Homeopathic Cough Medicine

Well, that's 1000 posts so I declare this thread officially over. Anyone posting from now on will be in breach of the Cuddles Accord of 2007 and will be subject to a severe tickling when they least expect it.
 
Moonlight is already a homoeopathic dilution - of sunlight.


I hope you all enjoyed my holiday! :D
(Moochie, shame on you not having the low-down on our local variety :o )

BJ
 
Some of my best friends are quantum mechanics. They are friendly people who are untroubled by this lack of understanding. And I think it is for the best.

In 1971, my organic chemistry professor began the semester by writing "H(psi) = E(psi)" on the chalkboard. Then he said "When they solve this equation, we will be out of business." Fortunately, they are no closer today than they were then.
To solving? Indeed they aren't closer to that. To computing useful approximate solutions for real problems? You bet "they" are already doing that.
 
Why is it that I find this part rather amusing?



(bold mine)

So THAT'S what those lighthouse keepers were doing, all by their lonesome selves.

Congratulations on posting the thousandth message to this thread.

I would like to reward you with a lifetime supply of generic homeopathic pills. Just swallow with water -- they will fix any ailment you may (or may not) have. :D

M.
 
Last edited:
I agree with you [Linda] when you said to Billy Joe that its kind of insulting to talk down to people or soften your arguments because they might not be as informed or smart as you.
I didn't say "soften" or "talk down to". I said explain in terms the person you're conversing with can understand. Not everyone has special knowledge. Not everyone has the same level of understanding. Not everyone even has the same ability to understand. If you don't take this into account, communication will fail. I don't consider that insulting, I consider that commonsense.
 
I didn't say "soften" or "talk down to". I said explain in terms the person you're conversing with can understand. Not everyone has special knowledge. Not everyone has the same level of understanding. Not everyone even has the same ability to understand. If you don't take this into account, communication will fail. I don't consider that insulting, I consider that commonsense.

That may have been what you were talking about, but it wasn't what I was talking about. It (using words the other can understand) also seems to be too obvious to bother discussing.

Linda
 
Congratulations on posting the thousandth message to this thread.

I would like to reward you with a lifetime supply of generic homeopathic pills. Just swallow with water -- they will fix any ailment you may (or may not) have. :D

M.

Awesome! My doctor said that I have a terrible case of hypochondria -- will the pills help? :D
 
...and then, of course, there is also denial

...no, I'm going to be big about this...I'm going to let you have the last word. :)

BJ
 
...and then, of course, there is also denial

Huh? When have I ever denied that I am not always understandable?

Just cuz I don't get it right on my first (or second or third...) go doesn't mean I'm not trying.

I know. Much better to pretend I obfuscate from ignorance or malice so you can take another dig at me. I'm tempted to unleash the full power of my lexicon in your general direction.*

Linda

*really lame Monty Python joke
 
Rodney,

I resurrected this thread to point out that now that Ioannidis' work is in the news again, numerous science bloggers are subjecting alt med therapies to the same kind of analysis and criticism that I applied to homeopathy in this thread. The same kind of analysis and criticism that you insisted was not a valid approach.

http://www.theness.com/neurologicablog/index.php?p=8
http://www.marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2005/09/why_most_publis.html
http://scienceblogs.com/insolence/2007/09/the_cranks_pile_on_john_ioannidis_work_o.php

So there. :seP:

Linda
 
In the past I have printed up business cards with information and weblinks about the uselessness of homeopathic remedies and left the cards on the shelf next to the products. I don't know how well it works, but here's hoping. One of my friends says that in the past he has printed up information half-sheets of cardstock, run them through one of those card laminators to make a nice, stiff (And most important, official-looking) card. He then attaches them to the shelf near the items.

Because it's laminated, it's official, right? He says that sometimes the cards remain for weeks before somebody figures out they are not official company documents and remove them. I may try this in the future...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom