtle argument but one which when you think about it makes total sense goes like this.

Underdeveloped nations can only get out of their rut by the people there wanting to raise their standard of living to be like the US and western Europe. What happens is then
1. they become offshore manufacturing sources for the developed nations
2. they develop their banking and technological infrastructure
3. the people see their standard of living raised and want more material goods
4. a shift occurs to service and information economies as has in the more developed nations

The argument is that you can only solve the problems of the underdeveloped nations by encouraging them fully down this path. Thus, (counterintuitively) lots of coal fired power plants for Africa is a good thing, and high emissions in the short run in China is a good thing, because in the medium term, they rise out of that. (nuclear power is the way out).

According to the IPCC and the alarmist crowd, this cannot be done because there is so much CO2 already in the air that it will have this continuing effect, urgent, crisis, yada yada yada. and so forth down that line of rhetoric.

The question is not whether the IPCC position is the nice or preferred position (of course it isn't) but whether it is scientifically correct.
 
Yes, CO2 it does what indeed it does, perhaps nothing.

Not possibly nothing. It's a greenhouse gas. Greenhouse science was worked-up to explain the observed and obvious difference between the Earth's actual temperature and the predictions of thermodynamics. Which, by a twist of fate, developed in concert with fossil-fueled industrialisation.

You still haven't exposed yourself to the basic science or history of the greenhouse effect, have you?

There's a third more of it doing nothing, also.

So your impossible "perhaps" becomes "is"? You're working hard at not being alarmed.

Can you show some relation between co2 increase and temperature?

See the CO2 feedback effect on Milankovich cycles. Or the world around you today. They're both good.

I have yet to see that.

With eyes clamped-shut, it's hardly surprising. Or did you steal Zaphod Beeblebrox's sunglasses?

Start with 1850, and take it from there...that's where there starts to be a little ice age ...

How little do they come? Are there pocket versions? Time was the Little Ice Age was around the 16thCE, and the concept was on a relegation slide in the history world long before it became a political issue. I could explain why if you like, but that would be History, not Science.

There was a big scary eruption around 1850, the name escapes me. There was a lot of that in the 19thCE, Tambora early on, this other one in the middle, the more famous Krakatoa towards the end. That goes a long way towards explaining the cold and chaotic nature of the 19thCE climate. They didn't have AGW to bail them out, since CO2-load was barely changing. The increase has been exponential. In 1850 many US railroads still ran on wood, not coal. That only stopped when the wood ran out.

and slight temperature increases from that. Perhaps use the relative increases and decreases in the atmosphere due to CO2 and correlate that with temperature increases and decreases.

Right?

Not so much right as incoherent.

You've made previous and cryptic reference to observed reductions in CO2-load after 1850. Do you have any reason to think they've occurred? Something more substantial than "perhaps they have"?
 
A subtle argument but one which when you think about it makes total sense goes like this.

Underdeveloped nations ...

It doesn't address undeveloped nations. It directly addresses your dislocation of GDP and consumption, which are intimately linked. In the first case you ignore China, in the second you include it.

It's not subtle. It doesn't have to be.
 
Last edited:
That it does something is easily proven in the lab, as was done years ago.

It's also an amazing fertilizer according to CO2 science. It's actually much more than that, it's where plants get their Carbon to make their organic compounds.

And yet it's such a tiny trace in the atmosphere.

Which is what they used to say about phosgene to boost morale ... :rolleyes:

In truth, of course, it was said to induce alarm, because it was frickin' alarming.

If CO2 was visible and/or made you choke, this discussion would be long dead. Absent that, it will drag on. Has dragged on, while AGW happens around us. But apparently not around some other people :) .
 
If CO2 was visible and/or made you choke, this discussion would be long dead. Absent that, it will drag on. Has dragged on, while AGW happens around us. But apparently not around some other people :) .
Yep.

And you know maybe we're wrong? Maybe Earth is feeling left out, wants to join the party. Or, it's like your next door neighbors really get along, have a lot in common, and there you are in the middle. Obstructing.

Because of the 4 terrestrial planets: Fine, Mercury essentially has no atmosphere. Throw it out.

Venus has an atmosphere of about 95% CO2.

Mars has an atmosphere of about 95% CO2.

Here we are with our disruptive Nitrogen / Oxygen atmosphere (with CO2 thrown in for a goof).

So it could be that Earth is tired of being the meddlesome neighbor guy in the middle? Wants to be like its neighbors, air-wise?
 
You've made previous and cryptic reference to observed reductions in CO2-load after 1850. Do you have any reason to think they've occurred? Something more substantial than "perhaps they have"?

Cryptic references? What on earth are you talking about.

I assume you have some place to get your science from other than me?

The issue was posed to you to prove up the assertion you made, if you were able to, other than basing it on belief. Find your own chart, make your own conclusions, and let's see what you come up with.
 
We are in total agreement on that perspective. ***IF*** IPCC/GORE AGW CO2 theory - note the CO2 theory statement - turned out to be accurate as of the Feb 2007 IPCC summary for policymakers, then I would agree that those who say the Feb 2007 IPCC SPM was too conservative were correct, or as you put it, "we're screwed".

The IPCC documents by the way have nothing to say about "tipping points" that is a separate contrivance by alarmists.

Now let's all return to reality from that brief exercise in science fiction.
There is no crisis and no reason for the alarmism.:D

Was that my exercise in science fiction? You described Africa in 2050 as a "shining beacon"; that's science fiction. You judge science by its implications, which is presumably why the subject frightens you so much. "It might not" may be a comfort to you, but it's not persuasive to anybody that's remotely literate scientifically. Which leaves you with a wide audience generally, but not so much in this environment.
 
Cryptic references? What on earth are you talking about.

I posted "We haven't had the opportunity to observe a decrease in CO2-load". You responded "Are you sure?" Is that cryptic, or what? I replied "yes", and there it lay. Recently you've asked for temperature curves matching the increase and decrease of CO2-load since 1850. Another cryptic reference, quite apart from its inherent silliness.

I assume you have some place to get your science from other than me?

My entire frickin' lifetime's education. Which you haven't contributed to in any scientific sense. In a behavioural sense, you have. Not much, but some.

The issue was posed to you to prove up the assertion you made, if you were able to, other than basing it on belief.

Again with the incoherence. I'm drunk as well, you know, and I can still tell.

Find your own chart, make your own conclusions, and let's see what you come up with.

Find my own chart? I don't need such comfort-blankets. I get out there in the real world and deal with it.
 
Cryptic references? What on earth are you talking about.

I assume you have some place to get your science from other than me?

The issue was posed to you to prove up the assertion you made, if you were able to, other than basing it on belief. Find your own chart, make your own conclusions, and let's see what you come up with.
​
I posted "We haven't had the opportunity to observe a decrease in CO2-load". You responded "Are you sure?" Is that cryptic, or what? I replied "yes", and there it lay. Recently you've asked for temperature curves matching the increase and decrease of CO2-load since 1850. Another cryptic reference, quite apart from its inherent silliness.

Find my own chart? I don't need such comfort-blankets. I get out there in the real world and deal with it.

So...

Whether or not there is a relation between a given quantity of CO2 in the atmosphere, and a given temperature, further, whether a causal relation can be established between CO2 and temperature, based on the historical variations in CO2 and temperature since 1850.

Regarding your conclusive opinion supported by facts with sources, or in the alternative, an unsubstantiated opinion based on belief.

That's all?

No comfort blankets of facts and science for the rest of us?

Just the arguments ad absurdo sidesteperado, ad argumentado obscurado, and ad argumento minutae?
 
So...

Whether or not there is a relation between a given quantity of CO2 in the atmosphere, and a given temperature, further, whether a causal relation can be established between CO2 and temperature, based on the historical variations in CO2 and temperature since 1850.

Regarding your conclusive opinion supported by facts with sources, or in the alternative, an unsubstantiated opinion based on belief.

That's all?

No comfort blankets of facts and science for the rest of us?

Just the arguments ad absurdo sidesteperado, ad argumentado obscurado, and ad argumento minutae?

It's all in the IPCC report.
 
The name of the book quoted says it all....

So, I bring a World Bank publication of 2007 to the table, and you dismiss it because of perceived left-wing issues... The World Bank...

Paranoia, thy name is hazy...
 
I don't see Megalodon clarifying Safe Keeper the great way he usually does

Unlike other people, Megalodon actually has a real life, and his PhD will not write itself.

I dedicate the time I find adequate to snipe at the idiocy I see posted in this forum. No more, no less.

But thank you for missing me, it's heart-warming :)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom