All of You, Who Once Believed in 9/11 Truth, Share Your Experiences

Is anyone here or knows who:

1) Began this 9/11 journey as an educated non-truther and switched to a truther.

2) Is a 9/11 non-truther but believes in other conspiracy theories, e.g. JFK, Moon landing, Pearl Harbor foreknowledge, et al.
 
How I became a truther: I am an engineer, design tall buildings for a living, worked at ground zero and I came across this forum in 2009. I started off having technical arguments with truthers and was pretty much ignored. I think that the truthers who understood my arguments were not really interested in discussing them.

Anyway when I lost my password one day I decided to open a new account as Telltale Tom the "honest truther". And since Jan 2010 I have tried to argue the case from an honest truther perspective: I have assumed that Richard Gage believes what he says ( which I don't, I think he lies) and I have tried to imagine what he had to think to enable him to reconcile his arguments with what happened. So I have taken delight in pointing out the obvious crazy technical inconsistencies in his arguments.

Why I changed my mind: Ten years after 9-11. There is no truther argument on this forum and nothing new is happening. It is time to walk away ... and this is my very last post. I don't think there is a truth movement any more: a small scam going on but nothing more.

And seeing all the 9/11 videos makes me wonder why I ever believed there was a truth movement. Engineers are not that gullible which is why I have tried to remind you on many occasions that there is only one or two registered structural engineers (PE's) from the thousands in the State of New York who have signed the ae911truth petition. Unfortunately one or two have signed it and they like to be different or are just challenged; not sure which.

Reflections from today: It's time to go. I had fun and I hoped I helped a few people see the "truth" Good luck all and good bye!
 
Telltale,

Sorry to see you go. Reading your posts always made me laugh, and absolutely enjoyed the honesty that you put forth.

But, I understand your position. There really is just nonsense.

Cheers and good luck to you sir!

~Tri
 
How I became a truther: I am an engineer, design tall buildings for a living, worked at ground zero and I came across this forum in 2009. I started off having technical arguments with truthers and was pretty much ignored. I think that the truthers who understood my arguments were not really interested in discussing them.

Anyway when I lost my password one day I decided to open a new account as Telltale Tom the "honest truther". And since Jan 2010 I have tried to argue the case from an honest truther perspective: I have assumed that Richard Gage believes what he says ( which I don't, I think he lies) and I have tried to imagine what he had to think to enable him to reconcile his arguments with what happened. So I have taken delight in pointing out the obvious crazy technical inconsistencies in his arguments.

Why I changed my mind: Ten years after 9-11. There is no truther argument on this forum and nothing new is happening. It is time to walk away ... and this is my very last post. I don't think there is a truth movement any more: a small scam going on but nothing more.

And seeing all the 9/11 videos makes me wonder why I ever believed there was a truth movement. Engineers are not that gullible which is why I have tried to remind you on many occasions that there is only one or two registered structural engineers (PE's) from the thousands in the State of New York who have signed the ae911truth petition. Unfortunately one or two have signed it and they like to be different or are just challenged; not sure which.

Reflections from today: It's time to go. I had fun and I hoped I helped a few people see the "truth" Good luck all and good bye!

Good luck Tom! :w2: I've always enjoyed your posts and your act. ;)
 
How I became a truther: I am an engineer, design tall buildings for a living, worked at ground zero and I came across this forum in 2009. I started off having technical arguments with truthers and was pretty much ignored. I think that the truthers who understood my arguments were not really interested in discussing them.

Anyway when I lost my password one day I decided to open a new account as Telltale Tom the "honest truther". And since Jan 2010 I have tried to argue the case from an honest truther perspective: I have assumed that Richard Gage believes what he says ( which I don't, I think he lies) and I have tried to imagine what he had to think to enable him to reconcile his arguments with what happened. So I have taken delight in pointing out the obvious crazy technical inconsistencies in his arguments.

Why I changed my mind: Ten years after 9-11. There is no truther argument on this forum and nothing new is happening. It is time to walk away ... and this is my very last post. I don't think there is a truth movement any more: a small scam going on but nothing more.

And seeing all the 9/11 videos makes me wonder why I ever believed there was a truth movement. Engineers are not that gullible which is why I have tried to remind you on many occasions that there is only one or two registered structural engineers (PE's) from the thousands in the State of New York who have signed the ae911truth petition. Unfortunately one or two have signed it and they like to be different or are just challenged; not sure which.

Reflections from today: It's time to go. I had fun and I hoped I helped a few people see the "truth" Good luck all and good bye!

Take care Tom...your posts often made me laugh and pointed out obvious issues within the "Truth Movement"...

Sorry to see you go.

Of course it is likely that each one of us will eventually follow in turn....there really is no debate anymore and the several debunking websites, thousand of posts on this forum, and various articles by experts are more then enough to answer every single truther talking point.

The up and coming debate this September will likely be one of the last ones of it's kind......after 10 years I think even some of the debunkers will begin losing interest in repeating the same stuff over and over.

Take care and thanks for your perspective.
 
Reflections from today: It's time to go. I had fun and I hoped I helped a few people see the "truth" Good luck all and good bye!
Awww! Some people disapproved of what you were doing, but amidst the joking I thought you also often made some really good points. It'll be a shame to lose that, but I also understand your reasoning, it's not like there's anything new to say. Good luck and goodbye to you, too.
 
I hate to see you go when there is so much more to this place than the CT forums.

Damn, I should have thought of saying that! Heed Pantaz's words, dear Tom! This place has a place for every topic of conversation, and I'd love to hear your thoughts on other things.
 
And seeing all the 9/11 videos makes me wonder why I ever believed there was a truth movement. Engineers are not that gullible which is why I have tried to remind you on many occasions that there is only one or two registered structural engineers (PE's) from the thousands in the State of New York who have signed the ae911truth petition. Unfortunately one or two have signed it and they like to be different or are just challenged; not sure which.

Psychological origins

According to some psychologists, a person who believes in one conspiracy theory tends to believe in others; a person who does not believe in one conspiracy theory tends not to believe another.

Psychologists believe that the search for meaning is common in conspiracism and the development of conspiracy theories, and may be powerful enough alone to lead to the first formulating of the idea. Once cognized, confirmation bias and avoidance of cognitive dissonance may reinforce the belief. In a context where a conspiracy theory has become popular within a social group, communal reinforcement may equally play a part. Some research carried out at the University of Kent, UK suggests people may be influenced by conspiracy theories without being aware that their attitudes have changed. After reading popular conspiracy theories about the death of Diana, Princess of Wales, participants in this study correctly estimated how much their peers' attitudes had changed, but significantly underestimated how much their own attitudes had changed to become more in favor of the conspiracy theories. The authors conclude that conspiracy theories may therefore have a 'hidden power' to influence people's beliefs.

Humanistic psychologists argue that even if the cabal behind the conspiracy is almost always perceived as hostile there is, often, still an element of reassurance in it, for conspiracy theorists, in part because it is more consoling to think that complications and upheavals in human affairs, at least, are created by human beings rather than factors beyond human control. Belief in such a cabal is a device for reassuring oneself that certain occurrences are not random, but ordered by a human intelligence. This renders such occurrences comprehensible and potentially controllable. If a cabal can be implicated in a sequence of events, there is always the hope, however tenuous, of being able to break the cabal's power – or joining it and exercising some of that power oneself. Finally, belief in the power of such a cabal is an implicit assertion of human dignity – an often unconscious but necessary affirmation that man is not totally helpless, but is responsible, at least in some measure, for his own destiny.
 
Last edited:
Psychological origins

According to some psychologists, a person who believes in one conspiracy theory tends to believe in others; a person who does not believe in one conspiracy theory tends not to believe another.

Psychologists believe that the search for meaning is common in conspiracism and the development of conspiracy theories, and may be powerful enough alone to lead to the first formulating of the idea. Once cognized, confirmation bias and avoidance of cognitive dissonance may reinforce the belief. In a context where a conspiracy theory has become popular within a social group, communal reinforcement may equally play a part. Some research carried out at the University of Kent, UK suggests people may be influenced by conspiracy theories without being aware that their attitudes have changed. After reading popular conspiracy theories about the death of Diana, Princess of Wales, participants in this study correctly estimated how much their peers' attitudes had changed, but significantly underestimated how much their own attitudes had changed to become more in favor of the conspiracy theories. The authors conclude that conspiracy theories may therefore have a 'hidden power' to influence people's beliefs.

Humanistic psychologists argue that even if the cabal behind the conspiracy is almost always perceived as hostile there is, often, still an element of reassurance in it, for conspiracy theorists, in part because it is more consoling to think that complications and upheavals in human affairs, at least, are created by human beings rather than factors beyond human control. Belief in such a cabal is a device for reassuring oneself that certain occurrences are not random, but ordered by a human intelligence. This renders such occurrences comprehensible and potentially controllable. If a cabal can be implicated in a sequence of events, there is always the hope, however tenuous, of being able to break the cabal's power – or joining it and exercising some of that power oneself. Finally, belief in the power of such a cabal is an implicit assertion of human dignity – an often unconscious but necessary affirmation that man is not totally helpless, but is responsible, at least in some measure, for his own destiny.


Other evolutionary psychologists, my handlers among them, believed that human and human society has evolved to favor conspiracy-type behaviours. In other words it is an intrinsic human trait, as normal as religion or music.

Obviously there will be an selective advantage gained by any group that shows strong in-group identity and mutualism, and stronger exclusion and ostracism of out-groups. But an even more powerful selective advantage is persuade the out-group that you have a co-identity with them (and there-by benefit from their in-group mutualism behaviour) yet still maintain a secret and stronger identification with your actual in-group. In a sense using a biological strategy of camouflage.

This is really the essence of conspiracy.
 
I know this is a pretty dead topic but I wanted to ask a related question about CT beliefs. Why is it that they seem to "snowball?" Believing in one CT seems to make you more vulnerable to believing in another, and another and another. Logically there should be a (very) finite number of possible "enormously complex conspiracies" in the world and yet the majority of CT with whom I have had interaction believe in dozens of them. Many of a contradictory and self-excluding nature (e.g. the government is actually run by both crypto-communists and by crypto-Muslims).

I think it stems from a lack of critical thinking ability.

They don't have the logical tools to filter the fallacies from the facts.

They read an article and accept it on face value, and if it's a conspiracy theory, it likely contains other fallacies that they adopt and add to their beliefs, even if it contradicts other beliefs. e.g. "They heard explosions" > "it was thermite", and then not accepting that thermite does not go "boom".

Of course, a "stick it to the man, man" attitude also helps ignore anything authoritative that might ask them to question something they've seen or read. They do like to adopt beliefs that not many people believe, because it makes them feel smarter than they actually are.
 
Thanks, good bye, and good luck in the future to you, Tom.

And thanks to all the participants for keeping this one of the most civil and on topic threads in this subforum's history. The stories in this thread are amazing.
 
I never was a Truther but I argued against it with a friend for years. On her request I went to a few meetings, watched Steven Jones videos, hated all of it. One day she blew up and at me and said I'm holding your feet to the fire until you REALLY look at this and research it! I watched the Richard Gage video Blueprint for Truth, and was impressed with his presentation. I kind of wondered for awhile.

I stopped wondering when I asked 14 physicists from local colleges etc about gravity and stuff. Then I personally asked other people: chemists, engineers, etc. and kept telling my friend about these things. She was not happy to see how my research was coming. Finally I challenged a local 9/11 Truth guy to a debate last October. Then I challenged Richard Gage to a debate in March. Now I have all those YouTube videos out (chrismohr911). Richard suggested I join jref to help prepare me for that debate. Wow did I get help.

I never was a Truther but my anger at Bush made me wonder sometimes if maybe gage was right. I have no regrets about those wonderings. Nothing wrong with being skeptical about the government. What's important is the willingness to ask and then not filter out answers that contradict your own inner Official Story!

My friend is not happy at how much I've researched 9/11 now.
 
a) How did you once become a truther?
I became a truther because of Alex Jones. I had seen him in the movie Waking Life I believe, and I wondered who he was. A quick IMDb search found him and from that I found the movie JFK II: The Bush Connection, and it left an impression on me. I've watched it again recently and it's still amusing because of how crudely edited it is.

From that, I found videos of Alex Jones talking about 9/11. You have to understand I was into hardcore punk when I was a bit younger - this is around 11 or 12 years old; I'm 19 now. That genre taught me to be a one-sided skeptic: DON'T TRUST THE GOVERNMENT! So I ate it up, I had no problem believing the government killed it's own people for a reason I really didn't understand.

b) What convinced you back from truther to non-truther?
I saw an episode of South Park called Mystery of the Urinal Deuce. I remembered the line "1/4th of Americans are retards.". It made me laugh, but I knew they were calling me retarded. It didn't offend me, but, it made me wonder why they would think it was stupid to believe 9/11 was an inside job. I thought of the creators of South Park as geniuses at the time.

I simply ignored the fact I believed it, and I ignored the official story as well. I didn't care at that point; what was presented as evidence was becoming confusing, especially now that I was actually questioning my beliefs instead of blindly accepting a conspiracy due to bias.

It wasn't until recently that I've started thinking about it again. I believe my research began with finding the site Debunking 9/11. The rebuttals to all of the main theories just made sense. There's also logistic problems I had with the conspiracy: How did they plant CD explosives/thermite, knowing exactly where the planes would impact? Why would they suspiciously take down WTC7? Why would Silverstein admit it on national television? Why not just have a plane hit the Pentagon and land in Shanksville?

c) What are your thoughts nowadays about your time as a truther?
Currently, I'm leaning more to the official story rationally, emotionally I still think of the idea as a possibility. These emotions are an appeal to authority due to guys like Steven Jones and Richard Gage. They claim to have evidence of thermite, but the users here question that due to faulty methodolgy.

I guess I'm still on the fence, somewhat. This is because physics and chemistry are way beyond anything I know.

I guess I just grew up.
 
Last edited:
How I became a truther: I am an engineer, design tall buildings for a living, worked at ground zero and I came across this forum in 2009. I started off having technical arguments with truthers and was pretty much ignored. I think that the truthers who understood my arguments were not really interested in discussing them.

Anyway when I lost my password one day I decided to open a new account as Telltale Tom the "honest truther". And since Jan 2010 I have tried to argue the case from an honest truther perspective: I have assumed that Richard Gage believes what he says ( which I don't, I think he lies) and I have tried to imagine what he had to think to enable him to reconcile his arguments with what happened. So I have taken delight in pointing out the obvious crazy technical inconsistencies in his arguments.

Why I changed my mind: Ten years after 9-11. There is no truther argument on this forum and nothing new is happening. It is time to walk away ... and this is my very last post. I don't think there is a truth movement any more: a small scam going on but nothing more.

And seeing all the 9/11 videos makes me wonder why I ever believed there was a truth movement. Engineers are not that gullible which is why I have tried to remind you on many occasions that there is only one or two registered structural engineers (PE's) from the thousands in the State of New York who have signed the ae911truth petition. Unfortunately one or two have signed it and they like to be different or are just challenged; not sure which.

Reflections from today: It's time to go. I had fun and I hoped I helped a few people see the "truth" Good luck all and good bye!


You were great. Sail on and good luck!
 
a) How did you once become a truther?
I became a truther because of Alex Jones. I had seen him in the movie Waking Life I believe, and I wondered who he was. A quick IMDb search found him and from that I found the movie JFK II: The Bush Connection, and it left an impression on me. I've watched it again recently and it's still amusing because of how crudely edited it is.

From that, I found videos of Alex Jones talking about 9/11. You have to understand I was into hardcore punk when I was a bit younger - this is around 11 or 12 years old; I'm 19 now. That genre taught me to be a one-sided skeptic: DON'T TRUST THE GOVERNMENT! So I ate it up, I had no problem believing the government killed it's own people for a reason I really didn't understand.

b) What convinced you back from truther to non-truther?
I saw an episode of South Park called Mystery of the Urinal Deuce. I remembered the line "1/4th of Americans are retards.". It made me laugh, but I knew they were calling me retarded. It didn't offend me, but, it made me wonder why they would think it was stupid to believe 9/11 was an inside job. I thought of the creators of South Park as geniuses at the time.

I simply ignored the fact I believed it, and I ignored the official story as well. I didn't care at that point; what was presented as evidence was becoming confusing, especially now that I was actually questioning my beliefs instead of blindly accepting a conspiracy due to bias.

It wasn't until recently that I've started thinking about it again. I believe my research began with finding the site Debunking 9/11. The rebuttals to all of the main theories just made sense. There's also logistic problems I had with the conspiracy: How did they plant CD explosives/thermite, knowing exactly where the planes would impact? Why would they suspiciously take down WTC7? Why would Silverstein admit it on national television? Why not just have a plane hit the Pentagon and land in Shanksville?

c) What are your thoughts nowadays about your time as a truther?
Currently, I'm leaning more to the official story rationally, emotionally I still think of the idea as a possibility. These emotions are an appeal to authority due to guys like Steven Jones and Richard Gage. They claim to have evidence of thermite, but the users here question that due to faulty methodolgy.

I guess I'm still on the fence, somewhat. This is because physics and chemistry are way beyond anything I know.

I guess I just grew up.

Good post. You're doing well.
 
This is incredibly fascinating and gives me hope that all my youtube video rebuttals of Gage's theories can be of some use. We have MANY stories here of former 9/11 Truth believers being convinced they were wrong by skeptics. Over 15,000 views and counting of my rebuttal videos in the past couple months (YouTube keyword chrismohr911) makes me think there may be many others who did not find this thread.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom