[Merged]Peer-reviewed technical paper to appear in mainstream journal

What I find very odd, is that almost all members have last names beginning with the letters A, B, or C.
What are the mathematical odds of this happening?

That's pretty funny. I suspect that by the time they got to the C's they had fulfilled their quota.

The whole thing is such a joke. (But did anyone here really expect anything else?) For truthers to go around crowing about this as the crowning acheivement of their movement is like finding a free toy in a box of Cracker Jacks and insisting it's the Nobel Prize.
 
What I find very odd, is that almost all members have last names beginning with the letters A, B, or C.
What are the mathematical odds of this happening?
Are we talking about the same journal? For example, I see more Wangs than those with As among the editorial board, and there are as many Ls and Ms as there are Bs or Cs.
 
Hello. This is my first post on the forums and I had a question or two concerning Jones and his co-authors paper and felt this was the right place to ask it.

Is there a danger that Jones could use this peer-reviewed letter simply as a means to legitimize his claims of thermite? Perhaps not legitimize, but lend some merit to them?

By being allowed to raise the issue in the first place, and citing his own work to back up the claims, does it not follow that the peer-review must have also reviewed the cited sources (Jones) and saw fit to allow him to include it in this letter? This seems to me to bit backwards. Shouldn't the research Jones uses to back up those claims be the first thing submitted to a peer-review, and then if it passes, that research can be used to confront the NIST, or further expanded on, in future publications?

Was a step skipped here and in the process Jones can know claim that there is some merit to his evidence for thermite use, and the fact that this paper was published is proof of it?
 
Hello. This is my first post on the forums and I had a question or two concerning Jones and his co-authors paper and felt this was the right place to ask it.

Is there a danger that Jones could use this peer-reviewed letter simply as a means to legitimize his claims of thermite? Perhaps not legitimize, but lend some merit to them?

By being allowed to raise the issue in the first place, and citing his own work to back up the claims, does it not follow that the peer-review must have also reviewed the cited sources (Jones) and saw fit to allow him to include it in this letter? This seems to me to bit backwards. Shouldn't the research Jones uses to back up those claims be the first thing submitted to a peer-review, and then if it passes, that research can be used to confront the NIST, or further expanded on, in future publications?

Was a step skipped here and in the process Jones can know claim that there is some merit to his evidence for thermite use, and the fact that this paper was published is proof of it?


Welcome, Regent. You raise an excellent point. I'm not overly familiar with scientific peer review, but I think your concern may be well founded.
 
Last edited:
Being wholly ignorant in how this process works, I would hazard a guess that if Jones did somehow subvert it (which wouldn't shock me in the least), it's not as if any legitimate scientists are actually going to fall for it. So there's probably little to fear on that front.
 
FWIW, I've contacted one of the people on the editorial advisory board, and he had confirmed that was really him (except for the editor, there are no full names on the list and I initially theorised the board members were simply made up, with names resembling well known experts in the field).

But he also said he had never done any peer reviews for the journal nor is he familiar with their peer review process. The only contacts with the journal were their initial mail, asking him to become editorial board's member, his inauguration process, and multiple further emails asking him to write an article for them. He was never asked to perform any peer reviews for them, as opposed to other journals, where he does, on average, up to 10 peer reviews annually.

Considering the size of their editorial advisory board, the fact that he hasn't done a peer review doesn't necessarily mean anything. Although it is an interesting data point when viewed with some of the other concerns brought up here. Of course that makes this whole thing sound like our own little conspiracy theory. The main difference being that we have individuals with relevant experience investigating this through proper channels.
 
Hello. This is my first post on the forums and I had a question or two concerning Jones and his co-authors paper and felt this was the right place to ask it.

Is there a danger that Jones could use this peer-reviewed letter simply as a means to legitimize his claims of thermite? Perhaps not legitimize, but lend some merit to them?

By being allowed to raise the issue in the first place, and citing his own work to back up the claims, does it not follow that the peer-review must have also reviewed the cited sources (Jones) and saw fit to allow him to include it in this letter? This seems to me to bit backwards. Shouldn't the research Jones uses to back up those claims be the first thing submitted to a peer-review, and then if it passes, that research can be used to confront the NIST, or further expanded on, in future publications?

Was a step skipped here and in the process Jones can know claim that there is some merit to his evidence for thermite use, and the fact that this paper was published is proof of it?

Jones was pretty careful about how he worded it. He used phrases like "it has been suggested that" when referring back to the JONES articles, so he didn't actually state any of his theories as fact in this article. A step wasn't skipped as such and It wouldn't fool anyone who is used to reading academic literature, but the truthers will feel galvanised regardless.
 
Jones was pretty careful about how he worded it. He used phrases like "it has been suggested that" when referring back to the JONES articles, so he didn't actually state any of his theories as fact in this article. A step wasn't skipped as such and It wouldn't fool anyone who is used to reading academic literature, but the truthers will feel galvanised regardless.

I agree that the truthers are making a bigger deal out of this paper than is warranted. If he is able to publish some physical evidence (e.g. analysis of his red chips), that would be much more interesting. I don't know what he's planning to do with his work on the red chips. Does anyone know what he's doing with it? He mentioned on 911blogger that there are other peer-reviewed papers in the works. Dunno if that's what he was referring to.
 
We may be able to help out here as well, for we have looked for such residues in the WTC remains using state-of-the-art analytical methods, especially in the voluminous toxic dust that was produced as the buildings fell and killed thousands of people, and the evidence for thermite use is mounting. [13, 22]

It was that last line I was speaking of. Saying that the evidence for the use of thermite is mounting, and that the evidence was unearthed through his own "state of the art" methods...well, it is tiptoeing around stating that his theory is fact, but it's not legitimate scientists reading this, or hearing Jones claim that this gives his work some merit, and believing it, that had me worried.

Thanks for the Welcome, Spitfire.
 
Are we talking about the same journal? For example, I see more Wangs than those with As among the editorial board, and there are as many Ls and Ms as there are Bs or Cs.
The editorial members of the engineering journal itself in which Jones paper is in. Remember, there are several different journals in different fields.
 
It was that last line I was speaking of. Saying that the evidence for the use of thermite is mounting, and that the evidence was unearthed through his own "state of the art" methods...well, it is tiptoeing around stating that his theory is fact, but it's not legitimate scientists reading this, or hearing Jones claim that this gives his work some merit, and believing it, that had me worried.

I'm not what "mounting" evidence Jones is talking about. He hasn't added any new research for months.
 
It was that last line I was speaking of. Saying that the evidence for the use of thermite is mounting, and that the evidence was unearthed through his own "state of the art" methods...well, it is tiptoeing around stating that his theory is fact, but it's not legitimate scientists reading this, or hearing Jones claim that this gives his work some merit, and believing it, that had me worried.

Quite. I have to admit, I wouldn't let an unsubstantiated comment like that fly in any paper I'd been asked to review.

But still, it's only the hardcore truthers that are going to be impressed with this. I imagine most fencesitters will take one look at the title and fail to be impressed.
 
Hello. This is my first post on the forums and I had a question or two concerning Jones and his co-authors paper and felt this was the right place to ask it.

Is there a danger that Jones could use this peer-reviewed letter simply as a means to legitimize his claims of thermite? Perhaps not legitimize, but lend some merit to them?

By being allowed to raise the issue in the first place, and citing his own work to back up the claims, does it not follow that the peer-review must have also reviewed the cited sources (Jones) and saw fit to allow him to include it in this letter? This seems to me to bit backwards. Shouldn't the research Jones uses to back up those claims be the first thing submitted to a peer-review, and then if it passes, that research can be used to confront the NIST, or further expanded on, in future publications?

Was a step skipped here and in the process Jones can know claim that there is some merit to his evidence for thermite use, and the fact that this paper was published is proof of it?

Welcome to the forum.

You are spot on, IMO, on the entire premise of his submission of his paper to this "Open" journal.

1. Why have we not seen it published in ANY reputable journal, peer reviewed or otherwise?

2. Why, when those in the know clearly know he and his colleagues disagree with NIST and feel they were part of the cover up, did he and his authors feel the need to title their paper so misleadingly?

3. Why, when asked by R. Mackey directly, was the editor of this journal evasive on why they published the article, instead telling Mackey to readdress his concerns to the author?

TAM:)
 
It just seems to me that Jones now has the talking point he's been looking for. He can say that he has a peer reviewed paper wherein he posits that there is merit to his claims of thermite use. All without having to actually submit that evidence for review and testing.

This wouldn't fly within legitimate scientific circles, but for the laymen (those who aren't fully educated on Jones claims, and are susceptible to the idea of a conspiracy) the claims that there may be some legitimacy to his "evidence" is worrisome in its implications.

Surely it's telling that a paper entitled Fourteen Points of Agreement with Official Government Reports on the World Trade Center Destruction culminates in the final point being centered around whether the NIST tested for thermite and the reasons they should have.

I should point out that I'm no expert on any of this. I'm making no claims to the veracity and thoroughness of the review processes of Bentham Open. I'm just genuinely interested on the sole point of the wording allowed in this paper in regards to the thermite evidence. And also interested to hear if there has been any further correspondence between R. Mackey and Dr. Jeng over this matter.
 
Are we talking about the same journal? For example, I see more Wangs than those with As among the editorial board, and there are as many Ls and Ms as there are Bs or Cs.
This is what I mean...

Editorial Advisory Board:

M. Abdel-Rehim (Sweden)
J.L. Ackerman (USA)
J.-S. Ahn (Korea)
N.W. Allen (USA)
E.G. Alexov (USA)
G. Alterovitz (USA)
P.B. Andrade (Portugal)
G. Anderluh (Slovenia)
I. Anegon (France)
Z. Apostolides (Africa)
V.D. Appanna (Canada)
M. Asashima (Japan)
D.S. Auld (USA)
K.-H. Baek (S. Korea)
M.V. Backer (USA)
T.L. Bailey (Australia)
R.A. Bakalova-Zheleva (Japan)
C. Bala (Romania)
K. Balasubramanian (USA)
G. Balizs (Berlin)
H. Balard (France)
F. Baldini (Italy)
J. Baranowska-Kortylewicz (USA)
C. Barbas (Spain)
L. Barre (France)
Y. Barenholz (Israel)
D.A. Barrett (UK)
R. Barnard (Australia)
A. Bassi (Italy)
G. Bazylak (Poland)
T.W. Beck (USA)


N. Beckmann (Switzerland)
J.H. Beijnen (Netherlands)
S. Beissert (Germany)
W. Berger (Austria)
J.H. Beumer (USA)
Y.-J. Bignon (France)
J. Blanco (Spain)
B.H. Bland (Canada)
B. Bocca (Italy)
M.J. Bogusz (Germany)
W. Boland (Germany)
V.L. Bonilha (USA)
G.M. Bonora (Italy)
F.R. Boockfor (USA)
E. Bornberg-Bauer (Germany)
L.M Botana (Spain)
J.M.J. Bouckaert (Belgium)
W. Bourguet (France)
N.E. Broude (USA)
A.T. Brunger (USA)
R. Buchet (France)
B. Buszewski (Poland)
S. Büttgenbach (Germany)
Z. Cai (Hong Kong)
C. Carru (Italy)
R. Casadio (Italy)
M. Castagnola (Italy)
S. Cathum (Canada)
H.M.A. Cavanagh (Australia)
A. Cifuentes (Spain)
J.V. Cizdziel (USA)


E.L. Chaikof (USA)
C.L. Chakrabarti (USA)
J.-Soo Chang (Korea)
H.-T. Chang (Taiwan)
L.-C. Chang (Taiwan)
T.G. Chasteen (USA)
C.-T. Chen (Taiwan)

D.-F. Chen (China)
L. Chen (China)
S.-M. Chen (Taiwan)
X.-W. Chen (USA)
Z. Chen (Australia)
S.N.S. Cheung (Australia)
K.-Y. Choi (Korea)
Y.H. Choi (Netherlands)
N.-H. Chow (Taiwan)
S.-H. Chiou (Taiwan)
P.V. Choudary (USA)
S. Fanali (Italy)
P.L. Irwin (USA)
K. Jinno (Japan)
S.T. Knudsen (Denmark)
R. Lobinski (France)
E.C. Nice (Australia)
G. Oliva (Brazil)
S. Scarlata (Italy)
R. Verpoorte (The Netherlands)
A. Vrielink (Australia)
C.E. Welinder (Sweden)
 
Hey. Calm down people. This journal is as legitimate as Vantage Press or Publish America. Geez. :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
For what it's worth, I've had no further response from Dr. Jeng. So it stands where it was -- the publisher is operating without oversight, the publisher has no idea what he's doing, and the publisher has yet to provide the reviewers' comments (or even their names) to their own editor-in-chief.

I suppose I could turn up the heat and let their respective universities' steering committees know about this little tale of academic fraud, but I'm not sure we need to. We know what we wanted to know -- Dr. Jones got published because he found a disreputable journal, and his paper was never properly reviewed. Game, set, match, and he's still out a few hundred bucks.

If this happens again, though, the responsible parties have been duly reminded of their responsibility.
 
Hello, I am new here. I have been trying to debate a friend of mine who saw LC and became convinced of the CT position. I can only debate with him some light issues, but when it comes to more complex stuff, I don't know what to say. I need to learn from you guys here.

I came across this link (which I can't post because the system is not allowing me to post a link) and wanted to get some comments about it. If ok with you guys.

Let me try this way: opednews.com / maxwrite / diarypage.php?did=7305

Apparently this article, which may be relevant was published on May 8.

I am overwhelmed by the amount of info out there and am stuck trying to explain to this CT friend of mine about peer reviews and all the scientific papers out there.
 
Your link: http://www.opednews.com/maxwrite/diarypage.php?did=7305

Nothing new there that I could see skimming through it except for this great takeaway:

It is said "the pen is mightier than the sword"; it may also be said that a 6 page letter with 5 civilian authors published April 18, 2008 in the peer-reviewed Open Civil Engineering Journal at bentham.org is more compelling than a 10,000 page report from a government agency that had hundreds of people working on it.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom