Halfway of what?
The questions about amputating arms, fingers and earlobes specifically are relevant to the discussion and more than justified.
Not anymore. I think I have more than satisfied the differences and distinctions between all those examples. I remain unconvinced that removing the foreskin from a baby actually makes sexual stimulation any less enjoyable later in life. I most certainly enjoy it myself. A lot! Would I have enjoyed it "even more" if I had a foreskin? Who knows? Would you enjoy it any less without one? Who knows?
The point is, it is a benign procedure that does not affect the person whatsoever throughout their life.
That you cannot answer them is a problem of your position and your ability to provide a rational justification for it: Your position simply leads to numerous inconsistencies.
I have. I just don't think you like my answers, and you seem disagree without even trying to understand. I may be wrong in this assumption, but I highly doubt it.
The entire point of this discussion is to point those out and resolve them one way or another. But in order to do that they will have to be pointed out and discussed.
No they do not. It is like comparing apples to oranges. You first have to demonstrate beyond any reasonable doubt that having a circumcision affects men throughout their lives, and that they really resent the fact their parents did it to them when they were babies. And for that, you must provide some kind of professionally-done survey, that published the results, the methods, the questions used, the methods of choosing the respondents, and so forth.
Other than that, I can only assume that circumcised men don't seem to care one way or the other, and seems to enjoy active, healthy sex lives and are able to produce children at exactly the same rate as uncircumcised men. Cutting off fingers, arms, and earlobes places OBVIOUS restrictions on that person's ability to function up to their full potential.
You seem to think that it is permissible at least to cut of a male baby's foreskin, yet you have a different opinion about
You keep asking my opinions. Opinions are subjective. Subjective opinions have no place in creating laws. There are no courts in the country that I am aware of that will rule on something, based on subjective arguments.
a) minor mutilations of female genitalia
I do not know enough about female circumcision. Nobody has posted any information in here. I was only told to look up "type 1" or whatever. Only thing I have heard throughout this conversation, is that female circumcision is not at all comparable to male circumcision in how benign the procedure and results are.
b) larger mutilations of male genitalia
Such as.....? I honestly never remember hearing a question about this. Sorry, you have to be more specific. I honestly have no idea what you mean by "larger mutilations."
c) amputations of digits or parts thereof
Already covered ad nauseum. See above as well.
d) amputations of earlobes
Already covered ad nauseum.
To further complicate your position, it seems that you think that circumcising a baby is no big deal but that you are quite happy that it should be illegal between adults.
An adult is an adult. It is quite illegal to mess around with an adult body while they are lying unconscious on a hospital bed, beyond administering the required care.
Now the interesting question is: What are the rational, consistent reasons that underly all these judgments?
The questions you have asked are quite disingenuous at best.
You have a problem explaining why it is okay to circumcise a boy but not okay to cut off his earlobes.
Apparently you must have missed that part of the conversation. I have answered that question that was posed. Asking it 800 times over doesn't change the answer a whole lot without any kind of significant argument.
If you are okay with cutting off earlobes you are definitely drawing the line at fingers.
I would say "yes." But you must first understand fully what my answer to the earlobe and finger hypothetical situations were.
And all the justification you have been able to come up with is that one is worse than the other and that one simply doesn't pass your personal thresholds for being "bad enough".
Correct. The law does the same thing all of the time. Such as outlawing the act of yelling "FIRE!" in a theater being "much worse" than the WBC protesting at funeral. The reason why libel and slander is illegal, but you can criticize the Federal Government.I hate to make assumptions, so please correct me if I am wrong. But you really seem as though you are not understanding the whole concept of weighing the amount of harm any particular act may cause both personally and socially, with freedoms in the Constitution. You have also failed to show any case law in connection to this situation, other than the Smith case with Native Americans use of peyote. But I have demonstrated how and why that case does not apply to this situation.
The problem is, we are talking not about you cutting off your own foreskin but somebody else's. In a society where on of the most basic principles of freedom is that you cannot impose your own thresholds on other people without good reason that is simply not good enough: That you see no problem with cutting off a little baby's foreskin is no more justification for doing it than it would be for me if I saw no problem with cutting off your earlobes. I'd go to jail if I did it no matter how much I believed it wasn't a big deal.
This argument presents nothing that has already been covered. The biggest problem with your argument, is that you are talking about two unrelated adults, and comparing that situation to a parent's rights to raise their children how they want. Their rights to practice their religion with their children. The benign nature of circumcision, compared to the much more risky behavior with much more adverse effects of cutting off earlobes.
To be fair, the earlobe situation was that all the risks and adverse affects were hypothetically the exact same as circumcision. The religious factor is exactly the same, and the social consequences exactly the same. Therefore, the act of earlobe cutting should be just as legal as circumcision.
But IRL, it is far more complicated. You cannot just say "The social consequences, health risks, religious factors (there are none for earlobes!!)," and so forth are nothing alike. Not at all comparable.
This is the exact reason why you lose a lot of credibility in a court of law when you propose hypothetical after hypothetical.