Should Registration for the the Military Draft in the USA be Abolished?

Selective Service registration has been in place for 30 years, and still no draft. I don't think it makes a big difference. If it ever comes to implementing the draft, we'll have the names ready. But even if there were no registration, we could still find them and draft them in a hurry.
 
I would at least repeal the Solomon Amendment that makes receiving federal financial aid for college conditioned on providing proof of registration. Seems like a substantial intrusion for dubious benefit.
 
No. Personally I think we should have mandatory conscription for all. No deferments for being rich. It might keep us from spending another 10 years in a dusty ass poppy field, if every family in America had to draw for the shortest straw.

That guy that just got the medal of honor has served 8 tours...6 in the poppy fields, and 2 in the oil fields, that's too many.
 
Why bother? We clearly can no longer afford to have a military at all. We should already be selling off all our slightly-used weaponry to the highest bidders, while simultaneously pulling precipitiously out of Iraq and Afghanistan, preferably before the drop-dead date of August 2.

But we should keep all the nukes and submarines, thereby guaranteeing that the next war, should we be forced into another one, WILL be nuclear. That should squinch up some monkey sphincters.
 
No. Personally I think we should have mandatory conscription for all. No deferments for being rich. It might keep us from spending another 10 years in a dusty ass poppy field, if every family in America had to draw for the shortest straw.

That guy that just got the medal of honor has served 8 tours...6 in the poppy fields, and 2 in the oil fields, that's too many.

So your position is that not only should those who don't want a career in the military be forced to do it for a couple of years, but that those who do want to make a career out of it should be forced to quit?
 
So your position is that not only should those who don't want a career in the military be forced to do it for a couple of years, but that those who do want to make a career out of it should be forced to quit?
Hey, baby, that's freedom*!

*Your idea of freedom may vary from that of the "social justice" crowd. No guarantee of satisfaction with the extent of your freedom is expressed or implied. Consult your physician before use.
 
Why bother? We clearly can no longer afford to have a military at all. We should already be selling off all our slightly-used weaponry to the highest bidders, while simultaneously pulling precipitiously out of Iraq and Afghanistan, preferably before the drop-dead date of August 2.

But we should keep all the nukes and submarines, thereby guaranteeing that the next war, should we be forced into another one, WILL be nuclear. That should squinch up some monkey sphincters.

I'll take it!
 
The Militia Act of 1903 is what you'd need to repeal. If you think the draft is bad, get this:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Militia_(United_States)#The_reserve_militia

All able bodied men, 17 to 45 of age, are ultimately eligible to be called up into military service and belong to the class known as the Reserve Militia, also known as the sedentary militia.

Even after you're too old for the usual selective service system, if they really want to they can draft you anyway.

(edit)This is also why the "guns are only for the militia" argument gun control advocates use would really only keep guns away from women.
 
Peace Through Hostages

Peace Through Hostages

Use an executive order to implement the draft.

Draft all the eligible family members of the Congress And Senate.

Draft all the eligible family members of the CEO's and managers of the top 20 defense firms.

The tradition back in Roman times was to exchange ruling class family members to ensure the peace.

It's an oldie, but a goodie.
 
Last edited:
Repealed?? We should have a new amendment REQUIRING a draft if war is declared. Then maybe the powers that be wouldnt be so quick to invade other countries.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom