Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
Why would the fingers not bend if it were a man in a suit? Patty's hand is well above the knee even when bent slightly forward, just like a man. Green etc have always said that the typical bigfoot has hands that extend below the knees. Should we say then that there are high hand and low hand bigfoot?
 
This is just silly. A *default* position is simply the simplest, or most likely.

Its quite fine for someone to say "Patty is a guy in a suit by default unless proven otherwise" because it is most likely. What's simpler, a man made a gorilla suit, or that there is an entire race of hairy bipeds that have escaped our attention for centuries despite our concerted efforts?

Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. Patty being a guy in a suit is not an extraordinary claim, it is quite ordinary (we know that men, and gorilla suits, exist). The claim that Patty is *not* a guy in a suit is extraordinary, and requires extraordinary evidence.

Stating that any "default position is meaningless" rings of the logic that "god may or may not exist, therefore the chances of him existing are 50%" which some feeble minded creationists dole out ad nauseum.

There is not a 50/50 chance that bigfoot exists, and therefore the default position of Patty being a guy in a suit is very apt.




reply:

There is no requirement that Patty look any particular way.

The tracks are so deep that no human in any suit can equal them.

Ergo, no human in any suit.

BINK!
 
Seems as if the 303 would have been able to dispatch even a Volkswagon lifting S.O.B.

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_1875547a8cdd8adf2a.jpg[/qimg][qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_1875547a8ce065ef30.jpg[/qimg]

Consider for a moment about which side you'd place the scabbard. If you shoot stock against right shoulder you might want to place the scabbard on the left side so all you have to do is reach with your right hand grab the rifle at the base of the stock and raise it to your right shoulder and your right hand trigger finger is nearly in firing position with little wasted motion.


Crowbrain:

There is no requirement that Bigfoot be f&b and we have no evidence it can be killed. Forget the bullet.

M.
 
Of course, there's no proof at all that a bigfoot made those tracks--any more than there is proof that a man in a suit made them. Or that Patterson, who had already practiced on fake tracks he made himself didn't just do it again, with or without the connivance of others.
 
This is just silly. A *default* position is simply the simplest, or most likely.

Its quite fine for someone to say "Patty IS a guy in a suit by default unless proven otherwise" because it is most likely.


First...I agree, it's perfectly fine for someone to say "Patty IS a man-i-a-suit, until proven otherwise".....but what I'm saying is that that statement doesn't really have any meaning...or carry any weight...if it isn't supported by actual evidence.
It's NO different than someone saying "I think Patty is a man". It's simply one person's opinion, which is pretty much worthless, if it can't be supported with evidence.

The word "is" in that default statement, is used in a "definite" sense....as if it is a known. But if someone cannot provide proof that Patty is a man....then they don't really know that Patty is a man.

As for what Patty is most likely to be....that depends solely on the true weight of the evidence....for and against her being a real Bigfoot.
There is evidence that Patty is a real live creature...and there is some evidence that points towards it being a suit. The question is, what are the weights of all the individual pieces of evidence, and which explanation ends-up carrying the most weight.


What's simpler, a man made a gorilla suit, or that there is an entire race of hairy bipeds that have escaped our attention for centuries despite our concerted efforts?

It doesn't matter which explanation is "simpler"....all that matters is the net weight of all the evidence.


Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. Patty being a guy in a suit is not an extraordinary claim, it is quite ordinary (we know that men, and gorilla suits, exist). The claim that Patty is *not* a guy in a suit is extraordinary, and requires extraordinary evidence.

"Patty being a guy in a suit" is an extraordinary claim....because Patty looks so much like a real creature.
The fact that nobody has ever been able to reproduce such a realisitic "man-in-a-suit...IN MOTION" speaks volumes about Patty's realism.

The fact that the film is still thought of as showing a possible real Bigfoot...after 40 years of analysis... by scientists and people who have reputations at stake, says a lot about Patty's realism.

Every other picture, or video, of a suit...which is comparable to the PG film...takes only between 2 and 5 seconds to tell you're looking at a suit.
Example....

HaHaHaHaHaHa1.jpg


(Actually...in the case of the BBC suit...it only takes .68 seconds to realize it's a suit, on average.)


There is not a 50/50 chance that bigfoot exists, and therefore the default position of Patty being a guy in a suit is very apt.

The "chance" or "degree of probability" that Bigfoot exists depends on the weight of the sighting reports, the footprint evidence, and other types of evidence.
 
Last edited:
"Patty being a guy in a suit" is an extraordinary claim....because Patty looks so much like a real creature.

Except that Patty doesn't look "so much like a real creature" to many qualified and unqualified observers, so you cannot state that as if it were an agreed upon point.

Nor does Patty look anything like any known creature, except a man in a suit.
 
Last edited:
LTC, you should have nailed me for this gobbledygook. It's confusing and is not literally accurate. Here...

William Parcher said:
You don't grab for the butt in a quick pull - instead you grab for the actual stock grip which is just behind the trigger. In the event of a "grab-the-gun-and-shoot" situation, you never have to re-adjust your stock-grip-hand (move it from a butt grab to the stock grip position) because you already first placed that hand at the stock grip location, and then you only need to bring the other hand to the trigger before aiming and shooting. Roger has his rifle in the perfect position for this in the 'actors' shot because he is a natural lefty. Grab the stock grip with your non-dominant hand and then pull the trigger with your dominant hand after aiming with your dominant eye.

Ideally, a rifleman will first grab the gun (from the scabbard) with the hand that will pull the trigger. Ideally again, that hand is already in position to pull the trigger at the first contact with the gun. You are grabbing it at the stock grip location, and you only need to slip your index finger into the trigger guard to lay it on the trigger. The other hand is applied afterwards to the forearm grip. Now you are ready to aim and shoot.

The question may still remain about whether Roger shoots as a righty or lefty, or both.

WP, the stills I can capture just aren't good enough, I'm afraid. I'll have to think of something else, or find a better version of the clip.

I understand. We may be able to work around that.
 
"Patty being a guy in a suit" is an extraordinary claim....because Patty looks so much like a real creature.

:jaw-dropp

You. Have. Got. To. Be. Kidding. Me.

Yes, a "real creature" that has not been clearly photographed, for which no type sample exists, and which no serious study of supporting evidence can verify.

Sorry, Sweaty; your argument doesn't hold water.

All it would take to silence skeptics is an actual sasquatch. To date, not a single specimen has been offered.

By contrast, there are thousands of examples of humans in ape suits.

The simplest explanation -- in this case the PGF is of a film of a man in a suit, rather than evidence of a supernaturally evasive gigantic bipedal ape -- is likely the correct one. That's not my idea; it belonged to a guy named "Occam". I think you and other Pattyphiles should become better acquainted with his writings.

Avindair
 
Avindair wrote:
By contrast, there are thousands of examples of humans in ape suits.


And not ONE compares with Patty....as far as "realism" goes.

That is the significant point that I made. Not one other comparable video or photo of a man-in-a-suit has caused people, with reputations at stake, to say that think it may actually be a real Bigfoot.

The LMS dvd only analysed the subject of the Patterson film. They didn't analyse the subjects of any other videos or photos.
There is a good reason for that.....Patty is outside of the ordinary... as far as her "realism" is concerned...hence, Patty's so-called "suit" is "extra-ordinary". ;)

It's easy for anybody to type into their computer..."Patty looks like a guy-in-a-suit".......but it's extremely difficult to create, or find, a video which can cause people to analyse the subject of the video for years on end, and still consider it to be most likely the real thing. :)

Dfoot is showing us all just how difficult it truly is!
 
Crowlogic,

I would like to say a couple of words regarding Kitakaze's line of questioning.
Please understand that this is not meant to pick up a fight or some other similar move. You must understand that at a critical thinking forum, the lines of reasoning are a bit different. People will probably check and question a claim or statement, regardless of who is making it and quite often regardless the importance it was meant originally to have. Sometimes it may look like nitpicking, sometimes it may seem someone is picking you. Statements and claims that would pass un noticed for one reason or another say, at BFF, will be questioned here due to the very nature of this place. Think of it as a more rigorous and demanding place. No critics are intended towards BFF regarding this issue; JREF and BFF are two different places, with different goals, codes of behavior and standards. This is something I believe most pro-bigfoot posters fail to understand for one reason or another. You may not agree with our conclusions, but regardless of these divergences (a fact some people find intorelable), JREF is a great place to sharpen your arguments. Of course, there's always the risk they will eventually get too thin. But I digress.

Please understand that speculation has a place here, but not as big as the place it has at other discussion boards. Speculations are welcome, but only if there's something of substantial at its foundations.

Now, if you understood what I exposed above, let us advance further. When you present a reasoning such as "I believe bigfeet existed but are now extinct", there's no escape, it will be critically examined, even if you had no intention to present it to debate. If you are stating this just as a belief, well, beliefs do not require solid backing by evidence, but since this is a critical thinking forum, people will think about what you wrote. And we will ask: What sort of evidence was used to build that claim? We will then try to find out by ourselves. When I think about it, personally, I find none. I am then forced to think it looks like a baseless speculation. The obvious next step is to ask you about the evidences you used to build and back your claim.

At
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=3367819&postcount=10686
You will find a quick review of a very similar situation.

I hope you understood what I exposed.
 
Ideally, a rifleman will first grab the gun (from the scabbard) with the hand that will pull the trigger. Ideally again, that hand is already in position to pull the trigger at the first contact with the gun. You are grabbing it at the stock grip location, and you only need to slip your index finger into the trigger guard to lay it on the trigger. The other hand is applied afterwards to the forearm grip. Now you are ready to aim and shoot.

Unless, for some strange reason on your quest for a big scary beast, you have chosen to ride a greenish horse that is likely to buck you off at the first sign of the beastie, leaving you trapped under said horse with your foot stuck in a bent stirrup, and unable to do much with your rifle. :D
 
And not ONE compares with Patty....as far as "realism" goes.
Highly debatable statement.
Perhaps you would like to add that this is according to the perceptions and criteria of the people who consider PGF shows a real bigfoot.

My personal opinion is that a number of vintage gorilla suits were more realistic.

That is the significant point that I made. Not one other comparable video or photo of a man-in-a-suit has caused people, with reputations at stake, to say that think it may actually be a real Bigfoot.
Of course. Its hard to find shaky footage showing a small figure of a guy in a gorilla suit. Montion pictures have far better images when it comes to focus, exposure and steadiness.

Don't forget also that when motivated by belief and/or profit, people have placed their reputations at stake for many other controversial subjects, many of them hoaxed. The MJ-12 documents, the documents from the Priory of Sion, the Shroud of Turim, etc. PGF is nothing but yet another example.

The LMS dvd only analysed the subject of the Patterson film. They didn't analyse the subjects of any other videos or photos.
A flawed and biased analysis, BTW, for the reasons that have already been exposed many times before here.

There is a good reason for that.....Patty is outside of the ordinary... as far as her "realism" is concerned...hence, Patty's so-called "suit" is "extra-ordinary". ;)
You mean, according to yout standards, because according to mines', there's nothing extraordinary there.

It's easy for anybody to type into their computer..."Patty looks like a guy-in-a-suit".......but it's extremely difficult to create, or find, a video which can cause people to analyse the subject of the video for years on end, and still consider it to be most likely the real thing. :)

Dfoot is showing us all just how difficult it truly is!
Are you sure of this?
Have you ever tried to build a Patty suit?
Are you sure Dfoot's way is the only way?
Are you sure the criteria these people are using to consider "Patty is most likely the real thing" are water proof?
Why should I consider their opinion to better than mines'?
 
Crowbrain:

There is no requirement that Bigfoot be f&b and we have no evidence it can be killed. Forget the bullet.

M.

You're right! And there is no evidence that you or me are F&B and that we can be killed. The 303 issue began with an off the cuff remark made by W.P. The scabbard issue concerns whether or not certain frames of film had been flipped and what if any relavance the flipped frames have.

BTW thanks for the compliment of Crowbrain. Most humans aren't clever enough to be Crows!
 
If Joyce and her daughter saw anything....they saw a Bigfoot.
Very interesting. Would you mind telling us how a hoax was ruled out?

It was 1983. It was a cow pasture at the corner of County Rt. 203 and State Farm Road in Kinderhook, New York.

Sweaty, what do you think of Kinderhook, Columbia County as habitat for an unidentified 8ft giant bipedal primate?
 
The question may still remain about whether Roger shoots as a righty or lefty, or both.

I'm able to shoot either left or right, though left is more comfortable. When playing baseball, I can bat either left or right, both are equally comfortable.

I write with my left hand, throw a football with my right, throw a baseball with either. It could be that Patterson was equally comfortable using either hand, depending on what it was being used for.

RayG
 
Good morning Kitakaze! You still haven't answered my question to you of why it is important to you speciffically to know why I have to dance to your tune?
Did it five pages ago:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3394665#post3394665

According to you, bigfoot went extinct and its range never extended east of Idaho. Also according to you, you are a skeptic.

What do you think Joyce saw in 1983 at the corner of County Rt. 203 and State Farm Road in Kinderhook, New York?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom