Frozenwolf150
Formerly SilentKnight
- Joined
- Dec 10, 2007
- Messages
- 4,134
Are you saying that the only reason theists behave morally is out of fear of punishment? This says a lot more about you than it does about atheists. You are essentially admitting that, without God or your belief in him, you would go on a crime spree, killing and stealing and taking whatever you want whenever you want. As it has been said many times already, atheists are moral because this is the only life we have, therefore the most sensible thing is to make the most of it. Morals and ethics can be easily derived from science, reason, and our own evolution as social animals. God is not necessary, and in many cases, God makes things worse by telling people to kill in his name.First of all, let me point out I'm not saying people who claim to be Christian or Jewish or any other theist belief don't commit crimes. And I'm not saying that there aren't some very ethical atheists out there. But in my opinion, if everyone in the world (rich, poor, and middle class) was atheistic and believed there was nothing after death, I would have to believe there would be more crime in the world.
Second, if you think that belief in an afterlife is a reinforcing factor for morality, then you're obviously excluding suicide bombers from the category of immoral people. Belief in an afterlife has a direct impact on the way people view the significance of this life, and on our ethical view of killing people. An atheist would believe that killing someone is snuffing them out of existence entirely, whereas a theist would say that killing someone is not the end of the line because there's life after death. Which view puts more value on human life?
Third, if you're advocating a return to the Christian moral values that the US used to be run under, then you must be overlooking the institution of slavery, the doctrine of manifest destiny, the conquest and subjugation of indigenous tribes, the treatment of women as chattel, and basically centuries worth of racism, sexism, and homophobia, much of which is still alive today.
Last edited: