Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
That's why we need to do meta-analyses in the first place.

Joey, Here's a meta-analysis for you, showing that out of 48 treatment options, AA and 12 Step facilitation ranked 37th and 38th in effectiveness. I still can't post links yet, so just add the www to behaviortherapy.com/whatworks.htm
 
It's just up there ^^^ you are saying I'm disagreeing with myself. No, I was telling you what the study concluded. This is clear, you saw one thing you could possible use against me and....

That's not a strawman by any stretch. I had an idea you didn't really know that. You might have called it quote mining, but you didn't. I honestly wanted you to clear up what I thought was a contradiction in your own argument. Not trying to attack you, there is a difference. ;)

No, what I'm saying is that the program of AA, the mental technology, the belief systems, all of that, isn't what helps you get sober, and the last 20 years of research have shown that. It's the social aspects, and that's exactly what the researchers just said.

This part I agree with completely, and is pretty much what I have been saying.
 
AA does offer that community support, but the nature of the program fosters a very unhealthy dynamic among members that seems to do more harm than good, ultimately.
Exactly, why can't someone just take control over the whole thing and make it professional? We need change. Get Obama in there, he's a good community organizer :p

Worst story I ever heard was board meeting or something where many veterans with +5 years got into a huge argument over management and everybody went out and got drunk! :confused:
 
Exactly, why can't someone just take control over the whole thing and make it professional? We need change. Get Obama in there, he's a good community organizer :p

Worst story I ever heard was board meeting or something where many veterans with +5 years got into a huge argument over management and everybody went out and got drunk! :confused:

To restate something I said earlier, the best way to force AA to change would be for a really good and effective alternative to become popular. I really don't think AA is going to change on its own.
 
That's not a strawman by any stretch. I had an idea you didn't really know that. You might have called it quote mining, but you didn't. I honestly wanted you to clear up what I thought was a contradiction in your own argument. Not trying to attack you, there is a difference. ;)
"A straw man is a component of an argument and is an informal fallacy based on misrepresentation of an opponent's position" So you were misrepresenting my position by suggesting my clarification on what the conclusions of a study were meant that I think it trumps any other science on AA effectiveness.

This part I agree with completely, and is pretty much what I have been saying
yay!
 
Why would I mean that? Why would I limit your evidence? Provide whatever evidence you like, even anecdotal, for your claim that threads like these have discouraged people from checking AA out.
No evidence other than my understanding of human nature, so we can just leave it "imo". Drunks I've known were already great at finding confirmation bias as to why they didn't need to stop drinking. IMO again, the It's a Relgion! meme just presents those want it another red herring.

That we have provided some of our evidence in a form you don't agree with is no barrier to you presenting yours, whatever it may be. Let us evaluate it, please, as you have evaluated ours.
I'd say nothing here has ever exceeded anecdotal, and too much of that is from people who state they are not alcoholics and have never attended an AA meeting.

The only anecdote I share is my own, and credit AA much more than rehab, psychiatry, or medical science in my continuing one-day-at-a-time recovery, and also note that in the parts of the world I'm acquainted with AA is the only no-cost, readily available, program available.



And as I have been for the many here who share this accomplishment, I am proud of and pleased for you. :D May you continue in good health.
Thank you. :)
 
No evidence other than my understanding of human nature, so we can just leave it "imo". Drunks I've known were already great at finding confirmation bias as to why they didn't need to stop drinking. IMO again, the It's a Relgion! meme just presents those want it another red herring.

Yeah, but Al, if I'm telling the truth when I say it's a religiously oriented program (and I firmly feel I am), it's simply not my fault that some drunks are going to use that as an excuse to stay in their cups. By that token, they'll use anything they can, because they aren't yet serious about getting sober. Not my fault, not this thread's fault.


Thank you. :)

You're more than welcome. :)
 
I found, and most also seem to find, AA meetings as religiously oriented -- or not -- as one personally desires.

Hard-core atheists comprise some very small fraction of AA attendees, and I hope they find some other cost effective treatment that suits. I'd say it'll be a cold day in hell before AA declares itself "non-spiritual"; and if one wants religion, go to church.
 
No. I have seen dozens of drunk people inside meetings, I have never seen anyone asked to leave. In fact, at one meeting we had three men in the back row opening their stubbies in the meeting; they brought their own.

Wow, if by stubbies you mean beer or other alcohol, wow. that is a very tolerant meeting. I think most groups will not tolerate you drinking, I know some groups ask people to leave who are intoxicated.
 
But that's my point too. That the anti-psych is not "the program" either. AA does not advocate this despite the hollow and fact free claims of others.

As stated earlier not interfering in medical treatmen could become a tradition, my claims were not empty they reflected the experience of myself and many people. There are meetings and members who discourage pcyhiatric treatment.

Whcih is why I think a tradition would not hurt.
 
Oh I don't know. Perhaps something that proves that AA (not some members) are anti-psychiatry. :rolleyes:
Maybe:
- letters from central office.
- official correspondence.
- even big book references (in context) might even nudge it.
- grapevine articles might do it.
- website statements.
- offical policy documents - maybe you should ask Tinyal to get them from the secret archives (lol).
- surely it's in the suggested steps and traditions? What's that? It isn't!? Well I'll be ....!

As I say, anything that shows AA is not anti-psych.

You see, I can show anecdotally too that AA is pro-psych and pro-meds simply by usung the same level standards that you do. Anecdotes are evidence, but they are very very weak.

It's your claim mate, the onus of proof is on you.

I stated clearly that I have found it to be a widespread problem amongst members, and AA could remedy it by a new traditions taht says members should stay out of each others medical treatment.

I have heard peopel say it at meetings, I have heard peopel rationalize why peopel should not seek psychiatric treatement at meetings, I have had clients who reported they were discouraged from treatment. I have heard many many people at meetings talk about how certain anxioltics will mimic alcohol dependance.

That is why a new tradition would be a good remedy.
 
Amazing, thank you!

http://www.behaviortherapy.com/whatworks.htm

A picture perfect view of some of the things AA fails to pay attention to or willfully ignores.

Not really.

That link discusses drinking problems which vary in severity, not alcoholism which is a severe malady.

The therapy the have ranked first is basically a visit to your family doctor which is laughable.

Also, many of those "treatments" receiving a higher grade than A.A. are routinely cited at meetings as being an abysmal failure, hence the participants presence at an A.A. meeting in the first place.

As Al Bell said above, I've also tried many of those remedies listed and the results were negligible at best.

Personal experiences isn't the greatest proof, I know that, but I'll be sober 3 years this July thanks to the help of A.A and in my own little insignificant world, that's all that matters.

ETA- Wanted to clarify the distinction between drinking a little too much and full blown alcoholism.
 
Last edited:
That link discusses drinking problems which vary in severity, not alcoholism which is a severe malady.

This is the old "real alcoholic" circular argument. It goes like this: AA works for real alcoholics. How do you know you're a real alcoholic? AA works for real alcoholics.

There is simply no point of reference outside of Alcoholics Anonymous for concepts like "real alcoholic" and "sobriety." So studies research cannot possibly account for those concepts -- there's no point of reference -- because they're simply AA lingo.
 
What a thread! A year long voyage into the AA rabbit hole of circular logic, fallacious arguments and ridiculous rationalizations. Alfie is quite the tour guide!

I haven't read this whole thread, because I don't hate myself, and asking what AA is, is like asking "how long is a string?" There are just too many conceptions of what it is, with each one being whackadoodle crazy in its own special way.

The question is not "is it religious?" (It is) The real question is: "which brand of AA religion do you subscribe to?"

You've got your AA fundies, who believe the AA 'Big Book' is infallable scripture. They go for the "God as you understand Him" god; the first 164 pages of the 'Big Book' is AA; and if you aren't working the steps, you aren't doing AA. Their god is the AA God, who for some reason fixates on the spiritual deficiencies alcoholics, while ignoring the plight of people like cancer and famine victims.

You've got your new age, hippie, Unitarian type of AAs. They go for the "god of your understanding," which is a subtle but an important re-wording of step 2, and which allows for a person to use a houseplant or a donkey as their higher power. This is the "spiritual AA."

Remember: Donkey = Spiritual; and an AA God who dotes over alcoholics, but didn't give a **** about them before they started going to meetings = Religious. But they're both really religious, because the Donkey and old-school AA God are both asked to perform exactly the same tasks (removing shortcomings, randomly performing "miracles" on the flock, removing resentments, etc.)

Then, of course, you've got everything in between.

One thing I do know. You'll never get a true believer to concede it is what it is.
 
Wow, you sure managed to find some crummy groups. Either that or you didn't understand anything you read or heard.

So sorry. Did you actually have a drinking problem? If so did you find something that helped?
 
Great Comments, both Jack and Ilsita - you both make excellent valid points (points, I might add, that myself, GB, Sling, and others have been making to one degree or another elsewhere in this thread).

As I've said in the past, a lot (if not all) of the harm & ineffectiveness of AA comes from it being a woo based program - the fact that the AA program (unchanged in nearly 80 years) considers alcoholism a spiritual disease whose only cure is a spiritual solution. (and no, I'm not going to repost - yet again - the data I based AA's harm [ex: increased binge drinking] & ineffectiveness [aprox 95% failure rate] - this info is elsewhere in this thread).

In my several decades of attending 1000's of meetings I've noticed an increase in the 'take what you can and leave the rest' statement - a statement unsupported by the AA program as written in it's core material (the big book & the 12x12). I've heard many people report to me that phrase started creeping into AA as more and more people came from treatment centers directly into AA - prior to 1989, I'd never heard it before. Such phrasing is still frequently shot down at many, many of the meetings I've attended recently, typically by those with more than 15 yrs sober time. They usually respond with some form of 'rarely have we found a person fail who has thoroughly followed our path' - concentration on the 'thoroughly'.

As far as this thread goes, I believe the question of AA's religious nature has been answered - positively. At some point I'll move to the next thread on this subject, whether I create it or someone else does (though I'm working on posting one on the cult nature of AA, as well as trying to answer the question 'what part of AA is worth saving - if any?').

We'll see if I have the time soon to start (and support) such a thread.

In the meantime, carry on :)
 
This is the old "real alcoholic" circular argument. It goes like this: AA works for real alcoholics. How do you know you're a real alcoholic? AA works for real alcoholics.

There is simply no point of reference outside of Alcoholics Anonymous for concepts like "real alcoholic" and "sobriety." So studies research cannot possibly account for those concepts -- there's no point of reference -- because they're simply AA lingo.

Oh boy here we go the strawman, this thread never changes.

Did you even read the contents of the link you posted?

One of the criteria used to measure the effectiveness of each treatment is labelled:

"Mean Severity of Treatment Population"

Any idea how they arrive at those numbers?
 
What a thread! A year long voyage into the AA rabbit hole of circular logic, fallacious arguments and ridiculous rationalizations. Alfie is quite the tour guide!

I haven't read this whole thread, because I don't hate myself, and asking what AA is, is like asking "how long is a string?" There are just too many conceptions of what it is, with each one being whackadoodle crazy in its own special way.

The question is not "is it religious?" (It is) The real question is: "which brand of AA religion do you subscribe to?"

You've got your AA fundies, who believe the AA 'Big Book' is infallable scripture. They go for the "God as you understand Him" god; the first 164 pages of the 'Big Book' is AA; and if you aren't working the steps, you aren't doing AA. Their god is the AA God, who for some reason fixates on the spiritual deficiencies alcoholics, while ignoring the plight of people like cancer and famine victims.

You've got your new age, hippie, Unitarian type of AAs. They go for the "god of your understanding," which is a subtle but an important re-wording of step 2, and which allows for a person to use a houseplant or a donkey as their higher power. This is the "spiritual AA."

Remember: Donkey = Spiritual; and an AA God who dotes over alcoholics, but didn't give a **** about them before they started going to meetings = Religious. But they're both really religious, because the Donkey and old-school AA God are both asked to perform exactly the same tasks (removing shortcomings, randomly performing "miracles" on the flock, removing resentments, etc.)

Then, of course, you've got everything in between.

One thing I do know. You'll never get a true believer to concede it is what it is.

I've been in A.A for three years and never experienced anything close to what you're describing, sorry it didn't work for you.
 
Not really.

That link discusses drinking problems which vary in severity, not alcoholism which is a severe malady.
Great, that's why AA should be paying attention them as well then, they don't know how to help people with varying degrees of problems. Also, I wasn't aware that there were kinds of alcoholism that aren't alcoholism.

Similarly in 1979 an expert World Health Organisation committee disfavoured the use of "alcoholism" as a diagnostic entity, preferring the category of "alcohol dependence syndrome" wiki

I'll let Ali Jaffe, phD addiction researcher, former abstainer explain for context.

Calling ******** on addiction treatment bullies
The "my way or the highway" version of addiction treatment is simply wrong


How many people leave AA, get themselves together and a drink normally for the rest of their lives? A lot. Part of the problem is what is "true alcoholic" and how do you distinguish? A disorder of the reward system, quite a malady, but a complex diagnosis, surely. I've heard that if you can go into the bar, have one drink, and not compulsively continue, you're not an alcoholic. That's literally how it is explained to some people in the program, I don't know how often. This is obviously ********...

The therapy the have ranked first is basically a visit to your family doctor which is laughable.
Why? If you have a good relationship with them and they are knowledgeable it helps people. The whole "doctors don't understand alcoholism" thing is so 1939. A doctor isn't a support group of fellow abstainers, but they are valuable, not laughable.

Also, many of those "treatments" receiving a higher grade than A.A. are routinely cited at meetings as being an abysmal failure, hence the participants presence at an A.A. meeting in the first place.

As Al Bell said above, I've also tried many of those remedies listed and the results were negligible at best.
Could be true for the people you talked to, doesn't mean they don't work for others with varying degrees of alcoholism or different genetic make-ups or whatever. There was a weight of evidence attached to those numbers...

Personal experiences isn't the greatest proof, I know that, but I'll be sober 3 years this July thanks to the help of A.A and in my own little insignificant world, that's all that matters.
That's awesome, hearing that success or hearing of birthdays in the program always lifts my heart. It has also helped several members of my family (or so they say ;) ) I've said before, I wouldn't dare to tell them to leave the program. I made my concerns known and surprisingly they agreed that these things were true and it was wacky but they just wanted to stay sober and help others so they put up with it for now, one day at a time.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom