Evidence of God's existence

Status
Not open for further replies.
So please explain how science explains the origin and cause of the universe.

It doesn't, because there's no need. There isn't any need for a cause.

Like I said in a previous post, there isn't any need for the law of conservation of matter and energy to apply outside the universe. There also wouldn't be any time outside the universe, and therefore no cause-effect relationships. Something could literally have come from nothing.

why do you think God is a exception ?

Because the rule which makes your god necessary is "everything needs a cause". If your god does not need a cause, then he is an exception to that rule, and you have therefore committed the special pleading fallacy.[/quote]

the facts shown in my opening thread ARE evidence. If not, please explain, why.

Because they're one giant mess of logical fallacies.

So everything coming from nothing. Makes that sense to you ?

Yes.

and where is the evidence ? and what caused that bubble of quantum stuff ?

Where is the evidence of your god? What caused that god?
 
So you need a tablet with 2 million semitic names, to accept evidence they lived in egypt ? No kidding.....
so youre picking and choosing which questions to answer now and creating strawman arguments as you go

it was very apparent that you didn't understand what "semitic" is when you made that post, attempting to inflate your lack of knowledge now is just digging your hole a little deeper
perhaps this will help
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Semitic#Ancient_Semitic_peoples

we see this quite a lot here, people like you who have used the bible as a history book always fail because you know nothing of the real history or how the bible doesn't fit into it. The bible is a book of faith, use it as such, anything else is a perversion of its cause
;)

forget all the other questions you couldn't answer because you don't know any of the answers
just answer me this one, you said
So everything coming from nothing. Makes that sense to you ?
So, who created your God ?
 
Last edited:
It doesn't, because there's no need. There isn't any need for a cause.

Like I said in a previous post, there isn't any need for the law of conservation of matter and energy to apply outside the universe. There also wouldn't be any time outside the universe, and therefore no cause-effect relationships. Something could literally have come from nothing.

that goes agianst all empirical observations. Everything from nothing is not reasonable. Actually, its complete b****s*****.


Because the rule which makes your god necessary is "everything needs a cause". If your god does not need a cause, then he is an exception to that rule, and you have therefore committed the


doesgodexist.org/Pamphlets/WhoCreatedGod.html

From a purely scientific standpoint, it is easy to demonstrate that matter cannot be eternal in nature. The universe is expanding from what appears to be a beginning point in space/time, which appears to be a one time event. Hydrogen is the basic fuel of the cosmos, powering all stars and other energy sources in space. If the fuel of the universe has been used eternally, that fuel will eventually be depleted; but the evidence is that the cosmological gas gauge, while moving toward “empty,” is yet a long way from being there—a condition incompatible with an eternal universe. The second law of thermodynamics insists that the cosmos is moving toward a condition of disorder, sometimes referred to as “heat death.” Even in an oscillating universe, things ultimately run out of energy and “die.” All of these evidences, and several others we have not made reference to, show that matter cannot be eternal,

If God is a being that is unlimited in time, and if He has access to every piece of time as if it were now, the question of who created God is an invalid question. The problem is like asking a student to draw a four-sided triangle. The terminology is self-contradictory.
When asked “Who or what created God?” we are making the assumption that God was created. If God exists outside of time and space, and if He is the Creator of time and space, He obviously was not created! God began the beginning! This is why He says, “I am Alpha and Omega, the beginning and the end, the first and the last” (Revelation 22:13).
God created time. The statement of Genesis, “In the beginning God created the heaven and the earth,” is making reference to the creation of time. The reason that things like heat death, the expansion of the universe, and the depletion of hydrogen do not apply to God is because He is outside of time. God has always been. He did things before time began (see 1 Corinthians 2:7). He not only began time; He will also end it. When time ends, all matter and all mankind will enter eternity—a timeless condition free of the negative things that time brings upon us now.
 
Last edited:
that goes agianst all empirical observations. Everything from nothing is not reasonable. Actually, its complete b****s*****.

Because, again, you are applying laws which only apply within the universe to the universe itself. Outside the universe, the laws which say that something can't come from nothing do not necessarily apply.

If God is a being that is unlimited in time, and if He has access to every piece of time as if it were now, the question of who created God is an invalid question. The problem is like asking a student to draw a four-sided triangle. The terminology is self-contradictory.

No, it isn't. Because if everything has to have a cause, then there cannot be an eternal being, because an eternal being does not have a cause. If there is an eternal being, then not everything has to have a cause, and you are committing the special pleading fallacy.

When asked “Who or what created God?” we are making the assumption that God was created. If God exists outside of time and space, and if He is the Creator of time and space, He obviously was not created! God began the beginning! This is why He says, “I am Alpha and Omega, the beginning and the end, the first and the last” (Revelation 22:13).
God created time. The statement of Genesis, “In the beginning God created the heaven and the earth,” is making reference to the creation of time. The reason that things like heat death, the expansion of the universe, and the depletion of hydrogen do not apply to God is because He is outside of time. God has always been. He did things before time began (see 1 Corinthians 2:7). He not only began time; He will also end it. When time ends, all matter and all mankind will enter eternity—a timeless condition free of the negative things that time brings upon us now.

All of this, besides being bare assertion, is still the special pleading fallacy. If your god did not need a creator, then not everything needs a creator, and you are committing the special pleading fallacy to insert him for no reason. If everything needs a cause, then he needs a cause.
Your argument contradicts itself.
 
The terminology is self-contradictory.
He did things before time began (see 1 Corinthians 2:7). He not only began time; He will also end it. When time ends, all matter and all mankind will enter eternity—a timeless condition free of the negative things that time brings upon us now.

Agreed ... self-contradictory. Define "before" in the absence of time.
 
that goes agianst all empirical observations. Everything from nothing is not reasonable. Actually, its complete b****s*****.
There are absolutely no empirical observations supporting creation ex nihilo.
From a purely scientific standpoint, it is easy to demonstrate that matter cannot be eternal in nature. The universe is expanding from what appears to be a beginning point in space/time, which appears to be a one time event. Hydrogen is the basic fuel of the cosmos, powering all stars and other energy sources in space. If the fuel of the universe has been used eternally, that fuel will eventually be depleted; but the evidence is that the cosmological gas gauge, while moving toward “empty,” is yet a long way from being there—a condition incompatible with an eternal universe.
This reasoning doesn't actually support your assertion. From a purely scientific viewpoint, the law of conservation of energy kicks in. Even when fuel is expended, energy is only ever transformed into other forms of energy. Our modern understanding is that mass is energy.

This hydrogen that gets "depleted" becomes heavier elements. And we're left with essentially just as much mass as we started with, and exactly as much energy. It doesn't matter how far you wind the clock--we have the same amount of energy.
The second law of thermodynamics insists that the cosmos is moving toward a condition of disorder, sometimes referred to as “heat death.” Even in an oscillating universe, things ultimately run out of energy and “die.” All of these evidences, and several others we have not made reference to, show that matter cannot be eternal,
And in the heat death scenario, matter is converted to unusable energy called entropy, but that energy is still there. This flies in the face of your assertion.

Conservation of energy stays around, and we have exactly as much of this energy at heat death as we had when all of this mess started.

No extra energy. No less energy.

Now you do have less useful energy, but that doesn't help your argument, because you're trying to argue that something isn't eternal. But the law of conservation of energy betrays you.
If God is a being that is unlimited in time, and if He has access to every piece of time as if it were now, the question of who created God is an invalid question.
Then why not save a step? If you have to have something that isn't created, why not the universe itself?

Sticking your god there is quite an arbitrary thing to do. It's unnecessary and speculative. You're saying that god must be there in order to explain the universe because the universe cannot be there without this god. But your reasoning doesn't apply to the god in itself, because he's an exception.

Why must this god exist? Again, if you're going to use this sort of appeal to evidence, use it right. Every sentient being we have ever seen has a brain. This god would have to have a brain. How did its brain get here?

ETA: You don't get to use the bible until you first establish that it's a reliable means of obtaining truth. This is supposed to be rational, remember?
 
Last edited:
This, plus several subsequent posts, suggests to me this is one of those students that has to engage with skeptics as part of a course requirement.
.
It would be interesting to see the report on this encounter. :)
A verbatim compilation of many of the replies might create some interest in the class.
The instructor would have to trot some evasions of the highest most mediocre quality. :)
 
Maibe we start with nr.1

Fine by me.

1. God makes sense of the origin of the universe.

Really? Let's take a closer look...

Without God:
  • The universe began through unknown processes.
With God:
  • A being of unknown origin existed before the universe.
  • This being acts through unknown forces.
  • It created the universe and us for unknown reasons.
  • It created the universe through unknown processes.
Clearly, the origin of the universe makes less sense with God than it does without God.

The Kalam Cosmological Argument

elshamah.heavenforum.com/astronomy-cosmology-and-god-f15/the-kalam-cosmological-argument-t132.htm

leaderu.com/truth/3truth11.html

1. Whatever begins to exist has a cause of its
existence.
2. The universe began to exist.
3. Therefore, the universe has a cause of its
existence. that cause was God.


What about...
  1. Whatever has a beginning has an end.
  2. The universe will expand forever, without end.
  3. Therefore the universe has no beginning.
Seriously, we don't know anything about the universe before it expanded beyond the Planck point as our understanding of the laws of physics don't apply. The belief that the universe had a beginning is more of an educated guess than a confirmed fact. As far as we know, the universe could have been expanding forever from an infinitely small point.

Also, your first postulate "Whatever begins to exist has a cause of its
existence" is false. Virtual particles, for example, pop into existence without cause all the time. If things can begin to exist without cause on a quantum level, then the universe could have began to exist without cause as a quantum fluctuation. After all, we have no idea what kind of physics applies.

Finally, even if there was a first cause what would it be like? To exist "before" the universe would make it timeless, existing outside of time, as time is a function of the universe. But both thought and actions are processes that require time, so your first cause must necessarily be incapable of thought or action, and therefore not a God. Of course, you could argue that a God might generate it's own special "time" in which to function, but the point is that the second part of the conclusion, "that cause was God" is a non-sequitur, it does not follow from your reasoning. There is nothing in the "first cause" arguments to suggest that the "first cause" is intelligent, which is a necessary prerequisite for a God.

So we have here three arguments, each of which completely invalidate the Kalam Cosmological Argument.
 
ok let me see if I have this right, as evidence for the existence of God you are submitting passages from the Bible
please read and fully understand this link before you post anything else
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Begging_the_question#Definition
.
This might help as well:


circularlogic.jpg
 
Last edited:
Yeesh, "yesterday", and it's up to 4 pages already.


From my personal virtual library :

Arguments for the Existence of God

elshamah.heavenforum.com/does-god-exist-origin-of-god-metaphysical-reality-f10/arguments-for-the-existence-of-god-t5.htm

five good reasons to think that God exists:

1. God makes sense of the origin of the universe.

No he doesn't. All it does is push off the question of what caused the universe to exist to what caused God to exist? "God always existed!" does not make any sense whatsoever.

2. God makes sense of the fine-tuning of the universe for intelligent life.

So does evolution, which adapts to amazing situations. It seems like fine-tuning, but any reasonable set of building blocks would work. By necessity, we would only arise in a universe that had them. In any case, presuming a god did it is scientifically silly, given our poor state of knowledge of how such "fine tuning" may have occurred, or if it even did.


3. God makes sense of objective moral values in the world.

God created death, so not killing people makes sense because of God? God created pain and terror and loss and loneliness, so humans wanting to ameliorate those is evidence of God? I'm not sure you're helping your case any.


4. God makes sense of the life, death, and resurrection of Jesus.

Incarnating as a human avatar to have oneself sacrificed to appease his own wrath, a hoop that only He cares about makes sense?

Just how do you define "makes sense"?


5. God can be immediately known and experienced.

No, God cannot be, since He doesn't exist. Whatever you're experiencing isn't a god.



The Kalam Cosmological Argument

elshamah.heavenforum.com/astronomy-cosmology-and-god-f15/the-kalam-cosmological-argument-t132.htm

leaderu.com/truth/3truth11.html

1. Whatever begins to exist has a cause of its
existence.
2. The universe began to exist.
3. Therefore, the universe has a cause of its
existence. that cause was God.

4. Therefore, something must have caused God to exist (premise 1) or the universe never began to exist (premise 2)
 
That goes against all empirical observations. Everything from nothing is not reasonable.

...snip...

From a purely scientific standpoint, it is easy to demonstrate that matter cannot be eternal in nature. The universe is expanding from what appears to be a beginning point in space/time, which appears to be a one time event.

...snip...

The second law of thermodynamics insists that the cosmos is moving toward a condition of disorder, sometimes referred to as “heat death.” Even in an oscillating universe, things ultimately run out of energy and “die.” All of these evidences, and several others we have not made reference to, show that matter cannot be eternal.

In the rest of your post, which I deleted because it was a mass of bible quotes, you mentioned the inanity of impossible definitions (e.g. the four-sided triangle) and then immediately went on to posit your god as the solution to all of this stuff above in a way that makes it clear that your definition of your god is impossible as well. I appreciate your post in that it has a clear line of reasoning, but nonetheless, it is merely an expansion on the same fallacious argument. The explanations not withstanding, the problem is still that you are failing to see other options and that what you suggest as a solution makes no more logical sense than what you're trying to solve. Square circles are impossible regardless of what you want to attribute them too. Indeed, a being that "can do the impossible" is itself a logical contradiction. If it is impossible, it cannot be done. If you're concerning yourself with logic, then you must be consistent about it. There is no such thing as an inconsistent logical argument -- only inconsistent illogical arguments.

To address your last point, you need to understand that what you're proposing as "outside the universe" and "outside time" is in essence, "outside reality". And of course, things that are outside reality is not real. If you'd like to retort to that and suggest that is merely outside "our reality", go right a head, but we can immediately posit the possibility of a natural, non-god-related forces that would accomplish the creation of the universe just the same. Your god solution remains unnecessary.

To address your first point, you're cherry picking scientific lore. That same set of thermodynamic laws suggests that matter and energy cannot be created or destroyed, only converted from one form to the other. Heat death, therefore, is not a loss of energy. If it were, thermodynamic laws would be contradictory. Further, you're line of argument suggests that you have a rather primitive and naive understanding of Big Bang theory, which is understandable since that's the way it is always explained. All that theory does, however, is describe the observations. It in no way suggests that what we see is the entire universe. While you're certainly in good company, taking it any further than that is speculation only.

In a similar maneuver, you're taking currently understood physical laws and principles, declaring them all that must exist and can be understood, and drawing conclusions from them. This is too hasty. As everyone else here has been telling you, all that can honestly be said is that we don't know. While suggesting that our observable universe might be only one of an infinite number of universes, or that we're a pimple on the "real" universe's face isn't any better than suggesting positing a god to explain an apparent finite status something like thermodynamics suggests, without more knowledge of how things work, it's difficult profess anything conclusively. For instance, I don't recall the second law having much to say about gravity, or repulsive "dark energy", or the nature of the "fabric of the universe". Mental masturbation exercises like M theory and brane theory aren't much yet more falsifiable than your god solution, but at least they acknowledge what isn't understood.
 
For such gigantic fluctuation to occur spontaneously is almost impossible.


Assuming that such fluctuations can occur, then given infinite opportunities for such fluctuations to occur, then it is almost certain that eventually such a gigantic fluctuation will occur.
 
But both thought and actions are processes that require time, so your first cause must necessarily be incapable of thought or action,

Nice post Brian. This is a really interesting perspective that I hadn't considered.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom