World Hunger

And speaking of the costs of freedom in this context:
After all, these are the costs of freedom; ‘deregulation’ requires a good dose of regulation now and then; ‘liberalization’ cannot be had for nothing; and money is, from a global economic perspective, better invested in building up a sweeping patent protection system than in providing a people with illegally-copied computer programs or prescription pills they are unable to pay for. In some countries, nothing will remain of what has been achieved in the way of public services — while in the other countries, nothing at all will be achieved — other than what business-minded firms can profitably peddle. For the advocates of a truly free world trade, this is not the price of economic progress: this is the progress.

(e) Agriculture
Ultimately, the demand for the worldwide liberalization of trade in agricultural products, too, is about the global commercialization of intellectual property. The United States government — once again in the driver’s seat — defines the rest of the world’s need for cereal products and agricultural crops as a field of business in which American capital, thanks to a revolutionary new technology it has at its disposal, would be unbeatable, if only it were allowed a fair chance of success everywhere.(7) On the one hand, in order to achieve this, all reservations concerning the achievements of American genetic engineering must be dropped, reservations made under the pretext of consumer protection, which Washington has long since seen through, and with which certain states — the EU and Japan being here the chief targets — sponsor and seek to technologically modernize their own farming community, still comparatively backward in the area of genetic engineering.(8) On the other hand, countries that up to now have had other concerns about their agriculture and public nutrition must finally and unreservedly uphold modern patent law, establish legal certainty for the American inventive genius realized in progressive agricultural goods, and get their peasants to understand that henceforth, respectable seeds come from U.S. laboratories, and with a small fee in recognition of their high-tech genetics. Incidentally, this fee is payable even when research scientists sponsored by these labs have deciphered genes on which the traditionally exploited, useful qualities of an exotic flora and fauna are based. Such achievements are henceforth simply too precious to serve small farmers as means of business, or to be allowed to be misused as a basis of survival by subsistence farmers unable to pay: even here, ‘liberalization’ requires effective legal supervision all the way down to the last seed stocks.(9) Since only in this way can it be guaranteed that, in the case of agriculture as well, the most powerful capital monopolizes agribusiness, namely by emancipating the means of agricultural production from any vestige of naturalness, and by turning them into means of production produced by capital; in other words by monopolizing the right of disposal over them. In this way it is guaranteed that no agricultural producer simply gets hold of such means of production, that soon nothing in the world grows anymore, and that, above all, the soon-to-be ten billion earthly inhabitants have nothing to eat, unless the high-tech firms in the genetic engineering sector and their affiliated farmers make money on it. At any rate, the next WTO ‘round’ has to take care of that; then the illegal circumstance of subsistence without money, and consequently completely without any economic sense and purpose, comes at last to an end.
As can be seen, the misery in this world didn’t go unnoticed in Seattle. It was even doubly appreciated: as a potential source of money for the right persons — and as an actual source of money for the wrong ones. http://www.gegenstandpunkt.com/english/wto.html
 
We do??! Well, that is certainly an interesting strawman ...

Don't forget that the exploited farm labourers primarily count as costs to a guy like balrog666 who seems to be complaining about the poor agricultural industrialists having to pay their workers at all, thus adding to their expenses!
Oh, the costs of it all!



Oh, yes, yes, oh, Great Dog, YES! I can barely wait until further development of crop hybrids and improved automation keep those poor illiterate migrant workers from having to toil out in the sun at all.

:rolleyes:
 
Oh, yes, yes, oh, Great Dog, YES! I can barely wait until further development of crop hybrids and improved automation keep those poor illiterate migrant workers from having to toil out in the sun at all.

:rolleyes:

I can see you skipped right over your previous strawman and erected a nice fresh one. Well done.

I'm not sure if you do this intentionally or you just have poor reading and comprehension skills. From what I read his point was that those poor illiterate migrant workers become completely reliant upon the big factory farms and those providing the technology (genetic engineering) for them. Which leaves them royally screwed and hungry if they can't afford to pay the prices that others are willing/able to pay.
 
People will starve until the food/population ratio balances out. It's a local problem, not a global one. I will explain to you:

I note the planet has about 6.5 billion people.

Let's say that next year 1.5 billion starve to death.

BFD.

The planet had about 4 billion when I was in high school. With five billion remaining we'd still be a billion to the good.

And think of the salutary impact this starvation has on the global warming problem, eh?

Please, anyone, explain to me where the following imbedded assumption comes from:

Continually increasing global human population has inherent virtue. This seems to underwrite the standard harangue about "world hunger" in contemporary discussion of the topic.

The Pope seems to feel that way, so why do some of our alleged Skeptics promote this idea (perhaps unwittingly)? Is the Pope right?

Do you even know what your assumptions are?

I wonder.

DR
 
Last edited:
Oh, yes, yes, oh, Great Dog, YES! I can barely wait until further development of crop hybrids and improved automation keep those poor illiterate migrant workers from having to toil out in the sun at all.
:rolleyes:

I'm sure that you can barely wait, but you make an interesting point: Whether migrant workers, literate or not, can eat is entirely up to agricultural companies. If improved automation makes it cheaper to replace the workers with machines, the workers no longer have an income and they no longer eat since hungry (ex-)workers without money are no 'incentive' to the capitalist way of production.
What you are also saying, of course, is that they should be happy to toil out in the sun at all for less than minimum wages since you are able to imagine even worse alternatives.
That's the wonderful extortion of capitalism according to its advocates.
 
The planet had about 4 billion when I was in high school. With five billion remaining we'd still be a billion to the good.

What does the fairly random number of people on the planet when you were in high school have to do with anything?

And think of the salutary impact this starvation has on the global warming problem, eh?

Is that supposed to be some kind of joke?

Please, anyone, explain to me where the following imbedded assumption comes from:

Continually increasing global human population has inherent virtue. This seems to underwrite the standard harangue about "world hunger" in contemporary discussion of the topic.

The Pope seems to feel that way, so why do some of our alleged Skeptics promote this idea (perhaps unwittingly)? Is the Pope right?

Could it be that your idea of the "imbedded assumption", "perhaps unwittingly" promoted by "alleged Skeptics", that "increasing global human population has inherent virtue" is nothing but a strawman?
Could it be that your skeptic opponents simply say that people deserve to eat? And could it be that so far the number of people on the planet does not really have anything to do with the number of starving people or the quantity of food available?
In Capital Karl Marx describes how a relative surplus population is created:
http://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/ch25.htm
Not relative to the quantity of food but relative to the number of workers needed by capital. The workers who aren’t needed don’t get paid, which means that they may starve – even though unmarketable foodstuffs are stockpiled elsewhere because the starving people don’t have the money to buy them.
 
Please, anyone, explain to me where the following imbedded assumption comes from:

Continually increasing global human population has inherent virtue. This seems to underwrite the standard harangue about "world hunger" in contemporary discussion of the topic.

DR

I would like to commend you on facing the reality of global population.

I wouldn't say that is exactly what is going on in world hunger discussions. It's more about the pain and suffering caused by starvation and what action is humanitarian. I do think religion plays a big part in the assumption that continually increasing global population is a good thing. I would say it is also partly because of history and trouble settling new places or colonies dying out that has been kept with us all this time. The more people the more survival. Finally it is because humanity has it in their heads that the Earth was made for man and man was made to rule it. So we need to swarm the entirety of the earth and force it into submission to become what we want it to be soley for us.
 
I am not sure about the conclusion, but perhaps as long as people are dying in third world countries from hunger, and we can stop that, we have no right to pursue our own happiness but need to invest all that we do in helping them.

Do you agree?
Well, CAN we stop people dying in third world countries from hunger?

Because the answer is not at all obvious. First step is to put a bullet through the head of every kleptocrat strongman in every starving Third World country, as they are the primary cause of the problem. Second step is to impose rule of law by force, lest new kleptocrat strongmen exactly like one before step in. Third, start distributing food...

Didn't we try this in Iraq not too long ago?

So in short, your question boils down to "As long as A and B, then C. Do you agree?". B is demonstrably false, so the answer is no.
 
If Marxism is the answer to the World's food problem, then explain why Russia, which before the Revolution was a net food exporter, could not feed itself, and why China under Mao has constant famines.
 
I'm sure that you can barely wait, but you make an interesting point: Whether migrant workers, literate or not, can eat is entirely up to agricultural companies. If improved automation makes it cheaper to replace the workers with machines, the workers no longer have an income and they no longer eat since hungry (ex-)workers without money are no 'incentive' to the capitalist way of production.
What you are also saying, of course, is that they should be happy to toil out in the sun at all for less than minimum wages since you are able to imagine even worse alternatives.
That's the wonderful extortion of capitalism according to its advocates.


Gosh, thanks for reading my mind! That must be exactly what I meant to post! :rolleyes:
 
You do know that this is what happens, don't you?
That your expectation of improved agricultural machinery
I can barely wait until further development of crop hybrids and improved automation keep those poor illiterate migrant workers from having to toil out in the sun at all.
does not mean that the burden of the workers will be lessened but instead that they will be out of a job?
This, of course, is the reason why it is a myth when futurists claim that a lightened workload means that in future people will work fewer hours: When one worker is able to do the work of three, two of the three are laid off.
Labour - Time That Pays Money
 
Last edited:
What does the fairly random number of people on the planet when you were in high school have to do with anything?
It has the same validity as the assumption that continuing to feed populations that increase willy nilly is in some way a virtuous idea.

Is that supposed to be some kind of joke?
No. Your dogma, however, is one.
Could it be that your idea of the "imbedded assumption", "perhaps unwittingly" promoted by "alleged Skeptics", that "increasing global human population has inherent virtue" is nothing but a strawman?
No, since I've been following the human aid junkie habit for about twenty years.
Could it be that your skeptic opponents simply say that people deserve to eat?
And therein lies your problem. Not only are these alleged skeptics not my opponents -- you completely misread what I am getting at in your obsession to resort to a polemic -- but you betray your own unconsidered assumption with a word.

Deserve.

Where do you get that assumption from? An element of the global warming problem is a resource constraint problem, as well as a resource management problem. So too the inability of rabidly growing populations to feed themselves. Consider this curious stat from last year, off the news wired: the average fertile woman in Kenya has seven offspring.

Do the math. What does that say for the requirements for Kenyan food production over the next two generations?

If you can't feed them, don't breed them, mister.

As to making sure you first know what your assumptions are before coming up with a solution to a perceived problem, I hear that is what scientists try to do. Some Skeptics try it as well.

Demagogues, like yourself, seem not to care for that approach, dann.

DR
 
Last edited:
No, since I've been following the human aid junkie habit for about twenty years.

Then I guess it shouldn't be an 'embedded assumption' anymore but a fact, so let's see all the evidence you've spent the last twenty years collecting.

Where do you get that assumption from? An element of the global warming problem is a resource constraint problem, as well as a resource management problem. So too the inability of rabidly growing populations to feed themselves. Consider this curious stat from last year, off the news wired: the average fertile woman in Kenya has seven offspring.

Do you know how many Kenyans it takes to burn the amount of fossil fuels you do?
I was about to say what you could do, personally, to contribute to easing the problem, but that would be a violation of the MA.

Do the math. What does that say for the requirements for Kenyan food production over the next two generations?

Do the math: How many of the seven children die prematurely - and not just from starvation?

If you can't feed them, don't breed them, mister.

"mister"?! I was not aware that I was breeding the people I think deserve to eat ...

As to making sure you first know what your assumptions are before coming up with a solution to a perceived problem, I hear that is what scientists try to do. Some Skeptics try it as well.

Demagogues, like yourself, seem not to care for that approach, dann.

I don’t know what makes this so difficult to understand for you, but you may have fallen prey to your own demagogy. You don’t have to be Einstein to realize that, but let's see what scientists say:
Production is carried on for profit, not for use. There is no provision that all those able and willing to work will always be in a position to find employment; an “army of unemployed” almost always exists. The worker is constantly in fear of losing his job. Since unemployed and poorly paid workers do not provide a profitable market, the production of consumers' goods is restricted, and great hardship is the consequence. Technological progress frequently results in more unemployment rather than in an easing of the burden of work for all.
And, no, it’s not a quotation from Karl Marx
 
If a community is breeding itself to death then this is a self correcting problem. This happens in nature. We actually help this process along in some cases (ie deer hunting). It may sound heartless and cruel but the best thing that can be done for overpopulation is spreading technology, education, and condoms to the people and hope they don't continue on the path of self destruction. Trying to feed them all is not going to solve the underlying problem and will only prolong the cycle of suffering.
 
If a community is breeding itself to death then this is a self correcting problem. This happens in nature. We actually help this process along in some cases (ie deer hunting). It may sound heartless and cruel but the best thing that can be done for overpopulation is spreading technology, education, and condoms to the people and hope they don't continue on the path of self destruction. Trying to feed them all is not going to solve the underlying problem and will only prolong the cycle of suffering.

It hink that may be correct a few decades ago, but in today globalized world, it isnt just those starving people that the cause of the problem themself.
Many other factors come into play nowadays.

And if we people in the overeaten world just close our eyes keep eating to much and let starv others its just a giant step backwards in moral values.
 
It hink that may be correct a few decades ago, but in today globalized world, it isnt just those starving people that the cause of the problem themself.
Many other factors come into play nowadays.

And if we people in the overeaten world just close our eyes keep eating to much and let starv others its just a giant step backwards in moral values.


You sound like one of those silly activists that think going on a hunger strike (for six hours) somehow feeds someone else 8000 miles away ...

:boggled:
 
Another amusing strawman from balrog. However, DC more or less brought it on himself when he seems to imply that there is some kind of connection between overeating in the capitalist countries and starvation in the third world.
 
The Pope seems to feel that way, so why do some of our alleged Skeptics promote this idea (perhaps unwittingly)? Is the Pope right?

Do you even know what your assumptions are?

I wonder.

DR

Growing population is an easy way to have a growing economy. I wonder if we had true "zero population growth", what that would do to world economics.
 
Growing population is an easy way to have a growing economy. I wonder if we had true "zero population growth", what that would do to world economics.
What? It doesn't grow income-per-capita, unless you're starting from scratch so to speak--like the US in the C18th-19th.

Zero population growth is quite compatible with income growth though, if labour productivity and capital intensity and any other type of productivity increases, which it has done for a very tiny fraction of human existence--just the last century or so.
 
And a key part of this is what abilities are analogous to "trained in medicine"

It isn't just have money and time to fight hunger, it's knowing how to apply them usefully. Sending money through the right channels may help save lives, but sending it through the wrong agencies may instead fund
1) Mostly the agencies themselves
2) The corrupt government/rebel group that's creating these conditions in the first place
3) Dependence on aid, creating a society that can't feed it's children without constant injection of aid.
4) Agricultural experiments with good intentions but disastrous consequences.
5) All sorts of other unintentional harm.

If you can navigate all this and understand that your efforts will really be helping, then yes you should help. But keep in mind that the ability of someone with enough money to make a difference and an understanding of how to actually help instead of make the situation worse is somewhat rare, so you owe it to those you help to continue to make lots of money and to have an active social life to keep yourself emotionally stable to keep that high-paying job and remain useful.

May I add, if someone hasn't already and I missed it: The complete emancipation of women a condition without which no civilization will achieve anything like a modern industrial state. That and the conditions listed above
are crucial before simple donation will change anything over the long term.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom