gold bull/bear survey

Where do you think the gold price is going?


  • Total voters
    138
OK, I can see the reasons for possible confusion. I'm not interested in short-term trading positions. I'm only interested in big pictures and longer timescales, where "long" means the next 18 months to two years. After that, my crystal ball doesn't seem to be functioning very well.

I don't see any confusion, only that you think you have a crystal ball for up to 18 months, but no more.


.
 
I have real time quotes and data.

Gold fell roughly (depending on what you use -- futures, continuous contracts, cash market, etc) from almost $1100 to almost $700 in 2008.

I'm not sure how what your saying here addresses my rather simple question to UE.


.
Just that I don't see anything even worth discussing on the price of gold in 2008, except that it was the beginning of a stage of higher volatility in price...compared to the prior 5 years.

year high low dif %dif
2011 1760 1302 458 135.18%
2010 1421 1058 363 134.31%
2009 1213 810 403 149.75%
2008 1011 712 299 141.99%
 
....

Yes, but the bullion dealer is running a business which does not depend on hoodwinking its clients. The truth is this: if the people selling their gold to these people knew what they could get for it from an honest dealer, then they wouldn't be selling it to the scammers.

I am not stuck with a buyback arrangement. Gold has just returned to its rightful place as the world's primary reserve currency. Why on Earth would I be restricted to selling it back to the dealer I bought it from?

Where did you get that idea from? Why are you scaremongering people??

....

You are stuck in a buyback arrangement. Try selling your gold right now at the spot price (net of 2%) to a different dealer. Each example you yourself posted explained amply that their guarantee was purely a buyback agreement and that you better not have scraped or defaced the bullion in any way or they'll charge you for holding it and resmelting it.

I have patiently explained to you that there are two distinct business models. The one you latched onto is the one appealing to net buyers of which you have explained you are one. Tippit is another. You people buy it and buy it and buy it and don't sell it.

The second model, the one you airily dismiss, is for net sellers of gold. You have amply explained that you are not a net seller although you claim to know what a net seller ought to experience. You have no evidence to support your claim because your personal experience is only as a net purchaser.

If you don't know how gold marketing works then you should ask someone who does know instead of posting stuff from websites that clearly does not support your claims.

Your last paragraphs support only your strong faith in a reserve currency that was obsolete two generations ago. This is why I know I can always sell gold to you at a premium and promise to repay you at a modest discount. I book the revenue and you hold onto your faith.
 
Just that I don't see anything even worth discussing on the price of gold in 2008, except that it was the beginning of a stage of higher volatility in price...compared to the prior 5 years.

year high low dif %dif
2011 1760 1302 458 135.18%
2010 1421 1058 363 134.31%
2009 1213 810 403 149.75%
2008 1011 712 299 141.99%

Volatility is just one part of the equation but I'm glad to see a goldbug understanding that this is a measure of risk. From what I gather you and djpar deal only in the derivatives and not the underlying commodity. Am I right about that?
 
Volatility is just one part of the equation but I'm glad to see a goldbug understanding that this is a measure of risk. From what I gather you and djpar deal only in the derivatives and not the underlying commodity. Am I right about that?

First, relative to your prior post, there is no issue whatsoever here with the local gold merchant buying identifiable coins whether you bought them from him or not. There is of course an issue with bars since they require assaying.

Second, you don't know who or what a gold bug is. No offense intended.

Dijar from what I've seen is a quite astute investor. As for me, I'd comment that the nature of a "diversified portfolio" has dramatically changed since 2007/2008.

Third, the numbers that I posted were not "volatility", unless you consider it strictly in the upward direction.....

Fourth, the dramatic change in trending in the last 30 days, in which gold and other commodities have shot in opposite directions, is quite alarming. As far as "reading trends".

Fifth, a general comment. The increase in value of gold of the last 3 years is in accordance with the predicted results of fundamentals investing.
 
Goldprise will come down significantly in a few years i heard.
 
You are stuck in a buyback arrangement. Try selling your gold right now at the spot price (net of 2%) to a different dealer. Each example you yourself posted explained amply that their guarantee was purely a buyback agreement and that you better not have scraped or defaced the bullion in any way or they'll charge you for holding it and resmelting it.

This is completely absurd. The gold I own is in the form of British sovereigns and half sovereigns. These are legal tender in the UK. That is why no VAT is payable on them, and why no capital gains tax is charged on them. They have been coins of the realm, exactly the same as they are today, since Queen Victoria was on the throne. You are seriously trying to convince the people reading this thread that I am stuck in a buyback arrangement? As for "scrapes", the coins I bought are mixed year bullion coins in good to fair condition - they are of no interest to coin collectors, and nobody is recording how scraped the coins are. Nobody is going to refuse to accept them because they are scraped and deliberately defacing them is illegal in the UK.

Right now, I expect that just about any bullion dealer in the country would buy those coins off me at near to spot price. I'd be bonkers to sell them if I don't have to, and the dealer would be well aware of this.

Last week it was still possible to buy gold by post for next day delivery in the UK. This week it is not, because the dealers are both running out of bullion and quite happy to sit on any remaining stock because they know where the price is going.

Your last paragraphs support only your strong faith in a reserve currency that was obsolete two generations ago.

You could not be more wrong. The bullmarket in gold has just entered a new and much more powerful phase. It is not gold but the US dollar which is about to become obsolete.

http://www.zerohedge.com/news/cme-h...d-ignores-completely-resumes-climb-above-1800

CME have just made a desperate attempt to get the price under control buy hiking the margins. This worked for silver in May. It has failed today for gold. The price is now heading rapidly towards $2000. How quick is it going to get there? The way things look at the moment, it could be before the end of this month. It could be next week. And it won't stop there.
 
Last edited:
.....You could not be more wrong. The bullmarket in gold has just entered a new and much more powerful phase. It is not gold but the US dollar which is about to become obsolete.

http://www.zerohedge.com/news/cme-h...d-ignores-completely-resumes-climb-above-1800

CME have just made a desperate attempt to get the price under control buy hiking the margins. This worked for silver in May. It has failed today for gold. The price is now heading rapidly towards $2000. .....

Well, as long as the predication of a rosy future for gold is based on investing on fundamentals, I'm in agreement. But the fundamentals are the entire basket of currencies, say for the G20, and they are all sinking although at different rates.

Generally speaking, a focus on gold isn't optimum. Shifts in consumer choices will not be toward gold, but toward "better currency instead of worse currency", or the same for trade goods.

On this subject may I suggest Hyack's essay?

http://mises.org/books/choice_in_currency_hayek.pdf
 
Just that I don't see anything even worth discussing on the price of gold in 2008, except that it was the beginning of a stage of higher volatility in price...compared to the prior 5 years.

year high low dif %dif
2011 1760 1302 458 135.18%
2010 1421 1058 363 134.31%
2009 1213 810 403 149.75%
2008 1011 712 299 141.99%

I'm more inclined to see Gold, and to a minor extent Silver, as a hedge against uncertainty.

I don't believe Gold is rallying due to the threat of hyper-inflation. It is rallying equally in all currencies. I think by looking at bond yields, commodity prices, etc. the markets are not pricing in any threat of hyper-inflation.

That is not to say that one can rule out hyper-inflation in $US. I would never suppose to do that, but at the present time it seems the least likely near-term event.

My point about 2008 is that there is a lot of uncertainty and there can be liquidity issues where participants have demonstrated already that they are willing to sell Gold.

You can characterize it as throwing the baby out with the bath water, and I would not argue against that. After all, I have already stated that I think the 3-5 year outlook for metals is that we are still going higher.



.
 
Volatility is just one part of the equation but I'm glad to see a goldbug understanding that this is a measure of risk. From what I gather you and djpar deal only in the derivatives and not the underlying commodity. Am I right about that?

Short answer is no.

I've already mentioned that I have been invested in funds (mining stocks, etc), ETF's, futures and physical.

I got out of everything except the physical and that's because I live in Panama and the physical is in the US. Plus, it's not as easy as entering an order to sell electronically. :)


.
 
Heard from who? Somebody who has lots of paper assets and no gold, by any chance?

Be very careful who you believe...

from alleged experts on CNN and other TV chanels.

i have no gold anymore, and do not plan to buy any. so i dont worry if its right or not. i just noticed that it is something that gets more mentioned since a few weeks, sometimes they even talk about the goldbubble.
 
I'm more inclined to see Gold, and to a minor extent Silver, as a hedge against uncertainty.

I don't believe Gold is rallying due to the threat of hyper-inflation. It is rallying equally in all currencies. I think by looking at bond yields, commodity prices, etc. the markets are not pricing in any threat of hyper-inflation.

That is not to say that one can rule out hyper-inflation in $US. I would never suppose to do that, but at the present time it seems the least likely near-term event.....
I'd have to pull a couple books down and peruse the footnotes but IIRC no market, say a bond market, has EVER in the incipient stages correctly factored hyperinflation.

Not to say it is a "black swan", it is anything but that. The reasons are psychological.
 
I'd have to pull a couple books down and peruse the footnotes but IIRC no market, say a bond market, has EVER in the incipient stages correctly factored hyperinflation.

Not to say it is a "black swan", it is anything but that. The reasons are psychological.

If I understand you correctly, I'd agree.

I would never tie my opinion on the prospects of hyper-inflation to one market. I listed a couple things I think would not be in-line with hyper-inflation, but left a lot unsaid.

I may be wrong, but I think the US is having a difficult time even maintaining the current level of inflation let alone having to face hyper-inflation.

But hey, I'm willing to change my mind based on the data. I don't have any real ideology on politics or economics that I'm wedded to. I just want to make the best investment decisions. :D


If you do pull down those books, I'd be interested in hearing what you find.



.
 
COMEX has started raising trading margins on gold in an attempt to control the price. Should be interesting to see what happens next.

Question for the bears: what is a fair non-bubble price for gold? where do you think it would/will fall to if/when the bubble bursts?
 
Undercover Elephant is a goldbug.

please define: goldbug ? - and presumably then, you are a paperbug?

also, could a couple of the 45 odd Gold bears express opinions on this question from page 3 please?


re the Poll results, I would also like to ask any of the people who voted "bear" what circumstances they envision driving the price down again?

ie massive deflationary crash (or grind) downwards dragging the price down

or slow recessionary pressure and people realising that it is just yellow metal that you cant eat after all?

or what exactly?

does anybody think we're (global economy) going to recover and pull back to relative economic health without too much major drama, and that will be the cause?
 
Last edited:
COMEX has started raising trading margins on gold in an attempt to control the price. Should be interesting to see what happens next.

Question for the bears: what is a fair non-bubble price for gold? where do you think it would/will fall to if/when the bubble bursts?

well, am obviously not a bear, but I think after the actual bubble and mania some way down the line yet, it conceivably could fall back down as low as $3-5k in new USDollars or equivalent.
 
Last edited:
also, could a couple of the 45 odd Gold bears express opinions on this question from page 3 please?

I didn't vote in the poll -- didn't even view the results -- mostly because none of the options quite capture my outlook (ie; 1-2 year weakness, but 3-5 year still bull market).

I think I gave a meager scenario in this post, but I really don't even care what the after-the-fact explanations may look like.

If it happens, armchair explanations will abound.

I know you're probably looking for more detailed causal reasons, but I'm just trying to make money. (I would like to think that this is everyone's goal, but I'm know better).



.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom