Should Ahmadinejad be allowed to speak at Columbia University?

Thanks Cleon for pointing out those two examples for me. That's new for me and I must say that freedom of speech in the U.S. is exaggerated in my opinion. That's going a little too far.

Well, the whole point is, who are you (or me, or Congress, or Prez'dent Dubya) to decide what is "too far" and what isn't?
 
Well, the whole point is, who are you (or me, or Congress, or Prez'dent Dubya) to decide what is "too far" and what isn't?

There is such a thing a a body of laws against libel and related activities.

So, let Achmadinutjob enter the US, let him claim that the jews have faked the Holocaust, and then let the wonderfully efficient US legal system lock the bastard up.
 
There is such a thing a a body of laws against libel and related activities.

So, let Achmadinutjob enter the US, let him claim that the jews have faked the Holocaust, and then let the wonderfully efficient US legal system lock the bastard up.
In this country, you can tell some lies without going to jail. I refer you to, uh, er, about every politician I can think of at the moment.

Not locked up.

Mahmoud the Mouth is just that, the mouthpiece. The real power in Iran, the HMFIC (Head Mullah Farsi In Charge) isn't going to leave his country. He sends Mahmoud out to do his light work, like trolling at Columbia.

Columbia may need to look to its own backside when all is said and done. Their rep on the line.

This should be entertaining as hell.

DR
 
Last edited:
So, let Achmadinutjob enter the US, let him claim that the jews have faked the Holocaust, and then let the wonderfully efficient US legal system lock the bastard up.

First, in the US, libel requires you to libel an actual person, not just a group.
Second, libel doesn't expose you to imprisonment, just civil liability.
Third, Achmedinejad enjoys diplomatic immunity as the Head of State of Iran.
 
Well, the whole point is, who are you (or me, or Congress, or Prez'dent Dubya) to decide what is "too far" and what isn't?
In my opinion, what is considered taboo in society should not be legally advertized or given freedom of speech.
 
In my opinion, what is considered taboo in society should not be legally advertized or given freedom of speech.

That's a very dangerous road to go down. Have you thought this through?

Atheism is considered taboo in much (most?) of the United States. Should it be illegal to have public meetings for atheists?

Your opinion basically sums up as "minority opinion should be banned," and I simply cannot see how you can justify that.
 
That's a very dangerous road to go down. Have you thought this through?

Atheism is considered taboo in much (most?) of the United States. Should it be illegal to have public meetings for atheists?

Your opinion basically sums up as "minority opinion should be banned," and I simply cannot see how you can justify that.
It sounds to me like the sort of thing that the Iranian president would say. I always find it interesting how the most extreme critics of places like Iran seem to share a common philosophy with their supposed enemy, standing against freedom and human rights.
 
This has been attributed to Voltaire, but I believe that it was actually written by Evelyn Beatrice Hall; "I disapprove of what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it".

Those exact words are on a number of fliers posted around the campus, only they all attribute it to Voltaire. Guess that shows the benefits of an Ivy League education. :D

I have to back to campus to deliver a lecture myself in half an hour or so, so it will be interesting to see how big the demo is. From what I saw earlier, it didn't look like there was much going on there, despite the stack of flyers posted all around the place.
 
Makes you wonder how much power Ahneedahandjob really has inside Iran? I think he must be something more than just a mouth, but I don't know how much. Not everything he says is necessarily vetted by the mullahs -- I'd even hazard a guess that he pains them at times.

But that's the trouble with dictatorships: nothing is defined, there's no law. Everything is constantly shifting, and, unlike democracies, power comes out the muzzle of a gun.
 
That's a very dangerous road to go down. Have you thought this through?

Atheism is considered taboo in much (most?) of the United States. Should it be illegal to have public meetings for atheists?

Your opinion basically sums up as "minority opinion should be banned," and I simply cannot see how you can justify that.

I beg to differ.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taboo
"A taboo is a strong social ban against words, objects, actions, discussions, or people that are considered undesirable or offensive by a group, culture, or society."
If we take the definition which regards to society then what I have said firmly stands its ground.
Minority opinions are always welcomed and not all minority opinions are taboo (in fact, most of them are not) as long as they are not pro violence, hatred or the likes towards others. (of course I'm not rewriting the laws here so what I'm saying is general and must be regarded as such)
On a side note, I don't understand how that men-boy association is allowed to advertize itself if underage sex is illegal (is it not illegal?).
 
Last edited:
In my opinion, what is considered taboo in society should not be legally advertized or given freedom of speech.
Not too long ago Darwins ideas were considered taboo in many societies. The whole purpose of freedom of speech is to allow examination of all different ideas and select the best. Some ideas will be crackpot, some brilliant. Initially the theory of evolution was considered the former, but it eventually turned out to be the latter.

The entire purpose of freedom of speech is to allow freedom of unpopular speech. And makes easier to spot idiots.
 
Not too long ago Darwins ideas were considered taboo in many societies. The whole purpose of freedom of speech is to allow examination of all different ideas and select the best. Some ideas will be crackpot, some brilliant. Initially the theory of evolution was considered the former, but it eventually turned out to be the latter.

The entire purpose of freedom of speech is to allow freedom of unpopular speech. And makes easier to spot idiots.
Almost Exactly the idea I had written.
Society had examined the idea of (for example) sex with minors (underage children) and has made it illegal because of certain reasons. It selected what it thought was best for itself and that was sex with who's considered an adult (age X and up). So sex with minors is taboo and should be discussed only at the organization which is responsible for law making in the country. Unless the idea had become legal it should not be advertized to the people. The same with rape, murder, theft, terror and so on.
 
I beg to differ.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taboo
"A taboo is a strong social ban against words, objects, actions, discussions, or people that are considered undesirable or offensive by a group, culture, or society."
If we take the definition which regards to society then what I have said firmly stands its ground.

No, it's just a question of degree. Minority opinion that is considered objectionable enough becomes "taboo," and thus outlawed.

I notice you glossed over my question about atheist meetings. Atheism is considered taboo. Should atheist meetings be banned?

Minority opinions are always welcomed and not all minority opinions are taboo (in fact, most of them are not) as long as they are not pro violence, hatred or the likes towards others.

Pro-violence? What does that mean? Supporting the war in Iraq is pro-violence. Supporting the IDF is pro-violence.

Pro-hatred? Same questions apply.

On a side note, I don't understand how that men-boy association is allowed to advertize itself if underage sex is illegal (is it not illegal?).

They're "allowed" to advocate that the law be changed. The moment they act on their ideas, they've crossed the line from "free speech" to "committing an illegal act."
 
Almost Exactly the idea I had written.
Society had examined the idea of (for example) sex with minors (underage children) and has made it illegal because of certain reasons. It selected what it thought was best for itself and that was sex with who's considered an adult (age X and up). So sex with minors is taboo and should be discussed only at the organization which is responsible for law making in the country. Unless the idea had become legal it should not be advertized to the people. The same with rape, murder, theft, terror and so on.

You're completely missing egslim's point, which is this: Should Darwin's ideas have been outlawed? They were considered taboo (and still are in many places).
 
Cleon said:
I notice you glossed over my question about atheist meetings. Atheism is considered taboo. Should atheist meetings be banned?
I don't understand how this relates to what I have said unless you're saying that Atheism is illegal. I have not heard that Atheism is illegal in the U.S. or Israel and so your question is irrelavant.
Pro-violence? What does that mean? Supporting the war in Iraq is pro-violence. Supporting the IDF is pro-violence.

Pro-hatred? Same questions apply.

I thought I had made myself clear on this:

yairhol said:
The same with rape, murder, theft, terror and so on.

and regarding the war in Iraq, do you consider what the united states is doing in Iraq as murder?
I've also said this:
yairhol said:
of course I'm not rewriting the laws here so what I'm saying is general and must be regarded as such
so don't ask me if X,Y,Z etc. are in my taboo list or not because rewriting the law is not my purpose here. I'm giving my reasons to a general subject.

Cleon said:
You're completely missing egslim's point, which is this: Should Darwin's ideas have been outlawed? They were considered taboo (and still are in many places).
You missed what I had written:
yairhol said:
Minority opinions are always welcomed and not all minority opinions are taboo (in fact, most of them are not) as long as they are not pro violence, hatred or the likes towards others.
Freedom of religion or lack of it should not be illegal. The same applies to science.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom