Purging voter registration roles as a way to cheat in an election

Skeptic Ginger

Nasty Woman
Joined
Feb 14, 2005
Messages
96,955
I've been posting on this topic in the CT forum as a conspiracy to effect the 2008 elections. That thread was specific to the federal attorney firing scandal and AG Gonzales' role. It's time to move the discussion to the politics thread and just discuss the caging issue. One of our forum members received a caging letter personally and posted a copy of it which bumped the CT forum thread. That thread is 12 pages long and has run its course. The following is a new report on this topic which was just published last month.

Caging Democracy: A 50-Year History of Partisan Challenges to Minority Voters; by Teresa James, J.D. Projectvote.org, will bring anyone up to speed who is interested in the subject. There's no sense in picking paragraphs, the whole document is relative. You can skim it or read it, but I'm hoping people take the time to find out what this is all about.

From the executive summary:
Voter caging is a term that drew public attention as a result of testimony provided by Monica Goodling, former White House liaison to the Department of Justice, to a 2007 House Judiciary Committee hearing on the firings of eight US Attorneys. Although public interest in voter caging is relatively recent, the practice is not new. Republicans have engaged in voter caging on the national and state level since the late 1950’s. According to many election observers, voter caging is a controversial political tactic that typically targets minority voters to directly disenfranchise them or suppress their vote by intimidation. Republican officials, on the other hand, maintain that voter caging is part of what they describe as “ballot security” measures necessary to combat voter fraud.

The following report reviews Republican voter caging operations during the last 50 years,
culminating with the unprecedented number of large voter caging operations conducted across the nation in the 2004 presidential election. ...



The author of the article since I think that is an important part of evaluating a source of information:
About Project Vote ... staff:
Teresa James, Counsel
Before joining Project Vote, Teresa James served as a legal editor with LexisNexis, a global legal and business information service. Her editing experience followed years in the practice of law at Legal Aid, a private law firm, and in her own practice. She is a graduate of Oberlin College and of Case Western Reserve Law School. During her time in college and in legal practice she maintained her community involvement with organizations such as the ACLU and the Lorain County Urban League . Teresa has served on the boards of the Oberlin ACLU and the Lorain County Legal Aid. She has also been active in Ohio community organizations involved in promoting open, fair, and transparent elections.
 
I recommend this video for those who aren't familiar with the lack
of oversight in all the different election-environments/systems:

HBO SPECIAL: Hacking_Democracy

Google Video This video is not hosted by the ISF, the ISF can not be held responsible for the suitability or legality of this material. By clicking the link below you agree to view content from an external website.
I AGREE
 
ZEP ---- Here ya go ---
caged_voters.jpg
 
Personally, I wish they would dump all the roles, now. Then, require proof of citizenship to register, and ID to vote.

I know that I was still on the roles for years after I moved from my folks. I could have voted twice, once for each address. Plus, at one point, I couldn't register at my residence, since I was living in a commercial unit. Totally legal, but the registrar didn't think so. Hmmm, maybe If I was registered as a Dem? Were Reps being caged? Was a Dem at the folks addy?
 
What IS "voter caging"?
You send out letters to people in the districts which are likely to vote against your party or candidate. The letters require people to prove they are the person registered to vote on the voter registration roles. Anyone who doesn't reply, you then take the returned mail to the voter registration office and protest that registered voter's legality. The voter is then removed from the voter registration role and they don't find out about it until they go to vote and cannot.


Variations on this depend on state laws regarding challenging the legality of a voter.

In FL in 2000, letters sent out had the fact you had to reply buried in fine print.

In the more recent Tim Griffin scandal, the letters went out to an area where lots of black military personnel lived who were in Iraq. The letters could not be signed for by anyone but the recipient and could not be forwarded. Those soldiers identified in the Excel list of names and addresses (which Greg Palast of the BBC news obtained and the Republican Party admitted was their list and which Monica Goodling testified to its use in a caging scheme under oath in the Attorney General Gonzales hearings over the suspiciously fired federal attorneys, one of whom was replaced by Tim Griffin who subsequently resigned since the caging scheme was illegal) which might favor Democratic candidates were sent letters the Republican Party knew the soldiers could not reply to since they were in Iraq. Did you follow that?

Caging is illegal when it clearly targets only voters likely to vote for one party or candidate. If you sent letters to the entire state to clean up out dated voter registration roles, it wouldn't be illegal.
 
Personally, I wish they would dump all the roles, now. Then, require proof of citizenship to register, and ID to vote.

I know that I was still on the roles for years after I moved from my folks. I could have voted twice, once for each address. Plus, at one point, I couldn't register at my residence, since I was living in a commercial unit. Totally legal, but the registrar didn't think so. Hmmm, maybe If I was registered as a Dem? Were Reps being caged? Was a Dem at the folks addy?
These are separate issues. No one is arguing against cleaning up voter registration roles as long as you clean them up without taking legit voters off the rolls and don't do it only in Democratic areas.

And, while a handful of people vote twice or vote using dead relatives' absentee ballots, there is no evidence it is widespread nor frequent enough and only one sided to impact an election outcome. This as well as voter picture ID requirements and the resulting voter disenfranchisement of poor and indigent voters who tend to vote Democratic was thoroughly discussed in the other thread is you are interested. See the OP link.
 
Caging is illegal when it clearly targets only voters likely to vote for one party or candidate. If you sent letters to the entire state to clean up out dated voter registration roles, it wouldn't be illegal.

What confuses me is that it seems to boil down to that simple issue: if you target certain areas, and not the entire state, to the advantage of one party, then it is clearly an illegal tactic. How can anyone be so stupid/ignorant/partisan as to not understand that?
 
What confuses me is that it seems to boil down to that simple issue: if you target certain areas, and not the entire state, to the advantage of one party, then it is clearly an illegal tactic. How can anyone be so stupid/ignorant/partisan as to not understand that?
Simple, there is a lot of science used in developing techniques of manipulating information in ways that fool a lot of people.
 
With electronic voting; none of this matters.

The problem many are having is still thinking that the two parties are against one another. I understand the emotional investment that many have made. Yet the results are the same no matter which party wins.

Did not the Dems run on the war during the mid term elections?

Did not the Dems; after winning, pass a NON-BINDING RESOLUTION?

I am throughly confused by those that can not see beyond the current political talking points; in particular those in the skeptical community.
 
Jerome, do I know you from another board? SFN maybe?

If we could elect Nader or Kucinich you would have a point. Otherwise your complaint is lacking in a viable alternative. Until we increase the critical thinking skills of the nation, we'll never overcome the power and influence of those most able to market their message. The alternative is to push for change from within and expect change to be very slow.
 
Last edited:
Did not the Dems run on the war during the mid term elections?

Did not the Dems; after winning, pass a NON-BINDING RESOLUTION?

I am throughly confused by those that can not see beyond the current political talking points; in particular those in the skeptical community.

Well what else could they have done? The democrats don't have a veto-proof majority, so they can only pass legislation that either the President or a decent sum of congressional Republicans approve of. Politics is about compromise, and when one side isn't willing to compromise, that means the other side has to compromise all the more to compensate.
 
Jerome, do I know you from another board? SFN maybe?

If we could elect Nader or Kucinich you would have a point. Otherwise your complaint is lacking in a viable alternative. Until we increase the critical thinking skills of the nation, we'll never overcome the power and influence of those most able to market their message. The alternative is to push for change from within and expect change to be very slow.

Ahh, he is the thing. The current system does not change; it continues in the same direction no matter which party is in control.

Can you really not see the continuing progression of control?
 
Well what else could they have done? The democrats don't have a veto-proof majority, so they can only pass legislation that either the President or a decent sum of congressional Republicans approve of. Politics is about compromise, and when one side isn't willing to compromise, that means the other side has to compromise all the more to compensate.

Congress controls the purse strings. At anytime congress can stop the funding. You can come up with all the excuses you want, but the fact remains that the Dems ran on the war and won. The Dems did not stop the funding. From this win they did nothing.

The Dems gave everyone who voted for them to stop the war the finger with a smile.

The majority of these same voters will vote for Hillary (who is for the war) and blame the GOP for the Dems inability to stop the war.

What a man believes upon grossly insufficient evidence is an index into his desires -- desires of which he himself is often unconscious. If a man is offered a fact which goes against his instincts, he will scrutinize it closely, and unless the evidence is overwhelming, he will refuse to believe it. If, on the other hand, he is offered something which affords a reason for acting in accordance to his instincts, he will accept it even on the slightest evidence. The origin of myths is explained in this way. - Bertrand Russell
 
I've been posting on this topic in the CT forum as a conspiracy to effect the 2008 elections. That thread was specific to the federal attorney firing scandal and AG Gonzales' role. It's time to move the discussion to the politics thread and just discuss the caging issue. One of our forum members received a caging letter personally and posted a copy of it which bumped the CT forum thread. That thread is 12 pages long and has run its course. The following is a new report on this topic which was just published last month.

Caging Democracy: A 50-Year History of Partisan Challenges to Minority Voters; by Teresa James, J.D. Projectvote.org, will bring anyone up to speed who is interested in the subject. There's no sense in picking paragraphs, the whole document is relative. You can skim it or read it, but I'm hoping people take the time to find out what this is all about.

From the executive summary:



The author of the article since I think that is an important part of evaluating a source of information:
About Project Vote ... staff:


Can you really be so obtuse that you failed to notice that WildCat was gently mocking your hysteria? He did not receive a "caging" letter.

No, that has no chance of sinking in. Let's try again:

HE DID NOT RECEIVE A "CAGING" LETTER!

The Republican Party had NOTHING to do with the notice he received. He received a routine notice from the Board of Elections, the sort I've received several times over the years (during which period I have NEVER changed my address), to confirm his address.

Your hobbyhorse is totally bogus, a transparent ploy by the Democrats to steal votes. I don't know who is more worthy of scorn--the cynical pols who perpetrate these scams, or the irrational, blinkered zealots like yourself who aid and abet them.
 
I had mixed interpretation of Wildcat's seriousness or sarcasm when he posted the letter, Pom, and I actually had to edit my post after reading his next post:
I have not moved, and my live-in g/f did not receive such a letter (though it could have been sent out and not yet received). I see no reason why I should have received this letter. I even voted in the last election....
He is of course welcome to comment further. Regardless of how anyone feels about the letter, someone was questioning his registration and that is how caging is done.

As far as did the Republicans have anything to do with the letter, you are drawing an unsubstantiated conclusion. Just as my Republican friend in WA got a letter from the elections board saying his signature didn't match his registration (from a couple decades earlier), the Republicans initiated the letter by challenging his mail in ballot signature. He at first thought the Democrats must have challenged his ballot but one's party affiliation was not indicated on that particular ballot. (Only in the primaries do you vote by party.) It turned out to be the Republicans challenging ballots in Democratic majority King County.

In short, you need to know who challenged WildCat's voter registration to know who initiated the inquest.
 
Last edited:
I had mixed interpretation of Wildcat's seriousness or sarcasm when he posted the letter, Pom, and I actually had to edit my post after reading his next post:He is of course welcome to comment further. Regardless of how anyone feels about the letter, someone was questioning his registration and that is how caging is done.

As far as did the Republicans have anything to do with the letter, you are drawing an unsubstantiated conclusion. Just as my Republican friend in WA got a letter from the elections board saying his signature didn't match his registration (from a couple decades earlier), the Republicans initiated the letter by challenging his mail in ballot signature. He at first thought the Democrats must have challenged his ballot but one's party affiliation was not indicated on that particular ballot. (Only in the primaries do you vote by party.) It turned out to be the Republicans challenging ballots in Democratic majority King County.

In short, you need to know who challenged WildCat's voter registration to know who initiated the inquest.



You need to know how elections boards operate. You don't, incidentally.
 
Pomer, you are just sticking your foot further and further in your mouth. If you would care to explain why Wildcat got that letter and his girlfriend didn't we are all anxious to hear. If you are aware of Cook County, Illinois' election board updating voter registration roles independent of any Republican challenges, that would support your case. If Cook County had a majority Republican voter history that would support your case. If you were familiar with the specific Illinois State law which describes who and how a voter's registration might be challenged and it did not allow anyone but election officials to challenge registrations, that would help your case.

As it turns out, political parties can purchase the voter registration data base in Illinois. I sent a PM to Wildcat asking
You mentioned you got the voter registration letter but not your girlfriend. I was curious if your house or apartment was in your girlfriend's name. I see one can buy the voter registration data base in Illinois and I was thinking maybe someone (aka some Republican) was going over the Cook County records and challenging voters registered as living at addresses not matching other records like utilities, home owner records or rental records. Cook County is majority Democratic Party isn't it?

That is one possibility. I don't know at this point why he got that letter. And from what you've posted, neither do you. I hope he looks into it and lets us know. In the meantime, the issues I posted about in this thread are not dependent upon Wildcat's letter being among one of the caging schemes. The schemes are well documented as noted in the very thorough document I linked to in the OP.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom