Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Twisting words has become something of a pasttime in this thread. I think from the moment the AA opponents made the "suggested" steps, a "compulsory" requirement, and then a "power greater than ourselves" a conformist deity. :rolleyes:

That's alright, though. AA proponents twist "higher" and "power" as well. So it's all good.
 
What is the actual purpose and intent behind step 3?
What is achieved psychologically, morally or lifestyle with step 3? How is a lifestyle positively changed by 'turning over' ones will to a god of our understanding? By what mechanism is our 'will' being guided?
If you are admit you are 'powerless,' what is being 'turned over' in step 3?

In short terms:
Alcholics have been running on self will their whole lives. They have been trying to manage everyone and everything.
Handing our will over removes a lot of expectation - for me it is a kind of hope for the best, plan for the worst type scenario. We need to mind our own business.
This does not mean we do not plan, have aspirations or hope; but we take a 'whatever will be will be' attitude.
 
In short terms:
Alcholics have been running on self will their whole lives. They have been trying to manage everyone and everything.
Handing our will over removes a lot of expectation - for me it is a kind of hope for the best, plan for the worst type scenario. We need to mind our own business.
This does not mean we do not plan, have aspirations or hope; but we take a 'whatever will be will be' attitude.

Originally Posted by A.A.Alfie
Twisting words has become something of a pasttime in this thread.

:dl:


Truer words were never spoken, or so aptly demonstrated.
 
Twisting words has become something of a pasttime in this thread. I think from the moment the AA opponents made the "suggested" steps, a "compulsory" requirement, and then a "power greater than ourselves" a conformist deity. :rolleyes:

The very disingenuous claim that the Steps are "suggested" is a Twisting of Words given that it is claimed that if you don't follow the Steps you won't receive the benefits of Recovery.

"A Power Greater than ourselves" is a Twisting of Words given that the Steps and The Big Book boldly state that this Power is God, to whom one Conforms one's will to.

GB
 
Last edited:
The very disingenuous claim that the Steps are "suggested" is a Twisting of Words given that it is claimed that if you don't follow the Steps you won't receive the benefits of Recovery.

"A Power Greater than ourselves" is a Twisting of Words given that the Steps and The Big Book boldly state that this Power is God, to whom one Conforms one's will to.

GB

That one's gone over Alfie's head since the beginning of the thread. I wonder if he'll get it this time?
 
Actually in step two it says "a power greater than ourselves". :)

Just how will you go about proving that there is such a "thing" as "a power greater then ourselves"????....

I mean other than pulling the "explanation" out of your a*s*s??

Edited by Locknar: 
Content removed, breach of Rule 12. Remember, it is address the argument not attack the arguer.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
So there is no-one or nothing stronger, smarter or with greater skills than you. Got it. ;)

Content removed, breach of Rule 12.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Locknar


Can you now show me where I said "there is a god" or where "there isn't a god"? Otherwise you are lying - again.

So now you deny your god...or are you just playing "semantic word" games??
 
Last edited by a moderator:
You're moving the goalposts. Your claim was that immersion was belief, not emotional response.
My previous posts make it abundantly clear that I'm arguing that emotional response IS "belief", on some level. I suspect that you realize this perfectly well, and are being deliberately obtuse.

Then I'd ask you for your definition of an addiction/obsession.
I've also made it abundantly clear that I do not intend to engage in that off-topic discussion. I will stick to my opinion that whatever it is, it arises out of (or is at least characterized by) irrational thinking/feeling.

Dealing with it certainly is.
Not what I asked.

It's in the twelve steps, Dymanic. How can you say it doesn't teach that ?
Kindly point out where in the twelve steps it is taught that the alcoholic:
...cannot_ quit without some higher power
 
Kindly point out where in the twelve steps it is taught that the alcoholic:

...cannot_ quit without some higher power

Service Material from the General Service Office
THE TWELVE STEPS OF ALCOHOLICS ANONYMOUS

1. We admitted we were powerless over alcohol—that our lives had become
unmanageable.
2. Came to believe that a Power greater than ourselves could restore us to
sanity.
3. Made a decision to turn our will and our lives over to the care of God as we
understood Him.
4. Made a searching and fearless moral inventory of ourselves.
5. Admitted to God, to ourselves, and to another human being the exact nature of our wrongs.
6. Were entirely ready to have God remove all these defects of character.
7. Humbly asked Him to remove our shortcomings.
8. Made a list of all persons we had harmed, and became willing to make
amends to them all.
9. Made direct amends to such people wherever possible, except when to do
so would injure them or others.
10. Continued to take personal inventory and when we were wrong promptly
admitted it.
11. Sought through prayer and meditation to improve our conscious contact with God, as we understood Him, praying only for knowledge of His will for us
and the power to carry that out.
12. Having had a spiritual awakening as the result of these Steps, we tried to
carry this message to alcoholics, and to practice these principles in all our
affairs.

Copyright  A.A. World Services, Inc.
Rev.5/9/02

Kindly point out where it doesn't. :p

GB
 
Just how will you go about proving that there is such a "thing" as "a power greater then ourselves"????....
I think a necessary prerequisite to that would be proving that there is such a thing as a "self".

How far down the Rabbit Hole (and off-topic) do you intend to go with your Sophistry and Red Herrings? It is not necessary to prove that a Self or a Deity does or does not exist to prove that AA is Religious.

GB
 
Kindly point out where it doesn't.
The preface: "Here are the steps we took which are suggested as a program of recovery" and all of the phraseology which follows. In other words, all of it.

It is not necessary to prove that a Self or a Deity does or does not exist to prove that AA is Religious.
I think it is necessary to proving the implied assertion above that nothing could be a power greater than a self. Not like I haven't asked before. Just what is a "self", and how big is it?
 
The preface: "Here are the steps we took which are suggested as a program of recovery" and all of the phraseology which follows. In other words, all of it.

Really???:jaw-dropp You really do live in a Bizarro World Bubble of Inanity and Sophistry don't you! In fact ALL OF IT proves precisely the opposite, including the notion that the Steps are "suggested."

Or perhaps you'd like to rephrase your question "Where in the Twelve Steps...", which in themselves demonstrate conclusively that "suggested" is nothing but a lie. READ THEM. I posted them just above.

Show me where in the 12 Steps that it says you can quit without the aid of a "Power greater than ourselves" (which the Steps define clearly as God). You can't do it, can you. Because that would be a flagrant lie.

Seriously, you've dug an intellectual hole so deep for yourself, that no-one with any intellectual honesty can reach down to pull you out.

I think it is necessary to proving the implied assertion above that nothing could be a power greater than a self. Not like I haven't asked before. Just what is a "self", and how big is it?

Which has nothing to do with the Religiosity of AA. Hence it's a Red Herring.

GB
 
In short terms:
Alcholics have been running on self will their whole lives. They have been trying to manage everyone and everything.
Handing our will over removes a lot of expectation - for me it is a kind of hope for the best, plan for the worst type scenario. We need to mind our own business.
This does not mean we do not plan, have aspirations or hope; but we take a 'whatever will be will be' attitude.
I disagree. I think that those who abuse alcohol don't have ENOUGH self will. They have been medicating themselves in order to "fake it to make it" through life. This is like dumpster-diving in the dark, where it's impossible to make good choices.
I think it would be better to use science than pie-in-the-sky philosophies. Brain scans to discover which areas of the brain are misfiring. Proper diagnosis of mood disorders, and medication if needed. Nutrition to add strength and remove discomfort. Rational-Emotive Therapy to apply practical tools to deal with issues. And the removal of the phrase, "I am an alcoholic," which constantly defines the person as an state of illness, and I believe keeps a person from moving foward, and keeps dragging them down with a shameful title.
 
Kindly point out where in the twelve steps it is taught that the alcoholic:

Originally Posted by Belz... View Post
...cannot_ quit without some higher power

I have, multiple times in this thread, through the literature and my own personal experience. I'll do it again just for laughs. You are being intellectually dishonest, and it's plain to anyone who has spent time in the program, like myself. "Working the program" is a mantra, those that fail are dishonest people. When the steps are read in meetings, the preface is read as well--and is a belief firmly held by AA members (for the third time):

Rarely have we seen a person fail who has thoroughly followed our path. Those who do not recover are people who cannot or will not completely give themselves to this simple program, usually men and women who are constitutionally incapable of being honest with themselves. There are such unfortunates. They are not at fault; they seem to have been born that way. They are naturally incapable of grasping and developing a manner of living which demands rigorous honesty. Their chances are less than average. There are those, too, who suffer from grave emotional and mental disorders, but many of them do recover if they have the capacity to be honest.

Our stories disclose in a general way what we used to be like, what happened, and what we are like now. If you have decided you want what we have and are willing to go to any length to get it - then you are ready to take certain steps.

At some of these we balked. We thought we could find an easier, softer way. But we could not. With all the earnestness at our command, we beg of you to be fearless and thorough from the very start. Some of us have tried to hold on to our old ideas and the result was nil until we let go absolutely.

Remember that we deal with alcohol - cunning, baffling, powerful! Without help it is too much for us. But there is One who has all power- that One is God. May you find Him now!

Half measures availed us nothing. We stood at the turning point. We asked His protection and care with complete abandon.

Big Book
, http://www.aa.org/bigbookonline/en_bigbook_chapt5.pdf

Furthermore, the The Twelve Steps and Twelve Traditions book expands on the God thoughts:

When we encountered A.A,, the fallacy of our defiance was revealed. At no time had we asked what God's will was for us; instead we had been telling Him what it
ought to be. No man, we saw, could believe in God and defy Him, too. Belief meant reliance, not; defiance. In A.A, we saw the fruits of this belief: men and women spared
from alcohol's final catastrophe. We saw them meet and transcend their other pains and trials. We saw them calmly accept impossible situations, seeking neither to run nor to
recriminate. This was not only faith; it was faith that worked under all conditions. We soon concluded that whatever price in humility we must pay, we would pay."

Twelve Steps and Twelve Traditions, p31 http://www.guardureyes.com/GUE/PDFs/The 12-Steps and 12 traditions.pdf
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom