What the Palestinians Really Want

I trust MEMRI as much as you trust the UN.
I'm pretty sure the UN translates correctly. As does MEMRI.

You have yet to show a single case of MEMRI making a material mistranslation ever. Will you be doing so?

And thanks for making my prediction come true! Apparently Thunder's excuse for Al-Zahhar is to claim he was mistranslated. Never mind that Thunder hasn't bothered to offer up a "correct" translation, he'll just continue to claim that whenever a Hamas honcho talks about expelling all Jews from Palestine it's because of a mistranslation.

lolol
 
you said you don't trust a single thing the UN says about Hezbollah.
It's well documented that Hizbullah has infiltrated the UN and the press in Lebanon.

I, don't trust a single thing MEMRI says about Muslims.

:)

deal with it.
You haven't shown any reason to believe that MEMRI has mistranslated anything. You reject MEMRI not because of any mistranslations (indeed, you haven't been able to show a single one), but because it conflicts with your dogmatic beliefs.

Much like truthers reject everything by NIST because it's funded by the government, not because they have shown NIST to be wrong about anything.
 
It's well documented that Hizbullah has infiltrated the UN and the press in Lebanon.

well then, you've given yourself an excuse to hand-wave away ANYTHING the UN says about Hezbollah, ever.

congrats. :D

oh...and the Lebanese press as well. wow, you're on a roll there.
 
well then, you've given yourself an excuse to hand-wave away ANYTHING the UN says about Hezbollah, ever.

congrats. :D
Not at all, I judge each case on its merits. UN observers were able to offer some impartial eyewitness testimnony to what happened when the Lebanese army sniper killed an Israeli office last year, for example.

You reject MEMRI solely because they don't say what you want to hear, not because of any history of mistranslation. You can't even come up with a reason you feel they mistranslate anything. Certainly, you haven't offered any alternative translations.
 
oh...and the Lebanese press as well. wow, you're on a roll there.
Because I can document the press in Lebanon engaged in such malfeasance, for example photoshopping pics to make Israeli bombing look more extensive than it was.

Got any examples of MEMRI making a material mistranslation Thunder?
 
You reject MEMRI solely because they don't say what you want to hear,

wrong.

fail.

incorrect......as always.


I reject MEMRI because of their ties to the Mossad. I think its a decent reason.

If there was an American organizations translating Arabic videos and audio, and it turned out they had connections to the CIA even though they claimed to be independent, I'd tell them go to scratch, too.
 
wrong.

fail.

incorrect......as always.


I reject MEMRI because of their ties to the Mossad. I think its a decent reason.

If there was an American organizations translating Arabic videos and audio, and it turned out they had connections to the CIA even though they claimed to be independent, I'd tell them go to scratch, too.
Exactly what I said. You can't actually document that any of the translations are wrong, so you seek to dismiss it instead by engaging in a poisoning-the-well logical fallacy.

Just like truthers do with NIST!

Just like the NIST investigation, MEMRI's translations stand or fall on their own merits, and nothing else.
 
Last edited:
Just like truthers do with NIST!

Just like the NIST investigation,

:p:p:p:p back to this old and tired game. comparing those who DARE to disagree with you, to 9-11 Truthers.

good one, Wildcat. what's next, comparing folks who believe in the two-state solution, to Bigfoot believers?

:p:p:p:p


....oh, you kill me.
 
:p:p:p:p back to this old and tired game. comparing those who DARE to disagree with you, to 9-11 Truthers.

good one, Wildcat. what's next, comparing folks who believe in the two-state solution, to Bigfoot believers?

:p:p:p:p


....oh, you kill me.
You're engaging in the exact same tactic, as I've already shown.

Have you found a single MEMRI mistranslation yet Thunder? I'm positive you were desperately googling away in an attempt to find one...

eta: 8 smilies! A sure sign that you know you're losing badly.
 
You're engaging in the exact same tactic, as I've already shown.

Have you found a single MEMRI mistranslation yet Thunder? I'm positive you were desperately googling away in an attempt to find one...

no, I was watching "The Untouchables". Unlike some other folks, I don't live for these discussions.

does disregarding ANYTHING and EVERYTHING the UN says about Lebanon and Hezbollah, make you like a 9-11 truther?

hmmmm..... ;)
 
I can't find anything that says MEMRI's translations are inaccurate. I was looking for something like MEMRIwatch, you know a site that offers up the "real" translations.

All I can find is the usual whining about MEMRI being pro-Zionist propaganda run by ex members of...yada yada.

Well, Duh. When I go to a pro Zionist site, I expect pro Zionist material. If somebody wants to make a case that the speakers in the videos are not saying what MEMRI is saying, then I'm all ears.

What about those IHH dudes, the ones on the Mavi Marmara, the ones who brought knives to a gunfight, what are they up to nowadays ? Still on the lecture circuit perhaps.
 
does disregarding ANYTHING and EVERYTHING the UN says about Lebanon and Hezbollah, make you like a 9-11 truther?

hmmmm..... ;)
No, claiming the translations are wrong without offering an alternative translation makes you like a 9/11 truther.

The videos are there, feel free to get a different translation Thunder. But the MEMRI translation stands until proven wrong.

Got an alternative translation Thunder? If not, maybe posting a bunch of smilies will convince a board of skeptics!
 
No, claiming the translations are wrong without offering an alternative translation makes you like a 9/11 truther.

:p:p:p you really are unable to get your mind out of that world huh?

you poor thing.

Got an alternative translation Thunder? If not, maybe posting a bunch of smilies will convince a board of skeptics!

TRUE skeptics don't accuse Hamas and Islamic Jihad of wanting to kill, convert, or exile all non-Muslims, and provide ZERO evidence for it. Even your right-wing buddies admit that its untrue.

...yeah, I know. stings like a wasp. ;)
 
Last edited:
All I can find is the usual whining about MEMRI being pro-Zionist propaganda run by ex members of the Israeli intelligence service, aka Mossad.

fixed that for clarity. "yada yada yada" just don't cut it.
 
TRUE skeptics don't accuse Hamas and Islamic Jihad of wanting to kill, convert, or exile all non-Muslims, and provide ZERO evidence for it. Even your right-wing buddies admit that its untrue.

...yeah, I know. stings like a wasp. ;)
This wasp is too pathetic to sting.

To recap:

Thunder: Show me the evidence that Hamas wants to evict non-Muslims from Palestine!

Me: Posts clip of Hamas official saying they will expel at least the Jews from Palestine.

Thunder: It's all faked!

Me: :hb:

Thunder: Show me evidence!

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

As I said somewhere else, maybe even this thread, Thunder wouldn't be convinced if Meshaal himself told him this personally.
 
This wasp is too pathetic to sting.

To recap:

Thunder: Show me the evidence that Hamas wants to evict non-Muslims from Palestine!

Originally Posted by WildCat
A battle against Jews, not just "zionists". The Covenant also proclaims that Palestine is exclusively for Muslims, others will have to live elsewhere if they want to live.


No, Wildcat. No. You can't rewrite your own claims, a day later.

YOU claimed that Hamas wants to KILL, exile, or convert any non-Muslims who remain in Palestine after they take over.

It may work in the Loose Change or Pilots for 9-11 Truth forums, to move the goal posts and have no one notice, but not here at JREF.

Here, we hold each one of us responsible for their claims. Their WHOLE claims.

So, Wildcat, what evidence do you have that Hamas wants to kill, exile, and convert all non-Muslims in Palestine?

:rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
No, Wildcat. No. You can't rewrite your own claims, a day later.

YOU claimed that Hamas wants to KILL, exile, or convert any non-Muslims who remain in Palestine after they take over.
One thing at a time sweetheart!

I proved that Hamas wants to, at the very least, expel Jews from Palestine, yes? Do you now accept the video I linked to, and the translation, or are you still going with claiming it's faked?
 
fixed that for clarity. "yada yada yada" just don't cut it.

Excellent, thank you. :)

In other words you don't find fault with MEMRI's translations but mistrust them because of....what exactly ?

Is this factually wrong ?

MEMRI Transcript said:
The series of expulsions continues to this day. Blood continues to be shed, martyrs continue to fall, our sons continue to hoist the banner high, and Allah willing, their expulsion from Palestine in its entirety is certain to come. We are no weaker or less honorable than the peoples that expelled and annihilated the Jews. The day we expel them is drawing near.



[...]



The nation that opens up its doors, its hearts, and its homes to the [Jews] who were expelled from all corners of the earth was the Islamic nation.



[...]



We extended our hands to feed these hungry dogs and wild beasts, and they devoured our fingers. We have learned the lesson – there is no place for you among us, and you have no future among the nations of the world. You are headed to annihilation.



[...]

Can you make some sort of case where this video was edited and the part where he says "we didn't really mean it" was left out ? If so then have at 'er.

Source
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom