The certainty of God's existence.

Here is what I see to be the impasse between me as a rational theist...
In all honesty and sincerity I don't believe that this is true. I'm not joking and I'm not trying to be difficult but I think that statement is very problematic.
 
Presumably the justification for P6 will have a workable definition of eternity. Here is what I based mine on:

Eternity:

Boethius: The simultaneously-whole and perfect possession of interminable life

Aquinas: Eternity is known from two facts: first, because what is eternal is interminable - that is has no beginning or end (that is, no term either way); secondly, because eternity itself has no succession, being simultaneously whole.

Elswhere it is described as immutable.

So something eternal has no (ontological) beginning, no (ontological) end, no succession and no change.

Note that Aquinas stipulated that a created world that had a temporal beginning could be eternal, thus he is making a sharp distinction between the beginning of a series of temporal events and beginning to exist..

I hope that Boethius and Aquinas qualify as what RevDisturba calls "metaphysical thinkers".

I hope that they qualify for what Yrreg calls "rational theists". Otherwise we have a problem.
 
Since most of this thread seems to have been a discussion on external sex organs, are you saying your's is bigger than ours? :boxedin:
Good point. But as yrreg also discusses about God, like here:

The first kind and degree of certainty is for things which like your nose and your external sex organ and also you whole physical being you can touch with your hands, as also others can touch with their hands.

The certainty of God is another kind and degree of human certainty.

I'm even more interested in:

yrreg, does God have a penis?

And if yes, is it bigger than yours?
 
Here is what I see to be the impasse between me as a rational theist and the atheists here:

I maintain that God exists and is a conscious intelligent being Who made everything in the whole totality of existence including the physical universe, and He put the scheme of intelligent order in the whole totality of existence as described.

Atheists here maintain that only matter (in place of God) exists and it 'works' by randomness whereby after billions of years man appears as a conscious intelligent being endowed with free will.​


The above is incorrect. It should read:

yrreg maintains that God exists and is a conscious intelligent being Who made everything in the whole totality of existence including the physical universe, and He put the scheme of intelligent order in the whole totality of existence as described.

Atheists do not maintain that God exists.​

Furthermore, where you have written:

"only matter (in place of God) exists and it 'works' by randomness whereby after billions of years man appears as a conscious intelligent being endowed with free will"

highlights your ignorance of general science, cosmology, abiogenesis and evolution. It should have read:

"only matter (in place of God) exists and it 'worked' by natural laws that lead (probably by chance) to the first simple, self-replicating molecules that made random copying errors, called mutations, which were either favoured or rejected by natural selection (which is the opposite of randomness), whereby after billions of years of natural selection of beneficial mutations, man appears as a conscious intelligent being endowed with free will along with tens of millions of other species on the planet".
 
*Hokulele does not subscribe to the fact that humans are conscious intelligent free agents, but when confronted further she or he said instead that (s)he was being funny.


You are incorrect ...

Atheists are always like that here, they will say something and then claim to be funny when confronted with the absurdity and impracticality of their ideological positions.


... but funny.
 
P1: If the universe has no beginning, there have been an infinite number of events.
P2: An infinite number of events is an absurdity and is impossible.
Asserted. Not axiomatic.

P3: Everything which has a beginning must have been caused by something.
And there are some very good theories that deal with what that cause was. Very possibly whenever a membrane in the 11th comes together it creates a new universe dimension.



Theoretical and elegant it doesn't require appeals to supernatural and unknown forces. IOW, it's parsimonious, sensible, reasonable.

P5: The cause of the universe is eternal.
Asserted and causes your argument to be internally inconsistent. This is a fatal flaw of the argument.

P6: The only way an eternal cause could produce something bound by time is for it to freely choose to.
Causing many, many inconsistencies. A choice is change. Change IS time. If there is no time there is no change. There is no known theory for an entity to exist outside of time and think and choose. That is inherently inconsistent. A fatal flaw of the argument.

I've read a number of criticisms of the argument and there are many but the most critical is that the argument posits unknown entities with unknown forces.

It's silly. It's ridiculous and it isn't compelling to theoretical scientists for the very simply fact that it fails on so many levels.

C3: The cause of the universe must be personal.
Nonsense for very many reasons.
 
Last edited:
Good point. But as yrreg also discusses about God, like here:



I'm even more interested in:

yrreg, does God have a penis?

And if yes, is it bigger than yours?


Furthermore, is God certain of his penis?
 
RevDisturba | Robin
|D1: An event is an entity that is the cause of it's successor if it has a successor and the effect of it's predecessor if it has a predecessor
|D2: A universe is an ordered set of events.
P1: If the universe has no beginning, there have been an infinite number of events.|P1: An ordered set of events is either infinite or has an event without a predecessor.
P2: An infinite number of events is an absurdity and is impossible.|P2: An actual infinity is impossible
C1: Therefore, the universe must have had a beginning.|C1: The universe has an event without a predecessor.
P3: Everything which has a beginning must have been caused by something.|P3: In an ordered set of events, any event that does not have a predecessor has a predecessor.
P4: If C1 and P3, then C2.|P4: If C1 and P3, then C2.
C2: The universe must have been caused by something.|C2: The first event in the universe has a predecessor
P5: The cause of the universe is eternal.|P5: The predecessor of the first event in the universe has no predecessors or successors
P6: The only way an eternal cause could produce something bound by time is for it to freely choose to.|P6: The only way that an event with no predecessors or successors could have a successor with predecessors and successors is for it to have a predecessor (an intention).
P7: If P5 and P6, then C3.|P7: If P5 and P6 then C3
C3: The cause of the universe must be personal.|C3: The cause of the universe must be personal.
RevDisturbia has claimed the argument in the right hand column is not a logical syllogism. Can anybody tell me the difference in logical structure between the argument in the right hand column and the argument in the left hand column?

Let me bump this having demonstrated that my rendering of P5 and P6 is consistent with one of the most widely used definitions of eternity.
 
Causing many, many inconsistencies. A choice is change. Change IS time. If there is no time there is no change. There is no known theory for an entity to exist outside of time and think and choose. That is inherently inconsistent. A fatal flaw of the argument.
Yes, exactly - basically what I said a number of pages back - if eternity is timeless, with no succession and no change then intention-action-result is both succession and change and so an eternal entity could not possibly possess intentional intelligence.

On the other hand if God can can do the intention-action-result trick then we can just run the whole argument again with God as the subject and, if it were valid, would prove that there was a God who created God.
 
Last edited:
Okay, you state your #1 operating premise, and be clear and definite about it.

Here is what I see to be the impasse between me as a rational theist and the atheists here:

I maintain that God exists and is a conscious intelligent being Who made everything in the whole totality of existence including the physical universe, and He put the scheme of intelligent order in the whole totality of existence as described.

Atheists here maintain that only matter (in place of God) exists and it 'works' by randomness whereby after billions of years man appears as a conscious intelligent being endowed with free will.*​

That is the impasse between me a rational theist and the atheists in this forum.



Are both of us certain of our number one operating premise?


I am certain as humans can be certain who allow their reason to work as God has intended it to work.


What about you atheists, are you certain of your number one operating premise, and what kind of certainty is it, human or what?




Yrreg


*Hokulele does not subscribe to the fact that humans are conscious intelligent free agents, but when confronted further she or he said instead that (s)he was being funny.

Atheists are always like that here, they will say something and then claim to be funny when confronted with the absurdity and impracticality of their ideological positions.​


Okay, atheists, you state your #1 operating premise, and be clear and definite about it.


For the present, don't attend to anything else in my post above, except to get the drift of the message.


I must say again, that it is very difficult to get any kind of viable exchange of thoughts with you atheists, because you just can't be relevant but must indulge in all kinds of diversionary tactics, indicating that you have almost nothing if anything at all clear and definite and categorical to which you can claim to have any conviction for.


Except that your words are rife with anger and hatred for God owing to your fear of God.






Yrreg
 
A penis but no hands? No wonder he's so angry.

His god created him with a penis and no hands? That is truly a nightmare! But at the same time, this is juicier than what happened to Job.. I'm thinking a sweet movie deal, possibly a new religion since I can make my god scarier than your god :p
 
Last edited:
Yes, exactly - basically what I said a number of pages back - if eternity is timeless, with no succession and no change then intention-action-result is both succession and change and so an eternal entity could not possibly possess intentional intelligence.

On the other hand if God can can do the intention-action-result trick then we can just run the whole argument again with God as the subject and, if it were valid, would prove that there was a God who created God.
Yes, except for those who would resort to special pleading. Some believe that god is a special case and therefore the argument doesn't apply to him/it/her/? whatever.

It's all after the fact reasoning. An attempt to justify a belief. Instead of looking at the facts and doing the math and accepting the consequences of the logic people start with a belief in god and then go in search of something that resembles logically valid argument and then defend it to the death.

If plugging god (whatever the hell that is) into the equations would provide explanatory power for the observable universe then there would be a paradigm that theorists would debate and grapple with and a consensus would form.

As it is it does nothing. Solves nothing. Answers nothing. It's a big blob of unkown in a conceptual punchbowl. It could be a turd for all anyone knows.
 
Except that your words are rife with anger and hatred for God owing to your fear of God.

I told you, my anger and hatred for God stems from the fact that he still owes me $500 and he ducks me every time I see him.

By the way, I wonder if you've seen that I met your challenge. Could you explain the true context of your comment?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom