Hardly any critical thinking regarding Ron Paul.

There's no need to amend the Constitution. Contrary to Ron Paul's claims, the absence of the enumeration of a right in the text of the Constitution does not imply that we do not have that right. If that wasn't clear enough by the nature of the Constitution (granting and limiting only government's power), the 9th Amendment makes it explicit.

We have a right to privacy. Ron Paul does not understand the fundamental nature of the American legal/political system. He is unqualified to hold public office in the US, much less the Presidency.

I didn't know how to respond until I read the Constitution. Look at the 9th and 10th amendments side by side.

I just noticed an argument structure that is used by everyone in every political party to pretend they discredited a candidate.

Either way, the "Subject X does not understand P, therefore Q" meme is overused, frequently with heavy distortion and hyperbole. It might reach thought-terminating-cliché-status someday.
 
Ron Paul recently approved a message that called for immigrants to stop coming from 'terrorist states'.

Anybody who uses such a false and polarizing statement in the modern age, does not deserve to be president.

I didn't approve of it, but you are engaging in the same cliché as the person above you.
 
I didn't know how to respond until I read the Constitution. Look at the 9th and 10th amendments side by side.

Amendments IX and X are largely irrelevant.

The right to privacy is found in Amendment IV:

The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated,


That's where the right to privacy is. If there is no right to privacy, then much of Amendment IV is pointless.
 
Amendments IX and X are largely irrelevant.

The right to privacy is found in Amendment IV:

The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated,


That's where the right to privacy is. If there is no right to privacy, then much of Amendment IV is pointless.

Going from Amendment IV to right to privacy, and then from right to privacy to a right to engage in sodomy is a little sketchy. I would think the right to sodomy is granted by Amendment IX but also subject to the powers reserved to the state and the people under Amendment X.

Along those lines, does Amendment II guarantee my right to bear arms (compact nuclear devices) or can a state regulate specifics?

I'm not disagreeing with you, but merely confused by the inconsistency.
 
Going from Amendment IV to right to privacy, and then from right to privacy to a right to engage in sodomy is a little sketchy. I would think the right to sodomy is granted by Amendment IX but also subject to the powers reserved to the state and the people under Amendment X.

Along those lines, does Amendment II guarantee my right to bear arms (compact nuclear devices) or can a state regulate specifics?
A state or the federal governement can forbid nuclear weapons under the "but that's ****ing insane" test, as established in the famous "Badnarik vs. Common sense" SCOTUS case. The test favours Constitutional interpretations that aren't downright retarded over those that are.
 
A state or the federal governement can forbid nuclear weapons under the "but that's ****ing insane" test, as established in the famous "Badnarik vs. Common sense" SCOTUS case. The test favours Constitutional interpretations that aren't downright retarded over those that are.

Yeah, but Michael Badnarik is a Constitutional scholar (it says so right on his website), and you are not. How dare you question him or any other Libertarian on Constitutional matters?
 
I don't think anyone here would accuse me of being a Ron Paul supporter. I do agree that some of the Ron Paul criticism I see seems to be dogpiling and not born out of skeptical thinking.

However, many people have legitimate criticisms of Ron Paul's ideas and proposals.

I for one will not bother arguing against some of these unfair Paul criticisms. I'm sick of the Ron Paul advocacy on this forum. Advocacy is not skepticism. I'll turn a blind eye while people dogpile on Paul because some white nationalist retards send him money. I'm sick of you Paul supporters. You are a running sore on this forum and I can't wait for Ron Paul's campaign to go down in flames so that you all go back to posting whereever it was before you started posting here.

Yea, it better be quick, so youtube is free of the RP supporter-plague that's spreading across the comments. But then we'll probably see a wave of people explaining how he was strangled by the NWO.
And eew, did anyone notice how he linked to prisonplanet? :boxedin: :p
 
Going from Amendment IV to right to privacy, and then from right to privacy to a right to engage in sodomy is a little sketchy. I would think the right to sodomy is granted by Amendment IX but also subject to the powers reserved to the state and the people under Amendment X.

No, it would still fall under Amendment IV.

Why?

Explain how you would know if two people were engaging in sodomy, in their own home (or apartment), without violating their right to privacy.


Along those lines, does Amendment II guarantee my right to bear arms (compact nuclear devices) or can a state regulate specifics?

No, it doesn't. Just like Amendment I doesn't guarantee your right to walk into a crowded movie theater just to yell "FIRE!"

I'm not disagreeing with you, but merely confused by the inconsistency.

What's confusing is where you're getting such weird ideas.

What's confusing is support for a man who believes that there is no right to privacy.
 
No, it would still fall under Amendment IV.

Why?

Explain how you would know if two people were engaging in sodomy, in their own home (or apartment), without violating their right to privacy.

No, it doesn't. Just like Amendment I doesn't guarantee your right to walk into a crowded movie theater just to yell "FIRE!"

What's confusing is where you're getting such weird ideas.

What's confusing is support for a man who believes that there is no right to privacy.


Whether a law is enforceable is not the same as whether a right to engage sodomy is specifically provided by Amendment IV.

Since you go from a partial description of privacy in Amendment IV to claiming a full right to privacy via Amendment IV and then to claiming a right to engage in sodomy, you are stretching Amendment IV. You'd have to derive the right via Amendment IX.

No, it doesn't. Just like Amendment I doesn't guarantee your right to walk into a crowded movie theater just to yell "FIRE!"

[sarc]Then Amendment I is meaningless.[/sarc]
 
Whether a law is enforceable is not the same as whether a right to engage sodomy is specifically provided by Amendment IV.

Since you go from a partial description of privacy in Amendment IV to claiming a full right to privacy via Amendment IV and then to claiming a right to engage in sodomy, you are stretching Amendment IV. You'd have to derive the right via Amendment IX.

I never argued anything other than a full right to privacy under Amendment IV. You are lying if you say otherwise.

I'll ask you again, since you seem to have missed it:

Explain how a law that, say, outlaws sodomy, can be enforced without violating the right to privacy. Can you do that?


[sarc]Then Amendment I is meaningless.[/sarc]

That's all you can say? Nothing of worth?
 
I never argued anything other than a full right to privacy under Amendment IV. You are lying if you say otherwise.

But Amendment IV discusses a very specific sort of privacy, and in fact, does not use the word "privacy" at all:

The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized

So I don't think it's appropriate to pretend Amendment IV grants privacy in the fullest sense(s) of the word.

I'll ask you again, since you seem to have missed it:

Explain how a law that, say, outlaws sodomy, can be enforced without violating the right to privacy. Can you do that?

I didn't miss it. In fact, I distinguished between the constitutionality of the law and the ability to enforce it, in my previous post:

Whether a law is enforceable is not the same as whether a right to engage sodomy is specifically provided by Amendment IV.
 
Last edited:
In the long run, RP's fanatical waving of the constitution is a false-flag operation. He just wants the federal government to butt out when the states pass draconian measures that violate the constitutional rights of the powerless.

If there were any critical thinking about RP over most of the population, he would still be earning his living as an OB/GYN.
 
As a side note, if I were a Supreme Court Justice, would I want to rule as if there were a right to privacy in the fullest sense(s) of the word? Sure. But that doesn't mean that's what the Constitution actually says.
 
He just wants the federal government to butt out when the states pass draconian measures that violate the constitutional rights of the powerless.

That's an interesting point of view. Or maybe he wants to return to using the Constitution, because it is a living document that can be amended to encompass privacy in the fullest sense of the word.
 
The 10th Ammendment seems to me a statement that there needs to be a valid state interest in regulating an activity. There is no valid state interest in sexual conduct until it begins to take on the nature of rape. Homosexual acts between consenting adults is not rape, thus not of valid concern to the state, thus not a proper subject of the law. State anti-sodomy laws are thus outside the scope of the constitution and violate the citizens' free choice.
 
The 10th Ammendment seems to me a statement that there needs to be a valid state interest in regulating an activity. There is no valid state interest in sexual conduct until it begins to take on the nature of rape. Homosexual acts between consenting adults is not rape, thus not of valid concern to the state, thus not a proper subject of the law. State anti-sodomy laws are thus outside the scope of the constitution and violate the citizens' free choice.

I think a better way to protect such rights would be via the equal protection clause in the XIV Amendment. I would imagine heterosexual couples are rarely prosecuted for sodomy.
 
The SCOTUS has struck down the sodomy laws.

The right to privacy comes from what the Court once called a "zone of privacy" created from several constitutional provisions. Those interested are invited to embrace the gift of google. It started with a case dealing with regulation of contraceptives, I don't recall off the top of my head.

I can't count the times a Libertarian has made the point that rights are not given by the constitution, that rights are innate, the people have all rights not expressly yadda yadda yadda....

Now we have Paul, a claimed libertarian, objecting to a court deciding that people have a right to privacy for the sole reason that said right is not clearly set out in the text of the Constitution. Nice.
 
Under the Constitution itself, the Supreme Court is the ultimate and final arbiter of what is "Constitutional" and what isn't. So Ron Paul can go do something with himself.
 
Under the Constitution itself, the Supreme Court is the ultimate and final arbiter of what is "Constitutional" and what isn't. So Ron Paul can go do something with himself.

Nice appeal to authority. The question isn't whether the Supreme Court is the arbiter, but whether they arbitrated normatively.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom