CA State Considers Stealing 12 Cents Per Can Of Soda Sold

I would prefer to have a government that strictly limited itself to mafia practices.

For example, if the government strictly did nothing but protect me from being looted by other criminal institutions, this would be a superior state of affairs to what we have now.

Indeed, I would willingly pay such an institution if the services it provided were reasonably priced.

I've been meaning to ask; You consider being taxed to be an act of theft, so do you consider demanding interest on an investment to be theft?
 
I've been meaning to ask; You consider being taxed to be an act of theft, so do you consider demanding interest on an investment to be theft?

Certainly not.

Time has value, therefore it is appropriate to charge for the lending of resources over time.
 
Certainly not.

Time has value, therefore it is appropriate to charge for the lending of resources over time.

You don't consider that taxes are repayment for the time spent in the country, which belongs to the government?
 
You don't consider that taxes are repayment for the time spent in the country, which belongs to the government?

No, because private individuals engaging in voluntary transactions can meet all consumer needs without the threat of violence or coercion.

Therefore, taxes are theft.

In order for taxes to be legitimate, voluntary transactions must not capable of providing all the services modern society requires. Of course, this is not the case, as such, taxes are theft.
 
No, because private individuals engaging in voluntary transactions can meet all consumer needs without the threat of violence or coercion.

Therefore, taxes are theft.

In order for taxes to be legitimate, voluntary transactions must not capable of providing all the services modern society requires. Of course, this is not the case, as such, taxes are theft.

But you're in THEIR country. Aren't you refusing to give them what is rightfully belong to them if you refuse to pay?
 
But you're in THEIR country. Aren't you refusing to give them what is rightfully belong to them if you refuse to pay?

No, because voluntary transactions could accomplish all the services the State provides.

Therefore, if I wanted some kind of service, I could pay for it voluntarily on my own.

The use of coercion is not necessary.
 
No, because voluntary transactions could accomplish all the services the State provides.

Therefore, if I wanted some kind of service, I could pay for it voluntarily on my own.

The use of coercion is not necessary.

Okay, suppose I move into a house you own, and then refuse to pay you rent, on the grounds that I no longer require your services. Does that make me a criminal?
 
Okay, suppose I move into a house you own, and then refuse to pay you rent, on the grounds that I no longer require your services. Does that make me a criminal?

Considering I own the house, it would make you a trespasser and a thief.
 
sure, if you could provide an actual point when posting it would be helpful to me when consuming your pro anti-State propaganda.

WOW, I guess that would be DITTO for you! Because the OP had absolutely ZERO sense or value! I mean what exactly is YOUR point?! That tax is theft? IF so why single out soda tax?
 
WOW, I guess that would be DITTO for you! Because the OP had absolutely ZERO sense or value! I mean what exactly is YOUR point?! That tax is theft? IF so why single out soda tax?

I believe you are mistaken.

It is valuable to demonstrate that the State uses coercion to rob people of their income while socially engineering society to meet the whims of power mad sociopaths.
 
So, doesn't that make you a trespasser and a thief if you refuse to pay taxes?

No, because the housing contract was entered into voluntarily between two willing participants.

When the State prevents free markets from forming due to regulations, and then forces people to pay for services the free market could provide on its own, then we can say the State is illegitimate in using coercion to fund its operations.
 
No, because the housing contract was entered into voluntarily between two willing participants.

When the State prevents free markets from forming due to regulations, and then forces people to pay for services the free market could provide on its own, then we can say the State is illegitimate in using coercion to fund its operations.

Don't you have the option of leaving the country? Why don't you have a choice about accepting the government's services?
 
Don't you have the option of leaving the country? Why don't you have a choice about accepting the government's services?

Saying I should leave the country does not address the fact that the State illegitimately prevented free market services from forming and then used coercion to fund its own brand of services.

Such an argument simply avoids the immorality and injustice of the State's business practices.
 
Saying I should leave the country does not address the fact that the State illegitimately prevented free market services from forming and then used coercion to fund its own brand of services.

Such an argument simply avoids the immorality and injustice of the State's business practices.

One other question I had outstanding: If you did get the government-free society you wanted, who would prevent a new government from forming?
 
Given that I bracketed my ad-libs, I wouldn't consider it lying.

No.

These are brackets: [ ]

These are parentheses: ( )

When you make editorial comments, you use brackets. You use parentheses when you are making a personal comment, adding an after-thought, or making clarifications to text you, yourself, wrote.

Considering you don't know the difference between brackets and parentheses, it's not surprising you don't know the difference between taxes and theft.
 
No.

These are brackets: [ ]

These are parentheses: ( )

When you make editorial comments, you use brackets. You use parentheses when you are making a personal comment, adding an after-thought, or making clarifications to text you, yourself, wrote.

Considering you don't know the difference between brackets and parentheses, it's not surprising you don't know the difference between taxes and theft.

Thank you mr. grammar police.

I shall now use brackets to insert my ad-libs from here forward.
 
No, because the housing contract was entered into voluntarily between two willing participants.

When the State prevents free markets from forming due to regulations, and then forces people to pay for services the free market could provide on its own, then we can say the State is illegitimate in using coercion to fund its operations.

Are you saying you are an unwilling participant in the social contract the American government has with its people?
 
Are you saying you are an unwilling participant in the social contract the American government has with its people?

In law, a contract is only enforceable if it is consensual:

Contract law is based on the principle expressed in the Latin phrase pacta sunt servanda, which is usually translated "agreements to be kept" but more literally means "pacts must be kept".[1]

Contract law can be classified, as is habitual in civil law systems, as part of a general law of obligations, along with tort, unjust enrichment, and restitution.

As a means of economic ordering, contract relies on the notion of consensual exchange and has been extensively discussed in broader economic, sociological, and anthropological terms (see "Contractual theory" below). In American English, the term extends beyond the legal meaning to encompass a broader category of agreements.[2]

Since I never consented to any social contract, there necessarily can be no legitimate social contract.

Consent requires that I either give a verbal or written declaration of my agreement to be bound by said contract.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom