Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
...or people who wouldn't tell you anything even if they did know (Noll) because we won't learn anything from them anyway. Noll likes his secret squirrel, bigfoot guru standing too much and has been dodging questions for too long to make such a big mistake...

All eyes on wolftrax vs. damndirtyape. ;)
 
WP, is Roger a left handed shooter?

Isn't his rifle scabbard always on the right side of his horse?

It wouldn't be unusual for him to shoot righty with the lack of left handed rifles, though. Hot cases in your face are not fun.

In that one pic between the trees with the gang, it looks like it'd be difficult for him to pull that rifle while riding.
 
Yep my canine brother is asking tough questions, I hope he gets further than I did but Noll is playing his usual hand...ignoring questions and pretending he didn't see them.
Did you see Noll's time line? He acted like he had no knowledge whatsoever of the reported activities of that day.
Noll also asked today about a source for the 3.5 mile tracking that Gimlin talked about, I don't for one second believe he never knew about that quote, for one thing it's in that thread several times.

I got really frustrated with his dodging tactics, his secret squirrel games and his condescending attitude and took it way too personally, it led to my departure from that board.
 
WP, is Roger a left handed shooter?

Isn't his rifle scabbard always on the right side of his horse?

It wouldn't be unusual for him to shoot righty with the lack of left handed rifles, though. Hot cases in your face are not fun.

In that one pic between the trees with the gang, it looks like it'd be difficult for him to pull that rifle while riding.

Use caution when trying to evaluate the rifles of P&G as being functional self-defense tools in the search for Bigfoot (as told by them in their testimonies). Instead consider them to be occasional props used in a pseudodocumentary.

The 'actors' shot: Place the rifle on the right side in full view of the camera.

No need for a rifle when you bring a dog on your Bigfoot search ;)...
 

Attachments

  • Riderwithdog.jpg
    Riderwithdog.jpg
    135.6 KB · Views: 146
Last edited:
Originally Posted by kitakaze
According to you bigfoot is extinct and its range did not extend east of Idaho. So, what did Sweaty's beloved Joyce see in the cow pasture in New York?

Perhaps she saw you?


If Joyce and her daughter saw anything....they saw a Bigfoot.
Given the conditions of the sighting (report)....there is a 0% chance (degree of probability) that they were watching a bear walk away from them through an open cow pasture.

Bonus Information....no charge....:)...
Joyce told me that the creature looked back at them twice as it walked away. They had MUCH more than a fleeting glimpse of the thing.
 
Yep my canine brother is asking tough questions, I hope he gets further than I did but Noll is playing his usual hand...ignoring questions and pretending he didn't see them. Did you see Noll's time line? He acted like he had no knowledge whatsoever of the reported activities of that day. Noll also asked today about a source for the 3.5 mile tracking that Gimlin talked about, I don't for one second believe he never knew about that quote, for one thing it's in that thread several times.

I got really frustrated with his dodging tactics, his secret squirrel games and his condescending attitude and took it way too personally, it led to my departure from that board.

My opinions: This is all because Rick Noll knows that the PGF is a hoax. I also don't think that he strongly believes that Bigfoot exists. He has a cult to tend to, and in his particular case, it is a cult of personality. Oh, almost forgot - there is money involved.
 
Last edited:
Use caution when trying to evaluate the rifles of P&G as being functional self-defense tools in the search for Bigfoot (as told by them in their testimonies). Instead consider them to be occasional props used in a pseudodocumentary.

Oh yeah. They are not the rifles one would normally use for very large game that can move fast. A heavy caliber double rifle gives you an instant second shot and high reliability. Your backup man might have a heavy caliber lever or bolt rifle, though. I'd also have a large caliber revolver as a last resort backup like a .44 magnum. I know that was available at the time, but I am not sure what else was in the way of hand cannons.
 
kitakaze wrote:
2) Stick your fingers on the keyboard and type an explanation as to why mechanically-controlled fingers are the most likely explanation for your two frame comparison if the PGF subject is indeed a man in a suit.

I can't post the Bob H./Patty comparison image right now...but the reason is, simply, that Bob's arms are too short for his fingers to be Patty's fingers. That is an absolute definite.

Since Patty's fingers clearly moved, a mechanically-controlled device would have to be responsible for the movement.....if it was indeed Bob Heironimus in a suit. Have a nice day. :)
 
Since Patty's fingers clearly moved

That's your belief, and you are certainly welcome to it. Why you think you will ever get away with stating it as if it were an agreed upon fact is beyond me, though.

I don't see any "fingers" at all, before we get to movement.

For arguments sake, I can talk about Patty's hand appearing to bend like a mitten, or I can even spot you the moving fingers as a fact, but only for the sake of discussion.

Of course, we've been through all this before and you have yet to show us any fingers at all. Just a hand. Yet you keep talking about fingers.

The simplest devices available at the time could move individual fingers, couldn't they?

Does Patty have webbed fingers?
 
I'd also have a large caliber revolver as a last resort backup like a .44 magnum. I know that was available at the time, but I am not sure what else was in the way of hand cannons.

That was the most powerful handgun cartridge at the time. A person like Roger would have had two choices for that:

S&W Model 29 - double action revolver.

Ruger Blackhawk - single action revolver.
 
Looks like the .454 Casull cartridge was available at the time as well. Not sure about what guns were available for that in 1967, though. The .44 magnum was earlier than the .454, but by 1967, both were out there.

Ol Rog was poor, though... right?
 
A quote from the article I posted yesterday, typifies what is going on these last couple weeks.

http://www.bermuda-triangle.org/html/gigantopithecus--_the_jury-rig.html
This is the “scientific world” of Bigfoot. It is a ghastly contradictory mess that survives because most scientists refuse to touch such chimeras as Krantz built and Meldrum contemplates. Only in the world of “proletarian Bigfoot investigators,” as Meldrum tastelessly would call them, could his and Krantz’s science of nonsense stand out as the most probable scientific theory.
 
Last edited:
Looks like the .454 Casull cartridge was available at the time as well. Not sure about what guns were available for that in 1967, though. The .44 magnum was earlier than the .454, but by 1967, both were out there.

You could buy the .454 Casull cartridges, but no handgun to put them in. The .44 Magnum really was the most powerful handgun in 1967.

Ol Rog was poor, though... right?

Bigfooters like to portray him as poor because they want you to think he could never afford to buy or build the suit. His typically stated occupation is rodeo cowboy. On October 25, 1967, he told The Province that "he makes his living devising farm machinery improvements..."

In a November 1967 interview with Jack Webster he says this:

Webster: You're financially independent?

Roger: Well, somewhat.

W: In other words you can go out for this kind of caper without suffering too much financially.

R: Well, it's been tough.

The real truth may have been that Roger was earning nearly all of his money by (pretending to be) hunting Bigfoot. If he felt he needed a big gun to defend himself against an encounter-gone-bad, I'm sure he could have persuaded DeAtley or Olson to buy him one.
 
If I were after something that could lob full 55 gallon drums at me, or pick up a VW beetle, and move swiftly and silently through the forest, I'd have the biggest artillery I could handle. I wouldn't have an old military bolt action rifle, even though the .303 British cartridge is acceptable for fairly big game.

There were much heavier rifle calibers available.

Their claim was that they would not shoot a bigfoot unless it came after them. Well, that's just when you need the heavy calibers to stop the beastie in it's tracks before it reaches you.
 
Sweety habitually pulls out that 2-frame hand .gif as if it were a whistle in Thunderdome. The problem is that we are not Blaster.

The two frames are not consecutive, and it is questionable that there is any flexing at all because of this. It should get interesting when Bill Munns gets to the Patty hand analysis - if he ever does. Sweety could hurry him to it, if only he had not been banned from the BFF for just being himself.
 
Look at the rifle and the position of the scabbard in the 'actors' shot. If there is any chance to see it, it would be obvious to a viewer regardless of which side it is on. It's big, and sticks out at an angle.

24c0dcb5.jpg


Now look at him pulling the packhorse at Bluff Creek. Your best view is when he rides directly towards the camera. I don't think he is carrying a rifle at all in this scene.

Challenge to Pattycakes: Find any clip or still frame showing Roger or Bob carrying a rifle at Bluff Creek.
 
Bill, blockfoot is hardly a new discovery and it certainly doesn't prove all that much.

The easy way around that is to say that it's mud caked around Patty's toes, and it's a reasonable explanation as far as I can see. It's not unreasonable to believe Patty stepped in some mud with her left foot.

Do I believe that's what it is? No, not really.

What's more interesting is when you contrast blockfoot and perfectfoot.

I do wonder wonder about this ad campaign they seem to be trying to start for bigfoot related items and a movie.
 
Last edited:
The coming at us scene must be the one that is flipped.

The left to right scene has Roger's rifle and canteen on the right side, where they belong as far as I know. If you flipped it, they would appear to be on the left side of Roger's horse.

The canteen is probably easily switched.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom