[Ed]Expertise and the challenge - homeopathy

dannagain

Thinker
Joined
Jun 20, 2007
Messages
175
Here's a new excuse for not taking the challenge:

" *I* can't win the million dollar challenge or "prove" that homeopathy works because I'm a *computer programmer* not a doctor or medical researcher. Stop being silly.

Incidentally, the term "proof" is appropriate for mathematics and logic, but not science. Science works by building consensus based on the preponderance of observational or experimental data and not by proof."

source: https://www.blogger.com/comment.g?bl...17644580996196


Feel free to merge if this doesn't warrant a seperate thread but it is an interesting excuse I think.

Can anyone think up or does anyone know of a very simple test that any person could do to demonstrate that homeopathic treatments are (or more likely aren't) more effective than a placebo?

I'm thinking of fls or rolfe for this one...
 
Incidentally, the term "proof" is appropriate for mathematics and logic, but not science. Science works by building consensus based on the preponderance of observational or experimental data and not by proof."

I alluded to this recently in another post. The confusion comes from the quacks cleverly picking up the language from the intellectually honest and perverting it. It concerns the definition (usage) of the word: proof. Around here, we know what proof is, and in order to be intellectually honest, a scientist has to say that science is not involved with proof. It's true.

However, for the layman, science all but proves the existence of certain principles. Principles like F=ma, or conservation of momentum have been demonstrated so many times that you and I may as well consider them to be proven.

So when a challenge glibly says prove it, they should mean: you don't have to show a preponderance of observational or experimental data, just at least show even one convincing data point!
 
Here's a new excuse for not taking the challenge:

" *I* can't win the million dollar challenge or "prove" that homeopathy works because I'm a *computer programmer* not a doctor or medical researcher. Stop being silly.

Incidentally, the term "proof" is appropriate for mathematics and logic, but not science. Science works by building consensus based on the preponderance of observational or experimental data and not by proof."

That is a straw man. The Million Dollar Challenge simply asks that something be demonstrated in such a way as to eliminate the possibility of cheating and to be highly unlikely due to chance. It does not ask for proof in the mathematical sense, but rather follows the ideas on which science is based.


This link doesn't work for me.

Feel free to merge if this doesn't warrant a seperate thread but it is an interesting excuse I think.

Can anyone think up or does anyone know of a very simple test that any person could do to demonstrate that homeopathic treatments are (or more likely aren't) more effective than a placebo?

I'm thinking of fls or rolfe for this one...

The experiment that Rolfe brought up recently would be a good candidate, I think. Since homeopathic provings involve strong effects on unafflicted individuals, anyone should be able to take part.

Linda
 
Not sure why the link didn't work.

Here it is again

https://www.blogger.com/comment.g?blogID=17340756&postID=1570317644580996196

but if that doesn;t work its on the second most recent post on a blog called www.hardcorezen.blogspot.com.

the title of the post is 'zen for fun and profit'

somehow i've gotten into an argument with a guy who's into homeopathy in the comments section. I will try to invite him to contribute here but i doubt he will because he is of the 'randi is a fraud and won't listen to the evidence for homeopathy camp'. I hope I am wrong though. it would be good to have him here so he can explain his position in more detail.

I PM'd Linda about a study he linked to which is:

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sites/entrez?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&list_uids=15532695&dopt=AbstractPlus

Maybe we could discuss this study?
 
Last edited:
I got the link to work this time, so I've read the discussion. I'm surprised that guy sent you a link to a study that clearly shows homeopathic preparations have no effect. I thought he was trying to convince you it wasn't complete bunk?

I don't think we need to seriously consider that this guy is interested in the challenge. He didn't bother to carefully read the protocol you forwarded there, since he is now off talking about treating disease, rather than provings. And FYI, taking the same drug 50 times does serve as independent trials - for example, a new cold medicine could be tested by taking a course of the drug at the start of every cold and recording the duration of symptoms. If each course consists of either active treatment of placebo (randomly assigned and blinded), the times when you took placebo and the times when you took active treatment could be compared in the same way that 50 different people taking the drug at one time could. It's just that it would take more than a decade to take the treatment 50 times and 'time' would be a confounder.

First, let's looks at the study.

http://www.smeddum.net/downloads/2005_Homeopathy_Proving_Symptoms_Nonlocal.pdf

It shows exactly what we'd expect if homeopathy has no specific effect. There were no differences in the amount and kind of symptoms experienced by those on placebo and those on homeopathic preparations. A homeopath was unable to tell what preparation was taken based on the symptom list, even when given a list of twelve possibilities. There were more symptoms experienced whilst taking the homeopathic/placebo preparation than there were in the two weeks before the preparation was given. All they actually managed to prove was that when you tell the homeopath what symptoms to expect, they are more likely to find those symptoms from amongst the mix. Lovely, lovely example of how non-blinding leads to bias.

Now, to a reasonable person, this would be a nail (several actually) in the coffin of homeopathy. However, they've totally spun this around in their discussion to conclude that homeopathy does have an effect. First of all, they assume that the increase in symptoms has to be due to a specific effect. It seems they've never heard of the power of suggestion or the 'nocebo' effect. Then they assume that the effects of homeopathy are non-local. That is, "the remedy and the whole of its preparation history,
together with the homeopathic experience that contains and produces the effect, and not only the remedy as such", so that even the placebo group partakes of this homeopathic experience. How else could you possibly explain the increase in symptoms in the placebo group, and that the placebo group was indistinguishable from the group taking the preparation?

So it looks like Yuri's test has already been done, and the excuses for the abject failure have already been wrapped up in a nice little package with a bow on top. So I propose a new test.

It follows the same procedure as the study. As many volunteers as possible are recruited to take an unknown preparation (chosen randomly from the list of twelve) or placebo. Diaries are kept for 1 week as a baseline (only for the purposes of looking for baseline differences in patient characteristics), and then for 2 weeks after the preparation has been given. The diary entries are then coded as described: "After the proving, the symptoms were saved in an electronic database. Symptoms were coded individually with onset, duration, location, sensation, extension and modality. The symptom database was arranged according to the head-to-foot-scheme, randomly shuffled so that entries were not discernible by volunteer or day..." However, instead of passing these entries on to one materia medica expert, they are passed on to as many as possible. Except half (chosen randomly) are told the correct name of the preparation, and half are told it was a different preparation (deliberately chosen from the list of twelve to have symptoms distinguishable from the correct preparation). It is important that these experts do not know (or know that it is possible) that they have been given incorrect information. Then the results can be compared for any differences between preparation and placebo, and any differences in the presence of typical and atypical symptoms between experts given the correct name and the incorrect name. If no differences are found, it confirms that the results are simply the result of cognitive bias, rather than anything specific to the homeopathic experience.

The problem is, the trial is no longer as simple, and can't be done by an individual. And it's possible that they would come up with an even more idiotic excuse to explain away their failure, and my head would finally explode.

I can come up with a way for an individual to do this, but realistically, it involves some dedication and the desire to actually test your ideas. And I really don't see that sort of sincerity from anyone in the homeopathy camp, or the woo you are arguing with.

Linda
 
Homeopathy Vs Allopathy

Edited by Darat: 
Content deleted: Generic notice - this Member has breached their Membership Agreement in several ways in all of their first posts bar one, the breaches cover Rule 11, Rule 6 and Rule 4 and possible other rules! All the content of the offending posts is being deleted and this message left in all posts edited.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Dr. Nancy Malik,

Shouldn't you be busy curing people with water and sugar pills rather than spamming internet forums? After all, you've got a lot of catching up to do with "allopathic" medicine.

Chop chop.
 
Homeopathy

Hi,
I read that the JREF has offered a one-million-dollar prize to any homeopath who can distinguish between homeopathic and non-homeopathic water.
I've just registered here yesterday and this is my first post here, so will someone enlighten me if effects (of the homeopathic water) like loose motion are acceptable?
Thanks in advance for the help.
Regards,
Ramaanand
 
Hi,
I read that the JREF has offered a one-million-dollar prize to any homeopath who can distinguish between homeopathic and non-homeopathic water.
I've just registered here yesterday and this is my first post here, so will someone enlighten me if effects (of the homeopathic water) like loose motion are acceptable?
Thanks in advance for the help.
Regards,
Ramaanand

I can't speak for the JREF, it is best to contact them directly. However, when we've discussed this before, the challengers were told that they were free to use whatever method they thought would work (i.e. whatever they wanted).

What do you mean by "loose motion"?

Linda
 
Hi,
I read that the JREF has offered a one-million-dollar prize to any homeopath who can distinguish between homeopathic and non-homeopathic water.
I've just registered here yesterday and this is my first post here, so will someone enlighten me if effects (of the homeopathic water) like loose motion are acceptable?
Thanks in advance for the help.
Regards,
Ramaanand


Challenge information here:

http://www.randi.org/joom/challenge-info.html

As Linda says, it would be better to get in touch with the JREF themselves, as the posters here don't actually speak for them.

But I think what she says is correct - if you can tell a homoeopathic remedy (at a potency at which none of the original solute would be expected to be present, i.e. at 12C/24X or higher) by any means whatsoever, that would qualify. The only restriction would be that the rules would not allow a test which might be expected to result harm to anyone involved. A previous application by a homoeopath who claimed to be able to cure type 1 diabetes foundered because he wanted a diabetic to stop taking their insulin, for example.

Rather than asking rather vague questions as you have done here, it would be better if you could say precisely what you are claiming to be able to do.

ETA: It wouldn't be advisable to spam them with lists of trials or other irrelevant information, by the way.
 
Last edited:
Hi,
I've just registered here yesterday and this is my first post here, so will someone enlighten me if effects (of the homeopathic water) like loose motion are acceptable?


On the other hand, I'm still waiting for that trial of homoeopathic toilet paper. :cool:
 
Hi,
I read that the JREF has offered a one-million-dollar prize to any homeopath who can distinguish between homeopathic and non-homeopathic water.
I've just registered here yesterday and this is my first post here, so will someone enlighten me if effects (of the homeopathic water) like loose motion are acceptable?
Thanks in advance for the help.
Regards,
Ramaanand


I assume you are asking whether identifying a homoeopathic preparation by its clinical effect is acceptable. The answer is yes.

All you have to do is show that you can reliably and repeatedly, to a high degree of accuracy, tell the difference between a potentised homoeopathic remedy of your own choice and a chemically-identical unpotentised preparation (the stock solvent or carrier material).

So, if you think that the potentised remedy causes loose motions and the carrier solvent does not, you can use that feature as your means of telling one from the other.

The point is that you will not know whether or not what you are dealing with at any one time is the remedy or not. You have to decide whether it is or isn't by observing whether the effects you expect do or do not occur.

Rolfe.
 
Isn't this type of testing going to take rather a long time (several days or weeks) to perform?

For about a 1 in 1000 chance of accurately identifying homoeopathic / non-homoeopathic remedies, 10 correct identifications out of 10 trials would be required.

If the testing is performed at a distance (i.e. through the post) to keep the costs down, doesn't this provide obvious room for excuses for a failure? E.g., homoeopathic remedies were weakened by radiation from machines or air transport used in the postal system.
 
Plea for calm.

What Dr. Jhingade has asked is a sensible question. It deserves sensible and reasonable replies.

Please, fellow-posters, do not launch into demands that he answer unrelated questions regarding homoeopathy such as whether individualisation is essential, or whether grafting is a valid method of preparation, or whether airport scanners inactivate remedies. Please do not demand that he explain how ultradilute preparations can possibly have a biological effect. Please do not launch into explanations of how one can deceive oneself into believing that inert preparations are having a beneficial effect. Please do not rail against woos and illogicality.

Please just concentrate on how he can show that he really can tell a remedy from the stock solvent, in such a way that would satisfy the requirments of the Challenge.

Rolfe.
 
Thanks Mojo and Rolfe

I'm going to work on the challenge rather than waste time arguing:catfight: with skeptics who've never tried Homeopathy:)
 
I'm going to work on the challenge rather than waste time arguing:catfight: with skeptics who've never tried Homeopathy:)

Several of us on this forum HAVE tried homeopathy. Please refrain from making uninformed assumptions when you're accusing others of making uninformed assumptions.
 
Bravo! Please do work on the challenge!

However, The Amazing one himself has repeatedly used Homeopathic "medicine". I am not familiar enough with the site to find the references quickly, but they are in the SWIFT newsletter (look for the "sleeping pills").
 
Dr. Jhingate - I studied Homeopathy for more than 15 years but I also studied statistics 40 years. Therefore I'm offering you a much much much better chance to win with me the 1,000,000 $ than with the JREF Challenge.

In Italy we have a game called LOTTO. It has no JACKPOT but multiplies the money you bet, e.g. if you you guessed right 5 numbers from 90 numbers ( 1-90) you'll get with the 0.10 Eur 600,000 Eur (almost one million $). If you bet 1 Eur you could win 6,000,000 Eur (almost 10 millon $). The chances to win are 1 in 43,949,268. If you live in Italy you have the possibility of playing this game. Living outside Italy makes it impossible to play but, I'm willing to play for you for free if you provide 5 numbers from 1 to 90 and you can play each week 3x. You can check the results on the LOTTOMATICA website (only in Italian but I think you'll be able to understand the numbers). You have my word that if you guess the right numbers you'll get from me one millon US$. It is much easier than wasting time with homeopathy as I did.
 
Dr. Jhingate - I studied Homeopathy for more than 15 years but I also studied statistics 40 years. Therefore I'm offering you a much much much better chance to win with me the 1,000,000 $ than with the JREF Challenge.

In Italy we have a game called LOTTO. It has no JACKPOT but multiplies the money you bet, e.g. if you you guessed right 5 numbers out of 90 numbers ( 1-90) you'll get with the 0.10 Eur 600,000 Eur (almost one million $). If you bet 1 Eur you could win 6,000,000 Eur (almost 10 millon $). The chances to win are 1 in 43,949,268. If you live in Italy you have the possibility of playing this game. Living outside Italy makes it impossible to play but, I'm willing to play for you for free if you provide 5 numbers from 1 to 90 and you can play each week 3x. You can check the results on the LOTTOMATICA website (only in Italian but I think you'll be able to understand the numbers). You have my word that if you guess the right numbers you'll get from me one millon US$. It is much easier than wasting time with homeopathy as I did.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom