For TokenConservative - Where should we get our information on climate from?

Careful, kind sir. Such emoting will only entrench the opposition*. Or so I am warned by a turtle.

(*aka damnable liars)

by emoting the dialogue, opposition becomes emotionally invested in defending itself, and not its arguments. as egos don't exactly taste good, forcing opposition to swallow its own upon concession is counter intuitive.

then again, i'm just a turt1e...
 
Data Availabilities Policy for Scientific Research

The model worked. The better models of today will work better. And the big bad analogue model will just keep rolling along as validation.

Mugs like you have fallen for the idea that the absence of all this crap might be in itself important. It's perfectly abnormal to publish code. You describe your methods, the data it's applied to, and the outcome. You leave it to others to reproduce - or not - your results. You'd no more provide your own code than any experimenter would provide their own apparatus.

What's important, twenty years along from Hansen et al 1988, is that it was predictively good. About 0.2C per decade, distributed very much as expected.

You take refuge is unproven hypotheses shielded from review by active refusal of scientists to reveal source code, data, and methods. You side with the concept of "conclusions" from such work being used to drive or influence public policy.

Science requires replication of results and replication requires the availability of both data and the computer programs used to obtain the results of an experiment or simulation. A good example is the requirements of the American Economic Association:
Data Availability Policy
It is the policy of the American Economic Review to publish papers only if the data used in the analysis are clearly and precisely documented and are readily available to any researcher for purposes of replication. Authors of accepted papers that contain empirical work, simulations, or experimental work must provide to the Review, prior to publication, the data, programs, and other details of the computations sufficient to permit replication. These will be posted on the AER Web site. The Editor should be notified at the time of submission if the data used in a paper are proprietary or if, for some other reason, the requirements above cannot be met.
As soon as possible after acceptance, authors are expected to send their data, programs, and sufficient details to permit replication, in electronic form, to the AER office.

“…Our policies differ somewhat for econometric and simulation papers, and for experimental papers.


For econometric and simulation papers, the minimum requirement should include the data set(s) and programs used to run the final models, plus a description of how previous intermediate data sets and programs were employed to create the final data set(s). Authors are invited to submit these intermediate data files and programs as an option; if they are not provided, authors must fully cooperate with investigators seeking to conduct a replication who request them. The data files and programs can be provided in any format using any statistical package or software, but a Readme PDF file documenting the purpose and format of each file provided, and instructing a user on how replication can be conducted, should also be provided. …”
​
http://www.aeaweb.org/aer/data_availability_policy.html
http://www.aeaweb.org/aer/submissions.html

You advocate not science but a perversion of it to political and far left agendas, irrespective of social costs or the merits of the theories espoused. Thank you for explaining this so clearly-
It's perfectly abnormal to publish code. You describe your methods, the data it's applied to, and the outcome. You leave it to others to reproduce - or not - your results. You'd no more provide your own code than any experimenter would provide their own apparatus.
​
 
Anyone can put themselves up for IPCC reviewer, even Vincent Gray, someone with no active research or current credentials. He appears to be pretty well ignored.

So the world's 2500 top scientists of the IPCC report is really just 2500 anybodies?
 
Trillions of dollars? Spread over how many years, over how many people? What is the payback of renewable energy when you won't have to blow trillions of overseas wars?

Meanwhile in Australia.... (couple of newspaper reports of fearsome monsters ir the climate closet)....We will be paying either way. The do nothing option doesn't exist.

Astonishing - you would discuss economics?
 
As much weigh as his argument deserves on its merits, no more or less.

Which is not a practical approach. Must every argument be judged and considered? How does one filter them for quality and relevance? How does a non-expert distinguish this?

Do you have a problem with his analysis?

Yes. It isn't in the peer reviewed climate science literature. If it had any merit, it would be publishable. And then I might read it.

Oh-by the way. I now see that although you are enamored by the IPCC process, some of its own reviewers seem to not meet your standards.

How can that be?

He doesn't meet my baseline standard: he doesn't publish in the peer reviewed climate science literature. It isn't complicated.
 
Yes. It isn't in the peer reviewed climate science literature. If it had any merit, it would be publishable. And then I might read it.

He doesn't meet my baseline standard: he doesn't publish in the peer reviewed climate science literature. It isn't complicated.

I'm not sure in what journal an article criticizing IPCC methods might fit.

  1. What journals constitute "climate science"?
  2. What PhDs or professional affiliations comprise a "climatologist"?
  3. Reports by government agencies and commissions are not peer reviewed. Example. The Wegman report. The Stern Report. These must be discarded, according to your strict constructionist view of the importance of peer review.
  4. The IPCC report is not peer reviewed.
 
Which is not a practical approach. Must every argument be judged and considered? How does one filter them for quality and relevance? How does a non-expert distinguish this?



Yes. It isn't in the peer reviewed climate science literature. If it had any merit, it would be publishable. And then I might read it.



He doesn't meet my baseline standard: he doesn't publish in the peer reviewed climate science literature. It isn't complicated.

Evidently you must have missed this one:
http://irina.eas.gatech.edu/EAS_spring2006/Stephens2005.pdf

Or are you only interested in IPCC material?
 
Are you suggesting the scientists don't understand the cloud process completely? They already know that. Are you going to err on the side of caution, or take the risk that it will all be OK when it already is clear that things are going worse than the AR4 estimated?



I don't think that clouds are adequately handled in the summary line above. Perhaps you do. However, recent research seems to show things quite differently.

You can't fall back on models and ther presumed efficacy when discussing cloud feedback, can you?
 
What is contemplated is trillions of dollars in taxes, fees, increased utility costs, gas price hikes, regulatory costs, and you advocate the righteousness of concealing the evidence on which public policy is predicated.

Policy that's being formulated now, twenty years on, is predicated on the performance of the model, not its details. Bury yourself is 1988 if you like, but as far as the informed decision-makers of the world are concerned AGW is real beyond question.

So what is contemplated? In the diplomatic world, a jam-fest in Bali starting next week. Where the trillions of dollars come into it is anybody's guess, I doubt the cost will push much past $US200m. Even in today's $US. (Somebody's bound to work out the carbon-footprint.)

By the way. How do you like that $10 USD/gallon gasoline price in England? Part of helping save the planet from global warming is letting the government take money out of your pocket a bit there, eh?

Petrol has long been more highly-taxed in the UK than the US, which is one reason why the impact of crude prices is more muted over here. None of which has any relevance to "saving the planet", since the high-tax policy was introduced to finance an aggressive road-building programme. Such a programme would never have got past the Treasury otherwise.

In the US the same thing was hidden in the military budget, but you could never get away with that over here.
 
[URL]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/142244696b7a46ad59.bmp[/URL]

I don't think that clouds are adequately handled in the summary line above. Perhaps you do. However, recent research seems to show things quite differently.

No observations indicate that the error-bars in this evergreen favourite graphic are wildly inaccurate, and they would have to be for the CO2 not to be dominant. The negative cloud-feedback thing has been just around the corner for decades now. Give it up.

You can't fall back on models and ther presumed efficacy when discussing cloud feedback, can you?

You can hide from reality by obsessing on minutiae. Trust me on that, I've seen people do it in all sorts of circumstances.
 
You take refuge is unproven hypotheses shielded from review by active refusal of scientists to reveal source code, data, and methods. You side with the concept of "conclusions" from such work being used to drive or influence public policy.

It's the correlation between the model predictions and the outcome that gives them weight. Gnaw on its foundations as much as you like you won't change that. You will stay grounded in 1988, but maybe that works for you.

Science requires replication of results and replication requires the availability of both data and the computer programs used to obtain the results of an experiment or simulation.

Bollocks. That's equivalent to replication of an experiment on the same apparatus, which is nonsensical. The method, data sources, and results were published. That's what was required for replication. Validation has accrued over time.
 
You advocate not science but a perversion of it to political and far left agendas, irrespective of social costs or the merits of the theories espoused.

You're not going to win a "Calm and Collected Response" award that way. You have to work the irony angle much harder.
 
Evidently you must have missed this one:
http://irina.eas.gatech.edu/EAS_spring2006/Stephens2005.pdf

Or are you only interested in IPCC material?

No, I didn't miss that one. Gray didn't write it. Why do you bring it up?

And hypothetically, if I was "only interested in IPCC material", what would be the problem? One can get an excellent overview of the science of AGW from the IPCC reports.

Should one not get information on climate from the IPCC reports?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom