If Everyone in the world was atheistic would there be more or less crime

First of all, let me point out I'm not saying people who claim to be Christian or Jewish or any other theist belief don't commit crimes. And I'm not saying that there aren't some very ethical atheists out there. But in my opinion, if everyone in the world (rich, poor, and middle class) was atheistic and believed there was nothing after death, I would have to believe there would be more crime in the world.
Are you saying that the only reason theists behave morally is out of fear of punishment? This says a lot more about you than it does about atheists. You are essentially admitting that, without God or your belief in him, you would go on a crime spree, killing and stealing and taking whatever you want whenever you want. As it has been said many times already, atheists are moral because this is the only life we have, therefore the most sensible thing is to make the most of it. Morals and ethics can be easily derived from science, reason, and our own evolution as social animals. God is not necessary, and in many cases, God makes things worse by telling people to kill in his name.

Second, if you think that belief in an afterlife is a reinforcing factor for morality, then you're obviously excluding suicide bombers from the category of immoral people. Belief in an afterlife has a direct impact on the way people view the significance of this life, and on our ethical view of killing people. An atheist would believe that killing someone is snuffing them out of existence entirely, whereas a theist would say that killing someone is not the end of the line because there's life after death. Which view puts more value on human life?

Third, if you're advocating a return to the Christian moral values that the US used to be run under, then you must be overlooking the institution of slavery, the doctrine of manifest destiny, the conquest and subjugation of indigenous tribes, the treatment of women as chattel, and basically centuries worth of racism, sexism, and homophobia, much of which is still alive today.
 
Last edited:
James Kennedy has a book entitled "What if America was a Christian Nation, Again". That about sums it up. How many times have you heard older people say that they never locked their doors when they grew up. Saying your a Christian and being and living like one are two different things. I doubt if there is much murder and crime in Amish country. Their the ones who really walk the walk. For those in other countries look up Amish on the web.
Which part of our secular ways deserves punishment???

Freedom of Religion?
Freedom of speech?
Right to Bear arms?
The Right to a fair and speedy trial?
The Right to face your accusers?
The protection against wrongful search and seizures?
women's rights?
Civil Rights?
Abolition of slavery?
Social security?
medicare medicaid?
disability rights?
Welfare?
No religious test required to take office?
equal rights acts?
FHA programs?
Peace Corps?

You would like to see these things removed from american culture.
 
James Kennedy has a book entitled "What if America was a Christian Nation, Again". That about sums it up. How many times have you heard older people say that they never locked their doors when they grew up. Saying your a Christian and being and living like one are two different things. I doubt if there is much murder and crime in Amish country. Their the ones who really walk the walk. For those in other countries look up Amish on the web.

What? No Christians in jails? News to me.:)
Small towns, neighborhoods, etc. compared to big cities. Life styles, sitting out on the porch, saying hello to all the neighbors, so many variables have changed. The Amish handle their own problems I suspect. Less drugs in the old days. That's the big key.

If you really want to see what a theocracy is like, check out North Korea. Their leader is a dead guy too. All the citizens are in "heaven" because they get to praise their leader all day every day, and thank him for every scrap of food or shelter, knowing they are mere slime of the earth, under penalty of death. They smile a lot too.

No thanks, I'll just stick to trying to get the fundie government here to do something about our country's drug problem that makes sense....like legalizing drugs and treating the problem as a medical one rather than a criminal offense. Oh, and keeping our people out of wars...

I really don't think Christians, at least the ones I know, would be very happy after their constitutional theocracy, once established, drifted towards Islam, atheism or Shinto, by a vote of the majority due to a "loophole" discovered by zealots....oh, and they will find one! I urge anyone with such thoughts to think again about it.

Separation of religion and matters of government protects us all. It does not mean that you have to be an atheist, a Christian, or any religion, but it permits you to do so. This country has never been a "Christian" nation, except for the fact that it has been, and is, populated by a lot of people who claim to be Christian.

If one does even a modicum of research, it will be noted that crime and incarceration in the USA are overwhelmingly drug related. It is religious pressure on lawmakers that keeps it a "sin", hence "crime" in our society, instead of a psychological problem.

These truths are so self-evident, that I am embarassed to have to write them, but I am quite worried when I see the numbers of folks that attach themselves to such odd beliefs.
 
Last edited:
Most theists would believe atheism is an imaginary entity.

WTF?

If we were talking about Suomi, perhaps or Northern Greenland, but the rest?
I guess it would be a big suprise for DOC as well that we don't have polarbears running amuck in the streets of Copenhagen during the period of the year when the sun never rises..........

What...no polar bears frolicking under the Northern Lights? No reindeer licking the outside of the igloo? No walruses sliding down the luge run?
 
James Kennedy has a book entitled "What if America Were a Christian Nation, Again". That about sums it up. How many times have you heard older people say that they never locked their doors when they grew up. Saying your a Christian and being and living like one are two different things. I doubt if there is much murder and crime in Amish country. Their the ones who really walk the walk. For those in other countries look up Amish on the web.


Ahh, I see. Not all of those 80% of Americans are true Christians.

First, may I ask for an estimate of what percentage of Americans are true Christians?

Also, please let me know if Roman Catholics and Mormons are Christians?

Lastly, please indicate the year or event that marked American no longer being a Christian nation.

I am also interested in what American would need to do to follow James Kennedy's vision to become a Christian nation once more; but that might be beyond the scope of this thread. If so, feel free to start another.


. . . . . . . . .
ETA: when you get a chance, learn the difference between "your" and "you're." You've made this mistake several times in this thread.
 
Last edited:
The code of Hammurabi pre-dates the Mosaic Law by 300-400 years. Laws of living righteously among other men existed pre 10 commandments. Even Abraham kept God's laws....what laws would they be since he lived before Moses.
 
What...no polar bears frolicking under the Northern Lights? No reindeer licking the outside of the igloo? No walruses sliding down the luge run?

Well, we do have Northern Lights, Reindeer and Midnight sun in Sweden, but that's quite far north. I've never seen it. Berlin is closer for me to go to :) (No igloos though :p but I guess Denmark can sort of claim the igloos if they really want to ;))

I think you can say, techncally speaking, that Norway do have Polar bears and walruses, since Svalbard belongs to Norway, and you can find these impressive arctic animals there. Some day I would love to go there :)
 
How many times have you heard older people say that they never locked their doors when they grew up.

I think people lock their doors today more out of paranoia than rational vigilance. The mass media is constantly bombarding us with frightening stories of home invasions, child abductions, satanic rituals, etc. I'm not sure these things happen today with any more frequency than they ever had, but our awareness of them has been raised.
 
The code of Hammurabi pre-dates the Mosaic Law by 300-400 years. Laws of living righteously among other men existed pre 10 commandments. Even Abraham kept God's laws....what laws would they be since he lived before Moses.

Yeah, but before Moses a lot of heathens got away with working on Saturday. On SATURDAY!!! And they didn't even get stoned (in the biblical sense)!
 
Why couldn't the charity work be done by some other organisation? Are you suggesting that atheist people don't give to charity?

No, but if they were Christian they'd probably give more. If God says give so and so, it might hurt but you got to do it. There is Godly giving and giving that is comfortable. Bill Gates might give a billion dollars to a charity but if you give 30 dollars it might mean more to God if it is more of a sacrifice to you.
 
No, but if they were Christian they'd probably give more.
completely Silly, unverified conjecture.

I could equally say:No, if they were christian they'd probably give nothing assuming the church will take care of the charity work.
 
Last edited:
No, but if they were Christian they'd probably give more. If God says give so and so, it might hurt but you got to do it. There is Godly giving and giving that is comfortable. Bill Gates might give a billion dollars to a charity but if you give 30 dollars it might mean more to God if it is more of a sacrifice to you.

Would they really give more, I mean these are the same people that are only not committing crimes because ceiling cat said so?

Also there is no evidence that this is correct/incorrect, after all isn't it better that they suffer first so that they can know the everlasting love and joy of having had a miserable/painful physical existance.
 
Ryan O'Dine said:
I’m also wondering if Christian supremacy is functionally equivalent to racism. That is, that the claim of superiority some religious people make with respect to the a-religious is tantamount to the claim of superiority some people make with respect to other races.
Well, using that line of thinking, then Jesus was a racist.


I'm not sure how to read your response. Are you conceding that you're a Christian supremacist? And are you claiming that Jesus was one, too?

Just so we're on the same page, are you aware that Jesus lived and died a Jew, and would hardly recognize today's Evangelical-style Christians (particularly the ones who consider the Jews spiritually inferior, and would condemn them to Hell)?
 
I think you can say, techncally speaking, that Norway do have Polar bears and walruses, since Svalbard belongs to Norway, and you can find these impressive arctic animals there. Some day I would love to go there :)

Bouvet Island is also part of the kingdom, so we have penguins as well! :D

ETA: And aliens and predators.
 
Last edited:
How do you know what constitutes a crime now would be a crime in an atheist-run world? Let us assume that atheists are immoral, moreso than theists. I think it would be safe to assume our evil atheist laws would reflect our evil atheist morals, or lack thereof. Therefore, we may NOT commit more crimes because our laws reflect what ATHEISTS view as right and wrong, not THEISTS.

You've got a point there. If everyone were atheists I'd be willing to bet sex with any consulting child would be legal. Incest would be legal. All drugs would be legalized. Polygamy would be legal. Homosexual marriages would be allowed. Public sex and nudity would be allowed. Porno would be allowed on all public TV channel that any child could watch. School would be optional at all ages. Handicapped and the mentally ill children would be allowed to be killed by their parents because they would be considered a burden to society. All abortions would be legal at all stages. We'd live in a totally different society. And after the society collapsed, the military would take over and of course it would be run by a ruthless dictator who would run a police state. Yes I'd be willing to bet all these actions would take place eventually.
 
Last edited:
So you CAN judge a book by its cover!

What a relief. I was afraid I was going to have to READ the damn thing.

You should read this book "What if Jesus had never been born" by Kennedy, its pretty good.
 
Last edited:
As noted previously, it is possible to be both religious and an atheist.

The problem is that if you make this claim it is not possible to ever definitively say what is and what is not a religion. And you get possibilities like scientific organizations classed as religions.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom