Ban circumcision in San Fran???

so it should be ILLEGAL to do ANYTHING to a child's body, unless it is a medical neccessity?

Are you being deliberately dishonest or are you truly confused and addled?
As I mentioned earlier, this is a strawman, something you have earlier (and erroneously) accused others of creating.
Oh, and it is also a complete dodge of the question.
 
really? what purpose does the tailbone, earlobe, and appendix serve? (other than getting infected and possibly killing you)

The appendix has a variety of uses in different species (also a variety of sizes and shapes). There are some ideas about its use in humans. The earlobe is a part of the Pinna structure. The coccyx is the end of the spinal column; it has to end somewhere, right?

Like I said, a perfect being is not born with useless organs, bones, and skin.

Clearly, human beings and probably most other mammals are born somewhat "imperfect".

The argument that a baby born with foreskin is perfect, and having his foreskin removed makes him imperfect, is silly. And ignores human anatomy & biology.

It makes him less perfect than when he was born, just as tattoos, piercings, or dental work do.

Who's ignoring anatomy and biology? Mammals often have sheaths over their penises. I'm not the one deciding that millions of years of evolution are just wrong.

The only health benefits of circumcision I'm aware of (excluding rare, extreme cases) can be offset by proper hygiene. If you want to be lazy and not properly clean yourself, be my guest.
 
Last edited:
alrighty then, please tell us what procedures should be legal to perform on a child's body, even though it has no medical neccessity.

I was hoping we could avoid going the checklist route, because it's typically unnecessary when you're dealing with people who are not obtuse.

I would say that unacceptable procedures on children typically involve most (but not necessarily all) of the following:

They are permanent.
They cause pain or discomfort.
They are done without any input of the child, or in spite of the child's protest.
They serve no immediate or foreseeable medical purpose.
They are done primarily for the religious or cosmetic "benefit" of the parents.

That's all I can think of off the top of my head. If anyone can see anything that should be added or removed, let me know.

And in case it's not clear, all of those reasons apply to circumcision. Hopefully this will also cut down on the, "What about haircuts? HUH? What about them???" comments.
 
We could always flow chart it with all the important questions leading to most appropriate answer. Would that make it easier?
 
Does this include the tail bone, appendix, third-eye lids, our ear-muscles, are ability to make goose-bumps, etc etc? These are all part of the "perfect" human being?

and without these body parts, a child is now "imperfect" or "disfigured"? huh.

No? But just like a burn victim who has lost all of his hair, ears and eyebrows isn't any less 'perfect' than someone who still has all of their hair, ears and eyebrowns intact doesn't stop the burn victim of being freakishly abnormal and disgusting to look at.
 
What argument?

I think it's that new borns should be circumcised because it's impossible to tell, but I really can't be sure.
After all, Thunder has sex with condoms, whereas most people choose a human partner.
 
prove it. I have sex with condoms all the time and I feel it. I lost my virginity while wearing a condom, and I clearly felt it.

So IDB87 and I either have seriously defective penises or are lying, yes?
are you also suggesting that sex for uncircumcised men with a condom is NO different than without a condom?

Are you kidding me? Seriously? Is this what you're flailing around at now Parky?
 
So IDB87 and I either have seriously defective penises or are lying, yes?

I'm saying this: I and ALL of my Jewish friends are circumcised. All of us have very pleasurable sex lives. None of us have ever complained about not feeling anything.

Yes, when using a condom, we feel less. When we don't use a condom, we feel more.

But doesn't that go for all men, circumcised or not?
 
Last edited:
huh..

I guess this means you've given up on the debate.

Not at all. It was a joke. You know, a litle light relief....
Now, how about why is it a good idea to circumcise an infant for no medical reason rather than allowing an adult to give informed consent?
 
yes, that tells us that it is IMPOSSIBLE to say that sex with foreskin is significantly more pleasureable than without foreskin.

No. In fact, I explicitly gave you a way to analyze the pleasure involved. The fact that test is difficult doesn't negate the test. It does, however, show how a guy feels when it comes to slicing up their own healthy penis. For some reason, people stop being rational when it comes to babies.

...thank you for assissting me with my argument.

It doesn't help your argument. The risk of serious injury is still there. The lack of informed consent is still there. The lack of a sufficient medical benefit is still there.
 
No. In fact, I explicitly gave you a way to analyze the pleasure involved.

um...so because no man is willing to be circumcised simply to be a guinea pig for a test on sexual-pleasure, that means that circumcision is bad?

I hate needles. They scare me. They hurt. Does that mean needles for a blood-test are bad?


huh...interesting logic there. or something.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom