Is the swine flu going to be pandemic?

Well now they've apparently just about killed every pig in the country, literally.

Egypt hunts last pigs as three new swine flu cases confirmed

There is a silver lining to this madness, however. There is a fair amount of bird flu circulating in Egypt right now. Eliminating the potential pigs as mixing vessels is not all bad.
Yeah. I don't understand why they aren't killing all the birds then. As well, hm, for stopping it on the pig vessel end they would need to kill all the pigs in the world to combat the "mixing vessel" problem. We have people and birds travelling the world and then carrying the mixed vessels' viruses all over the place.

So, what's next. Killing all humans with swine flu in that country? Well, as long as they are christians...
Mixing H1N1 and H5N1 in humans would be quite bad as well? The H1N1 disease is just not serious enough to be killing all of the pigs, and killing all of their pigs will not stop this particular flu virus from spreading to them.
What are the chances H1N1 could make H5N1 more dangerous when mixed in pigs?

Does H5N1 kill pigs?

Now I'm dying to mix viruses in pigs to find out, lol. Good thing I don't have access to a lab... *evil grin* There have been farms here killing all of their infected pigs because the farmer figures they won't be able to sell them anyways, since maybe some people won't accept that you can't get H1N1 from pork chops? Oy. I could take some sick pigs, and find some sick birds... mwah ha ha!

He added the government would vaccinate 60 million fowl as part of its campaign against the related H5N1, or bird flu, virus.

Last week, a four-year-old girl from the Nile Delta province of Daqahliya became the 27th person to die of bird flu in Egypt. Hers was the 72nd confirmed case of that virus in the country, MENA said.


Oh sure, vaccinate the birds. Kill all the pigs. There are peopled dead from bird flu, but none dead by "swine" flu. Talk about weird double standards. Where are they getting the vaccine from, and why isn't there one for humans against H5N1??

Okay, there is so much I don't know. Anyone have more information?
 
Last edited:
Yeah. I don't understand why they aren't killing all the birds then. As well, hm, for stopping it on the pig vessel end they would need to kill all the pigs in the world to combat the "mixing vessel" problem. We have people and birds travelling the world and then carrying the mixed vessels' viruses all over the place.
Well they aren't using the mixing vessel rationale, they are using either total ignorance about the actual hazard, or, using the flu as an excuse to clear out the pigs owned by an ethnic minority in Cairo (which is what the news link I posted earlier said was the real reason). I'm the one that suggested the sliver lining was eliminating the mixing vessel in that area at this time.

Pigs are actually thought to be a bigger mixing vessel risk than birds, however. The reason is they easily get both bird and human flu strains while birds and humans are thought to share their strains less often. So pigs are a potential bridge so to speak.

Does H5N1 kill pigs?
Yes but both ducks and pigs develop tolerance for these strains more readily than humans and poultry do. (Other bird species vary.)

Oh sure, vaccinate the birds. Kill all the pigs. There are peopled dead from bird flu, but none dead by "swine" flu. Talk about weird double standards. Where are they getting the vaccine from, and why isn't there one for humans against H5N1??

Okay, there is so much I don't know. Anyone have more information?
Killing the pigs is dumb. The bird vaccine is used where it is no longer possible to cull all the infected birds as the strain has become too widespread. Prior to the H5N1 becoming endemic in the bird populations, culling the infected flocks was used extensively. This is an effective method of control and is still used where the strain is not established as an endemic strain.

Yes, there is a human vaccine. It is not under production currently because the H5N1 virus is not widespread in humans. No sense producing it because if/when there is a pandemic of H5N1, it could be substantially different genetically and this vaccine may not be a good match. But just as with the H1N1 vaccine that should be ready in a few months, we could have an H5N1 in about that same amount of time. But not ahead of time, no way to predict the exact composition of the vaccine ahead of the outbreak.
 
Last edited:
Amazing. 37,000+ people now in the US that have caught H1N1 flu, 211 deaths and still following a strong growth curve yet it no longer holds much interests to us, either in the media or here at JREF. Strange how quickly we adjust and how fleeting novelty can be.
 
Amazing. 37,000+ people now in the US that have caught H1N1 flu, 211 deaths and still following a strong growth curve yet it no longer holds much interests to us, either in the media or here at JREF. Strange how quickly we adjust and how fleeting novelty can be.
Without wanting to talk this particular outbreak down or the concern about a new strain, the average annual deaths from "regular" flu are about 36,000 in the US. OK, figures are difficult to come by and sometimes a bit nebulous, but a comparison.

End of April
I'm not ignoring all the previous posts, but that's the reality. "Bird" and "Swine" flu are novel new strains, but while pandemic, don't look to be as wide spread as "regular" flu.

Don't get me wrong, I think it was responsible to plan to contain this, but the subsequent panic, just as with Avian Flu, was driven OTT by the media in my opinion, and many people have become blase about it because of media over-egging.
 
Half of which are in Victoria, for whatever reason.
I'm not all that worried, should I be?
Victoria has the highest per capita rate in the world, but it seems to be sparing the outer eastern suburbs where I live. :)

I'm not sure of the reason. Perhaps they're looking for it more, or perhaps it's just bad luck.

I'm not worried because it sounds like it's proving to be somewhat less severe than seasonal flu and I'm fit and healthy. Again, I could be unlucky and get it and die from it, but then I don't win lotto either.
 
I vote for Jenny McCarthy.

ETA: Preferably after she's refused to be vaccinated against it.
:D

What's the bet that if we ever get a severe flu pandemic and there's a vaccine that alll these people will slink off in secrecy to get their shots.
 
Prevalence in Scotland seems to be quite high, and they've stopped issuing statistics. I don't know anyone who's been ill though. It mainly seeme to be the west that's catching it. Though I heard today that our Aberdeen centre has encountered cases.

There have been a small number of deaths, but not all deaths initially attriuted to influenza have proved to be so when the post mortem was done. Most people are not especially sick, and it is believed that many are just staying home for a few days and not even calling the doctor.

My elderly mother is concerned, but since it's been shown that people born before 1920 have antibodies to this thing, she's probably in the best position of all of us! Actually, I don't know how resistant the over-90s are to infection though, as I don't suppose many have been exposed. We'll find out when it hits a care home, I suppose.

Rolfe.

ETA: I note that in Scotland, cumulative figures for the epidemic are standing at 40 hospitalisations and 2 deaths. 45% of the hospitalised patients had a "recognised risk factor".
 
Last edited:
A study in Australia has apparently shown that nearly all people with flu like symptoms at the present time have swine flu. In that case, my daughter has probably had it. She was actually quite unwell and spent her two week holiday at home and most of the first week in bed. None of the rest of us (5) got it though.
 
Out of about 1400 freshman, or about 5800 students total.

Doesn't sound all that virulent to me.
At this point, it appears not to be any more virulent than a seasonal flu; in other words, not significantly more likely to cause severe illness in those it infects. "Virulence" and "Pathogenicity" are often used interchangeably, and incorrectly. You have to be a little careful with the use of some of these terms or there's a good chance that some pedant will come along and, uh... call you on it (especially here). You could have avoided that risk altogether by saying "doesn't sound all that contagious", which is what I believe you meant.

But even that would be overlooking something important, which is that transmissibility does not reside solely with the virus, but is distributed between virus, host, and environment. For one thing, we're talking about a military academy here, not a daycare facility. If there were any setting in which control measures might be expected to be enforceable, that would have to be it. For another, we're talking about an influenza virus doing something very few influenza viruses demonstrate the ability to do, and that is to spread effectively during the peak of summer.
 
The interesting thing about the Academy is that is is a chance to study the spread in a closed system. So far, it seems that, with the caveats you brought up, it has only 'caught' about 1 percent.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom