autism-vaccine link?

I've been afflicted by the Beth curse - injured finger!

My wife just bought home a large potting table with marble top. Guess where the finger ended up. She forgot to tell me it was not attached to the bench yet! Then she wanted to squeeze it to stop the pain (like cures like?). I kept my distance. After about 30 minutes the pain is settling and the blood cleaned up.


I understand what you're saying, though I missed the Guido reference.
 
This is kind of different... when representatives from drug companies came to where I worked to show us how new and improved epi and insulin pens worked... we bought lunch and had it brought in. We bought the representatives lunch. Then I got to hear the great questions the nurses had for the representative, intelligent questions about the products.

I didn't see anything wrong with what happened, and patients ended up with better products and services.
 
A direct answer to a direct question. :)

What I'm finding difficult to understand is what expertise medical professionals have that professionals from other fields do not, which makes them the most (only?) suitable experts to decide which vaccinations to recommend.

Surely by the time the evidence is being considered, it should be in a format which most people with sufficient knowledge of statistics and the scientific method should be able to make reasonable decisions from?

I'm also a bit puzzled by the presence of the lay member(s) on most of the panels. If they haven't got sufficient knowledge to make reasonable decisions from (or even understand) the evidence (an accusation SG likes to hurl at me every so often:)), surely all they do is add noise to the decision making process?
I'd argue that it is the experience they have gained through years of working in that speciality. It is the history of what has gone before from which the right decisions can be made. For example, understanding of the genetic mutations that underlie the attenuation of a live virus vaccine and how that affects virulence. Understanding and selection of the appropriate assays for measuring the potency, stability etc that are essential for vaccine safety and efficacy. Complicated things like that require a broad but detailed knowledge of laboratory procedures in biochemistry, immunochemistry bacteriology and virology and how to apply those to the vaccine in question.

In the UK the MHRA do a similar thing and we have a laboratory based independent (independent of the manufacturers but funded by government) batch release procedure for all licensed vaccines.

Scientists/medical professionals in the vaccine field have families too, so would they not speak out against inappropriate vaccine policies? Or are all scientists not vaccinating their kids?
 
Last edited:
I've been afflicted by the Beth curse - injured finger!

You must have been about to say something here you were going to regret.

My wife just bought home a large potting table with marble top. Guess where the finger ended up. She forgot to tell me it was not attached to the bench yet! Then she wanted to squeeze it to stop the pain (like cures like?). I kept my distance. After about 30 minutes the pain is settling and the blood cleaned up.

Pressure can reduce the local tissue swelling and bleeding due to the injury. As can ice.

I understand what you're saying, though I missed the Guido reference.

Mafia thug.

Linda
 
I'd argue that it is the experience they have gained through years of working in that speciality. It is the history of what has gone before from which the right decisions can be made. For example, understanding of the genetic mutations that underlie the attenuation of a live virus vaccine and how that affects virulence. Understanding and selection of the appropriate assays for measuring the potency, stability etc that are essential for vaccine safety and efficacy. Complicated things like that require a broad but detailed knowledge of laboratory procedures in biochemistry, immunochemistry bacteriology and virology and how to apply those to the vaccine in question.

And yet, as Deetee pointed out for the pneumococcal vaccine, they're still not particularly accurate in their predictions of what will happen. From my perspective, it seems the net result of their discussions regarding a new vaccine is usually:

"It appears safe. Let's try it, monitor what happens and adjust our recommendation when we have more evidence from widespread use."

I agree the committees should have experts on them, but I think if the minimum level of knowledge considered adequate to make reasonable decisions regarding use is at ‘expert in the field’ level, then no one actually knows enough to recommend widespread use of any technology.

<snip>

Scientists/medical professionals in the vaccine field have families too, so would they not speak out against inappropriate vaccine policies? Or are all scientists not vaccinating their kids?

I think it depends on what you mean by ‘inappropriate’ and your perspective. Do I make inappropriate use of ever more complicated digital signal processing algorithms, which provide small increases in performance over their simpler counterparts, take exponentially more resources and longer to design and debug?
 
Well I was actually referring to "experts in the scientific method and statistics" are opposed to those who have a "layperson's understanding". I would agree that probably most medical professionals do not fit the bill and many would have no better than a layperson's understanding of the scientific method and statistics. They are hopefully not the medical professionals making the decisions about vaccines.

Ok.

It depends on the medical procedure.
And it depends on the person giving the informed consent.
If a physician tells a plumber that, on the basis of his symptoms, his blood test and his exercise ECG, he should have coronary bypass surgery, is that patient really in a position to discuss that decision with him? Even if he takes a few months long service leave to read up all about coronary heart disease and coronary bypass surgery, will he be in any better position? In that case, is he ever really in a position to give informed consent?

If not, isn’t “informed” consent just a game to make both patient and physician feel better about their actions?

Again, it depends on the person and the thing being decided.
And, again, the greater the knowledge, experience and background that person has with the particular thing being decided, the greater the chance that that person will make the correct decision. Do you disagree?

I think it depends on how narrow in detail the question is about. Also, the more details someone includes in their decision making, the greater the chance is to include red herrings.

How is it not?
The experts have a working knowledge, the layperson - and this is an exaggeration - understands only what he has read.

Isn’t the whole point of EBM to minimise the influence of ‘working knowledge’ on medical decisions?
 
Last edited:
You must have been about to say something here you were going to regret.


:D

Pressure can reduce the local tissue swelling and bleeding due to the injury. As can ice.


But it hurt too much already to apply pressure. And it didn't bleed for long because it was crushed, not cut. So I opted just for the rest and elevation.

Mafia thug.


You don't like those tactics. Fair enough. What about raising a levy against Pharmaceutical companies for an independent committee to use on appropriate CME activities? Would they feel better?
 
You don't like those tactics. Fair enough. What about raising a levy against Pharmaceutical companies for an independent committee to use on appropriate CME activities? Would they feel better?

I don't understand what you're getting at. Professional standards and ethics are very important to physicians. What is wrong with those standards that I referred to earlier? I don't think a levy is necessary - it only perpetuates the idea that somehow pharmaceutical companies have some responsibility toward CME.

Linda
 
If not, isn’t “informed” consent just a game to make both patient and physician feel better about their actions?


The patient needs to be informed about the success rate of the procedure, and the possible complications and the rates of these complications. And a comparison given with alternative forms of treatment such as stenting or medications. But I don't think the patient can be expected to have sufficient knowledge - and certainly no experience - to enable him or her to make a choice between these alternatives, if that is what you mean by "informed consent".

Isn’t the whole point of EBM to minimise the influence of ‘working knowledge’ on medical decisions?


By "working knowledge" I did not mean just the anecdotal evidence of the medical cases he has been involved in, but the totality of his medical experiences, reading, seminars, case discussions, etc, with which he is involved every day during his working life. As opposed to the very limited type of "knowledge" that could be obtained by a layperson.
 
I don't understand what you're getting at. Professional standards and ethics are very important to physicians. What is wrong with those standards that I referred to earlier? I don't think a levy is necessary - it only perpetuates the idea that somehow pharmaceutical companies have some responsibility toward CME.


I was wondering how you would go about ensuring that those standards are upheld. But your reference to the mafia suggested to me that you do not like having these standards enforced. That it is not even necessary to enforce them because they are very important to physicians. But perhaps not all physicians are like you. Maybe some do need some encouragement to stay on track.

Also there is the question of the hidden influence of the pharmaceutical companies and how this could be eliminated by raising a levy administered by an independent committee, thereby providing a buffer between them and physicians. And pharmaceutical companies already assume for themselves the responsibility of educating physicians by visits to their surgeries to promote their products and by sponsoring CME activities.
 
The patient needs to be informed about the success rate of the procedure, and the possible complications and the rates of these complications. And a comparison given with alternative forms of treatment such as stenting or medications. But I don't think the patient can be expected to have sufficient knowledge - and certainly no experience - to enable him or her to make a choice between these alternatives, if that is what you mean by "informed consent".

But they are asked to make a choice. The way I see it, capable patients need only trust experts’ assessment of the risks and benefits of a range of treatments, then they can use this high-level knowledge (and their personal values) to decide which course of treatment to have.

By "working knowledge" I did not mean just the anecdotal evidence of the medical cases he has been involved in, but the totality of his medical experiences, reading, seminars, case discussions, etc, with which he is involved every day during his working life. As opposed to the very limited type of "knowledge" that could be obtained by a layperson.

I meant that too. If large, well-conducted studies are performed to assess the efficacy of a range of treatments, and they show a particular treatment has better outcomes than others, all that experience and knowledge doesn’t mean a thing. Quite a few physicians are upset by this approach to medicine.

Check out this page:

http://www.overcomingbias.com/medicine/index.html

I particularly liked this post (:)):

http://www.overcomingbias.com/2007/12/doctors-lie.html

The first-of-its-kind survey of more than 1,600 physicians, published today in the Annals of Internal Medicine, found that 45 percent said they did not always report an incompetent or impaired colleague to the appropriate authorities -- even though 96 percent agreed that doctors should turn in such people.
Moreover, 46 percent said they had failed to report at least one serious medical error that they knew about, despite the fact that 93 percent of doctors said physicians should report all significant medical errors that they observe. ...
A majority said they would refer patients to an imaging facility in which they had a financial interest, but only 24 percent would inform patients of that financial tie. Yet 96 percent told researchers that doctors should put their patients' welfare above their own financial interests.
Also, more than a third of physicians, 36 percent, said they would order an unneeded MRI (magnetic resonance imaging) test if it were requested by a patient with low back pain, though most doctors say they do not want to waste scarce resources.
And while 93 percent said doctors should provide necessary medical care regardless of a patient's ability to pay, only 69 percent currently accept uninsured patients who are unable to pay.
 
I was wondering how you would go about ensuring that those standards are upheld. But your reference to the mafia suggested to me that you do not like having these standards enforced. That it is not even necessary to enforce them because they are very important to physicians. But perhaps not all physicians are like you. Maybe some do need some encouragement to stay on track.

I was making a joke. It's a self-regulating profession, which means that we are responsible for enforcing standards.

Also there is the question of the hidden influence of the pharmaceutical companies and how this could be eliminated by raising a levy administered by an independent committee, thereby providing a buffer between them and physicians.

That's the point of the guidelines.

And pharmaceutical companies already assume for themselves the responsibility of educating physicians by visits to their surgeries to promote their products and by sponsoring CME activities.

But we're not obliged to let them. Besides they're not taking on the responsibility of education. What they are doing is marketing under the guise of education (with the caveat that they are capable of good intentions, as well).

Linda
 
And yet, as Deetee pointed out for the pneumococcal vaccine, they're still not particularly accurate in their predictions of what will happen. From my perspective, it seems the net result of their discussions regarding a new vaccine is usually:

"It appears safe. Let's try it, monitor what happens and adjust our recommendation when we have more evidence from widespread use."
The clinical trials determine the safety for the majority.
I think it depends on what you mean by ‘inappropriate’ and your perspective. Do I make inappropriate use of ever more complicated digital signal processing algorithms, which provide small increases in performance over their simpler counterparts, take exponentially more resources and longer to design and debug?
The difference between us then is that I am prepared to accept an expert's opinion on matters I know little of, although I might still ask a question or two :).
 
http://www.cmaj.ca/cgi/content/full...c117d36e1bbc8ab15c30272e&keytype2=tf_ipsecsha

A related problem involves the tendency for people to form opinions on the basis of early information and, once these opinions are formed, their reluctance to change their opinions even when given important new information. Research in nonmedical settings suggests that experts are particularly prone to persevere with their initial ideas and to change their minds less frequently than would be ideal.10 Changing one's mind is unpleasant because it implies that the original thinking was incorrect. Changing one's mind in medicine is even more troublesome because of the need to explain the switch to patients, families, colleagues and others.
 
But they are asked to make a choice. The way I see it, capable patients need only trust experts’ assessment of the risks and benefits of a range of treatments, then they can use this high-level knowledge (and their personal values) to decide which course of treatment to have.


What percentage of patients could be described as capable?
What characteristics make patients capable?
In what situations could they be described as capable?

What happens if the patient makes a choice and the physician/surgeon disagrees strongly enough to refuse to be a party to carrying out that choice?

In fact, in most cases, the physician or surgeon will know what the correct choice is for the particular patient and will communicate that to the patient. And quite rightly so. He would not be a responsible professional if he did not do so.

I meant that too. If large, well-conducted studies are performed to assess the efficacy of a range of treatments, and they show a particular treatment has better outcomes than others, all that experience and knowledge doesn’t mean a thing. Quite a few physicians are upset by this approach to medicine.


Of course they are. That type of medicne can be left to robots. EBM are guidelines. These guidelines have to be interpreted in the context of the individual patient with his or her individual illness and co-morbidities.



This is more relevent to Linda's comment about medical profession self-regulation and the problem of enforcement.
 
Last edited:
I was making a joke. It's a self-regulating profession, which means that we are responsible for enforcing standards.


Is it working do you think? (see Ivor's link)
Otherwise there may eventually be some nasty bureaucrats looking to do the enforcement for you.

That's the point [counteracting hidden influence] of the guidelines.


But, if the influence is hidden, how will the individual doctor recognise the influence in order to act on it? If there is no one looking to see if the guidelines are adhered to and enforcing them, how do you prevent, for example, what has been happening in Australia for years where doctors attending CME activities had no idea that the pharmaceutical companies sponsoring the events had an input into the choice of subjects and speakers.

But we're not obliged to let them. Besides they're not taking on the responsibility of education. What they are doing is marketing under the guise of education (with the caveat that they are capable of good intentions, as well).


Well it seems they are doing the education (marketing in disguise) by default. And they are spending big bucks on it. Why not set up an independent committee and use those big bucks to do it properly.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom