Ear Candle Worked?

You know what worked? You laid on your side for about an hour in a position that allowed the eustatian (sp?) tubes in your head to naturally drain.

Next time you have an ear blockage like this, lay down on the couch with the offending ear canal facing dead straight upwards and stay there for an hour or so. Betcha it goes away.
 
I'd be interested in seeing the results between a hot,wet q-tip and ear candles

I dont doubt that ear candling is hot enough to make earwax run, I've witnessed the horror myself among audiophiles enough times, but they keep on doing it.

I would think that in a severely plugged ear, a warm, wet q-tip would work well, be safe-ish and the added benefit that you could tile your head towards the ground as you did it
 
First off, I'd like to say I'm thoroughly a skeptic when it comes to those products that claim to remove "toxins" or pretend to cure all. That being said, I had a clogged ear to the point where I could barely hear from it. I did not want to go through my sister's very unpleasant and painful experience of having her ear cleaned by her GP that caused several days of soreness.

That's odd, because I've had my ear canals cleaned by a gp and a technician, once with water and once with vacuum, and I didn't experience any discomfort whatsoever. I must have ears of steel!
 
Last edited:
2) aunty, how do you know it REALLY worked ? I have on regular basis wax obstruction , well guess what, sometimes those have a temporary remission on their own for a few hours, and then gradually close again. Sometimes it is enough for me to lay on the side of the head to get an effect (as opposed to stay standing).
You're right, I can't be. That's why I was doing some research and asking questions. I find it highly unlikely though that my ear purely randomly cleared up and stayed clear at the exact moment I removed the candle.

nvidiot suggested it was the fact that I was laying on my side, but that's how I sleep and I had the problem for several days.
 
I'd be interested in seeing the results between a hot,wet q-tip and ear candles

I dont doubt that ear candling is hot enough to make earwax run, I've witnessed the horror myself among audiophiles enough times, but they keep on doing it.

I would think that in a severely plugged ear, a warm, wet q-tip would work well, be safe-ish and the added benefit that you could tile your head towards the ground as you did it
Mineral oil works better than water.

My GP recommended mineral oil rinses for impacted wax, and it worked wonders for my ex. *shrug*
 
That's odd, because I've had my ear canals cleaned by a gp and a technician, once with water and once with vacuum, and I didn't experience any discomfort whatsoever. I must have ears of steel!
Or my sister has ears of tissue paper... or my gp is a sadist.
 
I read the link Bozman (actually yesterday when I was researching ear candles) and if you bothered to read anything I wrote, you'd see I never claimed it sucked the ear wax out! Nor did I say it had any effect on anything other than the ear wax clogging my ear. I did propose that heat and smoke could dry ear wax out having an effect on the blockage. I'm curious to know if that is at all possible. I don't need you to quote me a bunch of other stuff that I've repeatedly said I'm not contesting.

You're claiming that your candle effectively cleared wax from your ears. You can dance around with your explanations of what you didn't say all you want, the fact is that you're saying it was effective in clearing earwax. I'll give you the benefit of the doubt here assume that you probably had an experience that lead you to believe that the candle cleared wax from your ears. I'm not going to accuse you of lying or anything; these kinds of products manage to take people in all the time.

So let's look at this. First, was your ear actually impacted with wax to begin with? Do you have a history impacted ears? Was this actually confirmed at some point by a medical professional? It's very common for quack new age "healers" to convince people that they have all sorts of bogus medical problems. They typically tell people that they have conditions like "Toxin buildups" and that the problem has to be treated via whatever new age bogus remedy they happen to be selling. Ear "candlers" do it all the time too. They convince people to treat bogus ear impactions with candles that appear to draw wax from the ears, when in reality the ear "wax" comes from the burning of the candles themselves. So that's the first problem with an anecdotal claim like this. We don't even know what your ear condition actually was prior to using the candle. And, when you used it, what were the circumstances? Who administered it?

Again, the facts here are that this has been repeatedly shown to be an impossibility. Ear candles are nothing more than a New Age "holistic" BS gimmick. They're just like homeopathy, oxygen therapy, or whatever brand of snake oil happens to be popular at any given time: they're a way for scheisters to profit from people who are uninformed.
 
Last edited:
No one even commented on the actual question I asked and seemed to ignore everything I said.


Since your anecdote doesn't actually establish that the candling caused the relief, your question is kind of moot.

How hot did your ear get during the candling, by the way?
 
You're claiming that your candle effectively cleared wax from your ears. You can dance around with your explanations of what you didn't say all you want, the fact is that you're saying it was effective in clearing earwax. I'll give you the benefit of the doubt here assume that you probably had an experience that lead you to believe that the candle cleared wax from your ears. I'm not going to accuse you of lying or anything; these kinds of products manage to take people in all the time.

So let's look at this. First, was your ear actually impacted with wax to begin with? Do you have a history impacted ears? Was this actually confirmed at some point by a medical professional? It's very common for quack new age "healers" to convince people that they have all sorts of bogus medical problems. They typically tell people that they have conditions like "Toxin buildups" and that the problem has to be treated via whatever new age bogus remedy they happen to be selling. Ear "candlers" do it all the time too. They convince people to treat bogus ear impactions with candles that appear to draw wax from the ears, when in reality the ear "wax" comes from the burning of the candles themselves. So that's the first problem with an anecdotal claim like this. We don't even know what your ear condition actually was prior to using the candle. And, when you used it, what were the circumstances? Who administered it?

Again, the facts here are that this has been repeatedly shown to be an impossibility. Ear candles are nothing more than a New Age "holistic" BS gimmick. They're just like homeopathy, oxygen therapy, or whatever brand of snake oil happens to be popular at any given time: they're a way for scheisters to profit from people who are uninformed.

Never said it removed the wax, just that it cleared my ear, so I could hear again. Two different things. My assumption was that it shifted or broke up the wax, much in the same way laying on your side would.

No official diagnosis of wax, but I have had the sensation several times before and was able to successfully clear it with Q Tips. I have NEVER and would NEVER go to a new age "healer." I bought the candles and administered it myself using a mirror to make sure I wasn't setting fire to anything.

I never saw anything that tested what I proposed, if fact, the strait dope article noticed an indentation in the ear wax, which they assumed was from the candle pushing in, but the candle barely actually enters your ear at all. I doubt it could get down far enough to make a dent, unless the guy had really big ear holes.

I do agree with all the points you made about charlatans just being after your money, which is why I'm so perplexed that my experience with this product solved my problem.
 
Since your anecdote doesn't actually establish that the candling caused the relief, your question is kind of moot.

How hot did your ear get during the candling, by the way?

Please help me out here if I'm wrong, but I think she's trying to say that exposing the impacted wax in her ears to candle heat and smoke somehow caused it loosen and exit from the ear canal. I've read a bunch of sources on this though, and the technique always involves having the person lay their head down with one ear to the ground. The snake oil peddler then places a lit candle on top of the other ear in vertical position, with the bottom resting on something like a plate that also rests over the ear. The typical claim that the heat from the top of the candle causes a "reverse pressure" that sucks out the wax (which blatantly violates the laws of physics, but whatever).

Auntysocial on the other hand is saying that the smoke and heat caused the clearing. What I don't understand is how the actual smoke from the flame traveled downward from the top of the candle and entered her ear canal. Here's a picture to demonstrate.

Ear_Candling.jpg


I'm going to put aside the fact that a typical candle flame doesn't produce enough smoke at any given time to somehow cause earwax to melt or evaporate (not without enough exposure that would also cause burns anyway) for a second so I can just understand how you got the smoke into your ear.

Jesus, this is getting ridiculous.
 
Last edited:
Since your anecdote doesn't actually establish that the candling caused the relief, your question is kind of moot.

How hot did your ear get during the candling, by the way?
I couldn't provide unquestionable evidence over the internet anyway. Even if I had a doctor diagnose me, take a hearing test before and after and check that the wax was altered, it would still all be just an anecdote and you wouldn't believe me. The truth is: ear blocked for days, tried Q Tip and laying on side tried multiple times, no improvement, used ear candle, had slight improvement, used second ear candle, slight more improvement, used third ear candle, I could hear (might have only been 2). Don't believe me if you don't want to, but I thought it would be interesting to see if there was anyone who knew why it had that effect. I wasn't trying to prove anything, it was a curiosity. I suppose it could just be absolutely dumb luck that that was the exact moment my ear decided to clear itself, but that seems harder or at least just as hard to believe as the idea that pumping smoke into my ear had some effect on the position of the wax.

It didn't get hot at all, just a little warm.
 
You're right, I can't be. That's why I was doing some research and asking questions. I find it highly unlikely though that my ear purely randomly cleared up and stayed clear at the exact moment I removed the candle.

nvidiot suggested it was the fact that I was laying on my side, but that's how I sleep and I had the problem for several days.

In other word , while you have no basis and could not check what action might have cleared your ear, you chose to believe it was the candling action, as opposed to the other possible explanation, despite being told above that ear candling doesn't do anything, you still seem to assign a higher probability to have done an effect.

Think about this : you did not check what the state of the ear canal was before and after. So you have NO BASIS to say what and why you got to ear better before and after.
 
I couldn't provide unquestionable evidence over the internet anyway. Even if I had a doctor diagnose me, take a hearing test before and after and check that the wax was altered, it would still all be just an anecdote and you wouldn't believe me. The truth is: ear blocked for days, tried Q Tip and laying on side tried multiple times, no improvement, used ear candle, had slight improvement, used second ear candle, slight more improvement, used third ear candle, I could hear (might have only been 2). Don't believe me if you don't want to, but I thought it would be interesting to see if there was anyone who knew why it had that effect. I wasn't trying to prove anything, it was a curiosity. I suppose it could just be absolutely dumb luck that that was the exact moment my ear decided to clear itself, but that seems harder or at least just as hard to believe as the idea that pumping smoke into my ear had some effect on the position of the wax.

It didn't get hot at all, just a little warm.

You were already told the most probable explanation : the tip of the ear candle and the physical work of inserting and removing it broke the wax. I am not sure why you simply did not answer to that post "you are right, and I read your link ear candling is ********".
 
Think about this : you did not check what the state of the ear canal was before and after. So you have NO BASIS to say what and why you got to ear better before and after.

Lets throw in the fact that these candles are designed in such a way to leave a residue specifically designed to look like wax from your ears and you've got a classic, albeit silly, hoax.

This whole thing seems pretty ridiculous, especially when you could just go to the doctor and have him clean out your ears. I'm not sure why anyone would prefer to have someone do a whole thing with a lit candle, especially when you don't even know how it really works. And the person administering this "treatment" obviously has no medical training whatsoever. "Candlers" lack any kind of legitimate medical qualification and cannot legally diagnose or treat any type of disease. And you think seeing him for a problem like this is a good idea?
 
Last edited:
Please help me out here if I'm wrong, but I think she's trying to say that exposing the impacted wax in her ears to candle heat and smoke somehow caused it loosen and exit from the ear canal. I've read a bunch of sources on this though, and the technique always involves having the person lay their head down with one ear to the ground. The snake oil peddler then places a lit candle on top of the other ear in vertical position, with the bottom resting on something like a plate that also rests over the ear. The typical claim that the heat from the top of the candle causes a "reverse pressure" that sucks out the wax (which blatantly violates the laws of physics, but whatever).

Auntysocial on the other hand is saying that the smoke and heat caused the clearing. What I don't understand is how the actual smoke from the flame traveled downward from the top of the candle and entered her ear canal. Here's a picture to demonstrate.

I'm going to put aside the fact that a typical candle flame doesn't produce enough smoke at any given time to somehow heat up earwax for a second so I can just understand how you got the smoke into your ear. Jesus, this is getting ridiculous.
The smoke does come out of the bottom (and leaves a nasty residue, I can see why so many people have had problems), but you don't have to take my word for it. I'm new here so I can't post links, but if you go to YouTube and look up the video "Testing Ear Candles Hoax or Reality" you'll see a guy burning one and the smoke comes out of the bottom.
 
auntysocial, please describe the exact procedure used. Were you prone or upright? Where was the candle? Which end was where? How long did the treatment last? Was it self-administered or did someone help you?

Please provide as much detail as possible.
 
The smoke does come out of the bottom (and leaves a nasty residue, I can see why so many people have had problems), but you don't have to take my word for it. I'm new here so I can't post links, but if you go to YouTube and look up the video "Testing Ear Candles Hoax or Reality" you'll see a guy burning one and the smoke comes out of the bottom.

How does that work? Smoke from the flame of a candle is only going to travel downward if an opposing force, like wind, pushes or pulls it. This fact doesn't change regardless of whether it's from a candle that's sitting on your ear or from a fire that's burning down your house. Unless a small fan is also running under the candle and sucking the smoke downward (again this is ridiculous), I'm going to go out on a limb and say that what's really happening is that residue from the candle slides downward as the candle burns and that you probably felt its heat as it touched your skin (or whatever was between the candle and your skin). Since you're laying sideways and can't actually see it the candle anyway, you probably believe the smoke was there because the fake healer told you it was. His suggestion combined with said candle residue convinced you that smoke was really entering your ear. After all this whole bogus treatment rests on the fake notion that a reverse vacuum is created.

In real life, magical vacuums don't appear when you light a fire over your ear. Try it if you don't believe me. Since there's no actual vacuum, there's no actual smoke going into your ear. And even if these candles were magic candles or something and could cause smoke to somehow get into your ear canal, what would that do exactly? You put smoke in your ear and suddenly everything is all better. What kind of magic smoke is that?
 
Last edited:
I'm honestly really sad by all of your responses. No one even commented on the actual question I asked and seemed to ignore everything I said. Instead you just accuse me of lying, which I'm not. I DON'T believe the claims the ear candle people make, which I very clearly stated, and yet it worked. I'll also add, I was unaware of the dangers when I did try it since, as I said, I knew people who had used them without issue. I was truely interested to know if anyone had any idea why it did work from a purely non-woo scientific standpoint, but it looks like all you folks are interested in is ridicule.
Yes, I understand how you feel. However, you did, probably accidentially follow a pattern we have come to recognize all too well:

1) I'm really skeptical of [insert particular mode of woo].

2) However, I/my friend/my aunt/other person tried the following [insert anecdote of woo], and it worked!

3) What do you people think happened?

This may surprise you, but nine out of ten (at least) the person posting like this is far from a skeptic. Instead she/he is a hardcore woo who just thinks this is a clever trick to win proselytes, or at least shake skeptics a bit.

One further sign that you may belong to this chategory is the fact that you report using several candles. Now a real skeptic might try such a thing (pressure form others, curiosity, etc.), but having no effect after one try, the typical skeptic would have their skepticism confirmed and left it at that. ... But to keep trying.... :dio:

Of course you are entitled to the benefit of doubt, so here is my reply to your question:

1) You problem may have vanished independently of your candling.

2) Your problem may have vanished due to you spending what? Some ten minutes in an awkward position with something in your ear. Some wax problems and many pressure problems might be affected by this.

Now comes the acid test: You now have received mine and a couple of other's rational explanation (admittedly among some flak, but so is life). Your reaction to this will tell us whether you are really skeptical or not. :cool:

Hans
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom