Ban circumcision in San Fran???

Rastafarianism has smoking pot as one of the main religious practices. Do you think a first amendment argument would work for them? It's a current religion and I would be amazed if it didn't have adherents in the USA.

actually you would be hard pressed to make that case- it's certainly not universal in Rastafarianism.



it would, but wouldn't need to. The (federal) Religious Freedom Restoration Act would be enough, a law that was specifically enacted to allow for religious drug use.

Yes, that has already been covered a while back. Which is why I had retracted my earlier statement about how the law cannot discriminate based on religion. In other words, I had said the law should always apply equally to everyone, everywhere. But I dug up the Religious Freedom Restoration Act, which was a bill that was passed as a result of the Smith vs. Unemployment case in the Supreme Court.
 
does the first amendment only apply to existing religious practise?

I'm not a lawyer, so I can't answer that question. My opinion is that it appears to only apply to current religious practices and even so, they have to be within the law as it currently stands. Mormons aren't allowed to legally practice polygamy or marry girls younger than allowed by law.

Rastafarianism has smoking pot as one of the main religious practices. Do you think a first amendment argument would work for them? It's a current religion and I would be amazed if it didn't have adherents in the USA.

actually you would be hard pressed to make that case- it's certainly not universal in Rastafarianism.



it would, but wouldn't need to. The (federal) Religious Freedom Restoration Act would be enough, a law that was specifically enacted to allow for religious drug use.

I wasn't aware of that. I have heard there are Native American religions that use peyote or mushroom. Last I heard, they weren't allowed to do so legally.

At any rate, I think it should be covered under the first amendment but I'm not sure if the legal system agrees with me.
 
First Amendment.

The Supreme Court has repeatedly ruled that neutral laws that happen to impinge on some religious practices are constitutional.

Deal with it. Seriously. circumcision is not illegal.

This is not in dispute. The discussion is on whether a law should be passed to make it illegal.

The bill will be struck down if passed as being unconstitutional.

Please explain why the Morrill Anti-Bigamy Act and the Edmunds Act were not struck down, given that the First Amendment was no less binding in 1862 or 1882 than it is currently.

Dave
 
However, a statement that it is impossible to pass legislation banning a procedure on the grounds that the procedure is currently legal is not rational.

Rolfe.
 
The campaign to ban circumcision in San Francisco has just gone blatantly antisemitic. I mean, like, Nazi propaganda antisemitic, complete with Aryan heros fighting evil stereotyped orthodox jews.
 
The campaign to ban circumcision in San Francisco has just gone blatantly antisemitic. I mean, like, Nazi propaganda antisemitic, complete with Aryan heros fighting evil stereotyped orthodox jews.



The publication of the comic book was first reported Thursday in the San Francisco Chronicle, which asked Hess if he considered it to be anti-Semitic. "A lot of people have said that, but we're not trying to be anti-Semitic," he said. "We're trying to be pro-human rights."
The Anti-Defamation League, which was organized to fight anti-Semitism, issued a statement Friday sharply attacking the publication, which it called "an advocacy campaign taken to a new low."

"This is a sensitive, serious issue where good people can disagree," the ADL statement said. "It is one thing to debate it, is another thing to degrade it. 'Foreskin Man,' with its grotesque anti-Semitic imagery and themes, reaches a new low and is disrespectful and deeply offensive."

Hess did not immediately return a phone call seeking further comment Friday.

http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/lan...-circumcision-ban-superhero-anti-semitic.html
 
The campaign to ban circumcision in San Francisco has just gone blatantly antisemitic. I mean, like, Nazi propaganda antisemitic, complete with Aryan heros fighting evil stereotyped orthodox jews.

*some* of those campaigning for a circumcision ban went anti semitic. But the campaign as a whole don't seem that way. That would be stupid on many level (on top of being stupid because of anti semitism) since most circumcision in the USA are culturaly done on non-jew (~55% male circumcised in the USA as of 2010, but about 2% only jew in the population) and the USA circumcision cultural origin is not semitic, but some stupid prude idea on masturbation If i recall correctly. Bringing in judaism is senseless.

The ban on circumcision make a lot of sense on the whole, without bringing in judaism in there.

I do wonder at the objective of the author of the comic though and would like to have much more ifno than some random blog.
 
I do wonder at the objective of the author of the comic though and would like to have much more ifno than some random blog.

How much more info do you need than the contents of the comic itself? Are those pictures really not sufficiently self-explanatory?

As an aside (this doesn't have anything to do with the antisemtism aspect), the hero's logo is kinda gross and creepy.
 
How much more info do you need than the contents of the comic itself? Are those pictures really not sufficiently self-explanatory?

As an aside (this doesn't have anything to do with the antisemtism aspect), the hero's logo is kinda gross and creepy.

There is a lot info to be gained beyond shock value.
* were they really anti semitic, or simply a message which went too far ? I don't immediately attribute to malice what could be terminal incompetence or insensibility. Remember the debate on the picture of the woman kneeing before the man in another thread.
* how do the rest of those supporting the ban feel ? How many proportionaly really support that comic ? If it is a minority, then it isn't the same analyze result as if it was a majority.
* will this be used as ammo by those against the ban , even if in the previous point show it is a minority of idiot which spread the comic ?
* etc...

Plenty of question actually.


ETA: for me a campaign goes blatantely anti semitic only if a majority was supporting this comic. otherwise you can only at best say it got "anti semitic undertone due to the action of some , not supported by the majority of those for the ban".
 
Last edited:
* how do the rest of those supporting the ban feel ?

That's an important question, to be sure. Probably the only really important question from your list. But nothing about the author or his intentions will tell us anything about that.
 
* were they really anti semitic, or simply a message which went too far ? I don't immediately attribute to malice what could be terminal incompetence or insensibility. Remember the debate on the picture of the woman kneeing before the man in another thread.

The comics are blatantly anti-Semitic. Since they are associated with the group who proposed the ban, it it least calls into question their motivation:

But the “Foreskin Man” comic book, which was written and edited in 2010 by the founder of a San Diego group supporting efforts to ban circumcision in San Francisco and Santa Monica, gives further credence to the accusation that so-called intactivists are in fact motivated by anti-Semitism.

“The imagery in ‘Foreskin Man’ is functionally Anti-Semitic,” Abby Michelson Porth, associate director of the Jewish Community Relations Council (JCRC), said. “The motives of the proponents of this ban are questionable given their direct connection with “Foreskin Man.”
(...)
Lloyd Schofield is the official backer of the San Francisco initiative, which uses text from the group MGMbill.org, a San Diego-based group established by Matthew Hess. Hess is credited alongside the comic book’s illustrator and colorist on the comic’s website.

http://www.jewishjournal.com/bloggi...tic_imagery_into_circumcision_fight_20110603/

Note that these circumcision-haters could have addressed the issue as one of science, medicine, personal autonomy, or even just a social issue on which reasonable people can disagree.

But they didn’t. The case they’re making is that circumcision is evil because Jews do it as a religious observance.

http://hotair.com/greenroom/archives/2011/06/03/circumcision-hatred-it-was-only-a-matter-of-time/
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom