Ban circumcision in San Fran???

Ok, now that THAT is dealt with, can anyone please tell me why age of consent laws for medical procedures should be done away with, when it comes to circumcision?
 
now, what if a doctor tells a child's parents that it is in the child's best mental health interests, to be circumcised...just like his father and the rest of his community? is that enough of a reason to perform the procedure?

The doctor should probably have her medical licence revoked.

Are you now suggesting that circumcision is done to ensure social acceptance?
I'm sure you treated that suggestion with derision quite a few pages back.
 
I have no foreskin, and I think I'm doing just fine. Penis works perfectly. I see no harm in this procedure.

I've got a few family members who have smoked all their lives. They're still living. I should start smoking.

supporting the right of parents to circumcise their child, is not a stupid viewpoint.

Aside from the fact that you did exactly what I was just saying you did with such overwhelming irony, yes it is. It is a stupid viewpoint and a dangerous and disgusting one.

I'm going to try explain it to you in a different sort of way by the end of this post, maybe that logic will better resonate with you than the other points that have been made.

I'm asking you to be patient, give it a go, read it properly, and see if it makes anything shift around in your mind. If you want a fair trial, Thunder, this is my earnest attempt at giving you one, please don't throw it in my face.

so, to sums things up:

I believe in the parental right to cirumcise their son, as long as it is not to cause them harm.

So because the intention is benign, the result is acceptable by your standard? If the intention is malicious, the result is unacceptable by your standard?

That's the depth of your stance on the morality of this issue?

Parental rights are enshrined in the Civil Code of every state in the Union. Parents have the right to make decisions regarding their child's upbringing, schooling, location, health, and bodies, that the child themselves cannot legally make until they reach a certain age. This is good..and the way it should be.

Their bodies? You mean their very own bodies that are theirs and only theirs from the beginning of their life, til the end? The body which parents are there to protect as unconditional carers until the child is ready to start fending for itself? That's what a parent's job is, but nowhere in the job description does it give them any right to alter a normal body which is nor their own for no reason, no purpose, no justification whatsoever.

It disgusts me that you would so vehemently defend such an indefensible position. I'm hoping that maybe if you remove your personal connection, maybe if you looked at this issue as absorbingly as you possibly can, as objectively as you can, you would understand that altering your child's body without their consent in such a pointless, capricious, and thievish way is not something you can or should ever try to justify.

Seriously, and I really want you to consider this, here's my endpoint: what is going to go wrong if they just leave the boy to make the decision himself, about his own body (as if that point isn't immediately disqualifying enough), in the time it would take until he reaches the point where he can reasonably make that decision? Maybe 16, 18, whatever. What would the parents have given to their son or saved him from, if he were circumcised as a newborn that he would lose or miss out on by waiting until he reached that age, when all the ethical knots magically vanish?

It would be real good of you if you just answered that question, if you did it properly and honestly and in a dignified way. Think about your answer, edit it, then we'll go from there.

Deal?
 
Last edited:
So because the intention is benign, the result is acceptable by your standard? If the intention is malicious, the result is unacceptable by your standard?

that is one part of my standard, yes.

we aren't talking about cutting off a limb..or removing an eye...or removing the tongue. we are talking about a very small piece of skin here, that has not been shown to be neccessary for normal sexual activity.

Seriously, and I really want you to consider this, here's my endpoint: what is going to go wrong if they just leave the boy to make the decision himself, about his own body (as if that point isn't immediately disqualifying enough), in the time it would take until he reaches the point where he can reasonably make that decision? Maybe 16, 18, whatever. What would the parents have given to their son or saved him from, if he were circumcised as a newborn that he would lose or miss out on by waiting until he reached that age, when all the ethical knots magically vanish?

i never said that I like circumcision. I only said that I believe in parental rights, to make decisions for their children that do not cause them any serious harm, and are not intended to cause them harm.

the fact is, that Muslims & Jews circumcise their baby boys. why at such a young age? perhaps because its much more painful to do to adults..or adolescents.

do I believe it is immoral to remove your child's foreskin without his consent?

I don't know. But I do believe that just as I don't know, some other parents might believe its perfectly acceptable and moral. And until a doctor........or lots of doctors can tell me that the procedure causes a child serious and permanent harm, I'm gonna stick to parental rights.

perhaps some day I shall decide on the morality of this issue, but as of right now...I am very far from making up my mind.
 
Last edited:
that is one part of my standard, yes.

we aren't talking about cutting off a limb..or removing an eye...or removing the tongue. we are talking about a very small piece of skin here, that has not been shown to be neccessary for normal sexual activity.

No, but the quality of it, yes. And what would it matter? There's just no point, you're operating outside your rights and infringing on the personal rights of someone else to not have a part of them permanently and unnecessarily chopped off.

i never said that I like circumcision. I only said that I believe in parental rights, to make decisions for their children that do not cause them any serious harm, and are not intended to cause them harm.

the fact is, that Muslims & Jews circumcise their baby boys. why at such a young age? perhaps because its much more painful to do to adults..or adolescents.

Yes, but it's not his choice in that situation. Whereas if they just waited, no harm done, moral issues dodged regardless of whether you or I are correct, a little more pain but they'll be big boys, then there should be no problem.

do I believe it is immoral to remove your child's foreskin without his consent?

I don't know. But I do believe that just as I don't know, some other parents might believe its perfectly acceptable and moral. And until a doctor........or lots of doctors can tell me that the procedure causes a child serious and permanent harm, I'm gonna stick to parental rights.

Well how about we change up the tenses? How about "the procedure has caused a child serious and permanent harm"? Will you still stick to what you say are parental rights? A pointless and morally wrong removal of a part of someone else's body has caused many incidents of serious and simple medical complications across the world, as have been shown throughout this thread. Disregarding the real crux of the issue, is it still worth supporting anyway?

perhaps some day I shall decide on the morality of this issue, but as of right now...I am very far from making up my mind.

Well be as objective as you can, that's when things will always make the most sense, just a recommendation for your consideration. It seems to be comfortable for me, anyway, and I'm trying to give you that right now.
 
do I believe it is immoral to remove your child's foreskin without his consent?

I don't know.
Do you believe that it is immoral to deprive an adult of his foreskin without his consent? Should people have the right to deprive other adults of their foreskin without their consent?
 
babies are unable consent. does that mean we should not bathe them? not clothe them? not teach them to walk? not teach them to talk?

Red Herring!

babies are unable to consent to life-saving medical proceduders, should we therefore not perform them?
Red Herring!

a baby girl is unable to consent to clitoral reduction surgery. does that mean we should not perform it?

Yes!

when a baby is born, it very often is not breathing. because it cannot consent, does that mean we should not smack its butt to get it to cry and therefore breath? the smack causes pain, which by your logic..is harm. therefore we have no right to smack the baby's butt?

Red Herring!

Comparing life-saving procedures to medically unnecessary chopping off bits of a non-consenting person's anatomy is sheer sophistry.

It's the difference between Child Abuse and Child Caring.

You aren't even trying to make a valid argument are you?

GB
 
see, here's the thing: if you really cared about the thread, and didn't instead simply see it as an opportunity to take random, childish and useless shots at me, you would know that I answered your question the first time you asked it.

You mean like leveling unsupported charges of anti-Semitism? Anti-Islamism? Anti-Theism?

Maybe, just maybe, most of the people on this thread are Anti-Child Abuse.

GB
 
I have officially made Thunder's ignore list.
I believe this is the first time ever I have been so honoured.
Anyone who feels an unavoidable urge to paraphrase anything I post is free to do so, or is that circumventing the rules?
 
no, what's bizarre is how you consistently and purposefully fail to understand my very clear comments.

What's really bizarre is how you fail to make any clear comments...

....except for the part where you confessed you are fine with people chopping off bits of a non-consenting person's anatomy.

That was very clear.

GB
 
I have officially made Thunder's ignore list.
I believe this is the first time ever I have been so honoured.
Anyone who feels an unavoidable urge to paraphrase anything I post is free to do so, or is that circumventing the rules?

I will quote in full any post I respond to! Hopefully others will do the same.

Meanwhile, don't feel bad! It's happened to me. People only put you on their ignore list when they know they've lost the argument.

I suspect I too will make it onto Thunder's ignore list eventually.


GB
 
that is one part of my standard, yes.

we aren't talking about cutting off a limb..or removing an eye...or removing the tongue. we are talking about a very small piece of skin here, that has not been shown to be neccessary for normal sexual activity.



i never said that I like circumcision. I only said that I believe in parental rights, to make decisions for their children that do not cause them any serious harm, and are not intended to cause them harm.

the fact is, that Muslims & Jews circumcise their baby boys. why at such a young age? perhaps because its much more painful to do to adults..or adolescents.

do I believe it is immoral to remove your child's foreskin without his consent?

I don't know. But I do believe that just as I don't know, some other parents might believe its perfectly acceptable and moral. And until a doctor........or lots of doctors can tell me that the procedure causes a child serious and permanent harm, I'm gonna stick to parental rights.

perhaps some day I shall decide on the morality of this issue, but as of right now...I am very far from making up my mind.

Actually, you have made it very clear that you HAVE made up your mind. I guess you have already forgotten that you said this:

#1. I fully support clitoran reduction surgery. #2. I fully support the right of parents to decide to circumcise their male baby.
as far as FGM, I don't know that much about it yet, but I am against any surgery designed to reduce the person's sexual pleasure or sexual activity. But as far as what I see in level 1a, which simply removes the hood and leaves the clitoris alone, I guess I could maybe be ok with that.

...maybe. but it again depends on what the purpose is.

..........ok, I have now read that many women actually choose to have female circumcision level 1a, performed on themselves, in order to fully expose the clitoral hood. this suggests to me that such a procedure does not lead to a painful situation. I then read that this procedure used to be done to girls in the Western world, in order to discourage masterbation. I'm confused.

GB
 
That's not contradictory; you can think a thing is immoral but should be legal anyway.
 
that said, I disagree. I believe that when you restrict the rights of one religion, the rights of ALL religions are in danger.

So you disagree with laws and court cases that prevent Mormons from practising polygamy? How does this affect Baptists or those who adhere to traditional Native American religions?

But if history has taught us anything it's that you can restrict the rights of some religions but not put the rights of another religion in danger. The chosen denomination of the government will typically be protected from any restrictions while other religions and denominations may have restrictions placed on them.

now, what if a doctor tells a child's parents that it is in the child's best mental health interests, to be circumcised...just like his father and the rest of his community? is that enough of a reason to perform the procedure?

I say yes. The mental health of a person is just as important, and sometime even more important, than physical health.

So you see conformity as a valid reason to circumcise a child? Do you believe that this should extend to other practices if it would be in the interest of mental health?
 
What kind of society do you live in, Thunder, where communal showers are common for children, and teasing a child for having normal, natural genitals is seen as a good reason for mutilating (St Paul's word) the child?

I left school 30 years ago and our gym had individual showers in both the girls and the boys' changing rooms. My daughter's school was built in 1884 and it has individual showers in the gym block. My sons' schools, both based in Victorian buildings and recently built, all have individual showers.

Even if America is so behind the times that communal showers are still the norm, the circumcised boy is likely to be in the minority so your teasing argument is actually working against your point.

Your recent bait and switch to try to equate the normal intact penis with an abnormally enlarged clitoris isn't working either; it's coming across as if you believe the foreskin of an infant is an abnormality and I really don't think you want to go there.

An infant girl born with grossly abnormal genitalia might have surgery when she is older, but there is a wide variation on normal for both boys and girls (see our TV show Embarrassing Bodies for proof) and there is no need to subject a child to surgery which carries an inherent risk unless it's medically necessary. Social, religious and cultural reasons are not medical necessities.
 
Last edited:
the fact is, that Muslims & Jews circumcise their baby boys. why at such a young age? perhaps because its much more painful to do to adults..or adolescents.

Why at such a young age? Probably because it is more difficult to coerce an adult into making such a sacrifice. And there is no indication that it is much more painful as an adult.

As far as FGM goes, such as your big clit example, it is unlikely a doctor would suggest or perform such a surgery since it is prohibited by law to perform any type of genital alteration on an infant girl or child that is not medically therapeutic.

Girls are protected no matter the intent, no matter the degree, and no matter how it's done. Boys deserve the same respect.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom