Ed Why [you] Should Take Jared Loughner's Politics Seriously

I am 100% uninterested in his politics. All I am interested in, is what he wants for his last meal before he fries.

Excuse me?

Ever do volunteer work with the mentally ill, Parky? have any relatives with schizophrenia?

I do. I recognized the classic "word salad" symptoms when I read Loughners youtube rants. I'm as skeptical as the next guy when a garden variety miscreant tries to hide behind an insanity plea. But with Loughner, I am convinced based on what I've seen so far that he is legitimately mentally ill and is not guilty by reason of mental disease or defect.

Loughner should be placed under a state of permanent psychiatric observation, but he does not deserve the death penalty.
 
I spent 5 summer working at summer camps that had many severally mentally ill folks, including kids who were schizophrenic, autistic, psychotic, Down Syndrome, etc etc.

And you can't tell that this guy is legally not culpable for his actions?
 
And you can't tell that this guy is legally not culpable for his actions?

are you a judge? are you a psychoanalyst?

legally....this guy is charged with attempted assassination and murder.

that's all the law has to say at this moment.
 
He might be crazy but I couldn't care less if the US Government or the State of Arizona sticks a needle into his arm.
 
Thunder you'd be better off withdrawing the "let's just execute him, insane or not" comments and get back on topic.
 
Thunder you'd be better off withdrawing the "let's just execute him, insane or not" comments and get back on topic.

If a judge decides that he is indeed mentally unfit to stand trial and should instead be sent to a mental institution, I shall accept that judgement.
 
are you a judge? are you a psychoanalyst?

legally....this guy is charged with attempted assassination and murder.

that's all the law has to say at this moment.

Yeah, but it hasn't stopped you passing judgement and sentencing him though.

What hypocrisy.
 
He might be crazy but I couldn't care less if the US Government or the State of Arizona sticks a needle into his arm.

I think I agree with you, mostly because he killed a child.

I'm sorry guys, but when you gun down a child, my sympathy goes out the window.

:(
 
Yeah, but it hasn't stopped you passing judgement and sentencing him though.

What hypocrisy.

Sorry, but I have no sympathy for child-killers.

If you want to defend a child-killer, be my guest.
 
Last edited:
Loughner did't kill anyone by accident.

what a strange analogy.

Twenty years ago, a million of Mr Loughners sperm cells swam up Mrs Loughners fallopian tubes. And one carrying a bad gene got through.

That's what you want to kill him for.
 
Twenty years ago, a million of Mr Loughners sperm cells swam up Mrs Loughners fallopian tubes. And one carrying a bad gene got through.

That's what you want to kill him for.

No.

On the contrary, I want him executed for murdering a child.

Sorry..if that bugs ya.
 
Sorry, but I have no sympathy for child-killers.

If you want to defend child-killers, be my guest.

That is a grotesque misrepresentation of what I said. An honest person would withdraw a slur like this. Being so uncivil when just back from suspension is not really a good idea.
 
There a lots of people with serious mental illnesses. Somehow, the vast majority manage not to go on shooting sprees.
 
That is a grotesque misrepresentation of what I said. An honest person would withdraw a slur like this. Being so uncivil when just back from suspension is not really a good idea.

ok, post edited.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom