Limiting God to the Big Bang universe.

Read the last paragraph below put in bold by yours truly.
Talk about a waste of bandwidth - what was your reason for copying your whole long, inane post if you just wanted people to focus on the last paragraph?

Or do some very personal constructive thinking on what is evidence and what is proof, and verbalize your mental fruits concisely, precisely, and clearly, giving examples of evidence as of proof.
​
And oh yay, you've gone to the trouble of reprinting the same bolded last paragraph. You prefer to waste bandwidth listening to yourself speak when you could be reading decent responses to your questions, such as the one by Loss Leader. But you won't do that, because nobody is going to agree with your definition of evidence, which is essentially "Anything that yrreg experiences which makes him think of the god he grew up with."

So, are you guys going to do some personal thinking instead of plagiarizing by the hand scoops?
People have done thinking, and they've posted examples of evidence which are more specific than "anything that leads to other things, particularly a god which is the maker of everything." Yet you would rather repeat yourself ad nauseum, continually requoting yourself, adding increasingly insulting editorial remarks, and hoping that some atheists somewhere will agree with your preschool way of thinking.
 
Talk about a waste of bandwidth - what was your reason for copying your whole long, inane post if you just wanted people to focus on the last paragraph?

And oh yay, you've gone to the trouble of reprinting the same bolded last paragraph. You prefer to waste bandwidth listening to yourself speak when you could be reading decent responses to your questions, such as the one by Loss Leader. But you won't do that, because nobody is going to agree with your definition of evidence, which is essentially "Anything that yrreg experiences which makes him think of the god he grew up with."


People have done thinking, and they've posted examples of evidence which are more specific than "anything that leads to other things, particularly a god which is the maker of everything." Yet you would rather repeat yourself ad nauseum, continually requoting yourself, adding increasingly insulting editorial remarks, and hoping that some atheists somewhere will agree with your preschool way of thinking.
Please don't insult preschoolers.
 
"Anything that yrreg experiences which makes him think of the god he grew up with."


Actually, as I understand Gerry's argument, he's not really relying on experiential data. I think he believes that the existence of God can be deduced from the very definition of the word. This is why his definition of evidence was "any knowledge that leads to any other knowledge." It doesn't require any external input.

Also, when he tries to discuss experiences he has had that he believes are divine, he tends to end up saying sexist things about women and admining his own penis. This puts him, emotionally, at about twelve years old - a time when one was generally extraordinarily selfish and preoccupied with one's own thoughts (which were turning more and more towards sex, as though you were the one who invented the concept).

This, by the way, accords with my theory that Gerry was abused terribly by a person in a position of authority. The abuse would have started just about the time his emotional development ended. In fact, the abuse would have been the thing that stunted his development.

I don't think anyone can contemplate the events that would form a personality like Gerry's without horror.
 
Actually, as I understand Gerry's argument, he's not really relying on experiential data. I think he believes that the existence of God can be deduced from the very definition of the word. This is why his definition of evidence was "any knowledge that leads to any other knowledge." It doesn't require any external input.

Also, when he tries to discuss experiences he has had that he believes are divine, he tends to end up saying sexist things about women and admining his own penis. This puts him, emotionally, at about twelve years old - a time when one was generally extraordinarily selfish and preoccupied with one's own thoughts (which were turning more and more towards sex, as though you were the one who invented the concept).

This, by the way, accords with my theory that Gerry was abused terribly by a person in a position of authority. The abuse would have started just about the time his emotional development ended. In fact, the abuse would have been the thing that stunted his development.

I don't think anyone can contemplate the events that would form a personality like Gerry's without horror.

I have assumed all along that he's trying to zero in on an ontological proof, but hopes that if he zigs and zags enough it will somehow morph into something less instantaneously dismissible.

I won't try to guess what or who might have abused Gerry in the past, but I wish he wouldn't take it out on the English language.
 
Gerry, what is your problem with this?; Evidence, as others have said before, is anything that tends to make a statement more or less true.

Proof, as has been said before, is an accumulation of evidence sufficient to convince the mind.

Is there a problem with these simple requests? Why blather on and not try to engage with someone one on one. All you have to do is personally ENGAGE instead of continuing with such a pompous attitude. Hard to move anything forward when you write everyone off just because of what they request isn't the standard you have in mind. This your problem, not ours.
 
So, are you guys going to do some personal thinking instead of plagiarizing by the hand scoops?


Yrreg

Are you going to do some actual thinking instead of believing from litter box scoops?

You didn't type in cyan as you were told. Now you must switch the "P" and "N" keys on your keyboard before typing so your posts will look like this: NEPIS.
 
Done it for him.

I am giving you an idea, but you are the ones to tell me what is for you atheists the fundamental concept of evidence and of proof in relation to the universe.

So that I can be guided to prove the existence of God according to your exposition on what is evidence and what is proof, and also your examples.

Otherwise you atheists as usual will insist that I don't have the correct ideas about evidence and proof.


Anyway, I found a website from atheists which invites people to ask them questions.

And here is my question to them:


.

.
​
No, the question is not reproduced in their website, and I hope they will answer it in public.


It is useless to talk with you people here, because you are always beating about the bush, evading the business on hand.

If any thinkers today should be the ones most keen on what is evidence and what is proof, it should be atheists, but there are so far as I have searched in the web no systematic exposition by atheists on what is the fundamental concept of evidence as of proof in relation to the universe.


Tell you what, atheists, go to very well-stocked libraries and read up on evidence and proof, and give readers here the gist of what you find in published bibliography outside the web.

That will be a great service to the cause of atheists, and also to the advancement of knowledge for mankind in the field of what is evidence and what is proof.


Or do some very personal constructive thinking on what is evidence and what is proof, and verbalize your mental fruits concisely, precisely, and clearly, giving examples of evidence as of proof.

Here in this thread.



Yrreg

SmartLX from Ask the Atheist here, nice to join you. I traced yrreg's hyperlink back here (see post #470).

I've given yrreg his answer, for all the good it'll do him. I'm too new to do my own link, but here are the guts of the piece repeated directly. As I say in the introduction, no one else is obliged to accept my definitions, so pinning you lot down isn't going to be so easy for yrreg.

In my concept, evidence and proof are indeed connected, but here’s the difference between them:
Evidence for a claim is an object, event or argument which makes the claim more likely to be true.
Proof of a claim is an object, event or argument which makes the claim certain to be true.
Therefore proof is the ultimate evidence, but evidence is not necessarily proof.

Here are five examples of evidence that would at least make me re-evaluate the probability of a claim:

- A man’s unique dental imprint on a woman’s arm would be evidence that he bit her.
- Markers appearing in the middle of the second pair of human chromosomes, which normally only appear on the ends of chromosomes, are evidence that our (ape) ancestors had one more chromosome pair at one stage, and two of them later fused together.
- A man’s amputated arm growing back seconds after he bathed in the shrine at Lourdes would be evidence for the shrine’s advertised healing properties.
- A prophecy in the Bible which predicted the day and time of three 21st century earthquakes, which then actually happened, would be evidence that its author had some prior knowledge.
- An increase in the number of Christians worldwide which coincided with a similar decrease in the number of atheists would be evidence that non-believers were converting to Christianity in large numbers. (The reality is that Christianity today mostly increases through reproduction or, in some populations unaccustomed to missionaries, at the expense of more established religions.)

Proof is a lot harder to come by. As absolutes, proofs may only exist in pure mathematics, and even then they rely on axioms which are questioned by some philosophers. Each of the following five examples, however, would be good enough for me in its own context that I would unreservedly accept the given claim:

- Seeing a gaping wound in my leg after an accident, but not feeling any pain after several hours, would be proof that I had lost the feeling in that leg. (The wait would be necessary to make sure I wasn’t simply in shock.)
- If a positive integer is divided by every positive integer between 1 and itself (non-inclusive) and none of the results are integers, that proves the integer is a prime number.
- As JBS Haldane famously said, the discovery of fossilised rabbits from the Precambrian era would prove that there was a serious flaw in the theory of evolution, given that rabbits are thought to have evolved well after the Cambrian era.
- If when we first arrived on Saturn’s moon Titan we found that a stick figure ten kilometres tall had been burnt into the surface by a laser, it would prove that intelligent life had been there before us.
- If there’s an afterlife, its existence is proved to everyone after they die through their own continued existence. (Of course, this is no help to the living.)


Cheers everyone.
- SmartLX
 
In my concept, evidence and proof are indeed connected, but here’s the difference between them:
Evidence for a claim is an object, event or argument which makes the claim more likely to be true.
Proof of a claim is an object, event or argument which makes the claim certain to be true.


Thanks to SmartLX from Ask the Atheist for an excellent take on the definitions of evidence and proof.

However, his (I'm guessing at gender) definitions are fairly imprecise. He does not account for contravening evidence, nor does the definition of proof explicitly change based on the uses of it. He implies both things in his examples, and I think the examples are excellent, but does not state them clearly.

For instance, he talks about finding a giant stick figure drawn on a distant moon, but does not mention the possibility of evidence arising that it was a joke fed into the computer by one of the astronauts and not really present on the moon, or that it was an innocent coincidence of landscape which the brain interpreted as looking like a person, such as the famous Martian "Face."

This imprecision is in no way a flaw in SmartLX's thinking. It is just the common confusion that arises in a lay person who has not specifically studied the problem and who does not use shifting definitions of proof every single day at work.

I predict, however, that Gerry will prefer his definitions to mine, because he has a website called Ask The Atheist and I don't.
 
Ta.

Thanks for the link Mojo, and thanks LL for the critique. Yeah, I'm a guy.

To respond to the instance, of course the Titan stick figure would only be proof if it were actually there and it had clearly been burnt in with a laser beam. Goes to show there's no limit to the ways what we think is proof might not be, and how carefully we have to establish it.

It's so much simpler in mathematics, where there are proofs and attempted proofs (which are simply NOT proofs) and a solid process for distinguishing between them. I presume your shifting definitions have something to do with law, LL?

Anyway, tell me if it's poor form to pry, but I don't suppose there's any indication that yrreg is Gerry Rzeppa? That would be an interesting career progression for a freelance apologist.
 
I presume your shifting definitions have something to do with law, LL?


You presume correctly. The definition of proof can change four times in a single criminal trial.


Anyway, tell me if it's poor form to pry, but I don't suppose there's any indication that yrreg is Gerry Rzeppa?


There is no chance. If you look at just a handful of Yrreg's posts here (even at random), you will quickly see that this is a person utterly incapable of producing Rzeppa's writings. He's probably incapable of reading Rzeppa's writings.
 
Anyway, tell me if it's poor form to pry, but I don't suppose there's any indication that yrreg is Gerry Rzeppa? That would be an interesting career progression for a freelance apologist.


It would probably be considered poor form, yes. And it is a violation of the JREF membership agreement to post another user's personal information, so it might not be wise to even make guesses. All that said, as Loss Leader has already mentioned, Gerry Rzeppa, even if seriously misguided about reality, seems to be a reasonably articulate person. Yrreg, not so much.
 
Well to bring it all together then, the poster "yrreg"s name is evidence that someone typed a sequence of letters, and only speculation that they indeed mean to spell "Gerry" backwards.

It is not proof that he is Gerry Rzeppa however.
 
Let's cooperate, SmartLX, calmly: concisely, precisely, clearly thus productively.

Here is my fundamental concept of evidence for man in relation to the universe:


Anything man knows leading him to know another thing.​

What do you guys say?




Yrreg

[...]

In my concept, evidence and proof are indeed connected, but here’s the difference between them:
Evidence for a claim is an object, event or argument which makes the claim more likely to be true.
Proof of a claim is an object, event or argument which makes the claim certain to be true.
Therefore proof is the ultimate evidence, but evidence is not necessarily proof.

Here are five examples of evidence that would at least make me re-evaluate the probability of a claim:

- A man’s unique dental imprint on a woman’s arm would be evidence that he bit her.
- Markers appearing in the middle of the second pair of human chromosomes, which normally only appear on the ends of chromosomes, are evidence that our (ape) ancestors had one more chromosome pair at one stage, and two of them later fused together.
- A man’s amputated arm growing back seconds after he bathed in the shrine at Lourdes would be evidence for the shrine’s advertised healing properties.
- A prophecy in the Bible which predicted the day and time of three 21st century earthquakes, which then actually happened, would be evidence that its author had some prior knowledge.
- An increase in the number of Christians worldwide which coincided with a similar decrease in the number of atheists would be evidence that non-believers were converting to Christianity in large numbers. (The reality is that Christianity today mostly increases through reproduction or, in some populations unaccustomed to missionaries, at the expense of more established religions.)

Proof is a lot harder to come by. As absolutes, proofs may only exist in pure mathematics, and even then they rely on axioms which are questioned by some philosophers. Each of the following five examples, however, would be good enough for me in its own context that I would unreservedly accept the given claim:

- Seeing a gaping wound in my leg after an accident, but not feeling any pain after several hours, would be proof that I had lost the feeling in that leg. (The wait would be necessary to make sure I wasn’t simply in shock.)
- If a positive integer is divided by every positive integer between 1 and itself (non-inclusive) and none of the results are integers, that proves the integer is a prime number.
- As JBS Haldane famously said, the discovery of fossilised rabbits from the Precambrian era would prove that there was a serious flaw in the theory of evolution, given that rabbits are thought to have evolved well after the Cambrian era.
- If when we first arrived on Saturn’s moon Titan we found that a stick figure ten kilometres tall had been burnt into the surface by a laser, it would prove that intelligent life had been there before us.
- If there’s an afterlife, its existence is proved to everyone after they die through their own continued existence. (Of course, this is no help to the living.)


Cheers everyone.
- SmartLX


.​
You say:
Evidence for a claim is an object, event or argument which makes the claim more likely to be true.​

And I say:
Anything man knows leading him to know another thing.​

Now, to reduce the number of words you use and still retain the thought you want to communicate, instead of saying:
"Evidence for a claim is an object, event or argument,"​

You say:
"Anything man knows,"​

And instead of:
"which makes the claim more likely to be true,"​

You say:
leading him to know another thing.​


So, what do you say now?

Can you or can you not say what you want to say in fewer words and simpler ones and in a more encapsulating way: the depth and height and breadth of what is the fundamental concept of evidence for man in relation to the universe?


We, you and I, if I may submit, want to see things in the most deep, most high, and most wide perspectives of evidence (as of everything else), namely, in its fundamental concept for man in relation to the universe.


Hope you get my drift.




Yrreg
 
now, to reduce the number of words you use and still retain the thought you want to communicate, instead of saying:
"evidence for a claim is an object, event or argument,"​

you say:
"anything man knows,"​

and instead of:
"which makes the claim more likely to be true,"​

you say:
leading him to know another thing.​

so, what do you say now?


Are You Rule10ing Kidding Me?
 
Last edited:

.​
You say:
Evidence for a claim is an object, event or argument which makes the claim more likely to be true.​

And I say:
Anything man knows leading him to know another thing.​

Now, to reduce the number of words you use and still retain the thought you want to communicate, instead of saying:
"Evidence for a claim is an object, event or argument,"​

You say:
"Anything man knows,"​

And instead of:
"which makes the claim more likely to be true,"​

You say:
leading him to know another thing.​


So, what do you say now?

Can you or can you not say what you want to say in fewer words and simpler ones and in a more encapsulating way: the depth and height and breadth of what is the fundamental concept of evidence for man in relation to the universe?


We, you and I, if I may submit, want to see things in the most deep, most high, and most wide perspectives of evidence (as of everything else), namely, in its fundamental concept for man in relation to the universe.


Hope you get my drift.




Yrreg

Yrreg, are you deliberately lying here, or do you genuinely just not understand why everything you've just posted is wrong?
 
Are You Rule10ing Kidding Me?

Makes you wonder, doesn't it? We have to remember yrreG's control issues. He has to make other people say his words. Kinda creepy.



yrreG, here are fewer words: gods are made up. Even yours.

What do you say now? Do you get my drift?
 
Are You Rule10ing Kidding Me?


I think it demonstrates what most of us have known since our earliest interactions with Pachomius, yrreg, oslove, or whatever might be his nickname du jour. There is a fundamental flaw in his ability to construct an honest argument or engage in an honest discussion. Rather than even recognize that SmartLX is refining the definition of evidence and proof, attempting to move the conversation forward, yrreg blatantly and dishonestly changes the meaning of SmartLX's comment. This is a despicable method of constructing an argument. Sadly it appears to be common practice among the most fervently faithful Christians.
 

.​
You say:
Evidence for a claim is an object, event or argument which makes the claim more likely to be true.​

And I say:
Anything man knows leading him to know another thing.​

Now, to reduce the number of words you use and still retain the thought you want to communicate, instead of saying:
"Evidence for a claim is an object, event or argument,"​

You say:
"Anything man knows,"​

And instead of:
"which makes the claim more likely to be true,"​

You say:
leading him to know another thing.​


So, what do you say now?

<snip>



No, that is NOT what he is saying, yrreg.

Stop with your self-superior regulations on character count. You are the last person who should be posing restrictions on word use, what with your constant redundant repetitions and unnecessarily awkward phrasing.

Words have meaning, yrreg, and you can't simply re-define words to suit your purpose.

Why don't I just simplify your definition even further, and say you define evidence as "anything"?
The answer is because it makes the definition so vague as to be worse than useless. Much like your 'definition' of god, in point of fact.

SmartLX answered your post. Many people in this thread have done the same. But all you want to do is play your condescending word games.

Grow up.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom