The world according to Samuel Huntington

The very pro-American Der Spiegel comes today with a very alarming article about the state of American finances...

http://www.spiegel.de/wirtschaft/soziales/0,1518,742473,00.html

... and lists a number of US states that are facing immediate bankruptcy.

These developments will be studied with great interest in Beijing, who no doubt will be contemplating to go after Taiwan at the first opportunity. That moment could come quickly and will be accompanied by massive dumping of these 3 trillion dollars that China holds and in it's wake a few trillion Japanese dollars as well. At that moment the dollar will crash and the US will be unable to pay for any import whatsoever. At that moment Europe and Russia should intervene and come to aid with food and energy (with a few strings attached).
:dl:
 
Ever hear of Sunni vs Shiite? You will find Sunni Arabs in the Gulf are far more concerned with Shiite Iran than with India, China or Japan - even though Iran is culturally and religiously much closer to them.
But differences are always amplified over short distances. Huntington ignores that, which is why he's wrong.

Well put.

Ever since I read that book, I've been trying to put my finger on the fatal flaw in his theory.
I think you've put it very clearly and concisely.
 
Ever hear of Sunni vs Shiite? You will find Sunni Arabs in the Gulf are far more concerned with Shiite Iran than with India, China or Japan - even though Iran is culturally and religiously much closer to them.
But differences are always amplified over short distances. Huntington ignores that, which is why he's wrong.

Ahmadinejad, just like bin Laden (God rest his soul), is a hero in the eyes of the Arab masses, Sunni or Shia. Again you confuse the concerns of the Arab rulers, paid stooges of America and the Arab street.

But you admit yourself that Sunni and Shia differences exist, as we have seen in extenso in Iraq, proving Huntington's point that boundaries of future conflicts will be defined by centuries/millenia old cultural boundaries, not ideology (bolshevism, multiculturalism, Turkish nationalism, NWO or what Jewish ideologies have you) or (artificial) state borders.
 
Last edited:
http://www.lewrockwell.com/buchanan/buchanan151.html

Buchanan on Egypt...

Among the biggest losers of the Egyptian uprising are, first, the Mubaraks, who are finished, and, next, the United States and Israel...

As for America, if we are about to be thrown out of the Middle East, it would be neither undeserved nor an unmitigated disaster. After all, it's their world, not ours.

America Firster Buchanan can't wait to be thrown out of Arabia and abandon empire altogether.
 
Well put.

Ever since I read that book, I've been trying to put my finger on the fatal flaw in his theory.
I think you've put it very clearly and concisely.
Thanks. :)

Ahmadinejad, just like bin Laden (God rest his soul), is a hero in the eyes of the Arab masses, Sunni or Shia.
Rubbish.
In the Pew poll, solid majorities in all three Arab countries reported unfavorable views of Iran: Egypt, 66 percent; Jordan, 63 percent; Lebanon, 60 percent. Views of Ahmadinejad were even more negative: Among Egyptians, 72 percent said they had little or no confidence in him; 66 percent of respondents in Jordan and 63 percent in Lebanon said the same. [...]
In all three countries, support within those majorities ranged from 66 to 72 percent in favor of tougher economic sanctions against Iran.

Not to mention the massive sectarian violence in Iraq. The Sunnis there must really love Ahmadinejad, to fight the Shiite factions Iran supports there with so much violence.

But you admit yourself that Sunni and Shia differences exist, as we have seen in extenso in Iraq, proving Huntington's point that boundaries of future conflicts will be defined by centuries/millenia old cultural boundaries, not ideology (bolshevism, multiculturalism, Turkish nationalism, NWO or what Jewish ideologies have you) or (artificial) state borders.
What I showed is that Huntington's concept of nations cooperating in "cultural blocks" and facing the outside world together isn't getting anywhere.
The only exception is the EU, but the defining line there is economic/political, not religious.

I do agree with Huntington that the capitalism vs communism inspired Cold War is over and unlikely to return, with most capitalist Western countries having a bigger social security net than communist China.

Future conflicts are most likely to be over local issues, between countries (tribes) that are quite similar culturally and religiously, but who consider themselves wholly different. And of course major powers from elsewhere will be sucked into such conflicts.
 
Last edited:
In the Pew poll, solid majorities in all three Arab countries reported unfavorable views of Iran: Egypt, 66 percent; Jordan, 63 percent; Lebanon, 60 percent. Views of Ahmadinejad were even more negative: Among Egyptians, 72 percent said they had little or no confidence in him; 66 percent of respondents in Jordan and 63 percent in Lebanon said the same. [...]
In all three countries, support within those majorities ranged from 66 to 72 percent in favor of tougher economic sanctions against Iran.

Not to mention the massive sectarian violence in Iraq. The Sunnis there must really love Ahmadinejad, to fight the Shiite factions Iran supports there with so much violence.

This might all be true, but that does not change that the Arab street admires Ahmadinejad in that he stands up to the US, proving that Sunni Arabs prefer Shia Ahmadinejad over Christian Americans. Point for Huntington. At the same time we have seen that the lines of conflict in the Iraq civil war following the American invasion was exactly along the Sunni-Shia fault line. Point for Huntington again.

- Economist: Most Arab governments are queasy but the people feel more ambivalent.
- Radio Free Europe: Ahmadinejad Gets Hero's Welcome In Lebanon, As Israel, West Watch With Suspicion
- Wikileaks:

But the biggest gap in the recent coverage of the story has been understanding Arab public opinion toward Iran and how this affects government calculations. In fact, Iran has the ability to play the Arab-public-opinion card and reach out to groups that threaten the control of Arab governments. And there is evidence that they have succeeded in doing just that, even beyond the rising power of their allies, particularly Hezbollah in Lebanon. In large part, Tehran benefits from Arab public anger toward Israel and the United States, and from the perceived paralysis of their own leaders: consistently, in the past several years, all the polls I’ve conducted at the University of Maryland with cooperation from Zogby International show that in Egypt, Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates, Jordan, Morocco and Lebanon, the Arab public expressed views about Iran that highlighted just how different the public feels when compared to the elites. Last August, I released the 2010 Arab public opinion poll results, which indicated that Arabs polled were more open to Iran’s nuclear program, including the possibility of nuclear-weapons production, than ever before. In an open question about the world leader Arabs admired most, Ahmadinejad was chosen by 12 percent of those questioned—landing him in third place, behind only Turkish leader Recep Erdoğan and Venezuelan demagogue Hugo Chavez.

This paints a different picture than the one you present. There is surely Sunni-Shia rivalry (Huntington!), but Shia Iran is considered closer to Arabia than the West, meaning that the Arab street will choose for Iran and not America. Huntington again. This puts the Arab satraps in a very difficult position leading ultimately to their Ceauşescu-ization.

What I showed is that Huntington's concept of nations cooperating in "cultural blocks" and facing the outside world together isn't getting anywhere.
The only exception is the EU, but the defining line there is economic/political, not religious.

You have done nothing of the sort. We see that the former Soviet republics, like Ukraine and Belorussia are moving together again, in as far as they have an Orthodox identity. The Baltic states are Christian, so they move towards Europe. Christian America and Europe are still allies and will likely remain allies, although the center of gravity will inevitably go back to Europe after the coming collapse of the US and the dismantling of ZOG rule.
 
the Arab street admires Ahmadinejad in that he stands up to the US
The polls also show "the Arab street" has pretty good support for US sanctions against Iran. From the link I posted:
They found that a solid majority (57 percent) of Saudis favored tougher sanctions against Iran if it did not “accept new limits on its nuclear program.” A third even said they would approve “an American military strike against the Iranian nuclear facilities”—and a quarter said the same about an Israeli military strike.
[..]
Egyptians were considerably less hawkish on Iran. However, the Pechter poll found that they were still split roughly down the middle on sanctions, with 43 percent of those surveyed saying that they wanted a tougher sanctions regime against the country. Only one-quarter of Egyptian respondents said they would back U.S. military action against Iran’s nuclear program,


- Economist: Most Arab governments are queasy but the people feel more ambivalent.
- Radio Free Europe: Ahmadinejad Gets Hero's Welcome In Lebanon, As Israel, West Watch With Suspicion
- Wikileaks:
Apparently Latin American Hugo Chavez is more popular among Arabs than Ahmadinejad.

At the same time we have seen that the lines of conflict in the Iraq civil war following the American invasion was exactly along the Sunni-Shia fault line. Point for Huntington again.
Huntington claims conflicts will develop between nations and groups of different civilizations. The Iraqi sectarian war is a conflict between people from the same civilization as defined by Huntington.
If Huntington were right Iraq would be peaceful, and Saoudi Arabia and Iran would be the best of friends. Instead 57% of the Saoudis favours tougher sanctions against Iran.

There is surely Sunni-Shia rivalry (Huntington!), but Shia Iran is considered closer to Arabia than the West, meaning that the Arab street will choose for Iran and not America. Huntington again.
I will repeat what I said earlier:
Cultural differences are always amplified over short distances. Huntington ignores that, which is why he's wrong.
America is a bit complicated, because it has a strong military presence (is geographically close) in the Gulf.

Consider North Korea instead. Culturally and religiously it is far more distant from Saoudi Arabia than Iran. Both have a nuclear program, though North Korea's is more advanced. North Korea is also more reckless.
By Huntington's argument far more Saoudi people should advocate sanctions against North Korea than do against Iran. By my argument they should be mostly indifferent, because the geographical distance is much greater.
Unfortunately I haven't been able to find a poll, but all indications are Saoudis feel far more threatened by Iran than by North Korea.

We see that the former Soviet republics, like Ukraine and Belorussia are moving together again, in as far as they have an Orthodox identity.
Last time I checked Romania, Bulgaria and Greece are all Orthodox as well, but they're firmly in the EU-camp.

---

I think you misunderstand Huntington's thesis.
First of all, whenever there's conflict you can always find cultural and religious differences between the two groups. The Cold War was a conflict between Christian, freedom loving America and the atheist, autocratic Soviet Union. By your reckoning that's also a point for Huntington, even though the man himself said his thesis was valid only for the post-Cold War period.
Second, Huntington's distinguishing prediction is the formation of "cultural blocks" of people with similar culture and religion. He says future conflicts will mainly be between different blocks, not within the same block.
There's plenty of conflict between people within the same block, which is what destroys Huntington's thesis. Your argument is to reduce those blocks in size, so that each conflict still takes place on a border. Since endless reductions are possible, that makes your claim meaningless.
 
I think you misunderstand Huntington's thesis.

Let's have it then straight from the horse's mouth:

It is my hypothesis that the fundamental source of conflict in this new world will not be primarily ideological or primarily economic. The great divisions among humankind and the dominating source of conflict will be cultural. Nation states will remain the most powerful actors in world affairs, but the principal conflicts of global politics will occur between nations and groups of different civilizations. The clash of civilizations will dominate global politics. The fault lines between civilizations will be the battle lines of the future.

With this in mind I can react to your points:

First of all, whenever there's conflict you can always find cultural and religious differences between the two groups. The Cold War was a conflict between Christian, freedom loving America and the atheist, autocratic Soviet Union. By your reckoning that's also a point for Huntington, even though the man himself said his thesis was valid only for the post-Cold War period.

Huntington will tell you that the US/SU conflict was a conflict of ideology, not between Christianity and atheism. It was liberal capitalism versus authoritarian communism. Both ideologies ruled the 20th century and fault lines of conflict centered around these 2 ideologies.

Second, Huntington's distinguishing prediction is the formation of "cultural blocks" of people with similar culture and religion. He says future conflicts will mainly be between different blocks, not within the same block.
There's plenty of conflict between people within the same block, which is what destroys Huntington's thesis. Your argument is to reduce those blocks in size, so that each conflict still takes place on a border. Since endless reductions are possible, that makes your claim meaningless.

Conflict will indeed exist on all levels, from individuals, enterprises, cities, provinces and yes states, even between states in the same cultural block. But real conflict, with war potential, will only occur between cultural blocks.

Last time I checked Romania, Bulgaria and Greece are all Orthodox as well, but they're firmly in the EU-camp.

Romania is a mixed example. Romania is orthodox indeed but Latin in language. Bulgaria is the best example of a 'Huntingtonian anomaly'. But they are in it for the money, just like Turkey aspires to be a member of the EU (it is not going to happen as the multipolarization of the world progresses). It remains to be seen what Bulgaria and Serbia will do if the 'Glory of the West' will eclipse. And besides, both the West and Orthodoxy are Christian will relatively small inter-cultural distance with low potential for conflict.
 
Last edited:
This map summarizes Huntington's predictions. He predicts the emerging of 8 civilizational blocks succeeding that bipolar SU/US world order, resulting in a identitarian multipolar world order.

I somehow doubt that Georgia will want be counted in with the Russian Federation, but rather with the EU. Turkey and Azerbaijan also lean more towards the EU than the RF. Arguably, the world is moving from the bipolar US/USSR, via the hegemony of the US to a multipolar, difficult to understand world, where non-state actors also play a large role.

Also, what drives (violent) conflicts is almost never easy to ascertain (sp?).

Small objection. Before Napoleon there was no such thing as a 'nation'.

Could you explain this to me?
 
I somehow doubt that Georgia will want be counted in with the Russian Federation, but rather with the EU. Turkey and Azerbaijan also lean more towards the EU than the RF.

Only for the money. And because in the case of Georgia it is lead by a western educated president, here shown while eating his tie. Russian-Georgian relations are troubled because of Abkhazia and Ossetia, who both want to return to Russia (ethnic similarity, point for Huntington). Turkey will never become member of the EU.

Arguably, the world is moving from the bipolar US/USSR, via the hegemony of the US to a multipolar, difficult to understand world, where non-state actors also play a large role.

That is precisely what Huntington says!

Could you explain this to me?

Napoleon marked the watershed between the aristocratic ruled world where people's and territories were owned by aristocrats/kings/emperors and the nationalist world where the people's are governed by people's representatives and living in unified centralistic states.
 
Huntington will tell you that the US/SU conflict was a conflict of ideology, not between Christianity and atheism.
You obviously missed the point by a mile. I will clarify.

The Cold War was a conflict between freedom-loving christians on one side and authoritarian atheists on the other. In other words, a conflict between culture blocks as defined by Huntington.

The point is that any war between nations, historical or hypothetical, started for whatever reason, can always be described as a conflict between culture blocks. A war is always us vs them, each side emphasizes how it's different from the enemy.

But real conflict, with war potential, will only occur between cultural blocks.
The Iraqi invasion of Kuwait was post-Cold War, a real conflict with actual war, and between two countries within the same cultural block.
 
You obviously missed the point by a mile. I will clarify.

The Cold War was a conflict between freedom-loving christians on one side and authoritarian atheists on the other. In other words, a conflict between culture blocks as defined by Huntington.

The point is that any war between nations, historical or hypothetical, started for whatever reason, can always be described as a conflict between culture blocks. A war is always us vs them, each side emphasizes how it's different from the enemy.

Wrong. Huntington would not describe the USSR as a culture block. Huntington ackowledges Orthodox Christianity as the true identity of the Russians, not communism. Huntington is talking about identities that are centuries if not millenia old, not some easy come - easy come 13 in a dozen ideology.

The Iraqi invasion of Kuwait was post-Cold War, a real conflict with actual war, and between two countries within the same cultural block.

It was not conflict like the one between Germany and France during WW1. Iraq saw Kuwait as a breakaway province and wanted to incorporate it. Some American diplomat April Glaspie gave the wrong signals to Saddam that he could get away with it (possibly with deceptive intent to create a pretext for invasion). Obviously the ruling elite of Kuwait didn't want to be robbed off their tax base and were glad the US was willing to 'help'. This was not a conflict between 2 nations but between 2 ruling classes.
 
Let's have a look at huntington's map of 'cultural blocks' again:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Clash_of_Civilizations_map2.png

Huntington later realized the consequences of his own theory, namely that if immigration to the US (and Europe) would continue unlimited, that this in the end would lead to the disintegration of the US. If even Anglo constructs like Belgium, Jugoslavia, Czecho-Slovakia or Iraq could not be kept together, then there is no hope of keeping the new Babylon in one piece.

http://www.princeton.edu/~starr/nativist.html
Review of Huntington's Who Are We? The Challenges to America's National Identity which I read in the Dutch translation years ago. In this book Huntington reveals his deep seated worries about the future of the US and predicts the rise of the 'white nativists' (that would be 'white nationalists' in present day vocabulary). The Jewish conservative author Paul Gottfried expressed similar sentiments in his article "The Death of the WASP", published in Taki Magazine. Taki meanwhile pulled the article, underlining it's controversial nature, but the internet has a very long memory. Mirror here.

What happened spontaneously in Tunisia and Egypt during the past few weeks can easily happen in the US (or Europe) as well. We have witnessed the rise of the Tea Party movement, a 100% pure white movement although it goes at great length pretending it is not a white movement. The joke is that there are more black and jewish speakers than those listening in the public, illustrating that it are the whites who are angry but still feel an inner blockade to admit the truth even to themselves. But not too far under the surface there is a sentiment that is just waiting for an occasion to come right into the open. Take for instance this ironic blog-entry by Tea Party leader Mark Williams that caused a storm recently. White Americans understand very well that if they admit that they would prefer to be amongst themselves, that that would be the end of America. That is why they hesitate. They are fuming about 'big government' and 'oppression' and 'high taxes' but they still do not have the courage to openly say that they hate to become dispossed. Poor Euro-Americans; they are held hostage by their own myths. They were being brain-washed for decades by their zionized internationalist ruling class of being proud of their achievements during WW2, when they successfully combatted 'evil' (all a pack of lies, they were the war mongers together with their Bolshevik buddies). My guess is that the big internal blow will come after the inevitable fall of the dollar, when the US will be unable to import anything. What happened in Egypt will be a tea party compared to the US turning into a mega-post-Kathrina-New Orleans. The anger and frustration about decades of unlimited immigration will come to the surface. Unlike the Egyptians, the Americans are armed to the teeth. It will not be pretty.
 
Last edited:
Only for the money. And because in the case of Georgia it is lead by a western educated president, here shown while eating his tie. Russian-Georgian relations are troubled because of Abkhazia and Ossetia, who both want to return to Russia (ethnic similarity, point for Huntington). Turkey will never become member of the EU.

I think the trouble between the RF and Georgia are also due to the invasion by the RF. Also, this map shows that Ossetians are more related to their own ethnic group than to the Russians and the Abchazians are a completely different people.

There are also many muslims in this area, which would be a completely "block" than the orthodox Russians.

That is precisely what Huntington says!

I have the impression Huntington thinks he can divide the world into nine neat blocks. This clearly is not the case.

Napoleon marked the watershed between the aristocratic ruled world where people's and territories were owned by aristocrats/kings/emperors and the nationalist world where the people's are governed by people's representatives and living in unified centralistic states.

Perhaps we should call them 'states', then. The point that egslim made about different states fighting within "cultural blocks" still remains true, then.
 
Trans-national corporations will probably throw an enormous monkey wrench into the works and Huntingdon and whacky old Uncle Pat will be left by the side of the road drawing flies.
 
I've never been able to take Samuel Huntington seriously. His book shows some throughly superficial knowledge of the world and basically is a simple-minded Reader's Digest version of reality.

I lost any ability to take seriously his book when I read his section describing all of sub-saharan Africa as one "Civilization". It was so stupid as to be funny. He really thought that the Malagasy of Madagascar and Animist Ibo of Nigeria could be grouped as the "same"!? Only a mind steeped in deep ignorance could come up with that piece of crap. Sub-Saharan Africa is the most diverse, in terms of culture and traditional political mores of any palce on the planet. The superficiality was just mind numbing.

Regarding Euriope I was amused that he distinguished between "Orthodox" and the rest of Europe called Western. This was a distinction based on religion in this case Greek Orthodox versus Catholic / Protestant. Why he didn't distinguish between Protestant and Catholic as different "Civilizations" was a bit beyond me.

His creation of a Latin American "Civlization" was also amusing. Who knew that Argentina, Mexico and Costa Rica where all the same "Civlization". Once again Mr. Huntington shows his superficial grasp of reality. Argentina for example is very European in Culture etc., and Mexico for example is a society with a very strong Indian social and cultural element. The idea that they are the "same" is a bad joke.

I could go with Huntington's other absurdities including his ignoring of the deep riff in Islam between Shia and Sunni and the distinction between Persian and Arab cultures, attitudes etc. Even funnier was his ignoring of other distinctions between Islamic countries like the fact that culturally Indonesia is more "Indian" than "Islamic". THe distinction between Sinc and Japan as different "Civlization" is also stunningly arbitrary.

All in all the book is my opinion near worthless.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom