Ear candling

Nope! No mention of placebo there.

so despite the fact that the academic literature indicates that ear candling has no positive effects whatsoever, you're dismissing it because the article doesn't use the word "placebo". Nice open mind you've got there.
 
Actually what you seem to have there is the opinion of one person there (learned admittedly).
It does not appear to have had any scientific studies done, hence no mention of placebo.
Your accusations of a closed mind need to be redirected back at yourself I would suggest.
 
Last edited:
Nope! No mention of placebo there.

No, because they say there is no effect at all. Placebo effect is still an effect.

Evidence? If you had some that might confirm the placebo claim I could agree. Ultimately you might be right, but I have not seen anything that confirms it.

You are getting this wrong. Onus of proof is on the claimant. Whoever claims ear-candling works must provide the evidence. (You are, obviously, welcome to your personal anecdote, as long as you don't mistake it for evidence.)

The evidence against ear candling is that there is no plausible mode of action, except for the couple of things I mentioned earlier, which are generic for sticking anything in your ear, not specifically an ear candle.

.... Could we get an ear candle smiley?

Hans
 
Actually what you seem to have there is the opinion of one person there (learned admittedly).
It does not appear to have had any scientific studies done, hence no mention of placebo.
Your accusations of a closed mind need to be redirected back at yourself I would suggest.

wow, did you even bother to read the article? Here's another link in case that one was broken:

http://journals.cambridge.org/action/displayAbstract?fromPage=online&aid=403194

This isn't an opinion piece, apart from the final conclusion. It's a review article, looking at every mention of ear candling in the academic literature, including trials of ear candling.
 
See also the Quackometer blog: Hopi Ear Candling – Removing the Grey Goo Between Your Ears

There's a great testimonial on there as well:


Fork 'andles?


Nah, O's, Mon Repose, O's

Funny enough, my missus asked if I wanted to try them to help with a problem that I've had for a year. My timpanic membranes are concave due to an inability to equalise the pressure twixt inner and outer ear. I told her that if we try that we could also try putting a parrot on a coat-hanger while I lick it's back, twice a day for three days. Efficacy equality.
 
wow, did you even bother to read the article? Here's another link in case that one was broken:

http://journals.cambridge.org/action/displayAbstract?fromPage=online&aid=403194

This isn't an opinion piece, apart from the final conclusion. It's a review article, looking at every mention of ear candling in the academic literature, including trials of ear candling.

Fair enough. But it was claimed that ear candles have nothing more than a placebo effect. This is not my claim but yours (or someone elses), I have seen nothing that says anything to that effect.

As for the conclusion, what were the studies done to reach it? The report itself is silent, is it not? Or did I miss something?
 
Fair enough. But it was claimed that ear candles have nothing more than a placebo effect. This is not my claim but yours (or someone elses), I have seen nothing that says anything to that effect.

As for the conclusion, what were the studies done to reach it? The report itself is silent, is it not? Or did I miss something?

You missed something. I'm sorry, but I don't have the time to teach you how to read academic papers, except to point out that you should check their references.

This paper actually goes a lot further than those claiming that ear candling has nothing more than a placebo effect. What it establishes is that there is no evidence whatsoever of ear candling having any effects whatsoever apart from running the risk of injuring people.
 
Sigh.

So where is the evidence against invisible pink unicorns? Where are the trial reports?

Hans
 
Sigh.

So where is the evidence against invisible pink unicorns? Where are the trial reports?

Hans

"Here's a paper showing that no unicorns exist"
"ah, but it doesn't mention PINK unicorns, does it?"
 
Nope! No mention of placebo there.



Evidence? If you had some that might confirm the placebo claim I could agree. Ultimately you might be right, but I have not seen anything that confirms it.

Do you have any evidence that candling does work to remove wax from your ears?
 
Wow, "nothing is completely safe" for reals? For really reals? We're going to go there?

I'm just going to bow out, because I'm thinking things about you caniswalensis said I shouldn't.

That's the spirit! :D

...but I didn't actually mean to tell you how to think. I was just relating what works for me.

If this stuff gets you that bothered, my way is probably not going to work for you.
 
I can't believe anyone would stick a flaming waxy cardboard cylinder in their ear...even if it did remove ear wax build up...

There are safer ways.

When you add in the fact that the flaming doodad really doesn't do anything about ear wax, it's even more boggling.

Then when you read the explanation of how the flaming ear wax vacuum cylinder is supposed to work...your head explodes...
 
I find it hard to believe that an ear blockage disappears because of a placebo.

Hi Alfie,

I think in this case the placeo effect would be that someone uses an ear candle, and just the fact that they have laid down for awhile and treated themselves to some relaxing attention to themselves leads them to feel that the problem has improved. Maybe the ear feels a bit better, or different afterwards, even though no wax was actually removed. They might say to themselves something like: "Well, that's better, not 100% yet, but I can tell that helped."

Especially if the candling is done by someone else, or at spa. That's a lot like going and getting a massage. Who wouldn't feel good after that?

...and let's not forget, nobody wants to have to admit they just wasted time & money doing something.

Placebo effect is all about people convincing themselves that they feel better. We know that it happens, and we know that no actual improvement needs to happen for people to feel like they are better.

Everybody is susceptable to it, so there is no shame at all in allowing that the placebo effect might account for your personal experience. That just means you are a human, like the rest of us. :)
 
The easiest way to debunk ear candling is to ask the believer to burn an ear candle without the benefit of an ear, and see how much "ear wax" it removes.

They won't do this, of course, but it may shut them up.
 
My wife did this a couple of times. I cured her by saying "Honey, sing 'kill the wabbit!' " as she sat there with candles sticking out of her ears, which made her look like she was wearing a flaming Viking helmet.

After reading this post I had to look up "ear candling" on Google Images. Unfortunately, almost all pictures involve someone lying on one side with a candle sticking straight up.
 
I thought that earwax was beneficial.

Anyway, it was my claim that A.A. Alfie had experienced a placebo cure.

I made claim on the basis that:

  • Ear candling has been shown to have no effect (see the earlier quackwatch link)
  • A.A. Alfie said that he/she felt an improvement

Given that the treatment has been demonstrated to have no effect then all that was left was the placebo.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom