Is it ok to confuse "Jew" with "Israeli"??

Thunder

Banned
Joined
Nov 18, 2006
Messages
34,918
We read again and again how anti-semites, terrorists, nazis, muslem fundamentalists always interchange "jew" with "zionist" and "israeli".

this as poined to as proof that anti-Zionists are really anti-Semites
(or anti-Jew).

but the fact remains that many Jews ALSO interchange Jew with Zionist and Israelis.

If a Jew in Israel or abroad opposes settlemants and supports right for Arabs, he is often called a self-hating Jew, which assumes that one's Jewishness and Israel are one and the same.

Bibi Netanyahu once called the Jews of the world "Israel's embassador's" basically saying that non-Israeli Jews are really Israelis deep down.

Again and again..if a Jew critisizes Israel...his Jewishness..not his political ideology..is attacked. This means that as far as right-wing Jews are concerned...Jew=Israeli=Zionist.

That understood..is it therefore wrong for anti-Semites and others to interchange Jew with Zionist and Israeli? Not if they are following the logic of right-wing Jews..which makes up a good percentage of Jews world-wide.
 
No I don't thnk all Jews are Isrealis. Isreal is evolving into a curious entity. Is it me or do I see on an ever increasing scale a kind of acting out of the Holocaust concerning Palestine.
 
I am not a Jew, but I am a pro-semite agnostic.

Yes, I think that it is wrong to conflate Jews and Israelis. That includes when Jews or Israelis themselves do it. Because if they themselves do it, they can hardly blame the rest of us goyim from doing the same thing, can they. The problem stems from the fact that Israel is a religion-based state rather than a secular state. On the other hard, I also understand the logic behind Zionism, because the Holocaust proved that Jews (or any unpopular minority) cannot be sure that they will be safe as minorities in another state.

I believe that they can be safe in the United States, but I cannot guarantee that for all time. I don't understand how something like the holocaust could happen, but it did. So you always have to assume that human beings are capable of unspeakable evil on a mass social (national) level under certain circumstances.
 
Is it me or do I see on an ever increasing scale a kind of acting out of the Holocaust concerning Palestine.

It's you. There are no death camps for Palestinians. In fact, one of the arguments routinely raised to criticize Israeli policy is the idea that demographics (namely faster Palestinian population growth) means Israel can't keep doing what they're doing. Funny kind of holocaust where the "victims" increase in number faster than the "agressors".
 
No I don't thnk all Jews are Isrealis. Isreal is evolving into a curious entity. Is it me or do I see on an ever increasing scale a kind of acting out of the Holocaust concerning Palestine.

there are no death camps in the West Bank or Gaza. The Arab population of Israel has gone from 800,000 in 1949 to 1.4 million in 2009.

The comparison between the situation in Palestine and the Holocaust...is a horrible analogy. Better stick with Apartheid or Jim Crow......unless you are purposefully trying to make an incredibly rediculous analogy inorder to make supporters of Palestinian human rights seem like anti-Semitic extremists.
 
there are no death camps in the West Bank or Gaza. The Arab population of Israel has gone from 800,000 in 1949 to 1.4 million in 2009.

The comparison between the situation in Palestine and the Holocaust...is a horrible analogy. Better stick with Apartheid or Jim Crow......unless you are purposefully trying to make an incredibly rediculous analogy inorder to make supporters of Palestinian human rights seem like anti-Semitic extremists.
I didn't say that there are death camps in Palestine. (incidently a large segment of my family went up the chimney at the pleasure of Mr. Hitler and friends. So I understand full well the death camp scenerio. However before there were death camps there were the ghettos. It does not take full blown death camps to emulate certain elements of the Holocaust. I didn't imply that Isreal was even leaning in that direction which of course they have not. Yet Isreal does seem to be implimenting some of the same methodology we saw in the WWII ghettos. On the most basic level we can ask the question whether or not the Palestinians are considered first class citizens. Can it be argued that they are being treated as such?
 
I am not a Jew, but I am a pro-semite agnostic.

Yes, I think that it is wrong to conflate Jews and Israelis. That includes when Jews or Israelis themselves do it. Because if they themselves do it, they can hardly blame the rest of us goyim from doing the same thing, can they. The problem stems from the fact that Israel is a religion-based state rather than a secular state. On the other hard, I also understand the logic behind Zionism, because the Holocaust proved that Jews (or any unpopular minority) cannot be sure that they will be safe as minorities in another state.

I believe that they can be safe in the United States, but I cannot guarantee that for all time. I don't understand how something like the holocaust could happen, but it did. So you always have to assume that human beings are capable of unspeakable evil on a mass social (national) level under certain circumstances.

This sort of logic is deeply flawed. It's the same sort of logic that the Black Panthers used when they wanted to establish a separate state... err, no wait, the Black Panthers never hit that level of insanity.

When a doctrine compares unfavorably to the doctrines of groups that are insane, it's time to determine what that doctrine actually is - complete, utter, racist, bigoted nonsense. Its despicable. And that a government continues to embrace it makes it no different than any other tinpot country claiming that AIDs is a conspiracy or that their religion magically keeps away all the homosexuals.
 
It's you. There are no death camps for Palestinians. In fact, one of the arguments routinely raised to criticize Israeli policy is the idea that demographics (namely faster Palestinian population growth) means Israel can't keep doing what they're doing. Funny kind of holocaust where the "victims" increase in number faster than the "agressors".

No but I have seen an Israeli and american jew both expressing their approval for useing techniques that would have done Reinhart Heidrich proud.(reprisal killings)
 
This sort of logic is deeply flawed. It's the same sort of logic that the Black Panthers used when they wanted to establish a separate state... err, no wait, the Black Panthers never hit that level of insanity.

When a doctrine compares unfavorably to the doctrines of groups that are insane, it's time to determine what that doctrine actually is - complete, utter, racist, bigoted nonsense. Its despicable. And that a government continues to embrace it makes it no different than any other tinpot country claiming that AIDs is a conspiracy or that their religion magically keeps away all the homosexuals.

Which sort of logic? I'm afraid I don't quite understand what you are trying to say. The holocaust did happen. You don't deny that, do you? So, for that matter, did slavery. I'm not arguing that either will happen again, only that something that happened once or more could happen again. You can't rule it out. There certainly are unfortunate consequences to this logic, but that doesn't make it untrue either. I wish that everyone in the world could get along with each other without killing each other, but history and human nature suggest that state of affairs is not likely to continue forever.
 
Every Jew in this world is a potential Zionist who could sell his country out to that s****** state in the Middle East. Every Mossad agent knows this, and knows if he can convince him the survival of Israel is at stake, the Jew will betray his own country.
 
No but I have seen an Israeli and american jew both expressing their approval for useing techniques that would have done Reinhart Heidrich proud.(reprisal killings)
That meets two definitions of the word anecdotal.
 
Every Jew in this world is a potential Zionist who could sell his country out to that s****** state in the Middle East. Every Mossad agent knows this, and knows if he can convince him the survival of Israel is at stake, the Jew will betray his own country.

Ah, vile antisemitism at its most blatant. Even Ion never showed his true colors quite like you. Perhaps you aren't aware, but such antisemitic conspiracy beliefs are the province of history's losers, because only the stupid or the delusional could buy into this garbage. Look around see where and when antisemitism flourishes, and it's always worst in failed or failing societies. And failed or failing individuals. Like you.
 
Which sort of logic? I'm afraid I don't quite understand what you are trying to say. The holocaust did happen. You don't deny that, do you? So, for that matter, did slavery.
Hand the man a cookie.
I'm not arguing that either will happen again, only that something that happened once or more could happen again. You can't rule it out. There certainly are unfortunate consequences to this logic, but that doesn't make it untrue either. I wish that everyone in the world could get along with each other without killing each other, but history and human nature suggest that state of affairs is not likely to continue forever.
The problem with your 'logic' is that it turns the entire world into paranoid, isolationist countries determined to be 'pure' lest the evil of the past happen again. Shall I start? Well, first we'd need a separate country for the Native Americans and Black people. That almost goes without saying. And any Asians in America as well, we stuck them in camps. So that's three new countries we need. Also we need to form Kurdistan out of Turkey and Iraq, and definitely need new countries for the Shiites and the Suunis. Tibet? Yeah, we have a problem there. Also the Chinese have a few parcels of land they have to donate to their minorities. Australia has a nice parcel they owe to some Aborigines. I'm just getting started. Do you have any idea how many tribal tensions there are in Africa? We better take out a map and start redrawing.

Your logic is the logic of the insane. Sane people work out ways to coexist with people, because there's people everywhere. Insane people run away, and then act paranoid. You know the fun bit? Eventually the logic starts to hurt. I mean after all, Nazi Germany could have crushed an Israel sized country. So you need a military. Then you have to have room for all the Jews on earth. So you expand. And you can't enfranchise too many non-Jews, so you end up racist.

The fun really kicks in when you start classifying whose a Jew and whose not a Jew to keep your state pure...

So your 'logic' is in fact nothing of the sort.

Virtually everyone got hit by a genocide at some point in one of their ancestor's history. Hell, I'm part Irish.
 
The problem with your 'logic' is that it turns the entire world into paranoid, isolationist countries determined to be 'pure' lest the evil of the past happen again.

I understand that. It is unfortunate and tragic. It isn't 'my logic,' I'm just trying to understand how Zionists see things. If the logic is, as you say 'insane,' then they were driven insane. The Holocaust is a living memory, although it is beginning to fade. Personally, I don't agree with Zionism. The religious version especially (I.E., "this land is ours because God gave it to us"). My preferred solution would be for the Israelis to give up on Zionism and all move to the US. The more Jews, the better, as far as I'm concerned. But I don't think that will happen because the holocaust made enough of them paranoid that they resorted to this. Men are not angels.
 
I understand that. It is unfortunate and tragic. It isn't 'my logic,' I'm just trying to understand how Zionists see things. If the logic is, as you say 'insane,' then they were driven insane. The Holocaust is a living memory, although it is beginning to fade. Personally, I don't agree with Zionism. The religious version especially (I.E., "this land is ours because God gave it to us"). My preferred solution would be for the Israelis to give up on Zionism and all move to the US. The more Jews, the better, as far as I'm concerned. But I don't think that will happen because the holocaust made enough of them paranoid that they resorted to this. Men are not angels.

Give up on 'hard core' Zionism, but I don't see why they would have to move elsewhere. Eventually, Israel and it's region will either become another EU. It wasn't that long ago Europe was a raging storm of hatred and war.
 
Give up on 'hard core' Zionism, but I don't see why they would have to move elsewhere. Eventually, Israel and it's region will either become another EU. It wasn't that long ago Europe was a raging storm of hatred and war.

I hope so. Israel certainly has the right to exist, via UN resolution and gains of war, and 6 decades of statehood. The question of course (for rational people) is where their borders & autonomy end.

To the OP, I think it's a mistake for anyone to conflate Israelis and Jews. It's factually incorrect for one thing, for another there are non-Jews in the Israeli government, and the government is elected by popular vote (and as far as I know doesn't exclude non-Jews in any way). Every single ethnicity and religious type in Israel owns part of the blame or praise for its government, just as in any democracy.

If/when that changes (Israel excludes non-Jew citizens from power) it'll bring criticism, but it doesn't seem a problem now. The problem is the occupation of Palestine. If Israel offers Zionist motivation for the occupation, that can be argued against. But if it offers security concerns motivation, that has nothing at all to do with being Zionist.

I also don't think Zionists should be conflated with either Jews or Israel. For one hardly all Jews or Israelis are Zionists. Non-Jews who are radical in support of the Jewish state of Israel could also be called Zionists. And Jewish people are unusual in that they may by termed Jews due to either religion or ethnicity, but sometimes not both. Herzl for example was an atheist I think.

Treating all Israelis as Jews or Zionists is just stupid, both for pro-Israelis and for anti-Israelis. And for neutral parties who are quickly labelled by (some of) both of the former as anti-semitic, or Jew-lovers, etc.
 
Last edited:
I understand that. It is unfortunate and tragic. It isn't 'my logic,' I'm just trying to understand how Zionists see things. If the logic is, as you say 'insane,' then they were driven insane. The Holocaust is a living memory, although it is beginning to fade. Personally, I don't agree with Zionism. The religious version especially (I.E., "this land is ours because God gave it to us"). My preferred solution would be for the Israelis to give up on Zionism and all move to the US. The more Jews, the better, as far as I'm concerned. But I don't think that will happen because the holocaust made enough of them paranoid that they resorted to this. Men are not angels.
I'm fine with Israel as it is. As I said above, if we started listing the grievances that countries and people have had with eachother in the past, we'll never end. Hell, 'redistributing' the Arab's land in the Palestinian Mandate doesn't even count as the worst thing the British ever did (that would be their little genocide IMHO, but hey, there's a long list).

Moving the Israelis now would be answering a past wrong with a current wrong. Two wrongs do not make a right.

I just think that they need to weed out the elements of paranoid isolationism and start working with people.
 
Every Jew in this world is a potential Zionist who could sell his country out to that s****** state in the Middle East. Every Mossad agent knows this, and knows if he can convince him the survival of Israel is at stake, the Jew will betray his own country.

Every Christian in the world is also a potentional Zionist, who will do whatever he is told if convinced that somehow the birthplace of Jesus was in danger.
 
Israel is giving jews a bad name, but we should still be able to distinguish.

How many jews want to be blamed for a theocraty practicing apartheid?
 
How many jews want to be blamed for a theocraty practicing apartheid?

Hard to know given that no such entity exists except, of course, in the mindless rhetoric of those who have little knowledge of the most basic facts.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom