"We are going to see the worst depression in the history..."

Nonsense. Their sins were many but chief among them was the fact they couldn't make a profit by manufacturing and selling cars.

SUV's, which came about because of a Congressional mandate, do not enter the top 10 reasons for their collective failure.

;)

Nonsense. SUV's came about in contravention of Congressional mandate. The reason they failed was because greedy bankers extended credit to those who couldn't pay it back. Pick up a newspaper.
 
Jihad, are you aware the price bubble was driven by speculation not supply and demand.

Can you show any legit source that shows world demand doubled in 6 months or supply was cut in half in the first part of 08??
Price elasticity of oil demand is low. Price elasticity of oil supply is low too. Stockpiles aren't very big, either. Consequently, minor changes in supply or demand can lead to large changes in prices.

Who are these mysterious oil speculators? How did they store the vast amounts of oil? Where did they get the incredibly large amounts of money required for this manipulation? Is there any evidence that these speculators exist at all?
 
Nonsense. SUV's came about in contravention of Congressional mandate. The reason they failed was because greedy bankers extended credit to those who couldn't pay it back. Pick up a newspaper.
The carmakers needed to borrow cash to pay the bills, and then it turned out the carmakers couldn't even afford to repay the loan, so... the banks are to blame!

Are you serious?
 
Coal isn't running out just yet. Nat gas, nuclear, wind, solar, geothermal, biomass, oil shale, tar sands, cellulitic ethanol...They may not be economically viable now, but with oil at $200 a gallon? Maybe.


Alberta's oilsands projects were positively booming back when oil peaked last summer. Now, not so much. But if the price goes back up, oilsands production will surge yet again.
 
Price elasticity of oil demand is low. Price elasticity of oil supply is low too. Stockpiles aren't very big, either. Consequently, minor changes in supply or demand can lead to large changes in prices.

Who are these mysterious oil speculators? How did they store the vast amounts of oil? Where did they get the incredibly large amounts of money required for this manipulation? Is there any evidence that these speculators exist at all?

are you familiar with futures contracts in the commodities market and margin buying??

60 minutes did a very simple piece on it a few weeks ago im sure you can google it.

if you want something more detailed head over to amazon.com
 
Last edited:
Price elasticity of oil demand is low. Price elasticity of oil supply is low too. Stockpiles aren't very big, either. Consequently, minor changes in supply or demand can lead to large changes in prices.

Who are these mysterious oil speculators? How did they store the vast amounts of oil? Where did they get the incredibly large amounts of money required for this manipulation? Is there any evidence that these speculators exist at all?

Ummm; I assume you're being serious here, so I also assume you've never heard of futures markets? I'll admit I don't understand all the intricacies, but speculators driving up prices in the commodity (or other markets for that matter) markets is a fairly common cause of bubbles for any commodity throughout history. And as far as the "large amounts of money", I do believe futures involve buying that commodity at the set future date at that price.

I'm no economist, and maybe I'm totally off base, but I think this is the gist of what happened.
 
Can you show any legit source that shows world demand doubled in 6 months or supply was cut in half in the first part of 08??
This question makes an incorrect assumption about the slope of supply and demand curves (for oil) versus price.
Price elasticity of oil demand is low. Price elasticity of oil supply is low too. Stockpiles aren't very big, either. Consequently, minor changes in supply or demand can lead to large changes in prices.
Correct. It is not necessary for demand to do anything like double or supply to do anything like halve for the equilibrium price of oil to do either.
are you familiar with futures contracts in the commodities market and margin buying??
Ummm; I assume you're being serious here, so I also assume you've never heard of futures markets? I'll admit I don't understand all the intricacies, but speculators driving up prices in the commodity (or other markets for that matter) markets is a fairly common cause of bubbles for any commodity throughout history. And as far as the "large amounts of money", I do believe futures involve buying that commodity at the set future date at that price.

I'm no economist, and maybe I'm totally off base, but I think this is the gist of what happened.
The presence of futures markets doesn't change the price elasticity of oil demand and supply.
 
Francesca R: Thanks for putting it more eloquently than I ever could.

are you familiar with futures contracts in the commodities market and margin buying??
Yes, thanks. That's why I'm confident that oil futures trading activity did not cause the observed price behaviour. Are you familiar with supply and demand curves? Price elasticity?

Compared to other commodities, a given peturbation of the price of oil will lead to a smaller change in consumer activity. If oil prices increased, say, 10% overnight then most people would still drive to work, buy the same products containing chemicals derived from oil, and so on.

Similarly, compared to other commodities, a given peturbation of the oil price will lead to a smaller change in producer activity. Many oil producers are already working at or near capacity; much production is in the hands of sclerotic state-controlled dinosaurs; and even if a producers' hands are free, it can take many years to bring new capacity online. Consequently, if oil prices increased (say) 10% overnight then there wouldn't be much difference in the amount of oil that gets pumped.

Considered together, it becomes clear that small peturbations (a hurricane, a regional conflict, a warm summer/cold winter in part of the world) may only lead to a small mismatch between supply and demand, but in order to correct that mismatch you need a big change in prices.

60 minutes did a very simple piece on it a few weeks ago im sure you can google it.

if you want something more detailed head over to amazon.com
Perhaps you could explain how trading in oil futures made such a big difference to oil prices. For every contract on a future barrel of oil, somebody has to sell on a real barrel of oil at a future date. Good luck trying to "hoard" oil on paper if it's still being pumped out of the ground, into refineries &c just as before.
 
Francesca R: Thanks for putting it more eloquently than I ever could.


Yes, thanks. That's why I'm confident that oil futures trading activity did not cause the observed price behaviour. Are you familiar with supply and demand curves? Price elasticity?

Compared to other commodities, a given peturbation of the price of oil will lead to a smaller change in consumer activity. If oil prices increased, say, 10% overnight then most people would still drive to work, buy the same products containing chemicals derived from oil, and so on.

Similarly, compared to other commodities, a given peturbation of the oil price will lead to a smaller change in producer activity. Many oil producers are already working at or near capacity; much production is in the hands of sclerotic state-controlled dinosaurs; and even if a producers' hands are free, it can take many years to bring new capacity online. Consequently, if oil prices increased (say) 10% overnight then there wouldn't be much difference in the amount of oil that gets pumped.

Considered together, it becomes clear that small peturbations (a hurricane, a regional conflict, a warm summer/cold winter in part of the world) may only lead to a small mismatch between supply and demand, but in order to correct that mismatch you need a big change in prices.


Perhaps you could explain how trading in oil futures made such a big difference to oil prices. For every contract on a future barrel of oil, somebody has to sell on a real barrel of oil at a future date. Good luck trying to "hoard" oil on paper if it's still being pumped out of the ground, into refineries &c just as before.


so i guess what your telling me is the last day in september, when a barrel of oil shot up $30 in one day this had nothing to due with trading of contracts at all but everything to due with supply and demand price elasticity?

Why are the OPEC cuts not shooting cost through the roof these days??

So your saying that there was no bull run on oil contracts on the 1st half of 08 that led to a price spike??

I have been in the markets for years and I am always willing to learn more, thank you.
 
Ummm; I assume you're being serious here, so I also assume you've never heard of futures markets? I'll admit I don't understand all the intricacies, but speculators driving up prices in the commodity (or other markets for that matter) markets is a fairly common cause of bubbles for any commodity throughout history. And as far as the "large amounts of money", I do believe futures involve buying that commodity at the set future date at that price.

I'm no economist, and maybe I'm totally off base, but I think this is the gist of what happened.

I think you are (totally off-base).

The speculators that drive up bubbles do so by withholding goods from the market -- literally, by restricting supply.

This is literally impossible to do via a futures contract. Someone buying a cash-settled oil futures contract never sees possession of the oil, and must have a corresponding seller of a contract. Nothing is exchanged except paper. The actual amount of oil on the market -- the supply -- never changes, nor does the amount of oil being burned -- the demand.
 
^^^ right but the price is driven up by the same way a stock or a real estate market is when there is a lot of buyers.

supply and demand curves for the paper.

Was there less housing in the housing boom?? no just more buyers- it was hot. same concept.

If a stock is hot and there are alot of buyers driving the price up- its not because the company did something to warrant the gains- its because there are many buyers on the market.

There were many buyers on the market for the paper pushing the price of the paper through the roof.

Im not saying there were no supply and demand issues -just saying it was minor compared to this-.

In todays market look at gold -the next bubble IMO- for this happening right now. How else can you justify the swings we have seen in the last few years.
 
Was there less housing in the housing boom?? no just more buyers- it was hot. same concept.

Right. More buyers for the same physical houses.

If a stock is hot and there are alot of buyers driving the price up- its not because the company did something to warrant the gains- its because there are many buyers on the market.

Yes, again, that's because there are more buyers for the same physical stock. There are only umpteen million shares of Large Corporation, PLC on the market, and if you have one, I can't have it. If you have all of them, I can't have any.

That's not the case, however, with a cash-settled futures contract, precisely because there is no actual oil at stake; the number of barrels of oil has no relationship to the number of barrels that can be "traded" via futures. If I want to buy oil futures, I don't need to deal with an oil seller or anyone who has any connection with the oil industry at all. I just need to find someone who wants to sell a futures contract, and negotiate a price. When the contract comes due, we will settle the (paper) profits and losses, exchange cash, and walk away.

It's more like a bet on a sporting event than a purchase, precisely because there are no physical goods at stake. If I have $100 that says Duke will make the NCAA Final Four, I don't need to deal with Duke or any of the other teams. I just need to go into the local sports bar and announce that I have some freakish talking money. And it doesn't matter how heavy or how light I bet in Charlie's, it won't affect Duke's play. It won't even affect the Vegas line, because Vegas never sees our money. It's just between me and the Charlie the bartender.
 
Actually, the supply of housing increased considerably. But the supply of land didn't, so prices rose.

Wrong at several levels. People buying "housing" aren't buying "land."

For instance, tearing down farmland for single-family housing developments puts new housing onto the same amount of land, which tends to produce an increase in supply and a drop in prices.

Tearing down single family houses for apartment buildings does the same thing.

And, of course, zoning previously unusable land for residences does the same thing.

Of course, if the demand continues to increase faster than the (increased) supply, we'll still see price increase -- which is what actually happened in the reality-influenced world.
 
Rubbish. The demand for housing increased faster than the supply (some of it was speculative). Little to do with land.


Same with the oil

the demand was speculative.

someone on an earlier post was saying that for my point to be correct people had to be hoarding the oil.


its all negotiation over the paper.

the demand for that barrel might not have gone up but the demand for the contract so "joey broker" can move it in 2 months certainly did.

Once again while there are many examples of this over 2008 i will point again to the last day in sept. where the WTI index went up $30 a barrel.

Im not trying to have an mean spirited fight with anyone, I just think that the whole end of oil card that is being played on the internet is not correct.. at least not now.
 
Right. More buyers for the same physical houses.



Yes, again, that's because there are more buyers for the same physical stock. There are only umpteen million shares of Large Corporation, PLC on the market, and if you have one, I can't have it. If you have all of them, I can't have any.

That's not the case, however, with a cash-settled futures contract, precisely because there is no actual oil at stake; the number of barrels of oil has no relationship to the number of barrels that can be "traded" via futures. If I want to buy oil futures, I don't need to deal with an oil seller or anyone who has any connection with the oil industry at all. I just need to find someone who wants to sell a futures contract, and negotiate a price. When the contract comes due, we will settle the (paper) profits and losses, exchange cash, and walk away.

It's more like a bet on a sporting event than a purchase, precisely because there are no physical goods at stake. If I have $100 that says Duke will make the NCAA Final Four, I don't need to deal with Duke or any of the other teams. I just need to go into the local sports bar and announce that I have some freakish talking money. And it doesn't matter how heavy or how light I bet in Charlie's, it won't affect Duke's play. It won't even affect the Vegas line, because Vegas never sees our money. It's just between me and the Charlie the bartender.



Thats incorrect for most contracts.

When you hold most contracts that come due you are obligated to take delivery.
 
someone on an earlier post was saying that for my point to be correct people had to be hoarding the oil.
You do eventually have to hoard the oil, or pay to have it stored when it is delivered. You cant keep rolling ever-increasing futures positions.

And people were hoarding houses. Just not for very long in some cases. (Might be hedging contracts available on the Case-Shiller index . . . not sure, but I seriously doubt that would have been driving the (US) housing market if there are)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom