Ban circumcision in San Fran???

* were they really anti semitic, or simply a message which went too far ? I don't immediately attribute to malice what could be terminal incompetence or insensibility.

noble & blond warrior fighting to save the penis from evil, sinister, dark-haired Jews with no eye balls, salavating over the foreskin of their next victim. oh, and ofcourse the evil ones are black-clothes wearing ultra-Orthodox Jews, as if ONLY ultra-Orthodox Jews are the ones who circumcize their baby boys.

not anti-Semitic????????????????????????????

are you serious????
 
Last edited:
plus, any antisemitism doesn't make circumcision okay, anyway.

True. But even if you oppose circumcision, I don't think anyone looking at the issue rationally could conclude that circumcision is a bigger problem than antisemitism.
 
True. But even if you oppose circumcision, I don't think anyone looking at the issue rationally could conclude that circumcision is a bigger problem than antisemitism.

No?

How many Jews are being killed per year in the USA, and how many boys are being circumcised?

And - really - what does it matter which the bigger problem is? "yes, we are baby mutilating followers of a bronze age superstition, but it's okay because some people don't like us!" - ?
 
No?

How many Jews are being killed per year in the USA, and how many boys are being circumcised?

So it's only a problem if someone dies? Well, I think you just proved that BOTH issues are not problems.

But of course, that's not true. You think circumcision is a problem even without any deaths. Which means you knew your comparison was dishonest from the start. You are, in short, quite plainly arguing in bad faith.

And - really - what does it matter which the bigger problem is?

You really can't figure that out yourself? I'll again credit you with dishonesty, because the alternative is worse.

"yes, we are baby mutilating followers of a bronze age superstition, but it's okay because some people don't like us!" - ?

You think I give a crap that you call circumcision "baby mutilation"? Hyperbole will get you nowhere with me.

ETA: Furthermore, if you want to claim that this isn't about antisemitism, you need to address the fact that some people have their babies circumcised for reasons other than religion. So by attacking "bronze age superstition", you're hardly dispelling the notion that this opposition movement is infected with antisemitism.
 
Last edited:
Huh? Circumcision is baby mutilation by definition.

Mutilation:

1
: to cut up or alter radically so as to make imperfect <the child mutilated the book with his scissors>
2
: to cut off or permanently destroy a limb or essential part of : cripple

Nope, doesn't describe circumcision.
 
Mutilation:

1
: to cut up or alter radically so as to make imperfect <the child mutilated the book with his scissors>
2
: to cut off or permanently destroy a limb or essential part of : cripple

Nope, doesn't describe circumcision.

In what world does cutting off a foreskin not meet #1?
This right after you have accused someone else of arguing in bad faith.
It would be honest to say, yes it is mutilation, but minor enough that it is acceptable.
Would you describe amputating an earlobe as a mutilation?
 
This right after you have accused someone else of arguing in bad faith.

Because you did. And you have no response to that accusation except to try to change the subject. Not that this comes as a surprise. And I fully expect that you will continue to try to change the subject to a semantic debate about the definition of "mutilate".

Edit: I confused kerikiwi with Rasmus. My bad.
 
Last edited:
Because you did. And you have no response to that accusation except to try to change the subject. Not that this comes as a surprise. And I fully expect that you will continue to try to change the subject to a semantic debate about the definition of "mutilate".

Where did I argue in bad faith? Are you sure you are not confusing me with someone else?
If anyone is introducing a semantic debate about definitions it is you, since you say cutting bits off is not mutilation, and you introduced the dictionary.
Why is calling a mutilation a mutilation changing the subject?
What is the subject again?
 
What is the subject again?

To be technically correct, the topic of this thread was about the legal possibility of banning circumcision in the US--in San Francisco.

Of course, the thread quickly devolved into one of many about circumcision itself... for pages and pages.

Then the thread was revived when the originators of the ballot initiative may perhaps have had other motivations behind their actions than what they originally claimed.

Now we're apparently back to arguing about circumcision... I think. :boggled:
 
Last edited:
So it's only a problem if someone dies? Well, I think you just proved that BOTH issues are not problems.

But of course, that's not true. You think circumcision is a problem even without any deaths. Which means you knew your comparison was dishonest from the start. You are, in short, quite plainly arguing in bad faith.

No, i was simply pointing out that it is far from obvious and self-evident that antisemitism is the bigger of the two problems.


You really can't figure that out yourself? I'll again credit you with dishonesty, because the alternative is worse.



You think I give a crap that you call circumcision "baby mutilation"? Hyperbole will get you nowhere with me.

cutting bits that won't grow back of people is mutilation, weather you like it or not.

ETA: Furthermore, if you want to claim that this isn't about antisemitism, you need to address the fact that some people have their babies circumcised for reasons other than religion. So by attacking "bronze age superstition", you're hardly dispelling the notion that this opposition movement is infected with antisemitism.

way to miss the point. care to try again?
 
circumcision is as much a matter of aesthetics as it is a religious tradition.

Quite. I find it annoying that parents are giving their kids cosmetic surgery.

plus, studies have shown that circumcised men are less likely to contract aids.

Oddly, only in Africa. Condoms seem like a less intrusive and more protective choice.

i have known of two boys that had major infections in their foreskins.

And I know people who have had gall bladder problems. We still don't do surgery on them at birth for it Tonsils are the same, we do surgery when we see problems arising.

it seems that circumcision has advantages.

Run those by me again :confused: ? Also, you have to compare the incidence of problems related to foreskin and the incidence of problems relating to circumcision. Besides, these advantages reek of post hoc rationalizations tossed out to defend a cultural aesthetic.
 
No, i was simply pointing out that it is far from obvious and self-evident that antisemitism is the bigger of the two problems.

I never claimed it was self-evident. But I think it is pretty obvious. So are you willing to argue that this is not the case? Because otherwise, I think my claim can pretty much stand.
 
Condoms seem like a less intrusive and more protective choice.

It's certainly a more protective choice. But it's not a choice people always make, even when they should.

And I know people who have had gall bladder problems. We still don't do surgery on them at birth for it Tonsils are the same, we do surgery when we see problems arising.

Surgery on an internal organ is hardly the equivalent of snipping a bit of external skin.

Besides, these advantages reek of post hoc rationalizations tossed out to defend a cultural aesthetic.

And the opposition campaign reeks of antisemitism.

Let me know when you want to outlaw ear piercing for minors.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom