Even More Fun with Homeopath Dana Ullman, MPH(!)

Not hugely. They're all such individuals, aren't they!

The current occupant of the post of "my cat" is actually a different colour.

stubidz.jpg


Rolfe. :c1:
 
hmm, yes.

I finally did get that hat on him - round his neck and then he ran off. I found him later trying to get off the top of the cupboard. Everytime he made an attempt, the hat slung down obstructing his view of the floor below, and he would have to clamber back up again. After about a dozen attempts and boisterous laughter, he finally took a wild leap into the unknown.

All's well though - he landed safely, as cats tend to do.
(or is that another myth?)

BJ
 
Last edited:
Hey BillyJoe,
Thanx for bringing up the Heimlich maneuver. His wife, Jane Heimlich, wrote one of the popular homeopathic guidebooks (with M. Panos, MD). Thanx for reminding me of this one. You and your medical colleagues are surrounded by people who love and who have benefited from homeopathy.
So that makes Heimlich useful and his wife not so useful.
The only people I know who have benefited from homeopathy are those who make money by selling them water and lactose or writing books.

And because the people on this list insist upon double-blind placebo controlled trials, I know that none of you would consider undergoing the many surgical procedures that have not been tested with these scientific methods. As for me, I have a high respect for the appropriate use of surgery, despite the limitations of controlled clinical studies.
The strawman about surgery is adequately dealt with by BSM.
Oh well, there is so much in this world that is real and important and that cannot be tested in the same way by placebo-controlled trials (or that need important a research design that is sensitive to the therapeutic method tested).
Homeopathy is not one of them.

The wriggle factor is becoming very apparent.
Placebo controlled studies according to a homeopath:-
Homeopathy has been proved to work in placebo controlled studies
|
V
Well the so-called good studies showing it doesn't have flaws
|
V
Well placebo controlled studies are irrelevant because they can't be used in something completely different from homeopathy
-------
'Provings' as a test of Homeopathy by a homeopath:-
'Provings' show that homeopathic preparations, ie water/lactose are active
|
V
This trial shows that 'proving is correct.
|
V
'Proving' is a very difficult area to work in.
|
V
You just don't know anything about homeopathy.
-------
On 'potentiation' of preparations by a homeopath
Activity of samples without any material other than water/lactose through a memory effect has been shown biologically.
|
V
Well, we can show that they are different by physical means, showing that something is there.
|
V
Not being able to show any difference between water and water etc is totally irrelevant to homeopathy.
-------
Having been squeezed out of any logical, scientific or medical evidence based argument, what is a homeopath to do for his daily crust.

I know, let's write a book about famous people who may or may not have been fooled by this load of bollocks. I can still keep the money rolling in and who cares about anybody losing money for no treatment or dying because they haven't been treated with something that actually works.
 
Homoeopaths in Australia

From here: http://www.wholehealthnow.com/homeopathy_pro/australia.html

There are about 450-500 professional homeopaths and perhaps 20 serious medical homeopaths with another 130 MDs who use some homeopathic remedies.


From here:
http://www.health.gov.au/internet/m...2005-ta-abb096.htm?OpenDocument&yr=2005&mth=8

In 2003 there were 61, 261 registered medical practitioners in Australia



This gives the following percentages:
Code:
Percentage of medical practitioners who are also homoeopaths: [B]0.03%[/B]
     Percentage of medical practitioners who use homoeopathy: [B]0.24%[/B]

Also, there is 1 medical practitioner for every 333 Australians, but 1 homoeopath for every 40,000 Australians.

How lucky is Australia! :)
 
Heimlich has been in the news recently, and not in a good way
http://scienceblogs.com/aetiology/2007/06/malaria_to_cure_hiv.php


Following the logic of one particular person on this thread:

The Heimlich manoevre saved my life.
Heimlich believes that malaria cures aids.
Therefore I believe that malaria cures aids.

:D


Or...

Hey BillyJoe,
Thanx for bringing up the Heimlich maneuver. His wife, Jane Heimlich, wrote one of the popular homeopathic guidebooks (with M. Panos, MD).


The Heimlich manoeuvre saved my life.
Heimlich's wife believed in homoeopathy.
Therefore I believe in homoeopathy.

:D:D
 
Last edited:
I know a Senior Consultant in the NHS in the UK who uses homeopathy (and accupuncture) when the patient insists on it. He also administers the appropriate evidence based treament simultaneously. I would say the 130 Australian medics fall into this category. That leaves 20 medical doctors practicising homeopathy out of a minimum of 470 about 4.3%, just a little short of the vast majority that Ullman has claimed.

And even if his figures were correct, so what. At one time most of Europe thought the sun orbited the earth. No matter how many people are wrong, they are still wrong.
 
I know a Senior Consultant in the NHS in the UK who uses homeopathy (and accupuncture) when the patient insists on it.


As came out in the recent consultation over funding of the Tunbridge Wells homoeopathic hospital, although quite a lot of doctors refer patients for homoeopathic treatment, the referrals are almost always at the patient's request rather than as a result of a clinical decision.
 
It would be difficult to refuse these patients, but perhaps these doctors could accompany their referrals with a hand out explaining what nonsense homeopathy really is.
 
Nice reminder, Blue.
Also in the guardian report:
The GMC seems to be reminding us that the integration of complementary medicine has to be based on scientific evidence; otherwise it is in danger of amounting to professional misconduct.

It would be nice if the GMC unequivocally stated its position here. My inference is that doctors advocating or practicing CAM which is not evidence based (i.e. just about everything) are guilty of professional misconduct.
I doubt they would explicity ever state this however, since there are still many conventional therapies which are not evidence-based - so where would that leave them?
 
Last edited:
Well, they could point out that not all CAM therapies are safe (e.g. anti-vaccination stance of many therapists, the dangers associated with neck manipulation routinely administered by chiropractors and osteopaths), nor are they particularly cost-effective as this 2006 review indicates:

Prospective, controlled, cost-effectiveness studies of complementary therapies have been carried out in the UK only for spinal manipulation (four studies) and acupuncture (two studies). The limited data available indicate that the use of these therapies usually represents an additional cost to conventional treatment.

Cost-Effectiveness of Complementary Therapies in the United Kingdom—A Systematic Review
http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/articlerender.fcgi?tool=pubmed&pubmedid=17173105


They could also say that they want to strive for an increased evidence base:

It’s a sad moment for British medicine when the chair of the NHS Alliance, Dr M Dixon, states that ‘only 10% of what doctors do in primary care is evidence-based’.1 The actual evidence shows that the figure is around 80%!2 But even if the 10% figure were correct, this would not lend itself, as Dr Dixon does, to the integration of more unproven treatments into the NHS. We first need to ensure that a therapy generates more good than harm and only subsequently should we consider it for general use. This course of action is not ‘integrated medicine’ but follows the principles of ‘evidence-based medicine’.

1. Times, 17 January 2004.
2. Gill P, Dowe AC, Neal RD et al. Evidence based general practice: a retrospective study of interventions in one training practice. BMJ 1996; 312: 819–21.

http://www.medicinescomplete.com/journals/fact/current/fact0902a09n06.htm


It wouldn't resolve the dilemma completely, but it would be a start.
 
Last edited:
GIVE ONE, YOU ONLY NEED ONE, INCONTROVERTIBLE EXAMPLE, WITH REFERENCES, OF HOMEOPATHY CURING A NON-SELF-LIMITING CONDITION.
Badly Shaved Monkey,

I was just wondering if you can give one incontrovertible example, with references, of allopathy curing a non-self-limiting condition? You know, as a control.

Cause if no one can do it, then Dana's inability to comply isn't as significant, right?

Your example would also set some operational definitions and standards of what you mean by "incontrovertible," "references," "non-self-limiting condition" etc.

Thanks.
 
Badly Shaved Monkey,

I was just wondering if you can give one incontrovertible example, with references, of allopathy curing a non-self-limiting condition? You know, as a control.

Cause if no one can do it, then Dana's inability to comply isn't as significant, right?

Your example would also set some operational definitions and standards of what you mean by "incontrovertible," "references," "non-self-limiting condition" etc.

Thanks.

Meningococcemia was almost universally fatal before antibiotics were developed. Here is an example of 14 people involved in a clinical trial who did not die after receiving Pen G or Ceftriaxone.

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sites/entrez?db=pubmed&uid=3054778&cmd=showdetailview&indexed=google

Linda

P.S. There really isn't such as thing as "allopathy" (or rather it isn't something that anyone practices). You can simply use the term "medicine".
 
Linda

P.S. There really isn't such as thing as "allopathy" (or rather it isn't something that anyone practices). You can simply use the term "medicine".

Hey Linda...I'm glad that you can make such pronouncements and that you think that you have some authority or knowledge. You are a regular dictionary, but as compared with a dictionary, you make it up out of thin air. In the United States, "allopathic" is used by the American Medical Association, the National Residency Matching Program, and the Association of American Medical Colleges. The word "allopathy" is alive and living. Live with it.
 
{snip} I was just wondering if you can give one incontrovertible example, with references, of allopathy curing a non-self-limiting condition? You know, as a control.

Cause if no one can do it, then Dana's inability to comply isn't as significant, right? {snip}
Wrong! Dana's claim is that homeopathy is effective. The efficacy of any other system is irrelevant.

While fls (Linda) has satisfied your request, I point out, further, that all the cures of diseases and conditions that were fatal (and now are curable) are due to medicine. None is due to any quack notion. Moreover, homeopathetic resistance to vaccination (and other prophylactic care) spreads disease.
 
...I was just wondering if you can give one incontrovertible example, with references, of allopathy curing a non-self-limiting condition? You know, as a control.....

How about a couple of conditions mentioned in Hahnemann's Organon; gonorrhea and syphilis ?

They are both curable with antibiotics:
http://www3.niaid.nih.gov/healthscience/healthtopics/gonorrhea/treatment.htm and http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17342672
http://www3.niaid.nih.gov/healthscience/healthtopics/syphilis/treatment.htm and http://sti.bmj.com/cgi/reprint/81/6/448

Note that the second to last reference says "Syphilis is easy to cure in its early stages. Penicillin, an antibiotic, injected into the muscle is the best treatment for syphilis."

What is the record for homeopathy and those diseases?

By the way, what ever happened to leprosy? It is still with us, but it is treatable:
http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/articlerender.fcgi?tool=pubmed&pubmedid=16614253

What is the record for homeopathy with leprosy?

Speaking of records with diseases, do you mind telling us the homeopathic record with the following diseases and conditions:
polio, haemophilus influenza, measles, mumps, diabetes, neonatal seizures, tetanus, diphtheria, yellow fever, cholera, typhus, scarlet fever, pneumonia, hepatitis, encephalitis, hypertrophic cardiomyopathy, Helicobacter pylori, and a host of other conditions. Really, what non-self limiting condition has homeopathy dealt with better than real medicine?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom