Science of Global Warming And Possible Man Made Causation

Heh, honestly, you're more fun than a sack of puppies.

Please don't bring your private life into this.

Excited how? CO2 has several different modes in its spectrum, some of which are in the UV. What's important isn't what CO2 can do; what's important is what the energy of the photons it's exposed to are.

I knew I wouldn't get a yes/no. Bobo, CO2 in the atmosphere is exposed to all types of excitation sources. Which ones are you talking about that lead to your sainted AGW? Let's restrict the conversation to only those, OK? Now, excited by those specific sources, does carbon dioxide have to emit a photon in the IR range? Exclusively, that is. Does it? Yes or No.

You're having another one of those conversations in your head.

At least that would be an intelligent one.
 
Sorry to keep you waiting. I was ahem otherwise occupied.

I must preface that I've only seen a few graphs but I have to say that the practice of combining data sets generated by different methods is fraught with danger. In my experience, I have not seen it successfully done. I would have to agree with Gunnar that one can't just glue one data set onto another without fully investigating the ruggedness and the variability of each method against the other. That's an enormous task and, most often, we wind up analyzing all samples with the better method.

The rule of thumb is that any change worth making gives you a new method. No, cant' do that. Not allowed.
This means that there is only like a 3.4% confidence level for the statement that the present CO2 trend is unprecedented in the last 420,000 years.
​
Gunner's comment seems to have wide application then. Hockey stick, Mauna Loa CO2, what else?

Beck-referenced CO2 data series would give a much better confidence level, were known accurate within 3%, and were tossed out.
 
This means that there is only like a 3.4% confidence level for the statement that the present CO2 trend is unprecedented in the last 420,000 years.​
Gunner's comment seems to have wide application then. Hockey stick, Mauna Loa CO2, what else?

Beck-referenced CO2 data series would give a much better confidence level, were known accurate within 3%, and were tossed out.

I asked a question a while back that hasn't been answered. Is there no carbon dioxide reservoir that has been used to confirm ice core data? Is one available? If not, any results/ declarations that humanity is in peril are a bit premature (thanks to M. Twain).
 
This means that there is only like a 3.4% confidence level for the statement that the present CO2 trend is unprecedented in the last 420,000 years.
​
Gunner's comment seems to have wide application then. Hockey stick, Mauna Loa CO2, what else?

Beck-referenced CO2 data series would give a much better confidence level, were known accurate within 3%, and were tossed out.

Mauna Loa's validity is confirmed by the completely independent record at Cape Grimes. The Beck reference is 3% accurate, with no consideration given to the environment the readings were taken. Maybe Watt and McIntyre would like to follow up on that. The idea that CO2 concentration could change so dramatically in such a short time is obvious nonsense.
 
Mauna Loa's validity is confirmed by the completely independent record at Cape Grimes.

Maybe this is what I'm waiting for. Cape Grimes is independent of Mauna Loa? Are they both ice cores? Was the sampling technique different? (Yes, still trying to avoid a trip to the University's library!)
 
Doh, Cape Grim.

Cape Grim is like Mauna Loa, an isolated place where CO2 readings are taken. It's more recent than Mauna Loa, but agrees with the readings from Mauna Loa.

http://www.bom.gov.au/inside/cgbaps/information.shtml

So, it's not ice core data? Man a guy can't catch a break around here! ;)

Interesting, though. Is there a standardized method for measuring CO2 levels? I can look it up myself. Usually, there's methods from the OECD, the AOAC, the EPA, the NOAA, etc. and they're usually the same. I'll look that up, too. (Mental note.)
 
So, it's not ice core data? Man a guy can't catch a break around here! ;)

Interesting, though. Is there a standardized method for measuring CO2 levels? I can look it up myself. Usually, there's methods from the OECD, the AOAC, the EPA, the NOAA, etc. and they're usually the same. I'll look that up, too. (Mental note.)

Downloadable spreadsheet of the data.

http://www.environment.gov.au/soe/2...274/atm/a_07_greenhouse_carbon_dioxide_dl.xls

What it does show is that Beck is purely, and simply, wrong. Another Zombie beaten to death, but I know it will rise again.
 
I knew I wouldn't get a yes/no.
Nor will you, until you are sufficiently specific about what you're asking. You keep saying how complex it is, then pretending you can get a simple yes-no answer. You're either a hypocrite, or stupid. Which is it?

Bobo, CO2 in the atmosphere is exposed to all types of excitation sources. Which ones are you talking about that lead to your sainted AGW?
Well, since you say you know it's wrong, I guess I'd expect you'd know that. Otherwise, I guess you don't actually know whether it's right or wrong, huh? You just know you don't like it.

Here's a hint: know what blackbody radiation is?

Let's restrict the conversation to only those, OK?
Sure, once you specify what "those" are.

Now, excited by those specific sources, does carbon dioxide have to emit a photon in the IR range? Exclusively, that is. Does it? Yes or No.
You tell me, since you haven't specified what "those" are, I'll be awaiting your answer.

Oh, and here's another little tip for you on the whole "yes or no" thing: quantum mechanics says that we can't get any better answer than a probability distribution for some questions. Which, if you actually knew any physical chemistry, you'd pretty well already have to be aware of. The fact that you keep asking these "yes or no" questions in the face of that is pretty much prima facie proof that the supposed diploma on your wall is a figment of your imagination.

At least that would be an intelligent one.
Considering what I've seen so far, I doubt it.
 
Maybe this is what I'm waiting for. Cape Grimes is independent of Mauna Loa? Are they both ice cores? Was the sampling technique different? (Yes, still trying to avoid a trip to the University's library!)
Ummmmm... excuse me, you ARE aware that Mauna Loa is a very tall mountain in the middle of the Big Island in Hawaii, right?

And since you think you know enough to know that AGW is wrong, you're also aware that it's a site where they collect atmospheric samples to check CO2 levels, right?

Get out much?

This is surreal.
 
Downloadable spreadsheet of the data.

http://www.environment.gov.au/soe/2...274/atm/a_07_greenhouse_carbon_dioxide_dl.xls

What it does show is that Beck is purely, and simply, wrong. Another Zombie beaten to death, but I know it will rise again.

Thanks for the link. I got a perfect correlation (r = 1.00) and k = 1.55 ppm CO2/ yr so that's really compelling. As I'm not knowledgeable, how does this rebut Beck? What was Beck's opinoin that said this would be wrong?
 
Nor will you, until you are sufficiently specific about what you're asking. You keep saying how complex it is, then pretending you can get a simple yes-no answer. You're either a hypocrite, or stupid. Which is it?

Nope. Just trying to pin you down. You're the one who maintains that carbon dioxide is a perfect re-emission machine. Tough to deal with it when the hard questions come around, isn't it? You claim to be a scientist but are amazingly light on facts. So, again, does a carbon dioxide molecule excited by whatever you claim causes global warming have to emit a photon in the infrared or not? Easy question for you, if you knew what you were talking about. It's what you've been claiming all along, until now. Now, you want to make it a little grayer than it's been. Wonder why? A little light on facts, arent' you?

Really, you disgust me. There are good people here who have paid attention to your prattle for a while now. You fooled these people into thinking you were some kind of physicist who knew this stuff inside out. Now, you won't answer specific questions.

Until this point, you've been posting that carbon dioxide is a perfect re-emission heat machine. Now, at the point of commitment, you won't affirm that simple fact. Either you know this stuff or you don't. Is carbon dioxide the driver for AGW or not? If it is, it must by necessity be a perfect re-emission machine. Something the universe has never experienced before. So, do we have a heretofore unknown perfect system or not?

I really, really don't like posers. Especially posers who claim to know science but don't. You come from on high, a self-proclaimed expert in all thing physics. When asked for a definitive answer, you dawdle and hesitate, even though to other scientists, that's an answer in itself.

Here's a hint: know what blackbody radiation is?

Sure, once you specify what "those" are.

You tell me, since you haven't specified what "those" are, I'll be awaiting your answer.

Oh, and here's another little tip for you on the whole "yes or no" thing: quantum mechanics says that we can't get any better answer than a probability distribution for some questions. Which, if you actually knew any physical chemistry, you'd pretty well already have to be aware of. The fact that you keep asking these "yes or no" questions in the face of that is pretty much prima facie proof that the supposed diploma on your wall is a figment of your imagination.

Considering what I've seen so far, I doubt it.

Quantum mechanics has NOTHING to do with this issue. Your falling back on that idiotic argument just makes my blood boil. If you knew anything about that subject, you'd realize that all of its findings pertain exclusively and solely to the subatomic world, nothing larger than a proton. At this point, I'm reminded of how many times Randi has stated he's been confronted with the silly "Psychic Heisenberg Principle" by people who think that QM phenomena can be generalized to the everyday world. People like you make that possible. You and people like you feed that misperception by calling on it whenever you're cornered into a tight place. It's bunk. Any reputable scientist will tell you it's bunk. Absolute, unmittigated BS.

I'd tell you exactly where to put your black body radiation and your phony physics if it weren't for the new rules, poser. I'm not a physicist. I'm a chemist. I came here in an honest search for the truth about this issue because so many people care about it. Care deeply about it because they're afraid. Rightly so, as if the hypothesis holds water, we're all in deep trouble. My kids and I, too, not just the "believers" or "warmers'.

Here's what you don't realize. We know all about water. Water freezes at 0 C. No doubt. It's a physics constant. As a matter of fact, the Celsius scale is based on it. We know water better than we know carbon dioxide. Yet, water doesn't always freeze at 0 C, despite what we know about it. That's the only reason you have ice cream to eat, you pompous, pretentious, pseudo-scientific waste of flesh. So much for your "we know all about carbon dioxide" bull. You may know everything you think you might want to know about pure carbon dioxide in the lab but it's not so pure in the environment and the light sources are not so well-controlled.

There are real physicists on this Forum and they're not interested in this issue. All you have as a scientist in this tread is a stupid ass chemist who wandered in here wondering what all the fuss was about. So, why aren't the real physicists concerned enough to back you up? I know why and so do you.

I'm done with you, bobo. You're as dishonest as anyone name Sylvia who ever lived. You deal in the physics of the spririts. When I open my books, I see columns upon columns of universal constants that real physicists have labored to produce. Numbers I can trust. Numbers I have every confidence are measured with perspicacity that means that, at the frontier of our knowledge, this is what is known.

Yes, you and I are through. I know what you are and you are what I truly detest. You are not a human being. You are a squirming, evasive apologist for all that is unknowable and, frankly, not worth knowing.
 
Last edited:
Here's what you don't realize. We know all about water. Water freezes at 0 C. No doubt. It's a physics constant. As a matter of fact, the Celsius scale is based on it. We know water better than we know carbon dioxide. Yet, water doesn't always freeze at 0 C, despite what we know about it. That's the only reason you have ice cream to eat, you pompous, pretentious, pseudo-scientific waste of flesh. So much for your "we know all about carbon dioxide" bull. You may know everything you think you might want to know about pure carbon dioxide in the lab but it's not so pure in the environment and the light sources are not so well-controlled.

There are real physicists on this Forum and they're not interested in this issue. All you have as a scientist in this tread is a stupid ass chemist who wandered in here wondering what all the fuss was about. So, why aren't the real physicists concerned enough to back you up? I know why and so do you.

IMHO, the reason a lot of qualified physicists would avoid these threads is that they are startlingly similar to debates about evolution of bigfoot, that is, a debate not worth wasting their time on, when the other side offers so much rubbish as evidence. Beck, Jaworoski, Chrichton, the list of non entities in science never ends.
 
Nope. Just trying to pin you down. You're the one who maintains that carbon dioxide is a perfect re-emission machine.
Where was this, precisely? Looks like another one of those imaginary conversations.

Tough to deal with it when the hard questions come around, isn't it?
No, it's easy to deal with. Specification is key.

You claim to be a scientist but are amazingly light on facts.
I claim and have claimed nothing of the kind. Another imaginary conversation, perhaps.

So, again, does a carbon dioxide molecule excited by whatever you claim causes global warming have to emit a photon in the infrared or not?
Until you are specific about the source of the photon, and its frequency, there is no correct answer. And even if you are, there still isn't. There's a most probable answer, but you like logic-chopping too much to get that one. Be more specific. I'll consider if you've been specific enough, and if you have, I'll answer- otherwise, not.

Easy question for you, if you knew what you were talking about.
Not really, as you'd know if you knew any physical chemistry.

It's what you've been claiming all along, until now. Now, you want to make it a little grayer than it's been. Wonder why? A little light on facts, arent' you?
No, just wary of your rhetorical tricks, and not about to be taken in. You can be specific, or you can go whistle for an answer. It's no skin off my nose either way.

Really, you disgust me. There are good people here who have paid attention to your prattle for a while now. You fooled these people into thinking you were some kind of physicist who knew this stuff inside out. Now, you won't answer specific questions.
No, I won't answer NON-specific questions. Specify it better.

By the way, the fact that you don't apparently know the source of the photons the CO2 absorbs and re-emits is now clear. So basically, in arguing against AGW, you don't actually understand what you're arguing against. Typical. Worse yet, you don't apparently even know what blackbody radiation is, yet another extremely curious lack in someone who claims to have an education in physical chemistry.

Until this point, you've been posting that carbon dioxide is a perfect re-emission heat machine.
Lying again. Does the phrase "about half" ring any bells?

Now, at the point of commitment, you won't affirm that simple fact. Either you know this stuff or you don't.
Actually, I know it well enough to know that there are several different things that can happen. A fact which appears to have completely escaped you, despite your claim to be a physical chemist.

Is carbon dioxide the driver for AGW or not? If it is, it must by necessity be a perfect re-emission machine.
Oh, really? And why is that? As I said, you have no idea what you're arguing against.

I really, really don't like posers. Especially posers who claim to know science but don't.
You must hate yourself, then. I mean, seriously, how can someone claim to be a physical chemist and not know thermodynamics well enough to know what the FT is, not know what a blackbody is or what the characteristics of its radiation are, not know that QM shows that there are multiple outcomes possible and only gives probabilities for them, not know that energy is conserved, and the list goes on? No one can be a physical chemist and not know these things. They're essential to doing science in that field. How, for that matter, can a physical chemist not be familiar with one of the seminal books in the field, the first textbook on how the physics of electron shells determine the physical characteristics of samples of the materials the atoms those shells belong to make up? Seriously. This is ridiculous.

You come from on high, a self-proclaimed expert in all thing physics. When asked for a definitive answer, you dawdle and hesitate, even though to other scientists, that's an answer in itself.
No, it's a demonstration of precisely how wary I am of you. In my opinion, you're another basement dweller posing as a scientist, looking for a way to (in your mind) score cred points off someone who exposed you. That happened long ago, but you've never forgotten the sting of it; and you're out for revenge. You'll do anything to get it. If you want to know how I think of you, there it is. I hope you're proud of it.

Quantum mechanics has NOTHING to do with this issue.
Quantum mechanics has nothing to do with how a photon is absorbed? You are no physical chemist; you've never even met a physical chemist, wouldn't know a physical chemistry if it bit you on the ***.

Your falling back on that idiotic argument just makes my blood boil. If you knew anything about that subject, you'd realize that all of its findings pertain exclusively and solely to the subatomic world, nothing larger than a proton.
If you knew anything about physical chemistry, you'd be familiar with quantum electrodynamics, the study of the interactions of photons and electrons. When it comes to the absorption and emission of photons by atoms and molecules, the equations that describe these events are, by necessity, equations that are derived from QED. You cannot describe such events accurately in any other way. And without describing those events, you cannot interpret spectrograms. You have no basis to do so.

Every time you open your mouth, it becomes more and more obvious that you are not what or who you say you are.

At this point, I'm reminded of how many times Randi has stated he's been confronted with the silly "Psychic Heisenberg Principle" by people who think that QM phenomena can be generalized to the everyday world. People like you make that possible. You and people like you feed that misperception by calling on it whenever you're cornered into a tight place. It's bunk. Any reputable scientist will tell you it's bunk. Absolute, unmittigated BS.
No, but anyone posing as a scientist might try it as a ploy to avoid being unmasked.

I'd tell you exactly where to put your black body radiation and your phony physics if it weren't for the new rules, poser. I'm not a physicist. I'm a chemist.
You have claimed to be a physical chemist, which is something very different from a chemist. Having seen you prove conclusively that you cannot be a physical chemist because you do not know things that a physical chemist must know in order to practice in the field, I now seriously doubt any claim of expertise whatsoever. I have not the slightest reason to believe you. I suspect you in all ways, at all times. The truth is not in you.

Here's what you don't realize. We know all about water. Water freezes at 0 C. No doubt. It's a physics constant. As a matter of fact, the Celsius scale is based on it. We know water better than we know carbon dioxide. Yet, water doesn't always freeze at 0 C, despite what we know about it. That's the only reason you have ice cream to eat, you pompous, pretentious, pseudo-scientific waste of flesh.
Well, actually, there are a few problems with that statement. And if you were a physical chemist, you'd know what they are. Ad hom noted.

So much for your "we know all about carbon dioxide" bull.
Yet another product of a conversation that occurred in your head, no doubt.

You may know everything you think you might want to know about pure carbon dioxide in the lab but it's not so pure in the environment and the light sources are not so well-controlled.
And, of course, no physical chemists have ever studied the behavior of carbon dioxide in ordinary air, in the laboratory. Why would they do that?

There are real physicists on this Forum and they're not interested in this issue.
Yep, they all made their minds up long ago, and have better things to do. Me, I'm not a physicist, so I wrestle with the demons of stupidity. I'll let you think about where that leaves you.

All you have as a scientist in this tread is a stupid ass chemist who wandered in here wondering what all the fuss was about. So, why aren't the real physicists concerned enough to back you up? I know why and so do you.
Sorry, I figure they're just not all that interested in dealing with a troll like you. Funny how that works. Oh, well, someone's got to do the dirty jobs. As far as "wandered in," you'll pardon me if I note that it seems from your posting history that you "wandered in" with rather a chip on your shoulder, and stuck your face into whatever you got. Responding to a politely worded observation that you might not have thought your way all the way through things with a storm of vituperation and accusations of lying was perhaps not one of your more perspicacious maneuvers.

I'm done with you, bobo.
I bet you are; I've baited you into revealing that you cannot possibly be what or who you claim to be. It must be incredibly frustrating.

You're as dishonest as anyone name Sylvia who ever lived. You deal in the physics of the spririts.
Ad homs noted.

Yes, you and I are through. I know what you are and you are what I truly detest. You are not a human being. You are a squirming, evasive apologist for all that is unknowable and, frankly, not worth knowing.
Well, sport, I'm not done with YOU. I dislike people who pose as scientists when they aren't. So you can pretty much count on the fact that whenever you're around posing, I'll be there making sure people know you are, and pointing out where you're talking about things you have no real knowledge of. I'll be keeping a link to this post in my hip pocket, too. It's very revealing.
 
Beck believed he had demonstrated that the CO2 content of the atmosphere could show large changes in very short periods of time.

Not at all accurate, but then you never miss a chance to throw a slight at Beck and are likely proud of not having read his paper.

Beck simply compiled historical CO2 data taken by chemical analysis, some 135 sets of data. He then went into discussing why there were variations in the data - including issues of siting.

It's correct to say that the data compiled by Beck does indicate that the CO2 content can show large change in relatively short time periods.

Other historical analysis such as from plant stomata seems to indicate the same thing.
 
Not at all accurate, but then you never miss a chance to throw a slight at Beck and are likely proud of not having read his paper.

Beck simply compiled historical CO2 data taken by chemical analysis, some 135 sets of data. He then went into discussing why there were variations in the data - including issues of siting.

It's correct to say that the data compiled by Beck does indicate that the CO2 content can show large change in relatively short time periods.

Other historical analysis such as from plant stomata seems to indicate the same thing.

Another zombie rises from the dead. There is no evidence from Mauna Loa and Cape Grim that such a thing ever happens. The maximum that is observed is nothing like 10ppm per year.
 

Not at all accurate, but then you never miss a chance to throw a slight at Beck and are likely proud of not having read his paper.

Beck simply compiled historical CO2 data taken by chemical analysis, some 135 sets of data. He then went into discussing why there were variations in the data - including issues of siting.

It's correct to say that the data compiled by Beck does indicate that the CO2 content can show large change in relatively short time periods.

Other historical analysis such as from plant stomata seems to indicate the same thing.




Double click to enlarge images.

One question. Disregard the data quilting of Beck to Mauna Loa and just look at the Mauna Loa data, which starts in the mid 1950s. We know the Mauna Loa data is good data - ice core is another issue. Beck discusses dependence of chemical analysis of CO2 on geographical location.

Note the 60-80 year climate cycle graph shows a bottom of the curve about 1960, then there is a rise to present levels. Note the last ten years of no temperature increase does seem to indicate that this cycle is at work. The natural curve indicates something like a 0.4C increase followed by a decrease of a similar amount.

Some part or even the major part of the CO2 increase since 1960 is man made.

Does it overwhelm the natural cycle, or are its effects insignificant?

If actual data is backed out to climate sensitivity, what does one get?

On first glance looks like what you get is "nothing to worry about".
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom