Merged Silver Over 40.00 / Real and fake prices

It may burst all the way down to $12. That is what I would consider current rock bottom price w/o any speculation priced in.

I am not concerned, BTW. I am guessing it will stop at about $25.
Still buying.

My guess is also around $ 25.
But it would be great if it fell all the way to $ 15.
I'd definitely pick some up at that price.
 
I call minor bear run.

Just curious, do you have any stats on volatility of the gold/silver ratio, to support that there is a ratio that tends to be returned to? EG lower volatility when at the "right Ratio", etc.

No, my knowledge of the precious metals market is pretty shallow. I'm just pointing out what the ratio was in the recent past.

I don't know why silver over the past year has been (or had been) outperforming gold. There should be a reason, right? Is there any good reason why that you are aware of? If not, why wouldn't it return to a similar level to the recent past?
 
It may burst all the way down to $12. That is what I would consider current rock bottom price w/o any speculation priced in.

I am not concerned, BTW. I am guessing it will stop at about $25.
Still buying.

My guess is also around $ 25.
But it would be great if it fell all the way to $ 15.
I'd definitely pick some up at that price.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silver_as_an_investment

As recently as 2005 it was $7.31. In 2000 it was $4.95

Adjusted for inflation, that's $6.42 in 2011 dollars for 2000, and $8.36 in 2011 dollars for 2005.

Maybe the rise of China precludes it from returning to those levels, though.
 
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silver_as_an_investment

As recently as 2005 it was $7.31. In 2000 it was $4.95

Adjusted for inflation, that's $6.42 in 2011 dollars for 2000, and $8.36 in 2011 dollars for 2005.

Maybe the rise of China precludes it from returning to those levels, though.

Yeah,

In 2003 I bought some gold.
At the shop I considered buying some silver.
The guy behind the counter gave me a silver bar and said "this is € 20, do you really want to carry € 2000 worth to your car?"

I decided that it was not my ambition to own a forklift truck.

So, yeah it was a lot cheaper then.
 
No, my knowledge of the precious metals market is pretty shallow. I'm just pointing out what the ratio was in the recent past.

I don't know why silver over the past year has been (or had been) outperforming gold. There should be a reason, right? Is there any good reason why that you are aware of? If not, why wouldn't it return to a similar level to the recent past?
I know that six months to a year ago, various people in the metals investment arena started pushing silver, saying it was undervalued compared to gold. This smelled a bit, because the "gold is overvalued" meant that they found buyer resistence at the then current prices, so they were trying to make sales by moving the customers to another, "cheaper" item. EG, "look this is $1300, but this here is $25".

At least in part then, it is a manufactured event from the git go. But there is the OTHER PART that is of more interest. And some people think in terms of weeks or months for investments, other think in terms of years.

The signal that gold and silver have just only started a major upward run is that they have been mainstreamed as investment vehicles. People who would laugh at them 2 years ago now repeated hear of countries buying billions of dollars of gold, pension funds buying it, etc. So where you previously had a fringe minority, now you have a lot of people in this market.
 
The signal that gold and silver have just only started a major upward run is that they have been mainstreamed as investment vehicles. People who would laugh at them 2 years ago now repeated hear of countries buying billions of dollars of gold, pension funds buying it, etc. So where you previously had a fringe minority, now you have a lot of people in this market.

One thing I think that gold has going for it that silver does not is the 800 pound gorrilas known as central banks buying the stuff.

http://latino.foxnews.com/latino/money/2011/05/05/bank-mexico-buys-100-tons-gold/

Of course if those gorrilas stop or if they turn around and sell their gold it could go the other way.
 
One thing I think that gold has going for it that silver does not is the 800 pound gorrilas known as central banks buying the stuff.

http://latino.foxnews.com/latino/money/2011/05/05/bank-mexico-buys-100-tons-gold/

Of course if those gorrilas stop or if they turn around and sell their gold it could go the other way.
But the primary factor, the underlying factor, is the printing of trillions of dollars. That is a cause, the actions by central banks an effect. And the moving of gold/silver into the "mainstream of investing", that is another effect.

I average over a couple years, so I ignore month to month or week to week swings. But as that printed money gets into the street value of the dollar, metals and other commodities cannot help but rise. By this thinking, we should see 1500 gold go to 3000 (but not really change in value).

The thing that makes this hard to talk about is that the USD is not any good as a measure, a basket of commodities would be better or one of the ultra stable currencies.

As an example of this problem I have had bank account in the US and Australia. In 2006, exchange rate 1:42 AUD to 1 USD, now .....
 
China Buying Silver Overnight

GoldCorp submits: "Gold and silver are tentatively higher after their 2% and 8% falls yesterday. In silver, speculators on the COMEX continue to liquidate en masse after margin was increased a massive 84% and various stop loss levels are hit, leading to further falls in the futures market.

That's why Silver moved so sharply.

It will move back up.

It can't help it.

Bernanke has a printing press.
 
But the primary factor, the underlying factor, is the printing of trillions of dollars. That is a cause, the actions by central banks an effect. And the moving of gold/silver into the "mainstream of investing", that is another effect.
Evidence?

Because the first thing to show an effect when you print dollars is the value of dollars goes down. It is the most immediate, and so far as we can argue, "correct" valuation of the dollar. But silver is not matching lock-step with the dollar devaluation; anything but.

Now, if by 'cause' you mean people freak out and create a bubble, perhaps. But I would argue that is an oblique/confusing way of describing it, as the wording implies that somehow the current money status = some massive devaluation.
 
Evidence?

Because the first thing to show an effect when you print dollars is the value of dollars goes down. It is the most immediate, and so far as we can argue, "correct" valuation of the dollar. But silver is not matching lock-step with the dollar devaluation; anything but.

Now, if by 'cause' you mean people freak out and create a bubble, perhaps. But I would argue that is an oblique/confusing way of describing it, as the wording implies that somehow the current money status = some massive devaluation.

Yeah but the thing you are forgetting is that prior to Bernanke's insanity, almost no one was holding silver as a money (store of wealth). Most of silver's price was due to industrial usage and collectible coins. There has been a huge over-supply of silver because the fiat currency laws drove silver out of monetary usage and made all that silver available for industrial usage.

As silver and gold undergo the transition back into being a money, the demand for physical will out pace the devaluation of the dollar by a wide margin.

Eventually we will see silver reach at least a 16 to 1 price differential with gold simply because that's the ratio it has to gold in the ground. The many decades of undervalued silver are coming to an end and there will be severe shortages of the metal in the near future.

The eventual price of gold will reach a divisible number with all the wealth (real goods and services) available throughout the entire world. The GDP of the world is around 58 trillion dollars. 160,000 tons of gold has been mined.

That makes the eventual real dollar price of gold $362,500,000 a ton - or over $10,000 an ounce. That would make the eventual price of silver somewhere around $625 an ounce, not counting industrial usage.

All in today's dollar prices of course.
 
Last edited:
Evidence?

Because the first thing to show an effect when you print dollars is the value of dollars goes down. It is the most immediate, and so far as we can argue, "correct" valuation of the dollar. But silver is not matching lock-step with the dollar devaluation; anything but.

Now, if by 'cause' you mean people freak out and create a bubble, perhaps. But I would argue that is an oblique/confusing way of describing it, as the wording implies that somehow the current money status = some massive devaluation.

The bolded part is just flat wrong. Historically, inflation leads, lowered currency value lags. Let's say 18 months or longer, depending on several things. So there is after some money printing, an "unrealized or latent" inflation which may be simply forecast. Consider the very first day after printing a trillion extra. The street value of a dollar has not changed. Now consider how long it takes the street to absorb that new money, and for the values to average out.

And in some cases, GNP growth is 2-3 percent, and money printing is 2-3 percent, and they seem to cancel out for a while leaving currency values similar.

That's not going to happen on this merry go round, though.
 
Last edited:
Yeah but the thing you are forgetting is that prior to Bernanke's insanity, almost no one was holding silver as a money (store of wealth). Most of silver's price was due to industrial usage and collectible coins....

Right. Metals as investment "has been mainstreamed". So it's like looking at the number of espressos and lattes drank in the US before and after Starbucks mainstreamed them.

We are not going back to a pre Starbucks level on these specialty coffee drinks.

It's simply not possible. In fact, I suspect for a variety of reasons that this trend is just in the emerging stages.

But I disagree that any of this means the world is in large or small part headed back to a hard metals based currency whether implicit or explicit. That just ain't gonna happen, the unit of money now is the plastic credit card and the keyboard.
 
Last edited:
But I disagree that any of this means the world is in large or small part headed back to a hard metals based currency whether implicit or explicit. That just ain't gonna happen, the unit of money now is the plastic credit card and the keyboard.

Gold and silver can be represented electronically, which makes this argument moot.

As the government continues its debasement of the world reserve currency, we will see gold and silver become money once again.
 
But the primary factor, the underlying factor, is the printing of trillions of dollars.

But what I think you're missing is that the trillions printed comes at a time when the real estate market has lost trillions in value, so one effect cancels out the other.

Remember that as house prices were rising, people felt richer every year and they borrowed against the higher market values of their houses, and this new money went into the economy. Now that engine of growth has been reversed. The dollars being pumped in by the Fed are only to keep the economy from deflating, which would happen if the Fed sat idle while the housing market (and commercial real estate market) collapsed.

This is one reason why I don't expect hyperinflation. Another is the high unemployment. To get hyperinflation, you need an inflationary cycle, and that requires wage hikes as part of the cycle. If wages aren't going up, there's a limit to how much sellers can raise their prices, because consumers won't stand for it if their own wages aren't rising too. According to the latest jobs report this morning, wages only rose by 0.1% in April.

Finally, once real signs of inflation appear, the Fed will end its loose money policy. They know how to control inflation when the time comes.
 
But what I think you're missing is that the trillions printed comes at a time when the real estate market has lost trillions in value, so one effect cancels out the other.

Remember that as house prices were rising, people felt richer every year and they borrowed against the higher market values of their houses, and this new money went into the economy. Now that engine of growth has been reversed. The dollars being pumped in by the Fed are only to keep the economy from deflating, which would happen if the Fed sat idle while the housing market (and commercial real estate market) collapsed.

This is one reason why I don't expect hyperinflation. Another is the high unemployment. To get hyperinflation, you need an inflationary cycle, and that requires wage hikes as part of the cycle. If wages aren't going up, there's a limit to how much sellers can raise their prices, because consumers won't stand for it if their own wages aren't rising too. According to the latest jobs report this morning, wages only rose by 0.1% in April.

Finally, once real signs of inflation appear, the Fed will end its loose money policy. They know how to control inflation when the time comes.

Hyper-inflation comes when people lose confidence in the value of the dollar.

By people, I mean China, Japan, Russia, Western Europe, etc..

The inflationary cycle comes from a wide spread dumping of our treasury bonds by State actors.

It doesn't matter if there is an excess of housing or not.

Consider the options of China:

They can take Bernanke's printing in the butt and suffer a loss of real wealth or they can dump the dollar totally and tell Bernanke to go screw himself.

When the printing by Bernanke reaches a point that is more painful for China than getting out of the dollar, they will get out.
 
Last edited:
But what I think you're missing is that the trillions printed comes at a time when the real estate market has lost trillions in value, so one effect cancels out the other.

Remember that as house prices were rising, people felt richer every year and they borrowed against the higher market values of their houses, and this new money went into the economy. Now that engine of growth has been reversed. The dollars being pumped in by the Fed are only to keep the economy from deflating, which would happen if the Fed sat idle while the housing market (and commercial real estate market) collapsed.

This is one reason why I don't expect hyperinflation. Another is the high unemployment. To get hyperinflation, you need an inflationary cycle, and that requires wage hikes as part of the cycle. If wages aren't going up, there's a limit to how much sellers can raise their prices, because consumers won't stand for it if their own wages aren't rising too. According to the latest jobs report this morning, wages only rose by 0.1% in April.

Finally, once real signs of inflation appear, the Fed will end its loose money policy. They know how to control inflation when the time comes.

Well, no I am not missing the real estate issues. To reverse your statement, part of FED policy is to deflate real estate values and then to allow both commercial and residential owners to string along with loans higher than value, as well as taking something like a trillion in loans directly into the FED balance sheet. This policy cannot work in the long run unless real estate is permanently deflated. Yes in the short run you can deflate one sector, inflate another and have an average. But that average is still going to be affected by all that new money printed.

As for "full employment", traditionally it was thought that big time inflation could not occur without full employment. I don't think anyone believes that anymore and neither is is logical. The question is simply whether the number of dollars printed, and their effect on the economy, exceeds the effect of a simultaneous change in employment. And that's really obvious - if a 3% change in employment is exactly offset by $500B printed, then what happens if you print $2T?

So ultimately, those dollars printed have to come home to roost. And the FED cannot call them back in, without the banks having to call in loans. And that isn't going to happen, unless the FED wants to increase it's real estate inventory. This would be a socialization of the majority of real estate capital. Some might like that, and or some might try to effect it thinking the public would not realize what was happening.

Finally, I'll note one error in your thinking (in many respects we do agree). The FED or the government cannot control or manage hyperinflation. That is what happens when the people lose faith in the currency and the government behind it. By definition, hyperinflation is a loss of control. Historically, it seems to happen pretty easily and inevitably once certain conditions are set up.

Are those conditions set up in the USA now? Yep, pretty much. Does that mean we will experience hyperinflation? Nope, only if the attitude of the people shifts.

Is the current move toward gold good or bad for this?

The current move toward gold doesn't signal hyperinflation in the works.

What in my opinion would signal hyperinflation is very simple. It would be a failure politically by Boerner to extract a deal to cut trillions in exchange for raising the debt ceiling. As Bernanke said in 3-2009 "The medium term outlook for the US is quite dark".

"business as usual in washingon for 2011-2013" directly leads, inevitably to hyperinflation.

Well, that's my opinion.

:)
 
Last edited:
Hyper-inflation comes when people lose confidence in the value of the dollar.

By people, I mean China, Japan, Russia, Western Europe, etc..

The inflationary cycle comes from a wide spread dumping of our treasury bonds by State actors.

It doesn't matter if there is an excess of housing or not.

Consider the options of China:

They can take Bernanke's printing in the butt and suffer a loss of real wealth or they can dump the dollar totally and tell Bernanke to go screw himself.

When the printing by Bernanke reaches a point that is more painful for China than getting out of the dollar, they will get out.


Except for one problem. If the dollar falls to nothing we can't buy anything from China. At the current time that would hugely set back their economy. It would be economic suicide. In fact china has a policy of artificially propping up the dollar by under pricing the yuan.

In the future as they grow this could change. Hopefully we will get our house in order before then.
 
Except for one problem. If the dollar falls to nothing we can't buy anything from China. At the current time that would hugely set back their economy. It would be economic suicide. In fact china has a policy of artificially propping up the dollar by under pricing the yuan.

In the future as they grow this could change. Hopefully we will get our house in order before then.

It is a fallacy to think China will be just as hurt by this as the US.

China will still have a viable currency and will be able to trade internationally for products and services.

Further, the Chinese people will simply buy their own products, just like we used to do before we found out that printing money to pay for foreign goods is easier than trading real resources for them.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom